Wojna w Donbasie – przyczynek do rozważań nad niedopowiedzeniami teorii wojny sprawiedliwej

• Authors: Neumann-Karpiński Paweł

Title variants

EN

War in Donbas – considerations on the understatements of the just war theory

RU

Война на Донбассе – размышления о недосказанном на тему теории справедливой войны

• Languages of publication: PL

Abstracts

EN

The following article covers the analysis of the War in Donbas from the perspective of the “traditional concept of a just war” (as interpreted by Michael Walzer). The main axis of the analysis is determined by the issue of the possibility of third countries intervening in armed conflicts concerning the specific case of the War in Donbas. The text indicates the key factors that make it impossible to develop a conflict in eastern Ukraine according to traditional just war theories, such as the pursuit of incomplete secession of pro-Russian separatists, the status of the Russian Federation as an unofficial participant in the conflict, and the problem of the “reality” of the separatist intention itself. Therefore, the main problem of this work is the interpretation of Russian actions from the perspective of the principle of non-intervention, and the attitude of other third countries and their right to (not) intervene in this conflict, and its conclusion – in the author’s opinion – indicates the need to update the theory of just war, in a way that would clearly indicate the proper conduct in the event of secession in favour of the existing state.

RU

В данной статье проводится анализ войны в Донбассе с точки зрения «традиционной концепции справедливой войны» (по М. Вальцеру). Главной осью исследования является вопрос возможного вмешательства третьих сторон в вооруженные конфликты, в данном случае относительно войны в Донбассе. В тексте указаны ключевые факторы, которые не позволяют рассматривать конфликт на востоке Украины с помощью традиционных теорий «справедливой войны», в частности: стремление пророссийских сепаратистов к неполной сецессии, статус Российской Федерации как неофициального участника данного конфликта или проблема «реальности» самого сепаратистского намерения. В связи с вышесказанным главной проблемой статьи является интерпретация действий России с перспективы принципа «невмешательства», а также отношение других государств и их право на (не)интервенцию в этот конфликт, разрешение которого – по мнению автора – указывает на необходимость актуализации теории «справедливой войны», чтобы она ясно показывала, какими должны быть правильные действия в случае сецессии в пользу существующего государства.

Keywords

EN

War in Donbas, just war, just war theory, secession, military interventions

RU

война на Донбассе, справедливая война, теория справедливой войны, выход из состава государства, военное вмешательство

• Publisher: Wydawnictwo Adam Marszałek
• Journal: Nowa Polityka Wschodnia
• Year: 2021
• Volume: 2(29)
• Pages: 111–123

