PL EN


1978 | 4 | 261-272
Article title

Problemy rekonstrukcji nadal żywe i aktualne : na marginesie kolokwium w Augsburgu w marcu 1978 r.

Content
Title variants
EN
PROBLEMS OF RECONSTRUCTION STILL CURRENT AND OF INTEREST (A SIDE-NOTE FROM THE SEMINAR HELD AT AUGSBURG, MARCH 1978)
Languages of publication
PL
Abstracts
EN
The reconstrution o f the Golden Hall in Augsburg’s Town-Hall was the subject o f an international seminar held on March 8 and 9, 1978 on the initiative o f Augsburg’s Municipal Council. The Town-Hall at Augsburg, a world-known ediffice with magnificent interiors, was erected in the years 1615—1624 by Elias Holl (1575— —1646), an outstanding architect. Utterly burnt down in 1944, from the top down to the dome o f the vestibule o f the ground floor, the Hall was roughly rebuilt by 1955 and after restoration works it regained its exterior décor. The rebuilding o f the interiors carried out in 1958—1962 has left, however, open the question o f restoring former decor. The discussion held at the seminar showed that while the question o f restoring exterior and interior architectural decorations, especially o f preserving genuine parts o f the elements, did not give rise to any major reservations, then the problem o f painted décor was found to be highly controversial. The main problem was a search for the answer to the question whether it was justified, or even permissible, to reconstruct decorations o f the interiors devastated by fire when, except for the wall-building substance and the arrangement o f window openings and niches, only a very small percentage o f wall paintings that used to decorate the wall had been preserved. Nothing lite. rally was left from a rich architectonic and sculpturing wood. -carving. Finally, after a lengthy discussion and including amendments approved by the overwhelming majority, the commission presented the Municipal Council with an expertise made on behalf o f seminar participants. The expertise confirms a technical possibility o f reconstruction. Still, in recommends an earlier verification o f the reliability of the documentation. The expertise draws also attention to difficulties involved in eventual reconstruction. The problem o f reconstructing the Golden Hall is of both a cultural and political nature and its solution depends on the decision o f the town o f Augsburg itself. At any rate, it is advised to take on first only partial tasks, the results o f which would be every time assessed by a competent international body and would influence international body and would influence further decisions. It is also recommended to commence with easier and non-conflicting works such as floors, window partitions, doors and portals, tested first on models scaled 1:1. The existing provisional arrangement should make a point o f departure for partial steps. In the case o f a possible modern solution, defined as a rule as problematic, the architecture of Elias Holl should definitely not be changed. Also relics of the preserved wallpaintings, which must be maintained „in situ”, must stay unharmed.
Year
Issue
4
Pages
261-272
Physical description
Dates
published
1978
Contributors
  • prof, dr, Politechnika Gdańska
References
  • Bliższe dane o dziejach ratusza zob. w: R. v. Wa l t e r , Das Augsburger Rathaus. Architektur und Bildgehalt, Abhandlungen zur Geschichte der Stadt Augsburg, t. XX, Augsburg 1972. Zob. także dokumentację przygotowaną na kolokwium przez Stadt Augsburg — Hochbauamt : H. К i e s s 1 i n g, Das Augsburger Rathaus. Daten und Fakten zum Wiederaufbau und zur Gestaltung des Goldenen Saales, Augsburg 1978, s. 4—5, 11—12, 13—14.
  • L. Freiherr v. G u m p p e n b e r g (Munchen), Residenz in Munchen; M. S p e r 1 i с h (Berlin West), Schloss Charlottenburg; D. v. W i n t e r f e l d (Heidelberg), Schloss Bruchsal.
  • J. P a u l (Braunschweig), Das Rekonstruktionsproblem beim Wiederaufbau zersttorter Rathauser ; J. S t a n k i e w i c z (Gdańsk), Der Wiederaufbau des Rathauses in Gdańsk (Danzig).
  • W. F r o d l (Wien), Die rekonstruierende Kopie aus der Sicht des Denkmalpflegers; H. L i n d e (Stuttgart), Der rekonstruierende Kopie aus der Sicht des Architekten.
  • J. Z i m m e r (Munchen), Die historische Bedeutung des Augsburger Rathauses', B. B u s h a r t (Augsburg), Der Goldene Saal. Funktion und Erhaltungsgeschichte bis zur Gegenwart', A. Ma c h a t s с h e к (Wien), Die materiellen Voraussetzungen einer Rekonstruktion.
  • Por. także: M. S p e r l i e h, Denkmalpflegerische Prinzipien beim Wiederaufbau von Schloss Charlottenburg, [w :] Schloss Charlottenburg — Berlin — Preussen. Festschrift fur Margarete Kuhn, Deutscher Kunstverlag 1975, s. 13—22.
  • W tak zwanej Białej Sali ( Weisser Saal) ukończonej w 1742 r. w miejscu zniszczonego malowidła Antoine Pesne’a, niemożliwego do odtworzenia wobec braku dokumentacji kolorystycznej, w latach 1972—1973 nowoczesną kompozycję malarską stworzył Hann Trier. Por. M. S p e r l i c h , H. B o r s c h - S u p a n , T. E g g e 1 i n g, Der Weisse Saal und die Goldene Galerie im Schloss Charlottenburg, [w:] Aus Berliner Schlossern, Kleine Schriften, I, Berlin 1973, s. 9—13 oraz 15—23.
  • I. B e r g m a n n , Der Goldene Saal als Lehrstuck [w:] A Z Kommentar, „Augsburger Allgemeine” z 11 marca 1978 r., s. 12.
Document Type
Publication order reference
Identifiers
YADDA identifier
bwmeta1.element.desklight-6a73ec35-5bb1-43ba-986f-4f602fbddbc5
JavaScript is turned off in your web browser. Turn it on to take full advantage of this site, then refresh the page.