Cultural War and Reinventing the Past in Poland and Hungary: The Politics of Historical Memory in East–Central Europe
Languages of publication
This paper has been based on three assumptions that have been widely discussed in the international political science: (1) there has been a decline of democracy in East–Central Europe (ECE) with the emergence of “velvet dictatorships”, (2) the velvet dictatorships rely on the soft power of media and communication rather on the hard power of state violence that has provoked “cultural wars“ and (3) the basic turning point is the transition from the former modernization narrative to the traditional narrative with “reinventing the past” and “reconceptualising modernity” through the reference to the historically given collective national identity by launching the “politics of historical memory”. The velvet dictatorships have been using and abusing the national history as an ideological drug to consolidate their power. The (social and national) populism and Euroscepticism are the basic twin terms to describe the soft power of the new (semi)authoritarian regimes. They are convertible, the two sides of the same coin, since they express the same divergence from the EU mainstream from inside and outside. Soft power means that the political contest in the new regimes has been transferred from the hard to the soft fields of politics as the fight between the confronting narratives. The victory of the traditionalist–nativist narrative carries also the message that the people are only passive “subjects” and not active citizens, so the field of politics has been extremely narrowed in the “new brave world” in ECE.
- Akman, P. & Hussein K. (2010). “Myth and Myth–Making in the European Union”. Journal of Common Market Studies, 48(1), 111–132.
- Aniol, W. (2015). “A Social Deficit: Poland in the Face of Developmental Challenges in the 2010s”. Problemy Polityki Spolecznej, 31(4), 39–56.
- Ágh, A. (2015a). “De–Europeanization and de–Democratization trends in ECE: From the Potemkin democracy to the elected autocracy in Hungary”. Journal of Comparative Politics, 8(2), July 2015, 4–26.
- Ágh, A. (2015b). “The Triple Crisis in the New Member States: The historical trajectory of NMS–8 in the Past Quarter Century”. Southeastern Europe, 39(3), 294–317.
- Ágh, A. (2015c). “Radical party system changes in five East–Central European states: Eurosceptic and populist parties on the move in the 2010s”. Baltic Journal of Political Science, 4(4), 23–48.
- Ágh, A. (2015d). “Redemocratization efforts in Hungary as a second try: Civil society organizations and mass movements”. Problems of Social Policy, 31(4), 9–36.
- Ágh, A. (2016a). “The increasing Core–Periphery Divide and the New Member States: Diverging from the European Union’s mainstream developments”, 117–129, in J. Magone, B. Laffan & C. Schweiger (eds.) Core–Periphery Relations in European Union, London: Routledge.
- Ágh, A. (2016b). “Rocky Road of Europeanization in the New Member States: From democracy capture to the second try of democratization”. Polish Sociological Review, 1, 71–86.
- Banac, I. (2014). “Twenty–Five Years After the Fall of the Berlin Wall”. East European Politics and Societies and Cultures, Special Issue on the Post–1989 Developments in the Region, 28(2), pp. 653–657.
- Benner, T. & Reinicke, W. (2014). Fixing Europe’s Orbán Problem. Project Syndicate. Retrieved from http://www.project–syndicate.org/print/thorsten–benner–and–wolfgang–h––reinicke–demand–that–eu–leaders–force–hungary–s–authoritarian–prime–minister–to–change–course.
- Bernhard, M. & Jasiewicz, K. (eds.) (2015). Whither Eastern Europe? Changing Approaches and Perspectives on the Region in Political Science. East European Politics and Societies, Special Issue, 29(2), 311–322.
- Best, H., Lengyel, G., & Verzichelli L. (eds.) (2012). The Europe of Elites: A Study into the Europeannes of Europe’s Political and Economic Elites, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
- Bertelsmann Foundation (2015). Next Generation Democracy. Bertelsmann Foundation. Retrieved from http://www.bti–project.org/next–generation–democracy.
- Bertelsmann Foundation (2016a). Hungary country report. Bertelsmann Foundation. Retrieved from http://www.bti–project.org/en/reports/country–reports/country–reports/itc/HUN/.
- Bertelsmann Foundation (2016b). BTI 2016, Poland Country Report. Bertelsmann Foundation. Retrieved from https://www.bti–project.org/fileadmin/files/BTI/Downloads/Reports/2016/pdf/BTI_2016_Poland.pdf.
- Bouillette, A. (2014). An Autocrat Inside the EU. Foreign Affairs, No. 8, on–line. Retrieved from http://foreignpolicy.com/2014/08/21/the–autocrat–inside–the–eu/.
