British Film Propaganda in the Netherlands: Its Preconditions and Missed Opportunities

• Authors: Stachura Natalia

Abstracts

British film propaganda directed at neutral countries was meant to strengthen the pro-British attitude or at least weaken pro-German sentiments in the neutral countries. Directed at the wide strata of neutral societies as well as at intellectual, military and economic elites, factual films from the battle lines were believed not only to counteract German propaganda but also to overshadow hostile actions taken by British government against economic and political freedoms of the neutrals. This article is an attempt at understanding the reasons for the eventual failure of British film propaganda in the Netherlands. While mentioning various conflict areas between the countries, it focuses on cultural entanglements and cultural networks that developed, though precariously, throughout the war. The neglect of existing connections between British and Dutch filmmakers and the hesitant if not hostile attitude of War Office Cinematograph Committee towards expensive adaptations of literary works, and feature films in general, might be perceived, the article argues, as one of the core reasons, along political and economic tensions, why Britain lost the battle for Dutch cinema audiences.

Keywords

EN

The Great War; the Netherlands; wartime propaganda; indirect propaganda; cinema in wartime; The Battle of the Somme (film)

• Publisher: Institute of English Studies, University of Warsaw
• Journal: Anglica. An International Journal of English Studies
• Year: 2018
• Issue: 27/3
• Pages: 51-81

