PL EN


2015 | 1(31/2) | 45-65
Article title

The Politics of Language Policies: Hungarian Linguistic Minorities in Central Europe

Title variants
Languages of publication
EN
Abstracts
EN
The paper will adopt the position that language is an intrinsic and largely non‑negotiable part of individual culture and identity. The recognition of one’s own language receives more and more support in international political and institutional frameworks. The promotion of linguistic diversity is the official policy of the European Union. Due to such policies, it is to be expected that languages will remain in contact in the context of all sorts of levels of governance. In order to manage linguistic diversity in multilingual and multicultural areas, the introduction of a global regime of language policies is unavoidable. These policies will need to satisfy transnational requirements and conditions, like universal human rights and the norms and standards of Europeanization set by the EU, OSCE, Council of Europe, and so on. However, because there are manifold connections between language and power, as we know from the work of political scientists such as Pierre Bourdieu, and sociolinguists such as Peter Nelde, that a language element is always a part of intergroup conflict. Hence, it is to be expected that language policies will be subject to power conflicts and hegemonic strives. In order to support my claim, I will analyze the language policies of states with Hungarian language minorities in Central Europe, particularly Romania, Slovakia, Serbia (Vojvodina), and Ukraine (Trans‑Carpathia). The policies can be studied in terms of concrete variables, like individual/collective rights, territorial rearrangements, thresholds, the Language Charter, multilingual education, the linguistic landscape, and so on. The range in which these variables are instantiated is determined by local politics; hence, it is a case of the politics of language policy.
Contributors
  • University of Amsterdam
References
  • Bache I., George S., Bulmer S., Politics in the European Union, Oxford 2010.
  • Batory A., ‘Kin‑state Identity in the European Context: Citizenship, Nationalism and Constitutionalism in Hungary’, Nations and Nationalism, Vol. 16, No. 1 (2010), at .
  • Beregszászi A., Csernicskó I., ‘A magyar nyelv használatának lehetőségei Kárpátalján de jure és de facto’ in O. Nádor, L. Szarka (eds.), Nyelvi jogok, kisebbségek, nyelvpolitika Kelet‑Közép‑Európában, Budapest 2003 (Magyar Kisebbségi Könyvtár).
  • Bideleux R., Jeffries I., A History of Eastern Europe. Crisis and Change, London 1998.
  • Bowman I., The New World. Problems in Political Geography, London 1923.
  • Brubaker R. et al., Nationalist Politics and Everyday Ethnicity in a Transylvanian Town, Princeton 2006.
  • Cadzow J.F., Ludanyi A., Elteto L.J. (eds.), Transylvania. The Roots of Ethnic Conflict, Kent 1983.
  • Chaszar E., ‘Trianon and the Problem of National Minorities’ in B.K. Király, P. Pastor, I. Sanders (eds.), Essays on World War I. Total War and Peacemaking, a Case Study on Trianon, New York 1982 (War and Society in East Central Europe, 6. East European Monographs, 105. Atlantic Studies, 15).
  • Csergo Z., Talk of the Nation. Language and Conflict in Romania and Slovakia, Ithaca 2007.
  • Deets S., Networks and Composite States: Rethinking Minority Representation and Governance, Paper prepared for the International Studies Association Convention, 16 February 2010.
  • Dinan D., Ever Closer Union. An Introduction to European Integration, Basingstoke 2010.
  • European Commission, Special Eurobarometer 243: Europeans and their languages, Brussels 2006, at .
  • Extra G., Gorter D., ‘The Constellation of Languages in Europe: an Inclusive Approach’ in iidem (eds.), Multilingual Europe. Facts and Policies, Berlin 2008 (Contributions to the Sociology of Language, 96).
  • Extra G., Gorter D. (eds.), Multilingual Europe. Facts and Policies, Berlin 2008 (Contributions to the Sociology of Language, 96).
  • Fenyvesi A. (ed.), Hungarian Language Contact Outside Hungary. Studies on Hungarian as a Minority Language, Amsterdam 2005 (Impact: Studies in Language and Society, 20).
