The Role of Family Policy Regimes in Work–Family Adaptations: Polish Parents in Norway and Poland

• Authors: Bjørnholt Margunn , Stefansen Kari , Wężyk Agata , Merecz-Kot Dorota
• Languages of publication: EN

Abstracts

EN

The aim of this article is to examine how family policies contribute to changes in family practices and towards gender equality in families. Empirically we draw on interviews with two groups of Polish-born parents: Polish parents who have migrated to Norway and Polish parents living in Poland. Norway and Poland are relevant cases for our exploration because they represent different types of welfare states, which have followed different paths towards their current family policy package. In our analysis of actual work–family adaptations we found a convergence towards gender-equal dual-earner/dual-carer arrangements in both groups, although there were differences in the level of agency. Polish parents in Poland felt less entitled to use the measures available to them, and sometimes refrained from using them, compared to Polish parents in Norway who expressed a strong sense of agency in using family policy measures to create a good life in Norway and as part of a project of change towards more gender-equal sharing of work and care responsibilities. The analysis confirms the strong link between family practices and family policies, but also illustrates how the effect of policies on practices may be hampered or boosted by the wider historical-cultural context of the society in question. In conclusion, in analyses of the link between policy and practice it may be fruitful to distinguish between family policy packages – the concrete set of entitlements for working parents – and family policy regimes, meaning policies in their wider context, including migrancy as a mediating factor.

Keywords

EN

dual-earner/dual-carer model; family practices; work–family adaptations; gender equality; family policy

• Publisher: Ośrodek Badań nad Migracjami Uniwersytetu Warszawskiego oraz Polska Akademia Nauk
• Journal: Central and Eastern European Migration Review
• Year: 2017
• Volume: 6
• Issue: 2
• Pages: 31-50

