Zwierzęta jako nieosobowe podmioty prawa

• Authors: Elżanowski Andrzej , Pietrzykowski Tomasz

Title variants

EN

Animals as Non-personal Carriers of Legal Rights

• Languages of publication: PL

Abstracts

EN

The current body of knowledge about the subjectivity (cognition and value-laden experience) of some non-human vertebrates makes the juristic dichotomy between commodities and persons untenable. While the great apes may (with some limitations) be treated as persons, most vertebrates are non-personal agents that lack the awareness of their own agency, which does not necessarily diminish the intrinsic value of their lives. Unfortunately, the ongoing efforts to raise the status and thus improve the treatment of all sentient animals are hindered by the lack of realistic conceptual framework for translating the current knowledge of their subjectivity and ensuing individual interests into politics and legislation. Referring to Western philosophers of law (H. Kelsen, A. Ross, N. MacCormick, L. Petrażycki) we therefore propose to grant vertebrates (and possibly some other animals if their subjectivity is recognized by science) legal rights that are appropriate for non-personal subjects even if the scope of such rights has to be very limited in comparison to the rights of human beings.

• Publisher: Fundacja „Utriusque Iuris” i Uniwersytet Jagielloński
• Journal: Forum Prawnicze
• Year: 2013
• Issue: 1 (15)
• Pages: 18-27

Contributors

author

Elżanowski Andrzej

• Komitet Biologii Ewolucyjnej i Teoretycznej PAN

author

Pietrzykowski Tomasz

• Katedra Teorii i Filozofii Prawa Uniwersytetu Śląskiego