Między trafem moralnym [moral luck] a trafem prawnym [legal luck]

• Authors: Maciej Juzaszek

Title variants

EN

Moral luck and legal luck

• Languages of publication: PL

Abstracts

PL

Artykuł ma za zadanie wprowadzenie do problematyki prawnego trafu i wyznaczenie ścieżki dalszych badań związanych z tym tematem. Zawiera on odpowiedź na pytanie dotyczące relacji pomiędzy moralnym trafem (moral luck), a prawnym trafem (legal luck). Analizowane są trzy stanowiska. Pierwsze, reprezentowane przez Arthura Ripsteina, głosi, że moral luck i legal luck to autonomiczne względem siebie problemy. Drugie, którego przedstawicielem jest David Enoch, stanowi, że prawny traf to wynik przeniesienia moralnego trafu na grunt prawa. Trzecie zaś, prze-ciwnie, odnosi się do koncepcji moralnego trafu jako wyniku przeniesienia prawnego trafu na grunt moralności. Autor omawia poszczególne koncepcje, wskazuje na ich mocne i słabe punkty, by ostatecznie opowiedzieć się za jedną z nich, co prowadzi do określonej wizji dalszych badań nad prawnym trafem.

EN

The article aims to introduce the issue of legal luck and set the direction for further research on this topic. It contains an answer to the question about the relationship between moral luck and legal luck. Three positions are analyzed. The first one, represented by Arthur Ripstein, says that moral luck and legal luck are autonomous issues. The second one, represented by David Enoch, states that legal luck is the result of applying moral luck to law. The third one, on the contrary, refers to the concept of moral luck as a result of applying legal luck to morality. The author discusses diverse conceptions, indicating their strong and weak points, and finally opts for one of them, which leads to a certain view of further research on legal luck.

Keywords

PL

David Enoch; Artur Ripstein; moralny traf; prawny traf; relacje prawa i moralności

EN

David Enoch; Artur Ripstein; moral luck; legal luck; relations between law and morality

• Publisher: Instytut Filozofii - Uniwersytet Jagielloński
• Journal: Diametros
• Year: 2014
• Issue: 41
• Pages: 56-76

Contributors

author

Maciej Juzaszek

References

• Athanassoulis [2005] – Nafsika Athanassoulis, Morality, Moral Luck and Responsibility. For-tune's Web, Palgrave Macmillan, Hampshire 2005.
• Burg van der [1999] – Wibren van der Burg, Two Models of Law nad Morality, „Associa-tions” 3 (1) 1999, s. 61–82.
• Cushman [2008] – Fiery Cushman, Crime and punishment: Distinguishing the roles of causal and intentional analyses in moral judgment, „Cognition” (108.2) 2008, s. 353–380.
• Duff [2008] – Anthony Duff, Legal Punishment, „Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy”, 2008, URL = http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/moral-luck.
• Enoch [2008] – David Enoch, Luck Between Morality, Law and Justice, „Theoretical Inquiries in Law” 9 (1) 2008, s. 23-60.
• Enoch [2010] – David Enoch, Moral Luck and the Law, „Philosophical Compass” 5 (1) 2010, s. 42–45.
• Giudice [2009] – Michael Giudice, Joseph Raz's Legal Philosophy, “IVR Encyclopaedia of Jurisprudence, Legal Theory and Philosophy of Law”, 2009, URL = http://ivr-enc.info/index.php?title=Joseph_Raz's_Legal_Philosophy [10.01.2012].
• Kramer [2005] – Matthew Kramer, Moral and Legal Obligation, [w:] The Blackwell Guide to the Philosophy of Law and Legal Theory, red. Martin Golding, William, Edmundson, Blackwell Publishing, Oxford, 2005, s. 179–190.
• McLaughlin, Bennet [2005] – Brian McLaughlin, Karen Bennet, Supervenience, „Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy”, 2005, URL = http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/ supervenience/ [18.04.2013].
• Nagel [1993] – Thomas Nagel, Moral luck, [w:] Moral Luck, red. Daniel Statman, State Uni-versity of New York Press, Albany 1993, s. 57–71.
• Nelkin [2008] – Dana Nelkin, Moral Luck, „Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy”, 2008, URL = http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/moral-luck [10.01.2012].
• Nussbaum [1993] – Martha Nussbaum, Luck and ethics [w:] Moral Luck, red. Daniel Statman, State University of New York Press, Albany 1993, s. 73–108.
• Nussbaum [2001] – Martha Nussbaum, The Fragility of Goodness. Luck and Ethics in Greek Tragedy and Philosophy, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2001.
• Ripstein [2008] – Arthur Ripstein, Closing the Gap, „Theoretical Inquiries in Law” 9 (1) 2008, s. 61–95.
• Rosebury [1995] – Brian Rosebury, Moral Responsibility and „Moral Luck”, „The Philosophi-cal Review” 104 (4) 1995, s. 499–524.
• Statman [2008] – Daniel Statman, Mind The Gap: A Reply to Ripstein, „Theoretical Inquiries in Law” 9 (1) 2008, s. 12–16, URL = http://philo.haifa.ac.il/staff/statman/ pdf/Closing%20the%20Gap.pdf [21.01.2012].
• Statman [1993] – Daniel Statman, Introduction, [w:] Moral luck, Daniel Statman (red.), State University of New York Press, Albany 1993, s. 1–34.
• Sverdlik [1993] – Steven Sverdlik, Crime and Moral Luck, [w:] Moral luck, Daniel Statman (red.), State University of New York Press, Albany 1993, s. 181–194.
• Thomson [1993] – Judith Jarvin Thomson, Morality and Bad Luck, [w:] Moral luck, Daniel Statman (red.), State University of New York Press, Albany 1993, s. 195–216.
• Waldron [1997] – Jeremy Waldron, Moments of Carelessness and Massive Loss, [w:] Philosoph-ical Foundations of Tort Law, Owen (red.), Oxford University Press, USA 1997.
• Williams [1993] – Bernard Williams, Moral Luck, [w:] Moral luck, Daniel Statman (red.), State University of New York Press, Albany 1993, s. 35–55.