Denial of genocide and other war crimes in Bosnia and Herzegovina and its impact on violation of human rights

• Authors: Gurda Vedad
• Languages of publication: EN

Abstracts

EN

Since the war in Bosnia and Herzegovina (BiH) ended in 1995, hundreds of people have been found guilty by international, domestic and foreign courts, of various war crimes, including the most terrible crime of the genocide in Srebrenica. Nevertheless, in the past three decades, examples have been continuously registered in public sphere of denying, minimising and approving these crimes. It is especially dangerous that the denial of these crimes takes an institutional form. These denialist practices are primarily encountered in the BiH's entity Republika Srpska (RS) and neighbouring Serbia, as well as in Montenegro and North Macedonia. In 2021, the High Representative in BiH, imposed amendments to the Criminal Code of BiH, by which he criminalised the denial of genocide and other war crimes. Unfortunately, the criminalisation of denying these crimes did not stop the deniers. Although over 100 criminal charges have been reported, the Prosecutor's Office of BiH has filed only two charges, but none of the reported persons have been convicted to date. This article criticises this kind of prosecution practice. The article’s aim is to investigate the ways, in which certain political elites deny the genocide and other war crimes in BiH, as well as to analyse the prosecution of deniers before the BiH criminal justice authorities. The author attempts to answer the following research questions: (1) What are the dominant ways of denying genocide and other war crimes in the public sphere, and who are the most frequent deniers? (2) How has the denial of these crimes been criminalised, and do the competent courts in BiH prosecute the deniers? (3) What is the possible impact of denying these crimes on the human rights and freedoms of the victims, and does the incrimination and potential prosecution of deniers limit their freedom of expression? The research methods include analysis and synthesis, induction and deduction, as well as normative and dogmatic approach. At the end, the author concludes about the impact of processing genocide denial on human rights and freedoms, including the freedom of expression guaranteed by Art. 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

Keywords

EN

Bosnia and Herzegovina; Europe; genocide denial; war crimes; freedom of expression; the Srebrenica genocide; human rights

• Publisher: Wydział Nauk Politycznych i Studiów Międzynarodowych, Uniwersytet Warszawski
• Journal: Przegląd Europejski
• Year: 2025
• Issue: 1(75)
• Pages: 21 - 45

