What is Left from the Identity of the State of Israel Proclaimed in the Declaration of Independence?

• Authors: Schenhav Mordechai
• Languages of publication: EN

Abstracts

EN

The purpose of this article is twofold. First, to look at the Identity of Israel as both Jewish and democratic State in its Declaration of Independence and the status it acquired over the years within the Constitutional and law system. The second, to examine, through the evolution of the enounced principle of equality in the situation of economic, gender, religious and national minorities, how it was implemented and what has changed after 70 years. From the outset, the Declaration was not given a constitutional status but later the Supreme Court gave it an interpretive quality. With the two Basic Laws on Human Rights, limited as they were, it gave the Supreme Court much more advantage to intervene and impose the Identity of the State as Jewish and democratic in its interpretations of laws in spite of strong criticism and even to influence and criticize the Knesset legislation. However, Israel is still not a true liberal Democracy since the rights within it are determined more according to the ethnic-national religious belonging of the person that according to its citizenship and the principle of equality is only partially adopted in practice with different degrees as regards the various minorities. In some aspects, it even moves away from the original intended Identity of an exemplary liberal Democratic Nation State.

Keywords

EN

Israel’s identity; Declaration of Independence; principle of equality; Basic Laws of 1992/94

• Publisher: Wydawnictwo Adam Marszałek
• Journal: Polish Political Science Yearbook
• Year: 2018
• Volume: 2 (47)
• Pages: 167–187

Contributors

author

Schenhav Mordechai

• Strasbourg University (France)

