2019 | 1 | 69-87
Article title

National and European Identity – Opposing or Complementary Concepts in Czech, Polish and EU Law?

Title variants
Languages of publication
This article gives a practical overview of the legal aspect of European identity and the role it plays in the EU Law. It analyses the mutual relationship and legal function of two concepts of European Union Law: national identity and European identity. It also summarises the functioning of national identity concepts in Czech and Polish constitutional practice and compares it with practice in the European Union.
Physical description
  • Bakke E., The principle of national self-determination in Czechoslovak constitutions 1920–1992, “Central European Political Science Review”, vol. 3, no. 10/2002.
  • Calda M., Constitution-Making in the Post-Communist Countries: A Case of the Czech Republic,
  • Case H., Being European: East and West, in: European identity, J.T. Checkel, P.J. Katzenstein (eds.), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2009.
  • Cloots E., National Identity in EU Law, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2015.
  • Davies B., Resistance to European Law and Constitutional Identity in Germany: Herbert Kraus and Solange in its Intellectual Context, “European Law Journal”, vol. 21, issue 4.
  • Domańska A., Zasada suwerenności narodu. Rozważania na tle art. 4 Konstytucji RP z 1997 r., (Principle of national sovereignty. Reflections on the basis of Article 4 of the Polish Constitution of 1997), 11089/22960.
  • Faraguna P., Constitutional Identity – a Shield or a Sword? The Dilemma of Constitutional Identities in the EU, (13.10.2018).
  • Fligstein N., Euroclash: the EU, European Identity, and the Future of Europe, Oxford University Press, Oxford; New York 2008.
  • Follesdal A., Why there is a democratic deficit in the EU: A response to Majone and Moravcsik, “Journal of Common Market Studies”, vol. 44, issue 3, pp. 553–562.
  • Guild E., The legal elements of European identity: EU citizenship and migration law, Kluwer Law International, The Hague; 2004.
  • Harding Ch., The Identity of European Law: Mapping Out the European Legal Space, “European Law Review”, vol. 6, issue 2.
  • European identity revisited: new approaches and recent empirical evidence, eds. V. Kaina, I.P. Karolewski, S. Kuhn, Routledge: Taylor & Francis Group, London; New York, NY 2017.
  • Karolewski I.P., The citizenship – identity nexus in the EU revisited, in: European identity revisited: new approaches and recent empirical evidence, eds. V. Kaina, I.P. Karolewski, S. Kuhn, Routledge: Taylor & Francis Group, London; New York, NY 2017.
  • Kłoczowski J., Patriotyzm polski w długim trwaniu (Polish Patriotism In the Long Term), in: Patriotyzm wczoraj i dziś. (Patriotism yesterday and today), Seminarium, Polskiej Akademii Umiejętności 2002”, Kraków 2003, „Prace Naukowe Akademii im. Jana Długosza in Częstochowa”, vol.XX/2011.
  • Konstytucje w Polsce 1791–1990 (Constitutions in Poland 1791–1990), eds. T. Kołodziejczyk, M. Pomianowska, Wydawnictwo Przemiany, Warsaw 1990.
  • Konstadinides T., Constitutional Identity as a Shield and as a Sword: The European Legal Order within the Framework of National Constitutional Settlement, “Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies”, vol. 13/2011.
  • Kornacka-Skwara E., Tożsamość narodowa w świetle przemian kulturowych (National identity in the light of cultural changes), „Prace Naukowe Akademii im. Jana Długosza w Częstochowie”, vol. XX/2011, pp. 113–120.
  • Kuciński J., Wołpiuk W.J., Zasady ustroju politycznego państwa w Konstytucji Rzeczpospolitej Polskiej z 1997 roku (Principles of the political system of the state in the Constitution of the Republic of Poland of 1997), Wolters Kluwer, Warszawa 2012.
  • Lehning P.B., European Citizenship: Toward a European Identity?, “Law and Philosophy”, vol. 20/2001.
  • Maršálek P., Evropská integrace, unijní občanství a česká národní identita (European Integration, Union Citizenship and Czech National Identity), „Acta Universitatis Carolinae – Iuridica“, vol. 2/2014.
  • McKitterick R., Charlamagne: the formation of a European identity, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2008, CBO9780511803314.
  • Mlsna P., Občanství národních států a Evropské unie – filozofické základy a vývoj (Citizenship of National States and the European Union – Philosophical Basis and Development), “Acta Universitatis Caroliniae – Iuridica”, no. 2/2014.
  • Öbrink-Hobzová M., Siarda-Trochtová L., Sobková P., Národní identita v multikulturním prostředí (National identity in multicultural environment), “Sociální pedagogika/Social Education”, 2017
  • Přibáň J., Legal symbolism: on law, time and European identity, Ashgate Publishing, Aldershot; Burlington 2007.
  • Resta G., Beethoven’s Ninth and the Quest for European Identity. A Law and Music Perspective, in: Law and Opera, eds. F. Annunziata, G.F. Co lombo, Springer, 2018,
  • Sarmiento D., The EU’s Legal Identity and the Three Normative Ideals, in: National Constitutional Identity and European Integration, eds. A. Saiz Arnaiz, C. Alcoberro Llivina, Intersentia 2013.
  • Vlachová K., Řeháková B., Národ, národní identita a národní hrdost v Evropě (Nation, national identity and national pride in Europe), “Sociologický časopis/Czech Sociological Review”, vol. 40, no. 4/2004, pp. 489–508. von Bogdandy A., Schill S., Overcoming Absolute Primacy: Respect for NationalIdentity under the Lisbon Treaty, “Common Market Law Review”,vol. 48, issue 1.
  • von Bogdandy A., The European Union as a Human Rights Organization? Human Rights and the Core of the European Union, “Common Market Law Review”.
  • von Bogdandy A., The European Constitution and the European Identity: Text and Subtext of the Treaty establishing the Constitution for Europe, “InternationalJournal of Constitutional Law”, vol. 3, issue 2–3.
  • Wołpiuk W.J., Naród jako pojęcie konstytucyjne (Nation as a constitutional koncept), „Studia Iuridica Lublinensia“, vol. 22/2014.
  • Zpěvák A., Co je co? Národ, nacionalismus a národní identita (What is what? Nation, nationalism and national identity), “Časopis argument”,
Document Type
Publication order reference
YADDA identifier
JavaScript is turned off in your web browser. Turn it on to take full advantage of this site, then refresh the page.