Dates

published

2025

Contributors

author

Gurda Vedad

• University of Tuzla

References

• ATLAGIĆ Marko, MARTINOVIĆ Aleksandar (2021), Masakr u Srebrenici 1995. godine je najveći trijumf propagande, „Baština“. DOI: 10.5937/bastina31-34114
• BASAK Ertür (2019), Law of Denial. Law and Critique, „Birkbeck Institutional Research Online“, vol. 30, no. 1.
• BRNABIĆ: „Ratni zločin se desio, ali nije bio genocid“ (2024), https://avaz.ba/vijesti/region/904626/brnabic-ratni-zlocin-se-desio-ali-nije-bio-genocid (04.05.2024).
• BURSAĆ Dragan (2020), Lešinarsko kolo: Srebrenice, tako si mi mila, dabogda se ponovila!, „AlJazeera“, https://balkans.aljazeera.net/opinions/2020/1/3/lesinarsko-kolo-srebrenice-tako-si-mi-mila-dabogda-se-ponovila (03.01.2020).
• CRNA GORA: Smijenjen minister koji negira genocide u Srebrenici (2021), https://vijesti.hrt.hr/svijet/crna-gora-smijenjen-ministar-koji-negira-genocid-u-srebrenici-2117393 (17.06.2021).
• ČEKIĆ Smail (2018), Genocid u Republici Bosni i Hercegovini 1992-1995, „Pregled“, vol. LIX, no. 1.
• DE VLAMING Frederiek, CLARK Kate (2014), War Reparations in Bosnia and Herzegovina: Individual Stories and Collective Interests, in: Dubravka Zarkov, Marlies Glasius (eds), Narratives of Justice in and Out of the Courtroom: Former Yugoslavia and Beyond, Springer.
• DIMITRIJEVIĆ Vojin, HADŽI–VIDANOVIĆ Vidan, JOVANOVIĆ Ivan, MARKOVIĆ Žarko, MILANOVIĆ Marko (2013), Haške nedoumice: Poznato i nepoznato o Međunarodnom krivičnom tribunalu za bivšu Jugoslaviju (drugo izdanje), Beograd.
• DODIK PORUČIO "ne možemo dijeliti ni zrak". Evo šta na to kažu građani Banjaluke, Istočnog Sarajeva i Sarajeva (2024), https://n1info.ba/vijesti/dodik-porucio-ne-mozemo-dijeliti-ni-zrak-evo-sta-na-to-kazu-gradjani-banjaluke-istocnog-sarajeva-i-sarajeva/?comments (24.04.2024).
• DOSAD NAJDRSKIJI ISTUP LIDERA BOSANSKIH SRBA: U Srebrenici nitko nije ubijen! Sve što je stradalo, stradalo je izvan (2024), „Slobodna Dalmacija“, https://slobodnadalmacija.hr/vijesti/regija/dosad-najdrskiji-istup-lidera-bosanskih-srba-u-srebrenici-nitko-nije-ubijen-sve-sto-je-stradalo-stradalo-je-izvan-1392698 (30.05.2024).
• DVIJE OPTUŽNICE ZA TRI GODINE, a krivičnih prijava više od stotinu (2024), https://www.federalna.ba/dvije-optuznice-za-tri-godine-a-krivicnih-prijava-vise-od-stotinu-zakon-nije-dovoljan-qvwcz (29.02.2024).
• DŽANANOVIĆ Muamer, MEHMEDOVIĆ Adem, VUČIĆ Nikola, IKANOVIĆ Edin (2023), Srebrenica Genocide Denial Report 2023, Srebrenica Memorial Center, Srebrenica.
• EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT (2015), European Parliament resolution of 9 July 2015 on the Srebrenica Commemoration (2015/2747(RSP)), OJ C 265, 11.08.2017.
• EF: KAVAZOVIĆ: Negiranjem genocida žrtve se svjesno ubijaju po drugi put (2020), https://radiosarajevo.ba/vijesti/bosna-i-hercegovina/ef-kavazovic-negiranjem-genocida-zrtve-se-svjesno-ubijaju-po-drugi-put/382711 (08.07.2020).
• GREBO Lamija (2023), Kako su tužioci odbacili 27 prijava za negiranje genocida i veličanje zločinaca, „Detektor“, https://detektor.ba/2023/02/22/kako-su-tuzioci-odbacili-27-prijava-za-negiranje-genocida-i-velicanje-zlocinaca/ (22.02.2023).
