Full-text resources of CEJSH and other databases are now available in the new Library of Science.
Visit https://bibliotekanauki.pl

PL EN


Journal

2017 | 7(64/1) | 107-147

Article title

Retoryka i socjo-retoryka w lekturze tekstów Nowego Testamentu Cz. 2: Socjo-retoryka – projekt holistycznej lektury tekstu

Authors

Content

Title variants

EN
Rhetorical and Socio-Rhetorical Reading of New Testament Texts. Part II: Socio-Rhetoric: the Project of the Holistic Reading of Text

Languages of publication

PL EN

Abstracts

EN
Abstract: In the second part of the article on the rhetorical and socio-rhetorical reading of the New Testament texts, the author focuses on the socio-rhetorical approach. It is presented as a remedy to the fragmentary character of the sociological and anthropological studies on the Bible. The stress on the close reading of the text inherent in the socio-rhetoric gives both sociology and anthropology the anchorage they need not to stray from the main object of their inquiry. The author with broad strokes depicts the development and main concepts of the socio-rhetorical methodology. Then, he explains the six stages implied in the method: the analysis of inner texture, intertexture, social and cultural texture, ideological texture, sacred texture and the so called rhetorolects. The article finishes with the concise conclusions on the advantages of using the socio-rhetoric in comparison to the deficient and outdated historical-critical methodology.

Contributors

  • Instytut Nauk Biblijnych, Wydział Teologii, Katolicki Uniwersytet Lubelski Jana Pawła II