References

• Attwell, K. (2015). Jewish-Israeli National Identity and Dissidence. New York: Palgrave, Macmillan.
• Auron, Y. (2012). Israeli Identities: Jews and Arabs facing the Self and the Other. New York: Berghahn Books.
• Avnery, U. (1998). “Israel’s Declaration of Independence: Squaring the circle”. Palestine – Israel Journal, 5 (2). Retrieved from: http://www.pij.org/details.php?id=206.
• Becher, T. (2011). “The claim for recognition of Israel as a Jewish State”. Policy Focus, 108.
• Benziman, U. (2006). Whose Land is it? A Quest for a Jewish-Arab Compact in Israel. Jerusalem: Israel Democracy Institute.
• Berent, M. (2009). A nation like all Nations: Towards the Establishment of an Israeli Republic. Jerusalem: Carmel.
• Bishara, A. (1999). Between “I” and “We”: The Construction of Identities and Israel Identity. Tel Aviv: Hakibbutz Hameuchad.
• Burg, A. (2017). Haaretz, 30.4.2017.
• Cohen–Almagor, R. (2005). Israeli Democracy at the Crossroads. New York: Routledge.
• Cohen, A, & Susser, B. (2000). Israel and Politics of Jewish Identity: the secular religious impasse. Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press.
• Dowty, A. (1999). “Is Israel democratic? Substance and semantics in the ethnic democracy debate”. Israel Studies, 4(2), pp.1-15.
• Elshaikh, E. (2016). “Israel say no to Equality”. Retrieved from: http://muftah.org/.
• “Futur gouvernement de la Palestine”. (1947). Cahiers de l’Orient contemporain, XI-XII, 3è et 4è trimestres, pp. 163-180.
• Gal, R. (2012). Between the Yarmulke and the Beret: Religion, Politics and the Military in Israel. Moshav Ben-Shemen: Modan.
• Gavison, R. (1999). “Jewish and Democratic? A Rejoinder to the ‘Ethnic Democracy’ Debate”. Israel Studies, 1(4). pp. 44-72.
• Gavison, R. (1998). “A Jewish and democratic State: Challenges and risks”. In Mautner M., Sagi Avi & Shamir Ronen Eds. Multiculturalism in a Democratic and Jewish State. Tel Aviv: Ramot. pp. 213-278.
• Ghanem, A., Rouhana N.N. & Yeftachel O. (1998). “Questioning <<>>: A Response to Sammy Smooha”. Israel Studies, 3(2). pp. 253-267.
• Goldsmith, M. (2014). “Sermon: Vayetze: The Jewish State Bill & Equality in Israel”. Alyth. Retrieved from: https://www.alyth.org.uk/sermons-writings/publication/sermon-vayetze-the-jewish-state-bill-equality-in-israel/.
• Gross, A. (2014). “In Israel, Instead of Equal Rights, No Equality at all”. Haaretz. Retrieved from: https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-instead-of-equal-rights-no-equality-at-all-1.5333698.
• Gutmann, E., & Pinhas Y. (1999). The Declaration of the Establishment of the State of Israel: The Declaration and its implementation. Jerusalem: Ministry of Education, Culture and Sport.
• Halperin-Kaddari, R. (2004). Women in Israel: A State of Their Own. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
• Harel-Shalev, A. (2009). “The complexity of majority-minority relations in deeply divided democracies”. In Avnon D. & Benziman Y. (Eds.), Plurality and Citizenship in Israel (pp. 93-114). New York: Routledge.
• Hasisi, B. (2009). “Policing minorities in a deeply divided society”. In Avnon D. & Benziman Y. (Eds.), Plurality and Citizenship in Israel (pp.152-170). New York: Routledge.
• Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs. “Declaration of Establishment of State of Israel”. Retrieved from: http://www.mfa.gov.il/mfa/foreignpolicy/peace/guide/pages/declaration%20of%20establishment%20of%20state%20of%20israel.aspx.
• Kaplan-Sommer, A. (2017, 4, 25). “Explained: Why Secular Israelis Are Burning Mad Over Religious Coercion”. Haaretz. retrieved from: https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/.premium-why-secular-israelis-are-burning-mad-over-religious-coercion-1.5464120.
• Kimmerling, B. (2004). Immigrants, Settlers, Natives: The Israeli State and Society, Between Cultural Pluralism and Cultural Wars. Tel Aviv: Am Oved.
• Kimmerling, B. (2005). The Invention and Decline of Isræliness: State, Society, and the Military. Berkeley: University of California Press.
• “Knesset rejects bill for equality for all citizens” (2016, January 28). Retrieved from: http://www.middleeastmonitor.com/news/middle-east/23610.
• Kretzmer, D. (1990). The Legal Status of the Arabs in Israel. Boulder: Westview.
• Lorberboim, M. (1998). “Religion and State in Israel and the social contract”. In Mautner M., Sagi A. & Shamir R. Multiculturalism in a Democratic and Jewish State (pp. 279-300). Tel Aviv: Ramot.
• Manna, A. (2008). “Change and continuation in the existence of the Israeli Arabs in Israel – a state of affairs”. In Manna A. Arab Society in Israel (2): Population, Society, Economy. Tel Aviv: Hakibbutz Hameuchad.
• Maor, A. (1997). Women: The Rising Power. Tel Aviv: Sifriat Poalim.