Contributors

author

Stachura Natalia

• Independent scholar

References

• Aarten, Stephanie Sierou. 2015. Holland Neutraal: Een onderzoek naar de totstandkoming, receptie en vertoning van de Nederlandse leger en vloot fi lm gedurende de eerste wereldoorlog, aan de hand van kranten, opiniebladen, en fi lmvakbladen. Unpublished MA. Brussel: VUB.
• Abbenhuis, Maartje. 2006. The Art of Staying Neutral. The Netherlands in the First World War, 1914–1918. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.
• Abel, Richard. 1991. “French Film Melodrama: Before and After the War.” Imitations of Life: A Reader on Film & Television Melodrama. Ed. Marcia Landy Detroit: Wayne State University Press. 542–568.
• Badsey, Setephen. 2009. The British Army in Battle and Its Image 1914–18. London: Continuum.
• “Wat leert ons de Leger- en Vlootfi lm?” Bataviaasch nieuwsblad (6 February 1918): 2.
• Bishoff . Ruud. 1986. “De zwijgende speelfi lm.” Geschiedenis van de Nederlandse film en bioscoop tot 1940. Ed. Karel Dibbets and Frank van der Maden. Weesp: Het Wereldvenster. 53–104.
• —. 1988. Hollywood in Holland. De geschiedenis van de Filmfabriek Hollandia 1912–1923. Amsterdam: Thoth.
• Blom, Ivo. 1996 “Of Artists and Tourists. Locating Holland in Two Early German Films.” A Second Life: German Cinema’s First Decades. Ed. Thomas Elsaesser and Michael Wedel. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press. 246–255.
• —. 1997. “De eerste fi lmgigant in Nederland. De snelle verovering van Nederland door Pathé.” Jaarboek Mediageschiedenis 8: 129–152.
• —. 1999. “Chapters from the Life of a Camera Operator. The recollections of Anton Nöggerath – fi lming news and non-fi ction, 1897–1908.” Film History 11. 3: 262–281.
• —. 2001. “Business as usual? Filmhandel, bioscoopwezen en fi lmpropaganda in Nederland tijdens de Eerste Wereldoorlog.” Leven naast de catastrofe. Nederland tijdens de Eerste Wereldoorlog. Ed. Hans Binneveld, Martin Kraaijestein, Marja Roholl, and Paul Schulten. Hilversum: Verloren. 129–143.
• —. 2003. Jean Desmet and the Early Dutch Film Trade. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.
• Buelens, Geert. 2010. “The Silence of the Somme. Sound and Realism in British and Dutch Poems Mediating The Battle of the Somme.” Journal of Dutch Literature 1. 1: 5–27.
• —. 2016. “Inleiding.” Plots hel werd het. Jacobus van Looy en The Battle of the Somme. Ed. Geert Buelens. Rimburg: Huis Clos. 9–14.
• Carden, Ron. 2014. German Policy Toward Neutral Spain, 1914–1918. London and New York: Routledge.
• Compagnon, Olivier and Pierre Purseigle. 2016. “Géographies de la mobilisation et territoires de la belligérance durant la Première Guerre mondiale.” Annales . Histoire, Sciences Sociales (71e année): 37–64.
• Conrad, Sebastian and Shalini Randeria. 2002. Jenseits des Eurozentrismus: postkoloniale Perspektiven in den Geschichts- und Kulturwissenschaften. Frankfurt and New York: Campus Verlag.
• Convents. Guido. 2000. Van kinetoscoop tot café-ciné: de eerste jaren van de film in België, 1894–1908. Leuven: Universitaire Pers.
• Cürlis, Hans. 1918. “Aufzeichnungen und Vorschläge in Filmsachen anlässlich einer Reise nach Holland.” Bundesarchiv Berlin Lichterfelde R901/ 71961.
• Delpeut. Peter. 1997. “A Cinema of Accidental Incidents. Dutch Fiction Films 1896–1933. A Review.” Of Joy and Sorrow: a Filmography of Dutch Silent Fiction. Ed. Geoff rey Donaldson. Amsterdam: Stichting Nederlands Filmmuseum. 11–32.
• Dibbets, Karel and Wouter Groot. 2010. “Which Battle of the Somme? War and Neutrality in Dutch Cinemas, 1914–1918.” Film History 22: 440–452.
• Dijk, Kees van. 2007. The Netherlands Indies and the Great War. Leiden: KITLV Press.
• Duisberg, Carl Ludwig. 2001. “Revolution der Filmkunst. Gedanken ueber die Macht des Films (1917).” KINtop. Jahrbuch zur Erforschung des frühen Films. KINtop-Jahrbuch 10: Europäer in den USA. 95–102.