• GURDA Vedad (2020), Sporazumi o priznanju krivnje za ratne zločine u Bosni i Hercegovini: između pokajanja i konsenzualne pravde, „Zbornik radova Pravnog fakulteta u Tuzli“, no. 1-2.
• GURDA Vedad, MAHMUTOVIĆ Dževad, IVELJIĆ Maja (2021a), War Crimes Prosecution in Your Own Yard: Some Indicators of the Fifteen-Year Work of the War Crimes Chamber of the Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina, „Monumenta Srebrenica“, vol. 10.
• GURDA Vedad, MAHMUTOVIĆ Dževad, IVELJIĆ Maja (2021b), Postdejtonsko traganje za pravdom: Suđenja za ratne zločine u Bosni i Hercegovini pred nadležnim sudovima, „Historijski pogledi“, no. 6.
• GURDA Vedad (2022), Chronology of the Trial of Ratko Mladić for Genocide in Srebrenica and Other Crimes Before the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia, „Monumenta Srebrenica“, vol. 11.
• HALILOVICH Hariz (2017), Globalization and Genocide, in: Ali Farazmand (ed.), Global Public Administration, Public Policy, and Governance, Springer, New York.
• HASANOVIĆ Faris (2021), Govor mržnje i negiranje genocida u kontekstu slobode izražavanja – Međunarodnopravni okvir i relevantne odredbe krivičnog zakonodavstva u Bosni i Hercegovini, „Zbornik radova Pravnog fakulteta u Tuzli“, vol. VII, no. 2. DOI: 10.51558/2712-1178.2021.7.2.20
• HELEZ: Dodik je opsovao genocid u Srebrenici, Ademović je napustio sastanak (2023), https://nap.ba/post/797934/helez-dodik-je-opsovao-genocid-u-srebrenici-ademovic-je-napustio-sastanak (30.06.2023).
• HERCEG PAKŠIĆ Barbara (2017), Tvorba novih standarda u slučajevima teških oblika govora mržnje: Negiranje genocida pred europskim sudom za ljudska prava, „Zbornik Pravnog fakulteta u Zagrebu“, vol. 67, no. 2.
• HODŽIĆ Edin, MEHMEDOVIĆ Amra (2014), Krivična djela počinjena iz mržnje: Izazovi reguliranja i procesuiranja u BiH, Analitika – Centar za društvena istraživanja, Sarajevo.
• HR’S DECISION on Enacting the Law on Amendment to the Criminal Code of Bosnia and Herzegovina (2021), n 26/21, 23 July 2021, https://www.ohr.int/hrs-decision-on-enacting-the-law-on-amendment-to-the-criminal-code-of-bosnia-and-herzegovina/ (23.07.2021).
• HUSARIĆ OMEROVIĆ Azra (2024), Zašto su nekažnjiva najmanje 23 negiranja genocida Milorada Dodika, „Detektor“, https://detektor.ba/2024/05/23/zasto-je-nekaznjivo-najmanje-23-negiranja-genocida-milorada-dodika/ (23.05.2024).
• HUSEINOVIĆ Samir (2023), Napadi na povratnike u RS-u ugrožavaju opću sigurnost, „Deutsche Welle“, https://www.dw.com/hr/napadi-na-povratnike-u-rs-u-ugro%C5%BEavaju-op%C4%87u-sigurnost/a-66766863 (10.09.2023).
• ICMP (2022), ICMP i genocid u Srebrenici, International Commission on Missing Persons, https://www.icmp.int/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/ICMP-srebrenica-leaflet-BCS-2022-web.pdf (30.12.2022).
• IŠERIĆ Harun, MUFTIĆ Nasir, HERENDA Tahir (2022), Inkriminacija negiranja genocida u BiH: između bh. politike i slobode izražavanja, Inicijativa mladih za ljudska prava u BiH (YIHR BiH), Sarajevo.
• JUDGMENT OF GRAND CHAMBER (2015) in case Perinçek v. Switzerland (Application no. 27510/08), 15 October 2015.
• JUDGEMENT OF THE TRIAL CHAMBER OF ICTY (2003) in case Prosecutor v. Stanislav Galić, 5 December 2003.