References

  • Alter, R., The Art of Biblical Narrative (New York: Basic Books 1981).
  • Anderson, J.C. – Moore, S.D., Mark & Method. New Approaches in Biblical Studies (Minneapolis: Fortress Press 1992).
  • Bloomquist, L.G., „A Possible Direction for Providing Programmatic Correlation of Textures in Socio-Rhetorical Analysis”, Rhetorical Criticism of the Bible. A Comprehensive Bibliography with Notes on History and Method (red. D.F. Watson – A.J. Hauser) (Biblical interpretation series 4; Leiden – New York: Brill 1994) 61–96.
  • Bloomquist, L.G., „Methodological Considerations in the Determination of the Social Context of Cynic Rhetorical Practice: Implications for our Present Studies of the Jesus Traditions”, The Rhetorical Analysis of Scripture. Essays from the 1995 London Conference (red. S.E. Porter – T.H. Olbricht) (Journal for the study of the New Testament. Supplement series 146; Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press 1997) 200–231.
  • Bloomquist, L.G., „Methodological Criteria for the Determination of Apocalyptic Rhetoric: A Suggestion for the Expanded Use of Socio-Rhetorical Analysis’”, Vision and Persuasion. Rhetorical Dimensions of Apocalyptic Discourse (red. G. Carey – L.G. Bloomquist) (St. Louis, MO: Chalice Press 1999) 181–203.
  • Borgen, P. – Robbins, V.K. – Gowler, D.B. (red.), Recruitment, Conquest, and Conflict. Strategies in Judaism, Early Christianity, and the Greco-Roman World (Emory studies in early Christianity 6; Atlanta, GA: Scholars Press 1998).
  • Burke, K., Counter-Statement (Los Altos, CA: Hermes Publications 21953).
  • Castelli, E.A., Imitating Paul. A Discourse of Power (Literary currents in biblical interpretation; Louisville, KY: Westminster; John Knox Press 1991).
  • Chatman, S.B., Story and Discourse. Narrative Structure in Fiction and Film (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press 1978).
  • Combrink, B.H., The Challenge of Making and Redrawing Boundaries. A Perspective on Socio-Rhetorical Criticism . http://www.religion.emory.edu/faculty/robbins/SRS/combrink/ChallengeBoundSRC.pdf, 17. April 2016.
  • Combrink, B.H., The Challenges and Opportunities of a Socio-Rhetorical Commentary . http://www.religion.emory.edu/faculty/robbins/SRS/combrink/CombrinkSRCommentary.pdf, 17. April 2016.
  • Crossan, J.D., In Parables. The Challenge of the Historical Jesus (New York: Harper & Row 1973).
  • Culpepper, R.A., Anatomy of the Fourth Gospel. A Study in Literary Design (Foundations and facets : New Testament; Philadelphia: Fortress Press 1983).
  • Culpepper, R.A., „Mapping the Textures of New Testament Criticism. A Response to Socio-Rhetorical Criticism”, Journal for the Study of the New Testament 70 (1998) 71–77.
  • DeSilva, D.A., „A Sociorhetorical Interpretation of Revelation 14:6-13. A Call to Act Justly toward the Just and Judging God”, Bulletin for Biblical Research 9 (1999) 65–117.
  • DeSilva, D.A., Perseverance in Gratitude. A Socio-Rhetorical Commentary on the Epistle "to the Hebrews" (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans 2000).
  • Elliott, J.H., A Home for the Homeless. A Sociological Exegesis of 1 Peter, Its Situation and Strategy (Philadelphia: Fortress Press 1981).
  • Esler, P.F., Community and Gospel in Luke-Acts. The Social and Political Motivations of Lucan Theology (Society for New Testament Studies Monograph Series 57; Cambridge – New York: Cambridge University Press 1987).
  • Fauconnier, G. – Turner, M., The Way We Think. Conceptual Blending and the Mind's Hidden Complexities (New York: Basic Books 2002).
  • Flanagan, J.W., „Ancient Perceptions of Space/Perceptions of Ancient Space”, Semeia 37 (1999) 15–43.
  • Fowler, R.M., Let the Reader Understand. Reader-Response Criticism and the Gospel of Mark (Minneapolis: Fortress Press 1991).