  • Fowler B., Fuzzing Citizenship, Nationalising Political Space: A Framework for Interpreting the Hungarian “Status Law” as a New Form of Kin‑state Policy in Central and Eastern Europe, Brighton 2002 (Working Papers (ESRC Research Programme on One Europe or Several?), 40/02).
  • Gal S., ‘Hungarian as a Minority Language’ in G. Extra, D. Gorter (eds.), Multilingual Europe. Facts and Policies, Berlin 2008 (Contributions to the Sociology of Language, 96).
  • Gal S., ‘Polyglot Nationalism. Alternative Perspectives on Language in 19th Century Hungary’, Langage et Société, Vol. 2, No. 136 (2011), at .
  • Goldstein E., The First World War Peace Settlements, 1919‑1925, London 2002 (Seminar Studies in History).
  • Holton R.J., Globalization and the Nation State, Basingstoke 2011.
  • Hupchick D.P., Cox H.E., The Palgrave Concise Historical Atlas of Eastern Europe, New York 2001.
  • Ivanova V., ‘Language Politics and National Equality in Socialist Yugoslavia (1945‑1974)’ in L. Marácz, M. Rosello (eds.), Multilingual Europe, Multilingual Europeans, Amsterdam 2012 (European Studies, 29).
  • Janssens R., Mamadouh V., Marácz L., ‘Languages of Regional Communication (ReLan) in Europe: Three Case Studies and a Research Agenda’ in J. Normann Jorgensen (ed.), A Toolkit for Transnational Communication in Europe, Copenhagen 2011 (Copenhagen Studies in Bilingualism, 64).
  • Jutila M., Minorities of European Orders: Evolution of Transnational Governance of Minority Rights in Europe, Paper Prepared for the ISA Annual Conference, New York, 15‑18 February 2009.
  • Kántor Z. et al. (eds.), The Hungarian Status Law. Nation Building and/or Minority Protection, Sapporo 2004 (Slavic Eurasian Studies, 4).
  • Kocsis K. (ed.), South Eastern Europe in Maps, Budapest 2005.
  • Kocsis K., Bottlik Z., Tátrai P., Etnikai térfolyamatok a Kárpát‑medence határainkon túli régióiban (1989‑2002), Budapest 2006 (Elmélet, Módszer, Gyakorlat, 61).
  • Kocsis K., Kocsis‑Hodosi E., Hungarian Minorities in the Carpathian Basin. A Study in Ethnic Geography, Toronto–Buffalo 1995.
  • Kolláth A., ‘A szlovéniai kisebbségek nyelvi jogai – különös tekintettel a magyar kisebbségre’ in O. Nádor, L. Szarka (eds.), Nyelvi jogok, kisebbségek, nyelvpolitika Kelet‑Közép‑Európában, Budapest 2003 (Magyar Kisebbségi Könyvtár).
  • Kontra M., Hattyár H. (eds.), Magyarok és nyelvtörvények, Budapest 2002 (Magyarságkutatás Könyvtára, 26).
  • Korhecz T., ‘A hivatalos nyelvhasználat jogi keretei a Vajdaságban – Szerbiában – jog és gyakorlat’, Magyar Tudomány, Vol. 11 (2009).
  • Korshunova G., Marácz L., ‘Multilingualism and Transnational Communication Strategies in Europe: From Hapsburg to the European Union’ in L. Marácz, M. Rosello (eds.), Multilingual Europe, Multilingual Europeans, Amsterdam 2012 (European Studies, 29).
  • Kovács M.M., Tóth J., ‘Kin‑state Responsibility and Ethnic Citizenship: The Hungarian Case’ in R. Bauböck et al. (eds.), Acquisition and Loss of Nationality, Vol. 1: Comparative Analyses, Amsterdam 2009 (IMISCOE Research).
  • Kymlicka W., Multicultural Citizenship. A Liberal Theory of Minority Rights, Oxford 1996 (Oxford Political Theory).
  • Kymlicka W., Multicultural Odysseys. Navigating the New International Politics of Diversity, Oxford 2007.
  • Kymlicka W., Patten A. (eds.), Language Rights and Political Theory, Oxford 2003.
