The Church of Georgia in War

• Authors: TSURTSUMIA Mamuka
• Languages of publication: EN

Abstracts

EN

In Western Europe the Church as an institution was integrated into the military system and was obliged to serve the monarchy. Apart from performing vassal duties, the Latin clergy frequently participated in military actions. Although the Church laws forbade clergymen to shed blood, there were many examples of the violation of this rule. The attitude of the Orthodox Church in the Byzantine Empire concerning the possible participation of the clergy in war differed significantly from that of Latin Europe. The Byzantine priesthood did not become involved in military actions. The Greek Church possessed neither military units nor vassal commitment to the Empire. Despite a very close relationship with the Byzantine Church the attitude of the Georgian Church to the issue differs from that of Byzantium and is closer to the Western practice. The feudal organization of Georgia conditioned the social structure of the Georgian Church and its obligations before the monarchy. Despite the fact that the Georgian Church enjoyed many advantages, it had to take part in military campaigns. The upper circles of Georgian Church dignitaries were accustomed to both conducting military campaigns or taking part in the combat. In regard to military activities of clergy, Georgian law was much more lenient than Byzantine, and in the case of necessity, it even modified Greek legal norms. The conflict with the Christian canons was decided in favor of military necessity, and it was reflected in the legislation.

Keywords

EN

Latin Church; Byzantine Church; Georgian Church; Church Law; Warrior Bishops

• Publisher: Instytut Historii Uniwersytet w Siedlcach
• Journal: Historia i Świat
• Year: 2019
• Issue: 8
• Pages: 115-132