Contributors

author

Bjørnholt Margunn

author

Stefansen Kari

author

Wężyk Agata

author

Merecz-Kot Dorota

References

• Bell J., Erdal M. B. (2015). Limited but Enduring Transnational Ties? Transnational Family Life Among Polish Migrants in Norway. Studia Migracyjne – Przegląd Polonijny 41(3): 77–98.
• Bjørnholt M. (2007). The Good, the Bad and the Ugly; endring av mannsrollen, fedrerettigheter og likestilling, in: Å. Eldén, J. Westerstrand (eds), Guts and Glory: Festskrift till Eva Lundgren, pp. 86–107. Uppsala: Uppsala University.
• Bjørnholt M. (2010). Like Father, Like Son? The Transmission of Values, Family Practices, and Work–Family Adaptations to Sons of Work-Sharing Men. Fathering 8(3): 276–299.
• Bjørnholt M. (2012). From Work-Sharing Couples to Equal Parents. Changing Perspectives of Men and Gender Equality, in: M. Jansdotter Samuelsson, C. Krekula, M. Åberg (eds), Gender and Change. Power, Politics and Everyday Practices, pp. 53–72. Karlstad: Karlstad University Press.
• Bjørnholt M. (2014a). Changing Men, Changing Times; Fathers and Sons from an Experimental Gender Equality Study. The Sociological Review 62(2): 295–315.
• Bjørnholt M. (2014b). Theorising Love, Work and Family in Early Norwegian Family Research and Today, in: A. G. Jónasdóttir, A. Ferguson (eds), Love – a Question for Feminism in the Twenty-First Century, pp. 141–158. London,New York: Routledge.
• Bjørnholt M., Stefansen K. (2017). On the Move: Transnational Family Practices Among Polish Parents Working and Caring in Norway, in: K. Slany, E. Guribye, P. Pustułka, M. Ślusarczyk (eds), Polish Migration to Norway, pp.144–161. Frankfurt: Peter Lang.
• Bjørnholt M., Stefansen K. (forthcoming). Same but Different: Polish and Norwegian Parents’ Work–Family Adaptations in Norway. Article under review by journal.
• Bjørnholt M., Stefansen K., Gashi L., Seeberg M. L. (2017). Balancing Acts: Policy Frameworks and Family Care Strategies in Norway, in: T. Sirovátka, J. Válková (eds), Understanding Care Policies in Changing Times: Experiences and Lessons from the Czech Republic and Norway, pp. 161–184. Brno: Masaryk University Press, Centre for Studies of Democracy and Culture.
• Bradshaw J., Ditch J., Holmes H., Whiteford P. (1993). Support for Children. A Comparison of Arrangements in Fifteen Countries. Department of Social Security Research Report 21. London: HMSO.
• Bygnes S., Erdal M. B. (2016). Liquid Migration, Grounded Lives: Considerations About Future Mobility and Settlement Among Polish and Spanish Migrants in Norway. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, July 27, 2016, doi: 10.1080/1369183X.2016.1211004.
• Creswell J. W. (2007). Qualitative Enquiry and Research Design: Choosing Among Five Approaches. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
• Edlund J., Öun I. (2016). Who Should Work and Who Should Care? Attitudes Towards the Desirable Division of Labour Between Mothers and Fathers in Five European Countries. Acta Sociologica 59(2): 151–170.
• EIGE (European Institute for Gender Equality) (2015). Country Profile of Poland – Gender Equality Index 2015. Online: http://eige.europa.eu/rdc/eige-publications/poland-gender-equality-index... (accessed: 13 September 2016).
• Ellingsæter A. L. (2006). The Norwegian Childcare Regime and Its Paradoxes, in: A. L. Ellingsæter, A. Leira (eds), Politicising Parenthood in Scandinavia. Gender Relations in Welfare States, pp. 121–144. Bristol: Policy Press.
• Ellingsæter A. L., Gulbrandsen L. (2007). Closing the Childcare Gap: The Interaction of Childcare Provision and Mothers’ Agency in Norway. Journal of Social Policy 36(4): 649–669.
• Ellingsæter A. L., Leira A. (2006). Politicising Parenthood in Scandinavia: Gender Relations in Welfare States. Bristol: Policy Press.
• EU (2016). Country Report Poland 2016. Brusssels: European Commission.
• Eydal G. B., Rostgaard T. (2015). Fatherhood in the Nordic Welfare States. Comparing Care Policies and Practices. Bristol: Policy Press.
• Fineman M. (1995). The Neutered Mother, the Sexual Family, and Other Twentieth Century Tragedies. New York, London: Routledge.
• Fraser N. (1994). After the Family Wage: Gender Equity and the Welfare State. Political Theory 22(4): 591–618.
• Friberg J. H. (2012). The Stages of Migration: From Going Abroad to Settling Down. Post-Accession Polish Migrant Workers in Norway. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 38(10): 1589–1605.
• Fuszara M. (2005). Kobiety w polityce. Warsaw: Trio.
• Grabowska I., Garapich M. P., Jaźwińska E., Radziwinowiczówna A. (2017). Migrants As Agents of Change. Social Remittances in an Enlarged European Union. Basingstoke, London: Palgrave Macmillan.
• Grabowska I., Engbersen G. (2016). Social Remittances and the Impact of Temporary Migration on an EU Sending Country: The Case of Poland. Central and Eastern European Migration Review 5(2): 99–117.
• Halperin-Kaddari R., Freeman M. (2016). Backlash Goes Global: Men’s Groups, Patriarchal Family Policy, and the False Promise of Gender-Neutral Laws. Canadian Journal of Women and the Law 28(1): 182–210.
• Halrynjo S., Lyng S. T. (2009). Preferences, Constraints or Schemas of Devotion? Exploring Norwegian Mothers’ Withdrawals from High‐Commitment Careers. British Journal of Sociology 60(2): 321–343.
• Heinen J. (2002). Ideology, Economics, and the Politics of Child Care in Poland Before and After the Transition, in: M. Sonya, M. Rianne (eds), Child Care Policy at the Crossroads: Gender and Welfare State Restructuring, pp 71–94. New York: Routledge.