  • Gager, J.G., Kingdom and Community. The Social World of Early Christianity (Prentice-Hall studies in religion series; Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall 1975).
  • Gager, J.G., „Shall We Marry our Enemies: Sociology and the New Testament”, Interpretation 36/3 (1982) 256–265.
  • Gowler, D.B., Host, Guest, Enemy, and Friend. Portraits of the Pharisees in Luke and Acts (Emory studies in early Christianity 2; New York: Peter Lang 1991).
  • Gowler, D.B., „The Development of Socio-Rhetorical Criticism”, New Boundaries in Old Territory. Form and Social Rhetoric in Mark (red. V.K. Robbins – D.B. Gowler) (Emory studies in early Christianity 3; New York: Peter Lang 1994) 1–36.
  • Gowler, D.B., „Socio-Rhetorical Interpretation: Textures of a Text and its Reception”, Journal for the Study of the New Testament 33/2 (2010) 191–206.
  • Gowler, D.B., „The End of the Beginning. The Continuing Maturation of Socio-Rhetorical Analysis”, Sea Voyages and Beyond. Emerging Strategies in Socio-rhetorical Interpretation (Emory studies in early Christianity 14; Blanford Forum, Dorset: Deo Publishing 2010).
  • Hock, R.F. – O'Neil, E.N., The Chreia in Ancient Rhetoric (Texts and translations Graeco-Roman religion series 9; Atlanta, GA: Scholars Press 1986).
  • Horrell, D.G., „Ideology in Pauline Christianity A Structuration Theory Perspective”, Modelling Early Christianity. Social-Scientific Studies of the New Testament and Its Context (red. P.F. Esler) (London – New York: Routledge 1995) 219–231.
  • Jewett, R., The Thessalonian Correspondence. Pauline Rhetoric and Millenarian Piety (Foundations and facets; Philadelphia: Fortress Press 1986).
  • Lausberg, H. – Orton, D.E. – Anderson, R.D., Handbook of Literary Rhetoric. A Foundation for Literary Study (Leiden – Boston: Brill 1998).
  • Loubser, J.A., „Media Criticism and The Myth of Paul, The Creative Genius, and His Forgotten Co-Workers”, Neotestamentica 34/2 (2000) 329–345.
  • MacK, B.L., Rhetoric and the New Testament (Guides to biblical scholarship. New Testament series; Minneapolis: Fortress Press 1990).
  • Meeks, W.A., „The Man from Heaven in Johannine Sectarianism”, Journal of Biblical Literature 91/1 (1972) 44–72.
  • Meeks, W.A., „"Since Then You Would Need to Go Out of the World”. Group Boundaries in Pauline Christianity’”, Critical History and Biblical Faith. New Testament Perspectives (red. T.J. Ryan) (Annual publication of the College Theology Society; Villanova, PA: College Theology Society; Horizons 1979) 4–29.
  • Meeks, W.A., The moral world of the first Christians (Library of early Christianity 6; Philadelphia: Westminster Press 11986).
  • Meier, J.P., A Marginal Jew. Vol. 1: The Roots of the Problem and the Person (The Anchor Bible reference library; New York: Doubleday 1991).
  • Papieska Komisja Biblijna, Interpretacja Pisma Świętego w Kościele (Poznań: Pallotinum 1994).
  • Rhoads, D.M. – Michie, D., Mark as Story. An Introduction to the Narrative of a Gospel (Philadelphia: Fortress Press 1982).
  • Robbins, V.K., Beginnings and Developments in Socio-Rhetorical Interpretation . http://www.religion.emory.edu/faculty/robbins/Pdfs/SRIBegDevRRA.pdf.
  • Robbins, V.K., „A Socio-Rhetorical Response: Contexts of Interaction and Forms of Exhortation”, Semeia 50 (1980) 261–271.
  • Robbins, V.K., „Summons and Outline in Mark. The Three-Step Progression”, Novum Testamentum : an international quarterly for New Testament and related studies XXIII (1981) 97–114.
  • Robbins, V.K., „Mark 1.14-20. An interpretation at the intersection of Jewish and Graeco-Roman traditions”, New Testament Studies : published quarterly under the auspices of Studiorum Novi Testamenti Societas XXVIII (1982) 220–236.
  • Robbins, V.K., Jesus the Teacher. A Socio-Rhetorical Interpretation of Mark (Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press 1984).
  • Robbins, V.K., „Rhetorical Argument about Lamps and Light in Early Christian Gospels”, Context: Essays in Honor of Peder Borgen (red. P.W. Bøckman – R.E. Kristiansen) (Trondheim: Tapir 1987) 177–195.