- Blacker, U., Etkind, A., & Fedor J. (eds.) (2013). Memory and Theory in Eastern Europe, New York: Palgrave–Macmillan.
- Blacker, U. & Etkind, A. (2013) “Introduction” in Blacker, U., Etkind, A. and Fedor, J. (eds.), 1–22.
- Burean, T., Szocs, C.–E. & Badescu, G. (2014). “The long lasting effect of the economic crisis on political culture”. Politics in Central Europe. 1, 7–2.
- Cabada, L. (2014). “Neo–liberal, neo–Keynesian or just standard response to the crisis? Clash of ideologies in Czech political, scientific and public debate”. Politics in Central Europe. 1, 25–51.
- Case, H. (2009). “Being European: East and West”, in Checkel, J. and Katzenstein, P. (eds.), 111–131.
- Chadwick, V. (2016). “Putin–like?” Not us, say Poland and Hungary in response to Bill Clinton, Politico, 17 May 2016. Retrieved from http://www.politico.eu/article/us–democracy–putin–like–not–us–say–poland–and–hungary–in–response–to–bill–clinton/.
- Checkel, J. & P. Katzenstein (eds.) (2009). European Identity, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, p. 263.
- Della Sala, V. (2010) “Political Myth, Mythology and the European Union”. Journal of Common Market Studies, Special Issue edited by V. Della Sala, 48(1), 1–20.
- European Commission (2015). 25 years after the fall of the Iron Curtain: The state of integration of East and West in the European Union. Retrieved from https://ec.europa.eu/research/social–sciences/pdf/policy_reviews/east–west_integration.pdf.
- European Parliament (2016). Democracy, Rule of Law and Fundamental Rights (DRF) scoreboard document. Retrieved from http://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getDoc.do?pubRef=–//EP//NONSGML+COMPARL+PE–576.988+01+DOC+PDF+V0//EN&language=EN.
- European Policy Centre (2016). Europe’s Troublemakers: The Populist Challenge to Foreign Policy, February 2016, p. 59, http://www.epc.eu/documents/uploads/pub_6377_europe_s_troublemakers.pdf.
- European Catch–Up Index 2014 (2014). The Gravity Effect: Findings of the European Catch–Up Index 2014. European Policies Initiative–Open Society Institute, December 2014. Retrieved from http://eupi.osi.bg/cgi–bin/e–cms/vis/vis.pl?s=001&p=0070&g.
- Freedom House, (2016a). Country Report on Hungary. Retrieved from https://freedomhouse.org/sites/default/files/NIT2016_Hungary_0.pdf.
- Freedom House (2016b). Country Report on Poland. Retrieved from https://freedomhouse.org/sites/default/files/NIT2016_Poland_0.pdf.
- Fidesz (2010). A Nemzeti Együttműködés Programja: munka, otthon, család, egészség, rend (Program for the National Cooperation: work, home, family, health, order), p. 85. Retrieved from, http://www.parlament.hu/irom39/00047/00047.pdf.
- Fossum, J. E. & A. J. Menéndez (eds.) (2014). The European Union in crises or the European Union as crises?, Oslo: Arena.
- Galgóczi, B. (2016). “The southern and eastern peripheries of Europe: Is convergence a lost cause?” 130–145, in Magone, J, Laffan, B. and Schweiger, C. (eds.).
- Gaxie, D., Hubé, N. & J. Rowell, J. (eds.) (2011). Perceptions of Europe: A comparative sociology of European attitudes, Colchester: ECPR Press, p. 272.
- Hansen, L. & Williams, M. (1999). “The Myths of Europe: Legitimacy, Community and the ’Crisis’ of the EU”. Journal of Common Market Studies, 37(2), 233–250.
- Helgesen, V. (2014). Hungary’s journey back into past, Financial Times, 29 August 2014. Retrieved from http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/2234f99a–2942–11e4–8b81–00144feabdc0.html#axzz3Bko4IFrW.
- IMF (2014). 25 Years of Transition, Post–Communist Europe and the IMF, Regional Economic Issues, Special Report, October 2014. Retrieved from http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/reo/2014/eur/eng/pdf/erei_sr_102414.pdf.
- Innes, A. (2014). “The Political Economy of State Capture in Central Europe”. Journal of Common Market Studies, (52)1, 88–104, Special Issue on Eastern Enlargement Ten Years On.
- Juhász, A. & Molnár, C. (2016). Keleti extrémek (Eastern Extremes, Derex Index). HVG (Budapest), 11 August 2016, 20–23.
