Creation Is Not Generation: A Response to Brian Carl

• Authors: Chaberek Michał
• Languages of publication: EN

Abstracts

EN

Dr. Brian T. Carl published a paper, “Thomas Aquinas on the Proportionate Causes of Living Species,” in which he defends a thesis that the principle of proportionate cause, as understood by Aquinas, cannot be used to contradict the modern theory of biological evolution. This rejoinder explores thoroughly Carl’s argument, specifically his idea that spontaneous generation serves as a model to explain causality in biological evolution. It is shown that Aquinas indeed accepts proportionate causes in spontaneous generation, but this fact cannot be extrapolated to modern evolutionary theories. The origin of new species after creation was completed is not a straightforward thesis in Aquinas; rather Thomas sees it as a possible exception, which contradicts the evolutionary origin of the vast majority of species. Additionally, Carl misses the major point that in Aquinas the origin of new species belongs to the work of creation rather than the natural operation of secondary causes.

Keywords

EN

Thomas Aquinas; Aristotle; evolution; creation; causality; metaphysics; species; generation

• Publisher: International Étienne Gilson Society
• Journal: Studia Gilsoniana
• Year: 2021
• Volume: 10
• Issue: 1
• Pages: 11–43

Dates

published

2021-03-30

Contributors

author

Chaberek Michał

• https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8071-537X

References

• Aquinas, Thomas. Commentary on the Metaphysics of Aristotle. Translated by John P. Rowan. Chicago: Henry Regnery Company, 1961. Available online at: https://archive.org/stream/AquinasCommentaryOnTheMetaphysics/Aquinas.CommentaryOnTheMetaphysicsOfAristotleIi_djvu.txt. Accessed Nov. 14, 2020.
• Aquinas, Thomas. Quaestiones Disputatae de Potentia Dei. On the Power of God. Translated by the English Dominican Fathers. Westminster, Md.: The Newman Press, 1952, reprint of 1932.
• Aquinas, Thomas. Scriptum Super Sententiis, II. Available at: https://aquinas.cc/la/en/~Sent.II. Accessed Nov. 14, 2020.
• Aquinas, Thomas. Summa Contra Gentiles. Chapter II, translated by J. F. Anderson. Chapter III, translated by V. J. Bourke. New York: Hanover House, 1955–57. Available online at: https://isidore.co/aquinas/english/ContraGentiles.htm. Accessed Nov. 14, 2020.
• Aquinas, Thomas. Summa Theologiae. Second and Revised Edition, 1920. Literally translated by Fathers of the English Dominican Province. Available online at: https://www.newadvent.org/summa/. Accessed Nov. 14, 2020.
• Aquinas, Thomas. Treatise on Separate Substances. Translated by F. J. Lescoe. West Hartford, Conn.: Saint Joseph College, 1959. Available online at: https://isidore.co/aquinas/SubstSepar.htm. Accessed Nov. 23, 2020.
• Aristotle. Generation of Animals. Translated by A. L. Peck. London: William Heinemann LTD, Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1943. Available online at: https://archive.org/details/generationofanim00arisuoft/page/n5/mode/2up. Accessed Nov. 23, 2020.
• Aristotle. On the Generation of Animals. Translated by A. Platt. Available online at: https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/On_the_Generation_of_Animals/Book_II. Accessed Nov. 23, 2020.
• Aristotle. Metaphysics. Translated by W. D. Ross. Available online at: http://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/metaphysics.html. Accessed Nov. 23, 2020.
• Aristotle. On the Soul. Translated by J. A. Smith. Available online at: http://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/soul.2.ii.html. Accessed Nov. 23, 2020.
• Aristotle. The History of Animals. Translated by D’Arcy Wentworth Thompson. Available online at: http://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/history_anim.html. Accessed Nov. 14, 2020.
• Austriaco, Nicanor P. G. “In Defense of Thomistic Evolution: A Response to Chaberek.” Public Discourse. The Journal of the Witherspoon Institute. Available online at: https://www.thepublicdiscourse.com/2018/03/20975/. Accessed Nov. 23, 2020.
• Carl, Brian T. “Thomas Aquinas on the Proportionate Causes of Living Species.” Scientia et Fides 8, no. 2 (2020): 223–248. DOI: 10.12775/SetF.2020.020.
• Chaberek, Michał. Aquinas and Evolution: Why St. Thomas Teaching on the Origins Is Incompatible with Evolutionary Theory? Chartwell Press, 2019, 2nd edition.
• Darwin, Erasmus. Zoonomia or the Laws of Organic Life. Vol. 1. London: Printed for J. Johnson, in St. Paul’s Church-Yard, 1794, 2nd edition.
• Integrated Taxonomic Information System. Available online at: https://www.itis.gov/hierarchy.html. Accessed May 5, 2020.
• National Center for Biotechnology Information, USA. Available online at: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/taxonomy. Accessed May 5, 2020.

Notes

EN

DOI: 10.26385/SG.100101