Polish Antitrust Experience with Hub-and-Spoke Conspiracies

• Authors: Antoni Bolecki
• Languages of publication: EN

Abstracts

EN

A hub-and-spoke conspiracy involves an exchange of confidential information primarily concerning future prices. The exchange takes place generally between competing distributors via a common supplier but a reverse relationship is also possible. The essence of hub-and-spoke lies in the fact that there is no direct contact between competitors – the party guaranteeing the information flow is normally the common supplier (distributor in a reverse scenario). A hub-and-spoke conspiracy was first identified and specifically described by the British Office of Fair Trade in 2003. There are currently several pending investigations concerning hub-and-spoke practices in a number of EU Member States including Germany, France, Italy and the UK. Three cases of that type have been so far assessed in the Polish antitrust practice: Polifarb Cieszyn Wrocław (2007), Tikurilla (2010) and Akzo Nobel (2010). The main objective of this article is the reconstruction of hub-and-spoke conduct in Poland. Commented will also be issues such as: the connection between hub-and-spoke practices and ‘classic’ retail price maintenance; standard of proof, and duration of the agreements.

FR

La pratique de “hub-and-spoke” implique une échange d’information confidentielle, surtout celle concernant les prix envisagés. De façon générale, l’échange a lieu entre les distributeurs concurrents, au travers d’un fournisseur commun, mais une relation inverse est aussi possible. Le système de “hub-and-spoke” est fondé sur le fait qu’il n’y a pas de contact direct entre les concurrents – le flux d’information est garanti par le fournisseur commun (distributeur dans un scénario inverse). Trois cas de ce type ont été jugés dans la pratique antitrust polonaise: Polifarb Cieszyn Wrocław (2007), Tikurilla (2010) et Akzo Nobel (2010). Le but principal de cet article est de reconstruire la pratique de “hub-and-spoke” en Pologne. Autre questions, notamment la relation entre les pratiques de hub-and-spoke” et les prix de revente imposés, le standard de la preuve et la durée des accords, seront commentées.

Keywords

EN

hub-and-spoke; AtoBtoC coordination; exchange of information; vertical restraints; RPM; horizontal effect; standard of proof; duration of an agreement; initiator

• Publisher: Uniwersytet Warszawski. Wydział Nauk Ekonomicznych
• Journal: Yearbook of Antitrust and Regulatory Studies
• Year: 2011
• Volume: 4(5)
• Pages: 25-46

Dates

published

2011-11-30

Contributors

author

Antoni Bolecki

References

• Albors-Llorens A., ‘Horizontal agreements and concerted practices in EC competition law: Unlawful and legitimate Contacts between Competitors’ (2006) 51 Antitrust Bulletin.
• Bellamy & Child, European Community Law of Competition, Sixth Edition, Oxford 2008.
• Bolecki A., ‘Current Developments in Poland’ (2009) 5(3) European Competition Journal.
• Giovannetti E., Stallibrass D., ‘Three Cases in Search of a Theory: Resale Price Maintenance in the UK’ (2009) 5(3) European Competition Journal.
• Hay G. A., ‘Horizontal Agreements: Concept and Proof’ (2006) 51 Antitrust Bulletin.
• Information Exchanges between Competitors under Competition Law, OECD, 2010, (available at http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/12/52/48379006.pdf).
• Jones A., Sufrin B., EC Competition Law: Text, Cases, and Materials, Third Edition, Oxford 2008.
• Kohutek K., Sieradzka M., Ustawa o ochronie konkurencji i konsumentów, Komentarz [Act on Competition and Consumer Protection. Commentary], Warszawa 2008.
• Miąsik D., Reguła rozsądku w prawie antymonopolowym. Studium prawnoporównawcze [Rule of reason in antitrust law. Comparatory study], Kraków 2004.
• Piasecki K., System dowodów i postępowanie dowodowe w sprawach cywilnych [System of evidence and hearing of evidence in civil cases] , Warszawa 2010.
• Skoczny T., Jurkowska A., Miąsik D. (eds), Ustawa o ochronie konkurencji i konsumentów. Komentarz [Act on Competition and Consumer Protection. Commentary], Warszawa 2009.
• Whelan P., ‘Trading negotiations between retailers and suppliers: a fertile ground for anti-competitive horizontal information exchange?’ (2009) 5(3) European Competition Journal.
• Wollmann H., ‘Category Management, Private Labels und Informationsaustausch zwischen Wettbewerbern’ (2011) 1 Ecolex – Fachzeitschrift Für Wirtschaftsrecht.