Czy prawa człowieka mają charakter normatywny?

• Authors: Andres Ollero

Title variants

EN

ARE THE HUMAN RIGHTS NORMATIVE?

• Languages of publication: PL

Abstracts

EN

The paper points to the validity of the question indicated in its title and concerning the nature of human rights. The issue presented in the paper tries to answer the question concerning the normativity of these rights. For this purpose, the paper raises a number of fundamental problems, such as constantly controversial relationship between law and morality, formulation in a controversial way of rules and standards so-called positive law and the alleged hard choice between the parallel situated – the legal system and the natural law. In addition, also an important topic of coexistence of different anthropological concepts as different points of view on valuation and understanding of the law is emphasized. For this purpose author describes the transition from an individualistic anthropology through collectivism, to anthropology involving the legal regulation of social relations, which is related to the consecutive generations of human rights. Subsequently, the subject of consideration is the legal order. Namely, the author wonders whether it can be considered as composed only of norms or it includes also the rules, the same, or, more normative and significant than the norms. Author also leans over the controversial problem indicating that the empowerment of liberty and equality, which may serve as the basis of rights is in the law of nature, as well as over the lack of existence of unlimited rights, so that he eventually comes to the conclusion that, although there are no right before law, there are laws that overtake the state.

Keywords

PL

Prawa człowieka; Prawo konstytucyjne

EN

Human rights; Constitutional Law

• Publisher: Wydawnictwo Naukowe Uniwersytetu Szczecińskiego
• Journal: Acta Iuris Stetinensis
• Year: 2011
• Issue: 2
• Pages: 5 - 27

Contributors

author

Andres Ollero

• Uniwersytet Rey Juan Carlos (MADRYT)

References

• N. Bobbio,Presente y porvenir de los derechos humanos "Anuario de Derechos Humanos" 1981 (1);
• R.Dworkin,Taking Rights seriously London, Duckworth, 2005;
• J.Finnis,Natural Law and Natural Rights Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1999;
• K. Marks, Thesen über Feuerbach; en Marx-Engels Werke Institut für Marxismus-Leninismus, Berlin, Dietz, 1969, tom 3;
• A.Ollero, De la protección de la intimidad al poder de control sobre los datos personales. Exigencias jurídico-naturales e historicidad en la jurisprudencia constitucional Madrid, Real Academia de Ciencias Morales y Políticas, 2008;
• A.Ollero, Derechos humanos. Entre la moral y el derecho México, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, 2007;
• A.Ollero, Discriminación por razón de sexo. Valores, principios y normas en la jurisprudencia constitucional española Madrid, Centro de Estudios Políticos y Constitucionales, 1999;
• A.Ollero, El derecho en teoría Cizur Menor, Thomson-Aranzadi, 2007;
• A.Ollero, La coexistencialidad ontológica como fundamento del derecho "Persona y Derecho" 1982 (9);
• A.Ollero, La ponderación delimitadora de los derechos humanos: libertad informativa e intimidad personal, "La Ley" 11.XII.1998 (XIX-4691);
• L.PRIETO SANCHÍS, Las relaciones Iglesia-Estado a la luz de la nueva Constitución: problemas fundamentales, incluido en el libro colectivo editado por A.Predieri y E.García de Enterría sobre “La Constitución española de 1978” Madrid, Civitas, 1980;
• J. Rawls,The Law of Peoples: with "The Idea of Public Reason Revisited" Cambridge-Mass., Harvard University Press, 1999;
• Tomasz z Akwinu, Summa Teologica II.II, q.67, art.1, Madrid, BAC, 1956, t. VIII;
• M.VILLEY La formation de la pensée juridique moderne Paris, Montchretien, 1968;