Analiza stóp zwrotu z funduszy hedgingowych za pomocą miar efektywności opartych na dolnych momentach cząstkowych

• Authors: Pruchnicka-Grabias Izabela

Title variants

EN

Analysis of hedge fund rates of return with the use of efficiency measures based on lower partial moments

• Languages of publication: PL

Abstracts

PL

W literaturze przedmiotu oraz w praktyce gospodarczej widać powszechne zastosowanie wskaźnika Sharpe’a do pomiaru wyników inwestycyjnych funduszy hedgingowych. Tymczasem opiera się on na odchyleniu standardowym będącym miarą ryzyka wymagającą wprowadzenia założenia dotyczącego normalności stóp zwrotu. Tego rodzaju postępowanie jest przedmiotem szerokiej krytyki, co zaowocowało ciągłym tworzeniem nowych miar określanych w literaturze jako tzw. alternatywne. Jednocześnie przeprowadzone przez autorkę badania pokazują, że rankingi strategii stosowanych przez fundusze hedgingowe oparte na wskaźniku Sharpe’a oraz alternatywnych miarach efektywności (wskaźnik Omega, Sortino, Kappa) są identyczne. Powstaje zatem pytanie o zasadność stosowania miar alternatywnych w sytuacji, gdy poddawany szerokiej krytyce tradycyjny wskaźnik Sharpe’a prowadzi do niemalże identycznych wniosków.

EN

Sharpe ratio is largely used both in the literature and in practice to value hedge fund investment efficiency. Nevertheless, it is based on the standard deviation which requires taking the assumption on the normal distribution of rates of return. Such applications are widely criticized, and have led to the creation of new measures, most frequently referred to in the literature as alternative measures. However, alternative measures generate higher human factor risk reflected in calculation errors. At the same time the research done by the author shows that hedge fund strategies rankings made with the use of Sharpe ratio and alternative measures such as Omega ratio, Sortino ratio and Kappa ratio are identical. There arises a question concerning the validity of alternative measures application when Sharpe ratio gives such similar results.

Keywords

PL

fundusze hedge; efektywność; alternatywne miary ryzyka

EN

hedge funds; efficiency; alternative risk measures

• Publisher: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Ekonomicznego we Wrocławiu
• Journal: Prace Naukowe Uniwersytetu Ekonomicznego we Wrocławiu
• Year: 2018
• Issue: 531
• Pages: 390-403