- Kolvraa, C. (2016). “European Fantasies: On the EU’s Political Myths and the Affective Potential of Utopian Imaginaries for European Identity”. Journal of Common Market Studies, 54(1), 169–182.
- Krasztev, P. & van Til, J. (eds.) (2015). The Hungarian Patient: Social Opposition to an Illiberal Democracy, Budapest: CEU Press, p. 389.
- Kucharczyk, J. & Wysocka, O. (2008). “Poland”, 69–98, in Meseznikov, G., Gyárfásová, O. and Smilov, D. (eds.).
- Kucharczyk, J. & Meseznikov, G. (eds.) (2015). Diverging Voices, Converging Policies: The Visegrad States’ Reactions to the Russia–Ukraine Conflict, Prague and Warsaw: Heinrich Böll Stiftung, p. 216.
- Lebow, R. N. al. (eds.) (2006). The Politics of Memory in Postwar Europe, Durham: Duke University Press, p. 384.
- Magone, J., Laffan, B. & Schweiger, C. (eds.) (2016). Core–periphery Relations in the European Union. Power and Conflict in a Dualist Political Economy. London and New York: Routledge, p. 332.
- Manners, I. & Murray, P. (2016). “The End of a Noble Narrative? European Integration Narratives after the Nobel Peace Prize”. Journal of Common Market Studies, (54)1, 183–202.
- Marcussen, M. et al. (1999). “Constructing Europe? The Evolution of French, British and German nation state identities”. Journal of European Public Policy, (6)4, 614–633.
- Mark, J. (2010). The Unfinished Revolution: Making Sense of the Communist Past in Central–Eastern Europe, London: Yale University Press, p. 312.
- Meseznikov, G., Gyárfásová, O. & Smilov, D. (eds.) (2008). Populist politics and liberal democracy in Central and Eastern Europe, Bratislava: Institute for Public Affairs, p. 131.
- Michnik, A. (2015). The bitter taste of velvet dictatorship (published also in Hungarian, see Élet és Irodalom, Budapest weekly, 13 November 2015), originally in Polish, Gazeta Wyborcza, 17 October 2015.
- Mudde, C. (2014). The 2014 Hungarian parliamentary elections, or how to craft a constitutional majority. The Washington Post, 14 April 2014. Retrieved from http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/monkey–cage/wp/2014/04/14/the–2014–hungarian–parliamentary–elections–or–how–to–craft–a–constitutional–majority/.
- Muiznieks, N. (2014). Report by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe Following the Visit to Hungary from 1 to 4 July 2014, Strasbourg, 16 December 2014. Retrieved from https://wcd.coe.int/com.instranet.InstraServlet?command=com.instranet.CmdBlobGet&InstranetImage=2662996&SecMode=1&DocId=2218468&Usage=2.
- Muiznieks, N. (2016). Council of Europe Report on Poland. Retrieved from https://wcd.coe.int/com.instranet.InstraServlet?command=com.instranet.CmdBlobGet&InstranetImage=2924182&SecMode=1&DocId=2376250&Usage=2.
- Müller, J–W (2015). Hungary: Sorry About Our Prime Minister, 14 October 2015. Retrieved from http://www.nybooks.com/blogs/nyrblog/2015/oct/14/orban–hungary–sorry–about–prime–minister.
- Negotiating Modernity Project (2015). History of Modern Political Thought in East–Central Europe. Retrieved from http://www.negotiating.cas.bg/publications.html.
- Nowak, B. (2014). Viktor Orban and Europe’s New Populism, 25 April 2014. Retrieved from http://www.realclearworld.com/articles/2014/04/25/viktor_orban_and_europes_new_populism.html.
- Orbán, V. (1999). Interview to Világgazdaság, 17 December 1999. Retrieved from https://hu.wikiquote.org/wiki/Orb%C3%A1n_Viktor.
- Orbán, V. (2011). Speech on national holiday, 15 March 2011. Retrieved from http://index.hu/belfold/2011/03/15/a_nemzeti_egyuttmukudes_kiment_az_utcara.
- Orbán, V. (2012). We will not be a colony, 15 March 2012 (speech on national holiday). Retrieved from http://www.miniszterelnok.hu/beszed/nem_leszunk_gyarmat.
- Orbán, V. (2014). The End of Liberal Democracy, Talk on 26 July 2014. Retrieved from http://www.freehungary.hu/index.php/56–hirek/3123–full–text–of–hungary–pm–viktor–orban–s–scandalous–speech–at–the–xxv–balvanyos–free–summer–university–and–youth–camp.