• Engelen, Leen. 2005. “Cinematic Representations of the Enemy in Belgian Silent Fiction Films.” Warfare and Belligerence. Perspectives in First World War Studies. Ed. Pierre Purseigle. Boston: Brill. 359–378.
• Espagne, Michel. 1994. “Sur les limites du comparatisme en histoire culturelle.” Genèses 17: 112–121.
• Frey, Marc 2000. “The Neutrals and World War One.” Forsvarsstudier 3: 4–39.
• —. 2001. “Anglo-Dutch Relations during the First World War.” Unspoken Allies: Anglo-Dutch relations since 1780. Ed. Nigel Ashton and Duco Hellema. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press. 59–84.
• Haan, Jitze de. 1995. Polygoon spaant de kroon. Geschiedenis van fi lmfabriek Polygoon 1919–1945. Amsterdam: Otto Cramwinckel.
• Jung, Uli and Wolfgang Mühl-Benninghausen. 2005. “Ästhetischer Wandel. Dokumentarische Propagandafi lme.” Geschichte des dokumentarischen Films in Deutschland. Vol. 1: Kaiserreich 1895–1918. Ed. Uli Jung and Martin Loiperdinger. Stuttgart: Reclam. 429–453.
• “Fred Penley.” https://www.eyefi lm.nl/collectie/fi lmgeschiedenis/persoon/fredpenley
• Jeffery, Keith. 2010. MI6: The History of the Secret Intelligence Service 1909–1949. London: Bloomsbury Press.
• Klinkert, Wim. 2013a. Defending Neutrality: The Netherlands Prepares for War, 1900–1925. Leiden-Boston: Brill.
• —. 2013b. “A Spy’s Paradise? Germ an Espionage in the Netherlands, 1914–1918.” Journal of Intelligence History 12. 1: 21–35. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/1616 1262.2013.755017
• Kristel, Conny. 2007. “Propagandaslag. Nederlandse reacties op de Britse film ‘Battle of the Somme’ (1916).” Wankel evenwicht. Neutraal Nederland en de Eerste Wereldoorlog. Ed. Martin Kraaijestein and Paul Schutten. Soesterberg: Aspekt. 344–365.
• —. 2016. De oorlog van anderen: Nederland en oorlogsgeweld, 1914–1918. Amsterdam: De Bezige Bij.
• Kruizinga, Samuel. 2012. Overlegeconomie in oorlogstijd: de Nederlandsche Overzee Trustmaatschappij en de Eerste Wereldoorlog. Zutphen: Walburg Pers.
• “Kunst en Letteren. Cinema Palace. Oorlogsfi lms.” Het Volk (28 November 1916): 6.
• LEO. “Cinema Palace. De slag aan de Somme. De verovering van Gorizia.” De Telegraaf (28 November 1916): 6.
• Maden, Frank van der. 1986. “De komst van de fi lm.” Geschiedenis van de Nederlandse fi lm en bioscoop tot 1940. Ed. Karel Dibbets and Frank van der Maden. Weesp: Het Wereldvenster. 11–52.
• McEwen, J. M. 1979. “Lord Beaverbrook: Historian Extraordinary.” Dalhousie Review 59. 1: 129–143.
• McKernan, Luke. 2013. Charles Urban: Pioneering the Non-Fiction Film in Britain and America, 1897–1925. Exeter: University of Exeter Press.
• McKernan, Luke. 2002. “Propaganda, Patriotism and Profi t: Charles Urban and British Offi cial War Films in America during the First World War.” Film History 14 nos. 3–4.
• Messinger, Gary S. 1993. “An Inheritance Worth Remembering: The British Approach to Offi cial Propaganda During the First World War.” Historical Journal of Film, Radio and Television 13: 117–128.
• Moeyes, Paul. 2001. Buiten Schot: Nederland tijdens de Eerste Wereldoorlog 1914–1918. Amsterdam: de Arbeiderspers.
• “Papers of Sir Francis Oppenheimer (1870–1961).” Balliol College Archives & Manuscripts. http://archives.balliol.ox.ac.uk/Modern%20Papers/oppenheimer.asp
• Pfister, Manfred. 2008. “Introduction: Performing National Identity..” Performing National Identity: Anglo-Italian Cultural Transactions. Ed. Manfred Pfi ster and Ralf Hertel. Amsterdam and New York: Rodopi. 9–28.
• Ponsonby, Arthur. 1928. Falsehood in War-Time: Containing an Assortment of Lies Circulated Throughout the Nations During the Great War. London: Garland Publishing Company. http://gutenberg.net.au/ebooks10/1000011.txt