Dates

published

2019

Contributors

author

TSURTSUMIA Mamuka

References

• Anna Komnene, The Alexiad, tr. E.R.A. SEWTER, rev. P. FRANKOPAN, London 2009.
• Archili, Archiliani, v. 2, eds. A. BARAMIDZE, N. BERDZENISHVILI, Tbilisi 1937 [in Georgian]
• Beri Egnatashvili, New Life of Kartli, First Text, in: Kartlis tskhovreba, ed. S. QAUKHCHISHVILI, Tbilisi 1959, II: 326-442 [in Georgian]
• Bibliografia critica delle antiche reciproche corrispondenze, v. 2, ed. S. CIAMPI, Firenze 1839.
• Don Christophoro de Castelli, Information and an Album about Georgia, ed. B. GIORGADZE, Tbilisi 1976 [in Georgian]
• Don Giuseppe Giudice Milanese, Letters about Georgia (XVII c), ed. B. GIORGADZE, Tbilisi 1964 [in Georgian]
• Giorgi Mtatsmindeli, Life of Ioane and Euthymius, ed. I. ABULADZE. Tbilisi 1967 [in Georgian]
• Juansheri, The Life of Vakhtang Gorgasali, in Kartlis tskhovreba, ed. S. QAUKHCHISHVILI, Tbilisi 1955, I: 139-204 [in Georgian]
• King David’s Chronicler, The Life of King of Kings David, in Kartlis tskhovreba, ed. S. QAUKHCHISHVILI, Tbilisi 1955, I: 318 -364 [in Georgian]
• Matiane Kartlisa, in Kartlis tskhovreba, ed. S. QAUKHCHISHVILI, Tbilisi 1955, I: 249-317 [in Georgian]
• Monuments of Georgian Law, v. 1, ed. I. DOLIDZE, Tbilisi 1963 [in Georgian]
• Monuments of Georgian Law, v. 3, ed. I. DOLIDZE, Tbilisi 1970 [in Georgian]
• Monuments of Georgian Law, v. 6, ed. I. DOLIDZE, Tbilisi 1977 [in Georgian]
• Nicolai I. papae epistolae, in Monumenta Germaniae Historica. Epistolarum, v. VI, Berlin 1925, 257-690.
• Patrologia Graeca, v. 144, ed. J.P. MIGNE, Paris 1865.
• S. Bonifatii et Lulli epistolae, in Monumenta Germaniae Historica. Epistolarum, v. 3, Berlin 1892, 215-433.
• Sigeberti monachi Gemblacensis, Leodicensium epistola adversus Paschalem papam, in Monumenta Germaniae Historica. Libelli de lite imperatorum et pontificum, Hannover 1892, II: 449-464.
• Small Chronicles, ed. J. ODISHELI, Tbilisi 1968 [in Georgian]
• The Big Lawbook, eds. E. GABIDZASHVILI, E. GIUNASHVILI, M. DOLAKIDZE, G. NINUA, Tbilisi 1975 [in Georgian]
• The Chronicles and Other Materials about Georgian History, v. 2, ed. T. ZHORDANIA, Tiflis 1897 [in Georgian]
• The Histories and Eulogies of the Sovereigns, in Kartlis tskhovreba, ed. S. QAUKHCHISHVILI, Tbilisi 1959, II: 1-114 [in Georgian]
• The Lawcode [Datastanagirk’] of Mxit’ar Goš, tr. R. W. THOMSON, Amsterdam 2000.
• The Six Voyages of John Baptista Tavernier, tr. J. PHILLIPS, London 1678.
• The Small Lawbook, ed. E. GIUNASHVILI, Tbilisi 1972 [in Georgian]
• Travels of Jean Chardin in Persia and Other Oriental Countries (Information about Georgia), ed. M. MGALOBLISHVILI, Tbilisi 1975 [in Georgian]
• Vakhushti Batonishvili, Description of the Kingdom of Georgia, ed. S. QAUKHCHISHVILI, Tbilisi 1973 [in Georgian]
• ANCHABADZE G. (2010), ‘The Church and Warfare’, in The Problems of Georgian Military History (till 1921), Tbilisi, 53-60 [in Georgian]
• ANGOLD M. (2016), ‘The Fall of Jerusalem (1187) as Viewed from Byzantium’, in The Crusader World, ed. A.J. BOAS, New York, 289-308.
• ARNOLD B. (1989), ‘German Bishops and their Military Retinues in the Medieval Empire’, German History 7/2, 161-183.
• BRUNDAGE J. A. (2003), ‘Crusades, Clerics and Violence: Reflections on a Canonical Theme’, in The Experience of Crusading, v. 1, eds. M. BULL, N. HOUSLEY, Cambridge, 147-156.
• BUBULASHVILI E. (2004), ‘From the History of the Relationship between the Orthodox Church of Georgia and Georgian Army’, Logosi 2, 23-28 [in Georgian]
• BÜHRER-THIERRY G. (2018), ‘Bishops as City Defenders in Early Medieval Gaul and Germany’, in Between Sword and Prayer: Warfare and Medieval Clergy in Cultural Perspective, eds. R. KOTECKI, J. MACIEJEWSKI, J.S. OTT, Leiden, 24-45.
• CANARD M. (1936), ‘La guerre sainte dans lt monde islamique et dans le monde chrétien’, Revue Africaine 79, 605-623.
• DENNIS C. (2018), ‘“De clericis qui pugnaverunt, aut pugnandi gratia armati fuerunt”: Bishop Geoffrey of Coutances (1048-1093) and Clerical Participation in the Battle of Hastings’, in Between Sword and Prayer: Warfare and Medieval Clergy in Cultural Perspective, eds. R. KOTECKI, J. MACIEJEWSKI, J.S. OTT, Leiden, 88-116.
• DENNIS G.T. (2001), ‘Defenders of the Christian People: Holy War in Byzantium’, in The Crusades from the Perspective of Byzantium and the Muslim World, eds. A.E. LAIOU, R.P. MOTTAHEDEH, Washington, 31-39.
• DUGGAN L.G. (2013), Armsbearing and the Clergy in the History and Canon Law of Western Christianity, Woodbridge.
• DUGGAN L.G. (2018), ‘The Evolution of Latin Canon Law on the Clergy and Armsbearing to the Thirteenth Century’, in Between Sword and Prayer: Warfare and Medieval Clergy in Cultural Perspective, eds. R. KOTECKI, J. MACIEJEWSKI, J.S. OTT, Leiden, 497-516.
• GERRARD D.M.G. (2017), The Church at War: The Military Activities of Bishops, Abbots and Other Clergy in England, c. 900-1200, London.
• HOUGHTON R. (2018), ‘Italian Bishops and Warfare during the Investiture Contest: The Case of Parma’, in Between Sword and Prayer: Warfare and Medieval Clergy in Cultural Perspective, eds. R. KOTECKI, J. MACIEJEWSKI, J.S. OTT, Leiden, 274-302.
• JAVAKHISVILI I. (1982), History of Georgian Law, v. 1, Tbilisi [in Georgian]