• Marszałek-Kawa, J., & Wawrzyński, P. (2016). “Remembrance, Identity Politics and Political Transitions: a Comparative Study”, Polish Political Science Yearbook, 45, pp. 11-21.
• Mazori, D. (1986) “Avoiding the Abortion Law”. Ma’ariv, 2.21.
• Mehozay, Y. (2012). “How emergency Powers prevented Palestinian Assimilation in Israel”. Israel Studies Review, 27 (2), pp. 18-40.
• Mendilow, J. (2012). “Israel’s Palestinian Minority: from <<>> to Ethno-nationalism”. Israel Studies Review, 27 (1), pp. 142-160.
• Mercuro, N. (1995). “Religion, Multiculturalism and Equality: The Israeli Case”. Israel Yearbook on Human Rights, 25, pp. 193–210.
• Okun, B.S., & Friedlander, D. (2005) "Educational stratification among Arabs and Jews in Israel: historical disadvantage, discrimination, and opportunity". Population studies, 59 (2), pp. 163-180.
• Peled, Y., & Shafir, G. (2005). Being Israeli: The dynamics of Multiple Citizenship. Tel Aviv: Tel Aviv University Press.
• Peleg, I. (2000) “Israel as a Liberal Democracy: Civil Rights in the Jewish State". In Zittrain Eisenberg L., Caplan N. Review Essays in Israel Studies: Books on Israel (pp. 63-80). SUNY Press.
• Peleg, I., Waxman, D. (2011). Israeli Palestinians, the Conflict within. New York: Cambridge University Press.
• Pfeffer, A. (2014). Jewish Chronicle.
• Plesner, Y. (2017). “Who’s afraid of a Jewish State with Equality for all”. Retrieved from: http://en.idi.org.il/article/18820.
• Rabbis and Cantors for Religious Freedom and Equality in Israel – RRFEI. (14.6.2013/ January 2015/ 2.7.2015/ 16.6.2016). retrieved from: http://rrfei.org/about/rrfei-archives/.
• Raday, F. (1983). “Equality of Women under Israeli Law”. Jerusalem Quarterly, 27, pp. 81–108.
• Raday, F. (1992). “The Incorporation of Religious Patriarchy in a Modern State”. International Review of Comparative Public Policy, 4, pp. 209-226.
• Raday, F. (1995). “Religion, Multinationalism and Equality: The Israeli Case”. Israel Yearbook on Human Rights, 25, pp. 193-210.
• Raday, F. (2001). “The Israeli Perspective” in The Status of Women at the Beginning of the Twenty-First Century: Proceedings, UNESCO, pp. 113–144.
• Reiter, Y. (2005). Dilemmas in Arab-Jewish Relations in Israel. Tel Aviv: Schocken.
• Rosen-Tzvi, A. (2001). Religion, Liberty, Family and Society Conflict. Tel Aviv: Yale University Press.
• Rouhana, N. (1997) Palestinian Citizens in an Ethnic Jewish State: Identities in Conflict, New Haven: Yale University Press.
• Rudoren, J. (2014). “Israel struggles with its Identity: Bill on Status as Jewish State Fuels an Israeli Identity Crisis”. New York Times, 9.12.2014.
• Schattner, M. (2008). Israël, l’autre conflit: Laïcs contre religieux. Bruxelles: André Versaille.
• Schenhav, M. (2009). “Pour une nouvelle définition de l’Etat d’Israël “. Les Temps Modernes, 64è année, (nos. 652-653), janvier-avril, pp. 124-129.
• Schenhav, M. (2016). “Les clivages de la société israélienne – etat des lieux”. In Saquer-Sabin F., Persyn E. Regards sur le Proche-Orient éclaté – complexe – paradoxale. Villeneuve d’Ascq : Presses de l’Université Charles de Gaulle – Lille 3, pp. 137-150.
• Schenhav, M. (2016). “The minimal representation of women in the Israeli political system”. Revue Européenne des Etudes Hébraïques, 18, pp. XLII-LVIII.
• Shapira, Y. (1998). “The secular politicians and the status of the religion in the State of Israel”. In Mautner M., Sagi A. & Shamir R. Multiculturalism in a Democratic and Jewish State (pp. 663-674). Tel Aviv: Ramot.
• Sharon, J. (2017, September 22). “Anat Hoffman : Advancing values of equality in the Jewish State, Jewish leaders denounce cancelation of Wailing Wall deal”. Jerusalem Post, 22.9.2017.
• Shava, M. (2003). Jurisdiction in Family Law. Tel Aviv: The Israeli Bar Association.
• Smooha, S. (1990). “Minority Status in Ethnic Democracy: The Status of the Arab Minority in Israel”. Ethnic and Racial Studies, 13 (2), pp.389-413.
• Smooha, S. (2002). “The model of ethnic democracy: Israel as a Jewish and democratic State”. Nations and Nationalism, 8 (4), pp. 475-503.
• “Special issue for the elections to the Constitutional Assembly – elections parties’ platforms”. Bamakhane. (20.01.1949).
• Sultany, N. (2012). “The making of an underclass: the Palestinian Citizens of Israel”. Israel Studies Review, 27 (2), pp.190-200.
• The Economist (2014, November 27). How Jewish a State?.
• Triger, Z. (2012). “Civil Marriages and Cohabitation of Jews enter the Rabbinical Courts”. Israel Studies Review, 27 (2), pp.1-18.
• Yakobson, A, Rubinstein, A. (2003). Israel and the Family of Nations: Jewish Nation-State and Human Rights. Tel Aviv: Schocken.
• Yiftachel, O. (1999). “<<>>: the politics of judaizing Israel/Palestine”. Constellations, 6 (3), pp.364-390.