  • Robbins, V.K., „The Woman who Touched Jesus' Garment: Socio-Rhetorical Analysis of the Synoptic Accounts”, New Testament Studies 33 (1987) 502–515.
  • Robbins, V.K., „Foxes, Birds, Burials & Furrows”, Patterns of Persuasion in the Gospels (red. B.L. MacK – V.K. Robbins) (Santa Rosa, CA: Polebridge 1989) 69–84.
  • Robbins, V.K., „Luke-Acts: A Mixed Population Seeks a Home in the Roman Empire”, Images of Empire (red. L. Alexander) (Journal for the study of the Old Testament. Supplement series 122; Sheffield: JSOT Press 1991) 202–221.
  • Robbins, V.K., „Writing as a Rhetorical Act in Plutarch and the Gospels”, Persuasive artistry. Studies in New Testament rhetoric in honor of George A. Kennedy (red. G.A. Kennedy – D.F. Watson) (Journal for the study of the New Testament. Supplement series 50; Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press 1991) 157–186.
  • Robbins, V.K., „The Reversed Contextualization of Psalm 22 in the Markan Crucifixion: A Socio-Rhetorical Analysis”, The four gospels 1992. Festschrift Frans Neirynck (red. F. van Segbroeck – F. Neirynck) (Bibliotheca Ephemeridum theologicarum Lovaniensium 100,3; Leuven: Univ. Press [u.a.] (1992)) 1161–1183.
  • Robbins, V.K., „Progymnasmatic Rhetorical Composition and Pre-Gospel Traditions. A New Approach”, The Synoptic Gospels. Source criticism and the new literary criticism (red. C. Focant) (Bibliotheca Ephemeridum theologicarum Lovaniensium 110; Leuven: University Press; Peeters 1993) 111–147.
  • Robbins, V.K., „Oral, Rhetorical, and Literary Cultures. A Response”, Semeia 65 (1994) 75–91.
  • Robbins, V.K., „Socio-Rhetorical Criticism: Mary, Elizabeth, and the Magnificat as a Test Case”, The New Literary Criticism and the New Testament (red. E.S. Malbon – E.V. McKnight) (Valley Forge, PA: Trinity Press 1994) 164–209.
  • Robbins, V.K., „Divine Dialogue and the Lord's Prayer. Socio-Rhetorical Interpretation of Sacred Texts”, Dialogue 28/3 (1995) 117–146.
  • Robbins, V.K., „Social-Scientific Criticism and Literary Studies. Prospects for Cooperation in Biblical Interpretation”, Modelling Early Christianity. Social-Scientific Studies of the New Testament and Its Context (red. P.F. Esler) (London – New York: Routledge 1995) 274–289.
  • Robbins, V.K., Exploring the Texture of Texts. A Guide to Socio-Rhetorical Interpretation (Valley Forge, PA: Trinity Press 1996).
  • Robbins, V.K., „Making Christian Culture in the Epistle of James”, Scriptura 59 (1996) 341–351.
  • Robbins, V.K., „The Dialectical Nature of Early Christian Discourse”, Scriptura 59 (1996) 353–362.
  • Robbins, V.K., The Tapestry of Early Christian Discourse. Rhetoric, Society, and Ideology (London: Routledge 1996).
  • Robbins, V.K., „Rhetorical Composition and Sources in the Gospel of Thomas”, 1997 seminar papers. One hundred thirty-third annual meeting, November 22-25, 1997, San Francisco Hilton, Hotel Nikko, and Parc Fifty-five Hotel, San Francisco, California (Society of Biblical literature seminar papers series 36; Atlanta, GA: Scholars Press 1997) 86–114.
  • Robbins, V.K., „The Present and Future of Rhetorical Analysis”, The Rhetorical Analysis of Scripture. Essays from the 1995 London Conference (red. S.E. Porter – T.H. Olbricht) (Journal for the study of the New Testament. Supplement series 146; Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press 1997) 24–52.
  • Robbins, V.K., „From Enthymeme to Theology in Luke 11:1-13”, Literary studies in Luke-Acts. Essays in honor of Joseph B. Tyson (red. J.B. Tyson – R.P. Thompson – T.E. Phillips) (Macon, GA: Mercer University Press 1998) 191–214.
  • Robbins, V.K., „Socio-Rhetorical Hermeneutics and Commentary”, Epi to Auto. Studies in Honour of Petr Pokorný on His Sixty-Fifth Birthday (red. J. Keřkovský – P. Pokorný) (Praha: Mlýn 1998) 284–297.