• Reeves, Nicolas. 1983. “Film Propaganda and its Audience: The Example of Britain’s Offi cial Films during the First World War.” Journal of Contemporary History 18: 463–494.
• Reeves, Nicholas. 1986. Offi cial British Film Propaganda During the First World War. London: Croom Helm.
• Reeves, Nicholas. 2003 [1999]. The Power of Film Propaganda: Myth or Reality. London: Continuum.
• Reiter. Don. 1996. Crucible of Beliefs: Learning, Alliances, and World Wars. Ithaca-London: Cornell University Press.
• Rogin, Michael. 1985. “‘The Sword Became a Flashing Vision’: D. W. Griffi ths The Birth of a Nation.” Representations, Special Issue: American Culture Between the Civil War and World War I 9: 150–195.
• Rossini, Manuela and Michael Toggweiler. 2014. “Cultural Transfer: An Introduction.” Word and Text. A Journal of Literary Studies and Linguistics 4. 2: 5–9.
• Ruis, Edwin. 2016. Spynest: British and German Espionage from Neutral Holland 1914–1918. Stroud: The History Press.
• Sanders, M. L. 1975. “Wellington House and British propaganda during the First World War.” The Historical Journal 18: 119–146.
• Smither, Roger. 2005. “Der Magische Gurtel (The Enchanted Circle, 1917) – A Case Study in First World War German Propaganda.” War and the Media: Reportage and Propaganda 1900–2003. Ed. Mark Connelly and David Welsh. London: I.B. Tauris. 82–91.
• Stiasny, Philip. 2009. Das Kino und der Krieg. Deutschland 1914–1929. München: edition text + kritik.
• Tames, Ismee. 2006. Oorlog voor onze gedachten. Oorlog, neutraliteit en identiteit in het Nederlandse publieke debat, 1914–1918. Hilversum: Verloren.
• Taylor, Philp M. 2003 [1990]. Munitions of the Mind: A History of Propaganda from the Ancient World to the Present Era. Manchester: Manchester University Press. De Telegraaf (28 November 1916): 6.
• Thompson, Kristin. 1985. Exporting Entertainment: America in the World Film Market 1907–1934. BFI: London.
• Vaal, J. de, A. Grandia en H. Weijel. 1984. “Theo Frenkel Sr. Mentor van de Nederlandse Filmindustrie.” Filmmuseum cinemateek journaal. 57. 1983–1984: 19–22. Het Volk (28 November 1916).
• Vries, Tjitte de en Ati Mul. 2009. “They thought it was a Marvel.” Arthur Melbourne-Cooper (1874–1961) Pioneer of Puppet Animation. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press/Pallas Publications.
• “Wat leert ons de Leger- en Vlootfi lm? Bataviaasch nieuwsblad (6 February 1918): 2.
• Werner, Michael and Bénédicte Zimmermann. 2003. “Penser l’histoire croisée: Entre empirie et réfl exivité.” Annales. Histoire, Sciences Sociales. 2003/1 (58e année): 7–36.
• West, Nigel. 2013. Historical Dictionary of World War I Intelligence. Lanhan: Scarcecrow Press.
• Wielinga, Menno. 2014. Het Engelse Kamp Groningen 1914–1918. De geschiedenis van 1.500 Engelse militairen tijdens de Eerste Wereldoorlog. Bedum: Profi el Uitgeverij.
• Willems. Wim. 2004. Cultuur en migratie in Nederland. De kunst van het overleven. Levensverhalen uit de twintigste eeuw. Den Haag: Sdu Uitgevers.
• Zwaan, Klaas de. 2016. “De dood op het doek. The Battle of the Somme als mediagebeurtenis in Nederland.” Plots hel werd het. Jacobus van Looy en The Battle of the Somme. Ed. Geert Buelens. Rimburg: Huis Clos. 69–86.
• Foreign Office, INF 4/4A.
• FO 395/22/231749, 30 October 1916, Blakiston to Carson.
• FO 395/38/171180, Gowers to Lampson, 26 August 1917.
• FO 395/100/174949, Steward to Maxse, 28 August 1917.
• FO 395/102/214539, Maxse to Montgomery, 8 January 1917.
• FO 395/102/12446, Johnstone to Maxse, 9 January 1917.
• FO 395/102/12077, Wicks to Carson, 16 January 1917.
• FO 395/102/31076/Johnstone to Montgomery, 5 February 1917.
• FO 395/102/154058, Maxse to Montgomery, 4 August 1917.
• FO 395/102/196650, Steward to Maxse, 3 October 1917.
• FO 395/102/204071, Pryde Hughes to Montgomery, 18 October 1917.
