PL EN


Journal
2007 | 52 | 3(206) | 123-136
Article title

TEXTUAL HERMENEUTICS: A PATCHWORK OR A WHOLE WOVEN CLOAK? (Hermeneutyka tekstów: patchwork czy szata calodziana?)

Title variants
Languages of publication
PL
Abstracts
EN
In spite of the title, this article is not devoted exclusively to the issue of either unity or dispersion of the achievements of the branch of hermeneutics called (as distinct from philosphical hermeneutics) textual hermeneutics. The extreme form of this unity (as well as continuity) is symbolised here by the 'whole woven cloak'; while the extreme form of non-coherence is referred to as a 'patchwork' with an irregular pattern (the authoress was inspired here by Gadamer's statement that 'the word 'text' really refers to a fabric'). Based on this distinction, the authoress presents a provisional outline of her main thesis: the theory of hermeneutics, with a tradition reaching back to the Stoics' reflections on Homer, represents a continuity, which has been becoming unbreakable since the nineteenth century, while the practice of hermeneutics, initially a regular patchwork (which since the days Schleiermacher has incorporated the psychological aspect, i.e., the personality of the author) shaped by canonical norms, has striven and strives towards freedom, resembling a 'crazy' patchwork, i.e., such in which the sewing on of indiviudal patches is the work of momentary inspiration. The article also emphasises a number of important elements in Gadamer's hermeneutical philosophy which are not sufficiently stressed today. These include the use of the ideas originating from ancient Greece, such as the role of dialogue in bringing about understanding (the influence of Gadamer's study of Plato over many years). The authoress also recalls the influence of Gadamer's thinking on the musicology of H.H. Eggeebrecht, and pays attention to Gadamer's hermeneutical praxis; his studies of the nineteenth- and twentieth-century poetry. These studies bring Gadamer (otherwise regarded as the creator of philosophical hermeneutics) into the hermeneutic of texts - in its modern version, only loosely connected with the canon.
Journal
Year
Volume
52
Issue
Pages
123-136
Physical description
Document type
ARTICLE
Contributors
  • M. Piotrowska, Katolicki Uniwersytet Lubelski, Instytut Muzykologii, al. Raclawickie 14, 20-950 Lublin, Poland
References
Document Type
Publication order reference
Identifiers
CEJSH db identifier
09PLAAAA05774
YADDA identifier
bwmeta1.element.6b7c1cb1-40f8-34e5-9d5d-48c6a8aa91c9
JavaScript is turned off in your web browser. Turn it on to take full advantage of this site, then refresh the page.