The guerrilla strikes back: a comment on Yvonne Chiu

• Authors: Uwe Steinhoff
• Languages of publication: EN

Abstracts

EN

In a recent article Yvonne Chiu argues that nonuniformed combat is impermissible. However, her argument that by fighting without uniforms nonuniformed guerillas coerce civilians into participating in the armed conflict and thus into surrendering their immunity (their right not to be attacked) fails: there is no coercion, no participation, and no surrendering of immunity. Yet even if this argument of hers were correct, it would still not show that such “coercion” would amount to a rights infringement. Moreover, even if it did, there are examples that show that such an infringement would sometimes be perfectly justified. Finally, if she were right that forcing civilians into a moral position that they have not accepted or chosen is absolutely wrong, then this would affect the moral status of uniformed combatants no less than it would affect the moral status of nonuniformed ones.

Keywords

EN

Yvonne Chiu; civilian; combatant; guerrilla; uniform; war

• Publisher: Instytut Filozofii - Uniwersytet Jagielloński
• Journal: Diametros
• Year: 2011
• Issue: 30
• Pages: 61-75

Contributors

author

Uwe Steinhoff

• University of Hong Kong

References

• Benbaji [2008] – Y. Benbaji, A Defense of the Traditional War Convention, ―Ethics (118) 2008.
• Benbaji [2009] – Y. Benbaji, The War Convention and the Moral Division of Labour, ―The Philosophical Quarterly (59) 2009.
• Chiu [2010] – Y. Chiu, Uniform Exceptions and Rights Violations, ―Social Theory and Practice (36) 2010.
• Detter [2003] – I. Detter, The Law of War, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2003.
• Herman [1993] – B. Herman, The Practice of Moral Judgment, Harvard University Press, Cambridge 1993.
• Kutz [2005] – C. Kutz, The Difference Uniforms Make: Collective Violence in Criminal Law and War, ― Philosophy and Public Affairs (33) 2005.
• McMahan [1994] - J. McMahan, Self-Defense and the Problem of the Innocent Attacker, ― Ethics (104) 1994.
• McMahan [2010] – J. McMahan, The Just Distribution of Harm Between Combatants and Noncombatants, ―Philosophy and Public Affairs (38) 2010.
• Ramsey [2002] – P. Ramsey, The Just War: Force and Political Responsibility, Rowman & Littlefield, Lanham 2002.
• Steinhoff [2007] – U. Steinhoff, On the Ethics of War and Terrorism, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2007.
• Steinhoff [2010a] – U. Steinhoff, In Defence of Guerrillas, ―Diametros (23) 2010.
• Steinhoff [2010b] – U. Steinhoff, Benbaji on Killing in War and ‘the War Convention’: A Critique, ―The Philosophical Quarterly‖ (60) 2010.
• Steinhoff [2011] – U. Steinhoff, The Uselessness of Rawls’s ‘Ideal Theory’, unpublished ms. Thomson [1991] – J.J. Thomson, Self-Defense, ―Philosophy and Public Affairs (20) 1991.

Identifiers

DOI

10.13153/diam.30.2011.456