  • Robbins, V.K., „Rhetorical Ritual: Apocalyptic Discourse in Mark 13”, Vision and Persuasion. Rhetorical Dimensions of Apocalyptic Discourse (red. G. Carey – L.G. Bloomquist) (St. Louis, MO: Chalice Press 1999) 95–121.
  • Robbins, V.K., „The Claims of the Prologues and Greco-Roman Rhetoric. The Prefaces to Luke and Acts in Light of Greco-Roman Rhetorical Strategies.”, Jesus and the heritage of Israel. Luke's narrative claim upon Israel's legacy (red. D.P. Moessner) (Luke the interpreter of Israel 1; Harrisburg, PA: Trinity Press 1999) 63–83.
  • Robbins, V.K., „Rhetoric and Culture: Exploring Types of Cultural Rhetoric in a Text”, Rhetoric and the New Testament. Essays from the 1992 Heidelberg Conference (red. S.E. Porter – T.H. Olbricht) (Journal for the study of the New Testament. Supplement series 90; Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press 2001) 443–463.
  • Robbins, V.K., „Argumentative Textures in Socio-Rhetorical Interpretation”, Rhetorical Argumentation in Biblical Texts. Essays from the Lund 2000 Conference (red. A. Eriksson – T.H. Olbricht – W.G. Übelacker) (Emory studies in early Christianity 8; Harrisburg, PA: Trinity Press 2002) 27–65.
  • Robbins, V.K., „The Intertexture of Apocalyptic Discourse in the Gospel of Mark”, The Intertexture of Apocalyptic Discourse in the New Testament (red. D.F. Watson) (Society of Biblical Literature symposium series no. 14; Atlanta, GA: Society of Biblical Literature 2002) 11–44.
  • Robbins, V.K., „The Sensory-Aesthetic Texture of the Compassionate Samaritan Parable in Luke 10”, Literary Encounters with the Reign of God (red. S.H. Ringe – H.C.P. Kim) (New York: T & T Clark 2004) 247–264.
  • Robbins, V.K., „Bodies and Politics in Luke 1-2 and Sirach 44-50: Men, Women, and Boys”, Scriptura 90 (2005) 824–838.
  • Robbins, V.K., „The Rhetorical Full-Turn in Biblical Interpretation and Its Relevance for Feminist Hermeneutics”, Her Master's Tools? Feminist and Postcolonial Engagements of Historical-Critical Discourse (red. C. Vander Stichele – T.C. Penner) (Global perspectives on biblical scholarship no. 9; Leiden – Boston: Brill 2005) 109–127.
  • Robbins, V.K., „Interfaces of Orality and Literature in the Gospel of Mark”, Performing the Gospel. Orality, memory, and Mark : essays dedicated to Werner Kelber (red. R.A. Horsley – J.A. Draper – J.M. Foley – W.H. Kelber) (Minneapolis, MN: Fortress 2006) 125–146.
  • Robbins, V.K., „Oral Performance in Q: Epistemology, Political Conflict, and Contextual Register”, Oral Performance, Popular Tradition, and Hidden Transcript in Q (red. R.A. Horsley) (Society of Biblical Literature Semeia Studies 60; Atlanta: Society of Biblical Literature 2006) 109–122.
  • Robbins, V.K., „Conceptual Blending and Early Christian Imagination”, Explaining Christian origins and early Judaism. Contributions from cognitive and social science (red. P. Luomanen – I. Pyysiäinen – R. Uro) (Biblical interpretation series v. 89; Leiden – Boston: Brill 2007) 161–195.
  • Robbins, V.K., „Rhetography: A New Way of Seeing the Familiar Text”, Words Well Spoken. George Kennedy's Rhetoric of the New Testament (red. C.C. Black – D.F. Watson) (Studies in rhetoric and religion 8; Waco, TX: Baylor University Press 2008) 81–106.
  • Robbins, V.K., The Invention of Christian Discourse (Rhetoric of religious antiquity series 1; Blandford Forum: Deo Pub 2009).
  • Robbins, V.K., Sea Voyages and Beyond. Emerging Strategies in Socio-rhetorical Interpretation (Emory studies in early Christianity 14; Blanford Forum, Dorset: Deo Publishing 2010).
  • Robbins, V.K., „Precreation Discourse and the Nicene Creed: Christianity Finds its Voice in the Roman Empire”, Religion & Theology 18/3-4 (2011) 334–350.
  • Robbins, V.K. – Gowler, D.B. (red.), New Boundaries in Old Territory. Form and Social Rhetoric in Mark (Emory studies in early Christianity 3; New York: Peter Lang 1994).