- Orbán Viktor, a “dictator light” (2014). 10 December 2014. Retrieved from http://www.eszakonline.hu/itthon/65–ez–toertent/20290–orban–viktor–a–qdiktator–lightq.
- Orbán, V. (2015). Europe has been betrayed, Speech on 30 October 2015. Retrieved from http://www.kormany.hu/en/the–prime–minister/news/europe–has–been–betrayedhttp://www.kormany.hu/en/the–prime–minister/news/europe–has–been–betrayed.
- Orbán, V. (2015). Europe has been betrayed, Speech on 30 October 2015. Retrieved from, http://www.kormany.hu/en/the–prime–minister/news/europe–has–been–betrayed.
- Orbán, V. (2016). Speech on national holiday (15 March 2016). Retrieved from http://www.kormany.hu/hu/a–miniszterelnok/beszedek–publikaciok–interjuk/orban–viktor–unnepi–beszede.
- Pew Foundation (2009). “End of Communism Cheered but Now with More Reservations”. Retrieved from http://pewglobal.org/2009/11/02/end–of–communism–cheered–but–now–with–more–reservations.
- Pew Survey (2014). A Fragile Rebound for EU Image on Eve of European Parliamentary Elections, 12 May 2014, Retrieved from http://www.pewglobal.org/2014/05/12/a–fragile–rebound–for–eu–image–on–eve–of–european–parliament–elections.
- Pew Research Center (2016). Euroscepticism Beyond Brexit, 7 June 2016. Retrieved from http://www.pewglobal.org/2016/06/07/euroskepticism–beyond–brexit.
- Polyák, G. (2015). “The Hungarian Media System: Stopping Short or Re–Transformation?” Südosteuropa, Special Issue, Hungary’s Path Toward an Illiberal System, Vol. 63, No. 2, 272–318.
- Potyrala, A. (2016). “Poland towards the migration crisis of 2015–2016”. Political Science Review, No. 23, 75–87.
- Real–Dato, J., Göncz, B. & Lengyel, G. (2012). “National elites’ preferences on the Europeanization of policy making”, in Best, H., Lengyel, G., & Verzichelli L. (eds.), 67–93.
- Rupnik, J. (2007a). “From Democracy Fatigue to Populist Backlash”. Journal of Democracy, (18)4, 17–25, Special Issue of “Is East–Central Europe Backsliding?”.
- Rupnik, J. (2007b). “Populism in Eastern Central Europe”. Eurozine. Retrieved from http://www.eurozine.com/pdf/2007–09–10–rupnik–en.pdf.
- Rupnik, J. (2012). “Hungary’s Illiberal Turn: How Things Went Wrong”. Journal of Democracy, (23)3, July 2012, 132–137.
- Rupnik, J. & Zielonka, J. (2013). “The State of Democracy 20 Years on: Domestic and External Factors”. East European Politics and Societies, (27)3, 1–25, Special Issue on The State of Democracy 20 Years On.
- Szczerbiak, A. (2016). How Will The EU’s ’Rule of Law’ Investigation Affect Polish Politics. Social Europe. Retrieved from https://www.socialeurope.eu/2016/02/how–will–the–eus–rule–of–law–investigation–affect–polish–politics.
- The Economist (2014). Hungary’s Prime Minister: Orban the Unstoppable, 27 September 2014, 23–24
- The Telegraph (2015). Poland on “the velvet road of dictatorship” after Andrzej Duda wins presidential elections, 25 May 2015, (Adam Michnik reference). Retrieved from http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/poland/11628799/Poland–on–the–velvet–road–to–dictatorship–after–Andrzej–Duda–wins–presidential–elections.html.
- Uitz, R. (2008). “Hungary”, 39–69, in Meseznikov, G., Gyárfásová, O. & Smilov, D. (eds.).
- Wawrzyński, P., Muszyński, M. A., Czarnek, G., & Schattkowsky, R. (2015). “Individual differences and attitudes towards the government’s remembrance policy”. Polish Political Science Yearbook, 44, 122–138.
- WEF, World Economic Forum (2015). Global Competitiveness Report 2015–2016. Retrieved from http://www3.weforum.org/docs/gcr/2015–2016/Global_Competitiveness_Report_2015–2016.pdf.
- Winter, J. (1998). Sites of Memory, Sites of Mourning: The Great War in European Cultural History, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, p. 310.
Publication order reference