• JUDGEMENT OF THE APPEALS CHAMBER (2023) in case Prosecutor v. Jovica Stanišić and Franko Simatović, 31 May 2023 (case no. MICT-15-96-A).
• KAHROVIĆ Samir (2009), Tuzla šokirana Dodikovim izjavama, „Deutsche Welle“, https://www.dw.com/sr/tuzla-%C5%A1okirana-dodikovim-izjavama/a-4696252 (16.09.2009).
• KARAN OPET NEGIRAO GENOCID: U Srebrenici je poginulo 2.650 Srba, a Bošnjaka najviše 2000 (2024), https://cazin.ba/karan-opet-negirao-genocid-u-srebrenici-je-poginulo-2-650-srba-a-bosnjaka-najvise-2000/ (06.06.2024).
• KARČIĆ Fikret (2007), Krivično-pravna zabrana poricanja genocida: komparativna perspektiva, „Godišnjak Pravnog fakulteta u Sarajevu“, no. 50.
• KARČIĆ Hikmet (2015), Genocid nad Bošnjacima i njemačko pravosuđe: univerzalna jurisdikcija za genocid, Godišnjak Bošnjačke zajednice kulture „Preporod“, no. 1.
• KARČIĆ Hikmet (2021), Srebrenica Genocide Denial: From Dodik to TikTok in: Sead Turčalo, Hikmet Karčić (eds), Bosnian Genocide Denial and Triumphalism: Origins, Impact and Prevention, Sarajevo.
• KAROVIĆ Merisa (2013), Masakr na Markalama, 5. februara 1994., „Pregled“, no. 1.
• KAROVIĆ BABIĆ Merisa (2023), Zločin na tuzlanskoj Kapiji: Historijske činjenice, reakcije i negiranje odgovornosti, „Historijski pogledi“, vol. VI, no. 9.
• KLAMBER Mark (2009), International Criminal Law in Swedish Courts: The Principle of Legality in the Arklöv Case, „International Criminal Law Review“, vol. 9, no. 2.
• KOVAČEVIĆ Vladimir (2024), Dodik negirao Markale i presude Karadžiću i Mladiću, muslimanima poručio da je bolje da ostanu kući, „Detektor“, https://detektor.ba/2024/04/03/dodik-negirao-markale-i-presude-karadzicu-i-mladicu-muslimanima-porucio-da-je-bolje-da-ostanu-kuci/ (03.04.2024).
• MEHMEDOVIĆ Adem, ŠAKIĆ Kadira, IKANOVIĆ Edin, VUČIĆ Nikola (2022), Srebrenica Genocide Denial Report 2022, Srebrenica Memorial Center, Srebrenica.
• MEMIŠEVIĆ Ehlimana (2015), Krivičnopravna zabrana poricanja genocida – dozvoljeno ograničavanje slobode izražavanja?, „Godišnjak Pravnog fakulteta u Sarajevu“, no. 58.
• NASTEVSKI Aleksandar (2023), Mapa srpske sramote: Svih 308 lokacija na kojima se nalaze murali Ratka Mladića po gradovima, https://nova.rs/vesti/drustvo/spisak-lokacije-murala-ratka-mladica/ (14.03.2023).
• NA POZIV ALEKSANDRA VULINA: Studentice koje su veličale Ratka Mladića studij nastavljaju u Beogradu (2023), https://radiosarajevo.ba/vijesti/bosna-i-hercegovina/na-poziv-aleksandra-vulina-studentice-koje-su-velicale-ratka-mladica-studij-nastavljaju-u-beogradu/504737 (15.07.2023).
• NEŠIĆ SRAMOTNO ismijavao žrtve genocida u Srebrenici (2024), https://etto.ba/clanak/ne%C5%A1i%C4%87-sramotno-ismijavao-%C5%BErtve-genocida-u-srebrenici (22.05.2024).
• NURKIĆ Benjamin (2021), “Inzkov zakon” i ograničenje slobode izražavanja – Da li je “zakonodavac” otišao predaleko? „Zbornik radova Pravnog fakulteta u Tuzli“, vol. VII, no. 1.
• OVČINA Amila (2023), Iz Policijske uprave Zvornik za „Avaz“: Mladića iz Bratunca su napala tri maloljetnika, https://avaz.ba/vijesti/crna-hronika/840016/iz-policijske-uprave-zvornik-za-avaz-mladica-iz-bratunca-su-napala-tri-maloljetnika (28.06.2023).