• FO 395/102/206901, Northam to Montgomery, 27 October 1917.
• FO 395/102/213171, Guest’s Memorandum, 1 November 1917.
• FO 395/102/223309, Stewa rd to Maxse, 14 November 1917.
• FO 395/102/222554, Rothwell to Montgomery, 19 November 1917.
• FO 395/102/222558, Brunel to Montgomery, 20 November 1917.
• FO 395/102/242413, Gilmour to Steward, 20 December 1917.
• FO 395/102/238426, Steward’s Report, December 1917.
• Bundersarchiv R901/71951, German Embassy to Foreign Offi ce, 25 October 1917.
• Bundesarchiv R901/71961, NOT to Firma B. Vissers, 17 September 1918.
• Alsace. 1916. Dir. Henri Pouctal. Prod. Le Film d’Art.
• L’ Alsace attendait 1917. Dir. Henri Desfontaines. Prod. SPCA.
• The Battle of Arras 1917. Dir. unknown. Prod. Topical Films Committee, William
• Jury. Geoff rey H. Malins.
• The Battle of the Ancre and the Advancement of Tanks [The Battle of the Scarpe]
• 1917. Dir. Geoff rey H. Malins. Prod. WOCC, William Jury.
• The Battle of the Somme 1916. Dir. Geoff rey Malins and John McDowell. Prod. William Jury.
• The Battle of Waterloo 1913. Dir. Charles Weston. Prod. British & Colonial Kinematograph Company.
• Bei unseren Helden an der Somme. 1917. Dir. unknown. Prod. Bufa.
• Britain Prepared.1915. Dir. Charles Urban. Prod. Charles Urban.
• Called to the Front. 1914. Dir. Charles Weston. Prod. Regent Film.
• General Allenby’s Entry into Jerusalem [General Allenby Enters into Jerusalem]. 1918. Prod. WOCC, Topical Budget Films.
• Hearts of the World. 1918. Dir. D.W. Griffi th. Prod. D.W. Griffi th, WOCC.
• His Britannic Majesty’s Visit to His Grand Fleet [His Majesty’s Visit to His Grand Fleet or The King’s Visit to His Grand Fleet]. 1917. Dir. unknown. Prod. WOCC.
• Mater Dolorosa. 1917. Dir. Abel Gance. Prod. Louis Nalpas.
• Mères françaises. 1917. Dir. René Hervil, Louis Mercanton. Prod. Éclair.
• The National Film. 1918. Dir. D.W. Griffi th. Prod. D.W. Griffi th, WOCC.
• The Perils of Pauline. 1914. Dir. Louis J. Gasnier, Donald MacKenzie. Prod. Pathé Frères.
• Peronne [The Great German Retreat. The Capture of Peronne]. 1917. Dir. William Jury, Geoff rey Malins, J. B. MCDowell, H. C. Raymond. Prod. WOCC and Topical Film Company.
• Pimple’s Battle of Waterloo (1913). Dir. Fred Evans, Joe Evans. Prod. Folly Films.
• Portuguese Expeditionary Force in France [The Portugese Contingent]. 1917. Dir. unknown. Prod. WOCC and Topical Film Company.
• La Presa di Gorizia [La battaglia di Gorizia]. 1916. Dir. Luca Comerio. Prod. Luca Comerio.
• La Puissance militaire de la France. 1917. Dir. Henri Desfontaines. Prod. Section Cinématographique des Armées (SCA)
• The Road to Calais. 1914. Dir. Charles Weston. Prod. Regent Film.
• Sons of [our] Empire. Dir. William Jury, J. B. McDowell, H. C. Raymond. Prod. WOCC and Topical Film Company. 1917.
• The South African Labour Contingent in France [South African Labour Contingent
• Somewhere in France]. 1917. Dir. unknown. Prod. WOCC and Topical Film Company.
• Storm and the Drifters [The Story of the Drifters and of the Sea Dogs who man them, The or The Story of the Drifters and of the Sailors who man them]. 1917. Dir. F.W. Engholm. Prod. Admiralty.
• A Study in Scarlet 1914. Dir. George Pearson. Prod. George Pearson.
• The Timbertown Follies 2014. Dir. Leo van Maaren. Prod. Stichting Jazz van het Bankroet.
• Tommy Atkins. 1915. Dir. Bert Haldane. Prod. Barker.
• Ultus and the Secret of the Night. 1916. Dir. George Pearson. Prod. Gaumont GB. British Film Propaganda in the Netherlands: Its Preconditions and Missed Opportunities 81
• Ultus and the three-button mystery. 1917. Dir. George Pearson. Prod. Gaumont GB.
• Ultus, the Man from the Dead. 1916. Dir. George Pearson. Prod. Gaumont GB.
• The Valley of Fear. 1916. Dir. George Pearson. Prod. G. B. Samuelson Productions.