Contributors

author

Neumann-Karpiński Paweł

• Uniwersytet Szczeciński

References

• Fabre, C. (2016). Cosmopolitan Peace. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
• Finlay, Ch.J. (2015). Terrorism and the Right to Resist: A Theory of Just Revolutionary War. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
• Kernot, E. (red.). (2015). The war in Ukraine: lessons for Europe. Riga: The Centre for East European Policy Studies, University of Latvia Press.
• Laaneots, A., Ühendatud K. (2016). The Russian-Georgian War Of 2008: Causes And Implication. Estonian National Defence College.
• McMahan, J. (2009). Etyka zabijania na wojnie. W: T. Kuniński, T. Żuradzki (red.). Etyka wojny. Antologia tekstów. Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Naukowe PWN.
• Tukidydes (1998). Wojna Peloponeska. Warszawa: Czytelnik.
• Walzer, M. (2010). Wojny sprawiedliwe i niesprawiedliwe. Rozważania natury moralnej z uwzględnieniem przykładów historycznych (tłum. M. Szczubiałka). Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Naukowe PWN.
• BBC (2014a, 25 sierpnia). Ukraine crisis: ‘Column from Russia’ crosses border. BBC News. Pobrane z: https://bbc.com/news/world-europe-28924945.
• BBC (2014b, 5 września). Ukraine and pro-Russia rebels sign ceasefire deal. BBC News. Pobrane z: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-29082574. BBC (2014c, 26.08).
• Captured Russian troops ‘in Ukraine by accident’. BBC News. Pobrane z: https://bbc.com/news/world-europe-28934213.
• Borger, J. (2015, 11 maraca). Russian military shelled Ukraine from mid-July, report says. The Guardian. Pobrane z: theguardian.com/world/2015/mar/11/russia-struggling-ukraine-military-operations-report.
• D’Agata, Ch. (2014, 6 marca). Ukrainian city of Donetsk epitomizes country’s crisis. CBS News. Pobrane z: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/ukrainian-city-of-donetsk-epitomizes-countrys-crisis/.
• Gazeta.pl (2014, 24 maja). MSW: Już 17 tys. milicjantów po stronie separatystów; Merkel i Hollande dzwonią do Putina ws. ukraińskich wyborów [PODSUMOWANIE DNIA]. Wiadomości.Gazeta.pl. Pobrane z: http://wiadomosci.gazeta.pl/wiadomosci/1,114871,16027803,MSW__Juz_17_tys__milicjantow_po_stronie_separatystow_.html.
• Gordon, M.R. (2014, 22 sierpnia). Russia Moves Artillery Units Into Ukraine, NATO Says. New York Times. Pobrane z: nytimes.com/2014/08/23/world/europe/russia-moves--artillery-units-into-ukraine-nato-says.html.
• Grand, C. (2016, 4 lipca). Nuclear deterrence and the Alliance in the 21st century. NATO Review. Pobrane z: https://www.nato.int/docu/review/articles/2016/07/04/nuclear-deterrence-and-the-alliance-in-the-21st-century/index.html.
• Grove, T., Strobel, W. (2014, 29 lipca). Special Report: Where Ukraine’s separatists get their weapons. Reuters. Pobrane z: https://reuters.com/article/us-ukraine-crisis-arms-specialreport/special-report-where-ukraines-separatists-get-their-weapons-idUSKBN-0FY0UA20140729?feedType=RSS&feedName=worldNews.
• Grytsenko, O. (2014, 12 kwietnia). Armed pro-Russian insurgents in Luhansk say they are ready for police raid. KyivPost. Pobrane z: https://web.archive.org/web/20140412131249/http://www.kyivpost.com/content/ukraine/armed-pro-russian-insurgents-in-luhansk-say-they-are-ready-for-police-raid-343167.html.
• Harding, L., Walker, S. (2014, 17 marca) Crimea applies to be part of Russian Federation after vote to leave Ukraine. Guardian.com. Pobrane z: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/mar/17/ukraine-crimea-russia-referendum-complain-result.
• Interfax-Ukraine (2014, 18 marca). Law enforcers collect evidence of Russian services’ involvement in unrest in eastern Ukraine – Yatseniuk. Interfax.com.ua. Pobrane z: https://en.interfax.com.ua/news/general/196506.html.
• Kendall, B. (2008, 21 sierpnia). Russia’s neighbours go their own way. BBC News. Pobrane z: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/7575813.stm.
• Kramer, A.E., Gordon, M.R. (2014, 27 sierpnia). Ukraine Reports Russian Invasion on a New Front. New York Times. Pobrane z: nytimes.com/2014/08/28/world/europe/ukraine-russia-novoazovsk-crimea.html.
• Kushch, L. (2014, 16 marca) Pro-Russian demonstrators burn books, storm buildings in eastern Ukraine. Reuters.com Pobrane z: https://web.archive.org/web/20140316215525/https://www.reuters.com/article/2014/03/16/us-ukraine-east-idUSBREA2F0P 220140316.
• North, A. (2015, 14 lipca). Georgia accuses Russia of violating international law over South Ossetia. The Guardian. Pobrane z: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jul/14/georgia-accuses-russia-of-violating-international-law-over-south-ossetia.
• RFE/RL (2018, 11 sierpnia). Monitor Posts Video Of Truck Convoys Between Russia, Eastern Ukraine. Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty. Pobrane z: https://www.rferl.org/a/osce-monitor-publishes-video-truck-convosy-between-russia-ukraine-first--evidence-illegal-crossings/29427195.html.
• Sutyagin, I. (2015, 9 marca), Russian Forces in Ukraine, Rusi.org. Pobrane z: https://rusi.org/publication/briefing-papers/russian-forces-ukraine.
• TASS (2014, 16 kwietnia). Russia blasts US assessment of events in Ukraine’s southeast. TASS Russian News Agency. Pobrane z: http://tass.ru/en/russia/728304.
• Tsvetkova, M. (2015, 21 lipca). Ceasefire brings limited respite for east Ukrainians. Reuters. Pobrane z: https://web.archive.org/web/20150725132924/http://www.euronews.com/newswires/3041823-ceasefire-brings-limited-respite-for-east-ukrainians/.
• Tsvetkova, M., Osborn, A. (2015, 17 grudnia). Russia’s Putin lashes Turkey, says Russian forces were in Ukraine. Reuters. Pobrane z: https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-russia-putin-idUKKBN0U01KP20151217.
• TVN24 (2014, 15 kwietnia). Specnaz w Doniecku? Gubernator: Nie ukrywali dystynkcji, ich rozmowy słyszeli mieszkańcy. TVN24 Biznes i Świat. Pobrane z: https://www.tvn24.pl/wiadomosci-ze-swiata,2/specnaz-w-doniecku-gubernator-nie-ukrywali--dystynkcji-ich-rozmowy-slyszeli-mieszkancy,418659.html.
• Wirtualna Polska. (2014, 14 marca). Krym i Sewastopol uznane za części FR z chwilą podpisania traktatu. Wp.pl. Pobrane z: https://wiadomosci.wp.pl/krym-i-sewastopol-uznane-za-czesci-fr-z-chwila-podpisania-traktatu-6031307004600961a.
• Zinets, N., Madorsky, D. (2014, 22 sierpnia). Ukraine accuses Russia of invasion after aid convoy crosses border. Reuters. Pobrane z: https://web.archive.org/web/20140822150641/https://www.reuters.com/article/2014/08/22/us-ukraine-crisis-aid-convoy-idUSKBN0GM0IS20140822.

Identifiers

DOI

10.15804/npw20212905