• JENSEN C. S. (2018), ‘Bishops and Abbots at War: Some Aspects of Clerical Involvement in Warfare in Twelfth- and Early Thirteenth-Century Livonia and Estonia’, in Between Sword and Prayer: Warfare and Medieval Clergy in Cultural Perspective, eds. R. KOTECKI, J. MACIEJEWSKI, J.S. OTT, Leiden, 404-434.
• JOHNSON E.N. (1932), The Secular Activities of the German Episcopate, 919-1024, Lincoln, NE.
• JOJUA T. (2016-2017), ‘A Fragment of the Breviary (FR.216) Copied by Grigol Bandaisdze, the Deacon of the Largvisi Monastery, Commissioned by Ksenjefore Burduli, Son of the Archpriest of Lomisi Monastery, Dated to the 1410s, from the Personal Collection of Proffessor Varlam Dondua’, The Proceedings of the Institute of History and Ethnology 14-15, 640-722 [in Georgian]
• KARTVELISHVILI T. (2006), The Gurian Episcopates, Tbilisi [in Georgian]
• KEDAR B.Z. (1999), ‘On the Origins of the Earliest Laws of Frankish Jerusalem: The Canons of the Council of Nablus, 1120’, Speculum 74/2, 310-335.
• KLIMIASHVILI A. (1961), ‘Towards the Church army in Feudal Georgia’, Proceedings of the Institute for Manuscripts 3, 95-112 [in Georgian]
• KLIMIASHVILI A. (1964), ‘Materials for the History of Kartlian and Kakhetian Military Districts’, in Several historical documents of 14th-18th cc., ed. N. SHOSHIASHVILI, Tbilisi, 121-151 [in Georgian]
• KOLBABA T. M. (1998), ‘Fighting for Christianity: Holy War in the Byzantine Empire’, Byzantion 68, 194-221.
• KOTECKI R. (2016), ‘With the Sword of Prayer, or How the Medieval Bishop Should Fight’, Quaestiones Medii Aevi Novae 21, 341-369.
• KOTECKI R. (2018), ‘Lions and Lambs, Wolves and Pastors of the Flock: Portraying Military Activity of Bishops in Twelfth-Century Poland’, in Between Sword and Prayer: Warfare and Medieval Clergy in Cultural Perspective, eds. R. KOTECKI, J. MACIEJEWSKI, J.S. OTT, Leiden, 303-340. MACIEJEWSKI J. (2018), ‘A Bishop Defends His City, or Master Vincentius’s Troubles with the Military Activity of His Superior’, in Between Sword and Prayer: Warfare and Medieval Clergy in Cultural Perspective, eds. R. KOTECKI, J. MACIEJEWSKI, J.S. OTT, Leiden, 341-368.
• MARTÍNEZ C. (2018), ‘The Episcopate and Reconquest in the Times of Alfonso VII of Castile and León’, in Between Sword and Prayer: Warfare and Medieval Clergy in Cultural Perspective, eds. R. KOTECKI, J. MACIEJEWSKI, J.S. OTT, Leiden, 207-232.
• MOROZ I. (1999), ‘The Idea of the Holy War in the Orthodox World (On Russian Chronicles from the Twelfth-Sixteenth Century)’, Quaestiones medii aevi novae 4, 45-67.
• NAKASHIAN C.M. (2016), Warrior Churchmen of Medieval England, 1000-1250: Theory and Reality, Woodbridge.
• NICHOLSON H. (2004), Medieval Warfare: Theory and Practice of War in Europe 300-1500, New York.
• RAMÍREZ P. (2018), ‘The Aragonese Episcopate and the Military Campaigns of Alfonso I the Battler against Iberian Muslims’, in Between Sword and Prayer: Warfare and Medieval Clergy in Cultural Perspective, eds. R. KOTECKI, J. MACIEJEWSKI, J.S. OTT, Leiden, 233-273.
• REUTER T. (1992), ‘Episcopi cum sua militia: The Prelate as Warrior in the Early Staufer Era’, in Warriors and Churchmen in the High Middle Ages: Essays Presented to Karl Leyser, ed. T. REUTER, London, 79-94.
• SHAORSHADZE M. (2008), ‘Some Episodes of St John Mangleli’s Life and Public Activities’, Studies in Medieval History of Georgia 9, 187-191 [in Georgian]
• STOURAITIS I. (2011), ‘Jihād and Crusade: Byzantine Positions Towards the Notions of “Holy War”’, Byzantina Symmeikta 21, 11-63.
• STOYANOV Y. (2009), ‘Norms of War in Eastern Orthodox Christianity’, in World Religions and Norms of War, eds. V. POPOVSKI, G.M. REICHBERG, N. TURNER, Tokyo, 166-218.
• STRICKLAND M. (1996), War and Chivalry: The Conduct and Perception of War in England and Normandy, 1066-1217, Cambridge.
• TABAGHUA I. (1987), Georgia in European Archives and Book Repositories (13th - first quarter of the 20th century), Tbilisi [in Georgian]
• THOMSON R. W. (2005), ‘Christian Perception of History – The Armenian Perspective’,
• in Redefining Christian Identity: Cultural Interaction in the Middle East since the Rise of Islam,
• eds. J.J. VAN GINKEL, H.L. MURRE-VAN DEN BERG, T.M. VAN LINT, Leuven, 35-44.
• TYERMAN C. (1995), ‘Were There Any Crusades in the Twelfth Century?’, English Historical Review 110, 553-577.
• VACHNADZE N. (1975), Life of Serapion Zarzmeli as a Historical Source, Tbilisi [in Georgian]
• VISCUSO P. (1995), ‘Christian Participation in Warfare: A Byzantine View’, in Peace and War in Byzantium. Essays in Honor of George T. Dennis, S. J., eds. T.S. MILLER, J. NESBITT, Washington, 33-40.
• WAŚKO A. (2018), ‘“Freedom is the Greatest Thing”: Bishops as Fighters for Freedom in Fifteenth- Century Sweden’, in Between Sword and Prayer: Warfare and Medieval Clergy in Cultural Perspective, eds. R. KOTECKI, J. MACIEJEWSKI, J.S. OTT, Leiden, 470-496.
• ЗАОЗЕРСКИЙ Н.А., ХАХАНОВ А.С. (1902), Номоканон Иоанна Постника в его редакциях: грузинской, греческой и славянской, Москва.
• СОКОЛЬСКИЙ ВЛ. (1897), ‘Греко-римское право в уложении грузинского царя Вахтанга VI’, Журнал Министерства народного просвещения 313, 53-93.

Identifiers

DOI

https://doi.org/10.34739/his.2019.08.08