Contributors

author

Pruchnicka-Grabias Izabela

References

• Abugri B.A., Dutta S., 2009, Emerging market hedge funds: Do they perform like regular hedge funds?, Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions & Money, 19(5), s. 834-849.
• Ackermann C., McEnally R., Ravenscraft D., 1999, The performance of hedge funds: risk, return and incentives, Journal of Finance, 54(3), s. 833-874.
• Agarval V., Naik N.Y., 2004, Risks and Portfolio Decisions Involving Hedge Funds, The Review of Financial Studies, 7(1), s. 63-98.
• Agarval V., Ruenzi S., Weigert F., 2017, Tail risk in hedge funds: A unique view from portfolio holdings, Journal of Financial Economics, 125(3), s. 610-636.
• Bailey D.H., de Prado L.M., 2012, The Sharpe Ratio Efficient Frontier, Journal of Risk, 15(2), April, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1821643.
• Bali T.G., Atilgan Y., Demirtas K.O., 2013, Investing in Hedge Funds. A Guide to Measuring Risk and Return Characteristics, UK-USA, Elsevier.
• Bernardo A., Ledoit O., 2000, Gain, loss and asset pricing, Journal of Political Economy, 108(1), s. 144-172.
• Brooks C., Kat H.M., 2002, The Statistical Properties of Hedge Fund Index Returns and Their Implications for Investors, Journal of Alternative Investments, 5(2), s. 26-44.
• Brown S.J., Goetzmann W.N., Ibbotson R.G., 1999, Offshore hedge funds: survival and performance 1989-1995, Journal of Business, 72(1), s. 91-117.
• Chan N., Getmansky M., Haas S.M., Lo A.W., 2006, Systemic Risk and Hedge Funds, [w:] M. Carey, R. Stulz (eds.), The Risks of Financial Institutions, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, wersja książki bez numeracji stron dostępna na: http://books.google.pl/books?id=mTWtpwkGYGgC&pg=PA103&hl=pl&source=gbs_toc_r&cad=4#v=onepage&q&f=false [dostęp: 10.04.2018].
• Chen Y., 2011, Derivatives use and risk taking: evidence from the hedge fund industry, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 46(4), s. 1073-1106.
• Dowd K., 1998, Beyond Value at Risk. The New Science of Risk Management, John Wiley & Sons, New York.
• Eling M., 2006, Performance Measurement of Hedge Funds Using Data Envelopment Analysis, Working Papers on Risk Management and Insurance, 25, University of St. Gallen, listopad, s. 2-29.
• Eling M., Faust R., 2010, The performance of hedge funds and mutual funds in emerging markets, Journal of Banking & Finance, 34.
• Eling M., Schuhmacher F., 2007, Does the choice of performance measure influence the evaluation of hedge funds?, Journal of Banking and Finance, Nr 31(8), s. 2635-2637.
• Gregoriou G.N., Huebner G., Papageorgiou N., Rouah F. (eds.), 2005, Hedge Funds. Insights in Performance Measurement, Risk Analysis, and Portfolio Management, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, s. 549-550.
• Gupta A., Liang B., 2005, Do hedge funds have enough capital? A value-at-risk approach, Journal of Financial Economics, 77(1), s. 219-253.
• Harlow W.V., 1991, Asset Allocation in a Downside-Risk Framework, Financial Analysts Journal, September- October, s. 28-40.
• Ibert M., Kaniel R., Nieuwerburgh S.V., Vestman R., 2017, Are Mutual Fund Managers Paid for Investment Skill?, NBER Working Papers, April, s. 1-64.
• Kaiser D., Haberfelner F., 2012, Hedge fund biases after the financial crisis, Managerial Finance, 38(1), s. 27-43.
• Kaplan P.D., Knowles J.A., Kappa, 2004, A Generalized Downside Risk – Adjusted Performance Measure, Morningstar Associates and York Hedge Fund Strategies, January, s. 1-17.
• Karpio A., Żebrowska-Suchodolska D., 2013, The comparison of rankings created for open-end equity mutual funds with application of different effectiveness measures, Quantitative Methods in Economics, XIV(1), s. 202-211.
• Kazemi H., Schneeweis T., Gupta B., 2003, Omega as a Performance measure, research paper, Center for International Securities and Derivatives Markets, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, July, www.cisdm.org; http://www.edge-fund.com/KaSG03.pdf [dostęp: 30.03.2018].
• Keating C., Shadwick W.F., 2002, A Universal Performance Measure, Journal of Performance Measurement, 6(3), s. 1-42, https://faculty.fuqua.duke.edu/~charvey/Teaching/BA453_2004/Keating_A_universal_performance.pdf.
• Liang B., 1999, On the performance of hedge funds, Financial Analysts Journal, 55(4), lipiec/sierpień, http://finance.martinsewell.com/fund-performance/Liang1999.pdf [dostęp: 30.03.2018].
• Li H., X. Zhang, Zhao R., 2011, Investing in talents: Manager characteristics and hedge fund performances, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 46(1), s. 59-82.
• Ma L., Tang Y., Gomez J.P., 2016, Portfolio Manager Compensation and Mutual Fund Performance, Working Paper, https://www.rsm.nl/fileadmin/home/Department_of_Finance__VG5_/PAM2016/Final_Papers/Juan_Pedro_Gomez.pdf [dostęp: 23.04.2018].
• Markowitz H., 1952, Portfolio selection, Journal of Finance, 7(1), marzec, s. 77-91.
• Nguyen-Thi-Thanh H., 2010, On the consistency of performance measures for hedge funds, Journal of Performance Measurement, 14(2), s. 1-16.
• Ornelas J.R.H., Silva A.F., Fernandes J.L.B., 2012, Yes, the choice of performance measure does matter for ranking of US mutual funds, International Journal of Finance and Economics, 17, s. 61-72.
• Perez K., 2011, Wyniki inwestycyjne funduszy hedge. Czynniki wpływające na ich interpretację, Bank i Kredyt, 42(1), s. 85-124.
• Prado M.L. de, 2013, How Long does it take to recover from a drawdown?, working paper, https://ssrn.com/abstract=2254668, s. 1-43.
• Pruchnicka-Grabias I., 2015, Zastosowanie miar maksymalnej straty na kapitale w badaniu efektywności funduszy hedgingowych, Kwartalnik Kolegium Ekonomiczno-Społecznego Studia i Prace, 3(3), Oficyna Ekonomiczna, Szkoła Główna Handlowa w Warszawie, s. 133-145.
• Pruchnicka-Grabias I., 2016a, Lower partial moments and maximum drawdown measures in hedge fund risk – return profile analysis, “Universal Journal of Mathematics and Mathematical Sciences”, 9(1-2), s. 43-59.
• Pruchnicka-Grabias I., 2016b, Maximum drawdown measures in hedge fund efficiency appraisal, Quarterly e-Finanse, 12(4), s. 83-91.
• Pruchnicka-Grabias I., 2017, Pomiar ryzyka inwestycyjnego w funduszach hedgingowych przy użyciu dolnych momentów cząstkowych, [w:] I. Pruchnicka-Grabias (red.), Alternatywne instrumenty inwestycyjne,
• Wydawnictwa fachowe CeDeWu, Warszawa, s. 57-79.
• Shadwick W.F., Keating C., 2002, A Universal Performance Measure, Journal of Performance Measurement, wiosna, https://www.isdadocs.org/c_and_a/pdf/GammaPub.pdf.
• Sharma M., 2004, A.I.R.A.P. – alternative RAPMs for alternative investments, Journal of Investment Management, 2(4), s. 106-129.
• Sialm C., Tham T.M., 2016, Spillover Effects in Mutual Fund Companies, Management Science, 62(5), s. 1472-1486.
• Signer A., Favre L., 2002, The difficulties of measuring the benefits of hedge funds, Journal of Alternative Investments, 5(1), s. 31-41.
• Sortino F.A., van der Meer R., Plantiga A., 1999, The Dutch triangle, Journal of Portfolio Management, 26(1), s. 50-58.
• Statman M., Shefrin H., 1998, Behavioral Portfolio Theory, Leavey School of Business, Santa Clara University.
• Tudor D., Cao B., 2012, The absolute returns of hedge funds, Managerial Finance, 38(3), s. 280-302.
• Van Dyk F., van Vuuren G., Heymans A., 2014, Hedge Fund Performance Evaluation Using the Sharpe and Omega Ratios, International Business & Economics Research Journal, 13(3), s. 485-512.