  • Lábadi K., ‘Nyelvtörvények, nyelvi jogok Horvátországban’ in O. Nádor, L. Szarka (eds.), Nyelvi jogok, kisebbségek, nyelvpolitika Kelet‑Közép‑Európában, Budapest 2003 (Magyar Kisebbségi Könyvtár).
  • Marácz L., ‘European Tools of Conflict Management in Central European States with Hungarian Minorities’, Kommunikáció, Média, Gazdaság, Vol. 8, No. 1 (2010).
  • Marácz L., ‘Guarding the Hungarian Language and Identity in the New Europe: “The Nation Lives in Its Language”’ in idem (ed.), Expanding European Unity. Central and Eastern Europe, Amsterdam 1999 (Yearbook of European Studies, 11).
  • Marácz L., ‘Hybridity as a Characteristic Feature of Globalization’ in J. Róka (ed.), Globalisation, Europeanization and Other Transnational Phenomena: Description, Analyses and Generalizations, Budapest 2011.
  • Marácz L., ‘Language Policies in Central and East European States with Hungarian Minorities: Implications for Linguistic Rights Protection of National Minorities in the EU’ in I. Horváth, M. Tonk (eds.), Minority Politics within the Europe of Regions, Cluj‑Napoca 2011 (Workshop Series).
  • Marácz L., ‘Multilingualism in the Hungarian Kingdom (1867‑1918): Language Policy and Practice’ in J. Róka (ed.), Concepts & Consequences of Multilingualism in Europe, Budapest 2010.
  • Marácz L., ‘Towards a European System Guaranteeing Linguistic Minority Rights Protection: Including the Hungarian Cases’ in A. Alik (ed.), Concepts and Consequences of Multilingualism in Europe 2, Tetovo 2011.
  • Marácz L., ‘Will Hungarian Become a Lingua Franca in the Carpathian Basin?’ in B. Bodó, M. Tonk (eds.), European Union, Nations and National Minorities, Cluj‑Napoca 2009.
  • Marácz L., Rosello M. (eds.), Multilingual Europe, Multilingual Europeans, Amsterdam 2012 (European Studies, 29).
  • Maurais J., Morris M. (eds.), Languages in a Globalising World, Cambridge 2005.
  • Mintzel A., Multikulturelle Gesellschaften in Europa und Nordamerika. Konzepte, Streitfragen, Analysen, Befunde, Passau 1997 (Makroanalyse und Gesellschaftsvergleich, 2).
  • Nádor O., Szarka L. (eds.), Nyelvi jogok, kisebbségek, nyelvpolitika Kelet‑Közép‑Európában, Budapest 2003 (Magyar Kisebbségi Könyvtár).
  • Orban L., Is There a Future for Linguistic Diversity in Europe?, Speech delivered by European Commissioner for Multilingualism, 7 December 2009, at the University of Rennes, Rennes.
  • Péntek J., ‘Magyar nyelv, magyar nyelvhasználat Kolozsváron’ in A. Benő, S.N. Szilágyi (eds.), Nyelvi közösségek – nyelvi jogok, Kolozsvár 2006 (Szabó T. Attila Nyelvi Intézet Kiadványai, 3).
  • Péntek J., Benő A., ‘Nyelvi jogok Romániában’ in O. Nádor, L. Szarka (eds.), Nyelvi jogok, kisebbségek, nyelvpolitika Kelet‑Közép‑Európában, Budapest 2003 (Magyar Kisebbségi Könyvtár).
  • Plank P.H. van der, Etnische zuivering in Midden‑Europa. Natievorming en Staatsburgerschap in de XXe eeuw, Leeuwarden 2004 (Acta Launiana, 2).
  • Rindler Schjerve R. (ed.), Diglossia and Power. Language Policies and Practice in the 19th Century Habsburg Empire, Berlin 2003 (Language, Power and Social Process, 9).
  • Rindler Schjerve R., Vetter E., European Multilingualism. Current Perspectives and Challenges, Bristol 2012 (Second Language Acquisition, 147).
  • Sarnyai C.M., Pap T., ‘Personal Autonomy and/or National Councils in Vojvodina’ in I. Horváth, M. Tonk (eds.), Minority Politics within the Europe of Regions, Cluj‑Napoca 2011 (Workshop Series).