• PERVIZ Izet (2021), Zašto nema suđenja za zločine u Vogošći, https://stav.ba/vijest/zasto-nema-sudenja-za-zlocine-u-vogosci/22498 (21.12.2021).
• PRUITT William (2017), Understanding Genocide Denial Legislation: A Comparative Analysis, “International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences”, vol. 12, no. 2.
• PREDSTAVNIK SRBA U MAKEDONIJI genocid u Srebrenici nazvao „nekrofilskim diznilendom“, dobio je prijavu (2024), https://www.oslobodjenje.ba/vijesti/bih/predstavnik-srba-u-makedoniji-genocid-u-srebrenici-nazvao-nekrofilskim-diznilendom-dobio-je-prijavu-948108 (20.04.2024).
• PREMIJERKA SRBIJE: Haški tribunal nije objektivno procesuirao ratne zločine, uglavnom se sudilo Srbima (2017), https://www.source.ba/clanak/Region/451616/Premijerka-Srbije--Haski-tribunal-nije-objektivno-procesuirao-ratne-zlocine-uglavnom-se-sudilo-Srbima (02.11.2017).
• PODRŽAVAJU GA ŠIRE MASE DŽANANOVIĆ: Negiranje genocida postalo je duboko ukorijenjeno u ključnim institucijama RS-a i u Srbije (2023), https://nap.ba/qpost/240792/PODRAVAJU-GA-IRE-MASE-Dananovi-Negiranje-genocida-postalo-je-duboko-ukorijenjeno-u-kljunim-institucijama-Rs-ai-u-Srbiji (28.05.2023).
• RADIO SARAJEVO (2024), Podignuta optužnica protiv policajaca iz Osmaka koji su u stanici pretukli dječaka Ajdina (14), https://radiosarajevo.ba/vijesti/bosna-i-hercegovina/podignuta-optuznica-protiv-policajaca-iz-osmaka-koji-su-u-stanici-pretukli-djecaka-ajdina-14/531421 (02.02.2024).
• SIMIC Olivera (2024), “Celebrating” Srebrenica Genocide: Impunity and Indoctrination as Contributing Factors to the Glorification of Mass Atrocities, „Journal of Genocide Research“, February 2024. DOI: 10.1080/14623528.2024.2308326
• SKANDAL KOJI JE ZGROZIO BIH: Cijelo vodstvo kluba smijenjeno zbog degutantnog ispada navijača (2016), https://net.hr/sport/nogomet/degutantna-poruka-cijelo-vodstvo-kluba-smijenjeno-zbog-skandiranja-koje-je-zgrozilo-bih-7a9802f6-b1cd-11eb-b5a3-0242ac150024 (28.12.2016).
• SKANDALOZNO: Pribojski policajci se opijali i veselili uz „Srebrenice tako si mi mila, dabogda se tri put ponovila...“ (2022), https://avaz.ba/vijesti/bih/707524/skandalozno-pribojski-policajci-se-opijali-i-veselili-uz-srebrenice-tako-si-mi-mila-dabogda-se-tri-put-ponovila (02.01.2022).
• SOFTIĆ Sakib (2020), Some Legal Issues in the Dispute Between Bosnia and Herzegovina and Serbia for Violating the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, „Monumenta Srebrenica“, vol. 9.
• SPAIĆ Igor (2022), Gideon Greif tells Haaretz 8,000 were killed in Srebrenica, https://n1info.ba/english/news/gideon-greif-tells-haaretz-8000-were-killed-in-srebrenica/ (19.01.2022).
• SWISS POLITICIAN cleared of racial discrimination charges (2018), https://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/srebrenica-massacre_swiss-politician-cleared-of-racial-discrimination-charges/44645500 (27.12.2018).
• ŠUNJIĆ Vanja (2022), Šta znači uzvik Nož žica Srebrenica?, https://www.mreza-mira.net/vijesti/clanci/sta-znaci-uzvik-noz-zica-srebrenica/ (24.11.2022).
• TACAR Pulat (2014), Perinçek v. Switzerland Judgement of The European Court of Human Rights, „Review of Armenian Studies“, no. 29.