  • Robbins, V.K. – Gowler, D.B. – Bloomquist, L.G. – Watson, D.F., Fabrics of Discourse. Essays in Honor of Vernon K. Robbins (Harrisburg, PA: Trinity Press 2003).
  • Roberts, K.A., „Toward a Generic Concept of Counter-Culture”, Sociological Focus 11 (1978) 111–126.
  • Runesson, A., Exegesis in the making. Postcolonialism and New Testament studies (Leiden – Boston: Brill 2011).
  • Segovia, F.F., Decolonizing biblical studies. A view from the margins (Maryknoll, NY: Orbis Books 2000).
  • Smith, J.Z., „The Social Description of Early Christianity”, Religious Studies Review 1 (1975) 19–25.
  • Smith, J.Z., Drudgery Divine. On the Comparison of early Christianities and the Religions of Late Antiquity (Chicago studies in the history of Judaism 14; Chicago: University of Chicago Press 1990).
  • Tannehill, R.C., The Sword of His Mouth (Semeia supplements 1; Philadelphia: Fortress Press 1975).
  • Trible, P., God and the Rhetoric of Dexuality (Overtures to biblical theology 2; Philadelphia: Fortress Press 1978).
  • Trible, P., Texts of Terror. Literary-Feminist Readings of Biblical Narratives (The Lyman Beecher lectures at Yale, 1981-1982 13; Philadelphia: Fortress Press 1984).
  • Via, D.O., The Parables. Their Literary and Existential Dimension (Philadelphia: Fortress Press 1967).
  • Watson, D.F., „Why We Need Socio-Rhetorical Commentary and What It Might Look Like”, Rhetorical Criticism of the Bible. A Comprehensive Bibliography with Notes on History and Method (red. D.F. Watson – A.J. Hauser) (Biblical interpretation series 4; Leiden – New York: Brill 1994) 129–157.
  • Watson, D.F. (red.), Miracle Discourse in the New Testament (Atlanta: Society of Biblical Literature 2012).
  • Watson, D.F. – Robbins, V.K., „Dialogue Between Vernon Robbins and the Reviewers”, Journal for the Study of the New Testament 20/70 (1998) 109–115.
  • Wilde, J.A., „The Social World of Mark’s Gospel: A Word about Method”, Society of Biblical Literature I978 Seminar Papers (red. J.P. Achtemeier) (Missoula, MT: Scholars Press 1978) 47–70.
  • Wilder, A.N., The Language of the Gospel. Early Christian Rhetoric (New York: Harper & Row 1964).
  • Witherington, B., Conflict and Community in Corinth. A Socio-Rhetorical Commentary on 1 and 2 Corinthians (Grand Rapids MI. – Carlisle: Eerdmans; Paternoster Press 1995).
  • Witherington, B., The Acts of the Apostles. A Socio-Rhetorical Commentary (Grand Rapids, Mich. – Carlisle, U.K.: Eerdmans; Paternoster Press 1998).
  • Witherington, B., The Gospel of Mark. A Socio-Rhetorical Commentary (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans 2001).
  • Witherington, B., 1 and 2 Thessalonians. A Socio-Rhetorical Commentary (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans 2006).
  • Witherington, B., A Socio-Rhetorical Commentary on Titus, 1-2 Timothy and 1-3 John (Letters and homilies for Hellenized Christians Volume 1; Downers Grove, IL: IVP Academic 2006).
  • Witherington, B., A Socio-Rhetorical Commentary on 1-2 Peter (Letters and homilies for Hellenized Christians Volume 2; Downers Grove, IL: IVP Academic 2007).
  • Witherington, B., Letters and Homilies for Jewish Christians. A Socio-Rhetorical Commentary on Hebrews, James and Jude (Downers Grove, IL. – Nottingham, UK: IVP Academic; Apollos 2007).
  • Witherington, B., Paul's Letter to the Philippians. A Socio-Rhetorical Commentary (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans 2011).
  • Witherington, B. – Hyatt, D., Paul's Letter to the Romans. A Socio-Rhetorical Commentary (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans 2004).

Document Type

Publication order reference

Identifiers

EISSN
2451-2168
ISSN
2083-2222

YADDA identifier

bwmeta1.element.desklight-50ab5a4c-c49f-407b-a085-c6bb34716431
JavaScript is turned off in your web browser. Turn it on to take full advantage of this site, then refresh the page.