  • Sasse G., EU Conditionality and Minority Rights. Translating the Copenhagen Criterion into Policy, San Domenicao (Fl) 2005 (EUI Working Papers, 16).
  • Sasse G., ‘The Politics of EU Conditionality: the Norm of Minority Protection during and beyond EU Accession’, Journal of European Public Policy, Vol. 15, No. 6 (2008), at .
  • Schöpflin G., Hungary and its Neighbours, Paris 1993 (Chaillot Papers, 7).
  • Schwellnus G., ‘The Adoption of Nondiscrimination and Minority Protection Rules in Romania, Hungary, and Poland’ in F. Schimmelfennig, U. Sedelmeier (eds.), The Europeanization of Central and Eastern Europe, Ithaca 2005 (Cornell Studies in Political Economy).
  • Skovgaard J., Towards a European Norm? The Framing of the Hungarian Minorities in Romania and Slovakia by the Council of Europe, the EU and the OCSE, Florence 2007 (EUI Working Papers SPS, 7).
  • Smith A.D., National Identity, London 1991 (Penguin Politics and Current Affairs).
  • Szabómihály G., ‘A szlovákiai kisebbségek nyelvi jogai és a kisebbségi nyelvhasználat színterei, különös tekintettel a magyar közösségre’ in O. Nádor, L. Szarka (eds.), Nyelvi jogok, kisebbségek, nyelvpolitika Kelet‑Közép‑Európában, Budapest 2003 (Magyar Kisebbségi Könyvtár).
  • Szarka L., ‘Államnyelv, hivatalos nyelv – kisebbségi jogok Kelet‑Közép‑Európában’ in O. Nádor, L. Szarka (eds.), Nyelvi jogok, kisebbségek, nyelvpolitika Kelet‑Közép‑Európában, Budapest 2003 (Magyar Kisebbségi Könyvtár).
  • Szilágyi I., A vajdasági statútum történelmi, politikai elözményei, az elfogadás körülményei, Budapest 2009.
  • Szoták S., ‘Az ausztriai kisebbségek nyelvi jogai – különös tekintettel a magyar kisebbségekre’ in O. Nádor, L. Szarka (eds.), Nyelvi jogok, kisebbségek, nyelvpolitika Kelet‑Közép‑Európában, Budapest 2003 (Magyar Kisebbségi Könyvtár).
  • Teleki P., The Evolution of Hungary and its Place in European History, New York 1923.
  • Tóth Á., National and Ethnic Minorities in Hungary, 1920‑2001, trans. by N. Arato, Boulder 2005 (East European Monographs, 698. Atlantic Studies on Society in Change, 124).
  • Tóth J., ‘Kin Minority, Kin‑state and Neighbourhood Policy in the Enlarged Europe’, Central European Political Science Review, No. 17 (2004).
  • Trifunovska S. (ed.), Minority Rights in Europe. European Minorities and Languages, The Hague 2001 (Minority Rights in Europe).
  • Vertovec S., Transnationalism, New York 2010 (Key Ideas).
  • Vizi B., ‘Az Európai Unió és a kisebbségi nyelvek’ in O. Nádor, L. Szarka (eds.), Nyelvi jogok, kisebbségek, nyelvpolitika Kelet‑Közép‑Európában, Budapest 2003 (Magyar Kisebbségi Könyvtár).
  • Vizi B., ‘Minority Languages and Multilingualism in Europe and in the European Union’ in L. Marácz, M. Rosello (eds.), Multilingual Europe, Multilingual Europeans, Amsterdam 2012 (European Studies, 29).
  • Volman Y., ‘The Lisbon Treaty and Linguistic Diversity: Policy and Practice in the European Institutions’ in L. Marácz, M. Rosello (eds.), Multilingual Europe, Multilingual Europeans, Amsterdam 2012 (European Studies, 29).
  • Wiener A., Diez T., European Integration Theory, Oxford 2009.
Document Type
Publication order reference
YADDA identifier
bwmeta1.element.desklight-30a2214c-bf58-4600-8120-9f23a7ecbde8
JavaScript is turned off in your web browser. Turn it on to take full advantage of this site, then refresh the page.