PL EN


Journal
2009 | 17 | 4(68) | 11-22
Article title

THE DEDUCTIVE-NOMOLOGICAL MODEL OF EXPLANATION OF C. G. HEMPEL AND THE EXPLANATION IN HUMAN SCIENCES (Dedukcyjno-nomologiczny model wyjasniania Hempla a wyjasnianie w naukach humanistycznych)

Authors
Title variants
Languages of publication
PL
Abstracts
EN
The starting point of the article is a claim, that the well-known distinction between natural sciences as explaining and human sciences as interpreting made by W. Dilthey and distinction between idiographic and nomothetic sciences made by H. Rickert are both inadequate at present. Human sciences separate their research areas using logics and statistics and formulating many generalizations and even laws. So it can be argued that they can give explanations sensu stricto. First part of the article describes contemporary controversy naturalism-antinaturalism in formulation of M. Salmon, who presents the third middle way, that some human science as linguistics or evolutionary psychology can give causal explanations without appealing to human reasons as causes. This standpoint, however, can lead to reductionism and necessity of separating in each human science some kind of 'scientific core', which seems to be undesirable. Second part of the article presents possible applications of the D-N model of explanation of C. G. Hempel in human sciences, which is connected with well-known controversy whether these sciences formulate any laws (especially history but also linguistics for example). Leaving out, however, this important question and accepting statement proposed by J. Such, that some generalizations can serve as a premises in D-N arguments, we can claim that some D-N explanations are possible also in human sciences.
Journal
Year
Volume
17
Issue
Pages
11-22
Physical description
Document type
ARTICLE
Contributors
  • Adam Wlodarczyk, ul. ks. T Boguckiego 3 m. 69, 01-508 Warszawa, Poland.
References
Document Type
Publication order reference
Identifiers
CEJSH db identifier
10PLAAAA07292
YADDA identifier
bwmeta1.element.70ba7886-50e9-3185-9882-733b4877e23e
JavaScript is turned off in your web browser. Turn it on to take full advantage of this site, then refresh the page.