• THE COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION (2008), Council Framework Decision 2008/913/JHA of 28 November 2008 on combating certain forms and expressions of racism and xenophobia by means of criminal law, OJ L 328, 6.12.2008.
• THUS Valeria (2015), Armenian Genocide: Perinçek Case - Does The European Court of Human Rights Embody a New Form of Denial Based on Trivialisation?, paper in “Genocidios y Derechos Humanos, a cien años del Genocidio Armenio”, Genocide International Congress, Faculty of Law, University of Buenos Aires, August 2015.
• TOKAČA Mirsad (ed.) (2012), The Bosnian Book of the Dead: Human Losses in Bosnia and Herzegovini 1991-1995, Istraživačko dokumentacioni centar, Sarajevo.
• TUŽITELJSTVO BIH RADI na prijavi protiv hrvatskog predsjednika Milanovića (2022), https://www.slobodnaevropa.org/a/milanovi%C4%87a-istrazuju-bih-zbog-negiranja-genocida/32119251.html (07.11.2022).
• U SRCU SANDŽAKA: Veličali Ratka Mladića, uzvikivali „Nož, žica, Srebrenica“, pa dobili batine (2023), https://faktor.ba/sport/fudbal/u-srcu-sandzaka-velicali-ratka-mladica-uzvikivali-noz-zica-srebrenica-pa-dobili-batine/169017 (10.11.2023).
• UKLONJENA PLOČA sa imenom Radovana Karadžića na Palama (2020), https://ba.voanews.com/a/bih-radovan-karadzic-ploca-studentski-dom-pale/5694585.html (10.12.2020).
• VLASTI SRBIJE zabranile oglašavanje robe sa natpisom 'nož, žica' (2021), https://balkans.aljazeera.net/news/balkan/2021/1/15/vlasti-srbije-zabranile-oglasavanje-robe-s-natpisom-noz-zica (15.01.2021).
• VOORHOOF Dirk (2016), European Court of Human Rights: Perinçek v. Switzerland, European Audiovisual Opservatory, IRIS 2016-1:1/1, https://merlin.obs.coe.int/article/7434 (20.12.2016).
• VUČIĆ: U SREBRENICI SE DESIO STRAVIČAN ZLOČIN, ali oni neće pijetet za žrtvu, već pravnu formu (2019), https://www.oslobodjenje.ba/vijesti/region/vucic-u-srebrenici-se-desio-stravican-zlocin-ali-oni-nece-pijetet-za-zrtve-vec-pravnu-formu-473571 (15.07.2019).
• VULIN PORUČIO STANU: Genocida u Srebrenici nije bilo i Srbi nisu narod genocida, pa koliko god da prijetite i kažnjavate (2024), https://borba.me/vulin-porucio-stanu-genocida-u-srebrenici-nije-bilo-i-srbi-nisu-narod-genocida-pa-koliko-god-da-prijetite-i-kaznjavate/ (14.06.2024).
• UNITED NATIONS (WWW), International Residual Mechanism for Criminal Tribunals: MLADIĆ, Ratko (MICT-13-56), https://www.irmct.org/en/cases/mict-13-56 (29.05.2024).
• WOJCIK Malwina (2020), Navigating the Hierarchy of Memories: The ECtHR Judgment in Perinçek v Switzerland, „The King’s Student Law Review“, vol. XI, issue 1.
• ZWIERZCHOWSKI Jan, TABEAU Ewa (2010), The 1992-95 War in Bosnia and Herzegovina: Census-Based Multiple System Estimation of Casualties’ Undercount, Conference Paper for the International Research Workshop on ‘The Global Costs of Conflict’ The Households in Conflict Network (HiCN) and The German Institute for Economic Research (DIW Berlin), 1-2 February 2010, Berlin.
• EUROPEAN CONVENTION ON HUMAN RIGHTS (1950), signed in Rome on 4 November 1950, as amended by Protocols Nos. 11, 14 and 15, supplemented by Protocols Nos. 1, 4, 6, 7, 12, 13 and 16, https://www.echr.coe.int/documents/d/echr/convention_ENG (5.09.2024).