• Heinen J., Wator M. (2006). Child Care in Poland Before, During, and After the Transition: Still a Woman’s Business. Social Politics: International Studies in Gender, State and Society 13(2): 189–216.
• Hipsz N. (2013). O roli kobiet w rodzinie, in: M. Grabowska (ed.), Rodzina i jej przemiany, pp. 10–26. Opinie i Diagnozy 26. Warsaw: Centrum Badania Opinii Społecznej.
• Kitterød R. H., Nymoen E. H., Lyngstad J. (2012). Endringer i bruk av barnetilsyn fra 2002 til 2010. Rapport 23/2012. Oslo: Statistics Norway.
• Korkut U., Eslen-Ziya H. (2011). The Impact of Conservative Discourses in Family Policies, Population Politics, and Gender Rights in Poland and Turkey. Social Politics: International Studies in Gender, State and Society 18(3): 387–418.
• Lewis J. (1992). Gender and the Development of Welfare Regimes. Journal of European Social Policy 2(3): 159–173.
• May P. J., Jochim A. E. (2013). Policy Regime Perspectives: Policies, Politics, and Governing. Policy Studies Journal 41(3): 426–452.
• Melby K., Pylkkänen A., Rosenbeck B., Wetterberg T. C. (2006). The Nordic Model of Marriage. Women’s History Review 15(4): 651–661.
• Messner M. A. (2016). Forks in the Road of Men’s Gender Politics: Men’s Rights vs Feminist Allies. International Journal for Crime, Justice and Social Democracy 5(2): 6–20.
• Nowicka W. (2007). The Struggle for Abortion Rights in Poland, in: R. Parker, R. P. Petchesky, R. Sember (eds), Sex Politics: Reports from the Front Lines, pp. 167–196. New York: Columbia University Press.
• Paternotte D. (2014). Christian Trouble: The Catholic Church and the Subversion of Gender. CritCom: A Forum for Research & Commentary on Europe. Online: http://councilforeuropeanstudies.org/critcom/christian-trouble-the-catho... (accessed: 10 September 2016).
• Pawlak M. (2015a). Othering the Self: National Identity and Social Class in Mobile Lives, in: H. Cervinkova, M. Buchowski, Z. Uherek (eds), Rethinking Ethnography in Central Europe, pp. 23–40. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
• Pawlak M. (2015b). Recognizing the National Identity: Cultural Intimacy and the Polish Migration to Norway. Prace Etnograficzne 43(3): 241–258.
• Ryan L. (2011). Transnational Relations: Family Migration Among Recent Polish Migrants in London. International Migration 49(2): 80–103.
• Sainsbury D. (2001). Gender and the Making of Welfare States: Norway and Sweden. Social Politics: International Studies in Gender, State & Society 8(1): 113–143.
• Siara B. (2013). The Construction of Gender in the Migration Space: Polish Women in the UK. GENDER. Zeitschrift fur Geschlecht, Kultur und Gesellschaft 5(1): 105–120.
• Slany K., Pustułka P. (2016). Children, Parents and Institutions in the Mobility Maze. Central and Eastern European Migration Review 5(1): 5–12.
• Ślusarczyk M., Pustułka P. (2016). Norwegian Schooling in the Eyes of Polish Parents: From Contestations to Embracing the System. Central and Eastern European Migration Review 5(1): 49–69.
• Statistics Norway (2017a). Barnehager 2016 endelige tall. Online: https://www.ssb.no/barnehager (accessed: 28 April 2017).
• Statistics Norway (2017b). Innvandrere og norskfødte med innvandrerforeldre, 1. Januar 2017. Online: https://www.ssb.no/befolkning/statistikker/innvbef/aar/2017 (acessed: 12 July 2017).
• Stefansen K., Farstad G. R. (2010). Classed Parental Practices in a Modern Welfare State. Caring for the Under Threes in Norway. Critical Social Policy 30(1): 120–141.
• Stefansen K., Skogen K. (2010). Selective Identification, Quiet Distancing: Understanding the Working‐Class Response to the Nordic Daycare Model. The Sociological Review 58(4): 587–603.
• Szelewa D. (2012). Childcare Policies and Gender Relations in Eastern Europe: Hungary and Poland Compared. Harriet Taylor Mill-Institut für Ökonomie und Geschlechterforschung Discussion Paper 17, 03/2012. Berlin School of Economics and Law. Online: http://www.harriet-taylor-mill.de/images/docs/discuss/DiscPap17.pdf. (accessed: 23 September 2016).
• Szelewa D., Polakowski M. P. (2008). Who Cares? Changing Patterns of Childcare in Central and Eastern Europe. Journal of European Social Policy 18(2): 115–131.
• Tavory I., Timmermans S. (2009). Two Cases of Ethnography. Grounded Theory and the Extended Case Method. Ethnography 10(3): 243–263.
• Timmermans S., Tavory I. (2012). Theory Construction in Qualitative Research from Grounded Theory to Abductive Analysis. Sociological Theory 30(3): 167–186.
• Velluti S. (2014). Gender Regimes and Gender Equality Measures in Central Eastern European Countries Post-Accession: The Case of Hungary and Poland. Journal of International and Comparative Social Policy 30(1): 79–91.
• Weldon L. (2011). When Protest Makes Policy: How Social Movements Represent Disadvantaged Groups. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
• White A. (2016a). Polish Migration to the UK Compared with Migration Elsewhere in Europe: A Review of the Literature. Social Identities 22(1): 10–25.
• White A. (2016b). Social Remittances and Migration (Sub-)Cultures in Contemporary Poland. Central and Eastern European Migration Review 5(2): 63–80.
• Wærdahl R. (2016). The Invisible Immigrant Child in the Norwegian Classroom: Losing Sight of Polish Children’s Immigrant Status Through Unarticulated Differences and Behind Good Intentions. Central and Eastern European Migration Review 5(1): 93–108.