Wpływ protestu społeczności lokalnej na rozstrzygnięcie decyzji o środowiskowych uwarunkowaniach

• Authors: Goździewicz-Biechońska Justyna

Title variants

EN

Impact of the local community protest on the decision on environmental conditions

IT

Le proteste delle comunità locali e la loro incidenza sulle autorizzazioni ambientali

• Languages of publication: PL

Abstracts

EN

The paper aims to determine the significance and legal effects of a local community protest expressed as part of public participation in an individual environmental impact assessment. More specifically, it is to determine the impact of such a protest on the decision on environmental conditions, and in particular whether the protest may constitute a basis for refusing to issue such a decision. In the conclusions, the author indicates that the protest expressed as part of the public participation in the proceedings concerning the issuance of a decision on environmental conditions cannot constitute a sufficient basis for a negative decision. Based on the rational planning model, it is also argued that the concept of public participation in environmental proceedings as defined by law is still deeply rooted in the rational model of environmental impact assessments. As a consequence, it determines the actual limits of public participation in these matters.

IT

L’articolo si propone di determinare l’importanza e gli effetti giuridici ai quali possono portare le proteste delle comunità locali intese come presa di posizione sociale sull’impatto ambientale. Si tratta di determinare una loro possibile incidenza sul rilascio di autorizzazioni ambientali, in particolare il diniego. Nella parte conclusiva, l’autrice afferma che le proteste in oggetto non possono costituire motivazione sufficiente proprio per un eventuale diniego. Sulla base dell’analisi svolta in chiave modellistica, essa constata inoltre che la partecipazione dei cittadini alle questioni ambientali è una concezione, così come disposta dalla legge, tuttora profondamente radicata in un modello razionalista di opinioni relative all’impatto ambientale. Ciò, di conseguenza, delimita i suoi reali confini.

• Publisher: Uniwersytet im. Adama Mickiewicza w Poznaniu
• Journal: Przegląd Prawa Rolnego
• Year: 2019
• Issue: 1 (24)
• Pages: 11-24

Contributors

author

Goździewicz-Biechońska Justyna

• Uniwersytet im. Adama Mickiewicza w Poznaniu

References

• Armeni C., (2016), Participation in environmental decision-making: reflecting on planning and community benefits for major wind farms, “Journal of Environmental Law” nr 28(3)
• Arnstein S. R., (1969), A Ladder Of Citizen Participation, “Journal of the American Planning Association” nr 35(4)
• Enríquez-de-Salamanca A., (2018), Stakeholders' manipulation of environmental impact assessment, “Environmental Impact Assessment Review” nr 68
• Glucker A. N. i in., (2013), Public participation in environmental impact assessment: why, who and how?, “Environmental Impact Assessment Review”, nr 43
• Haładyj A., (2014), Konsultacje czy partycypacja? Refleksje terminologiczne w odniesieniu do udziału społeczeństwa w ochronie środowiska, w: Dolnicki B. (red.), Partycypacja społeczna w samorządzie terytorialnym, Warszawa
• Haładyj A., (2015), Udział społeczeństwa w strategicznej ocenie oddziaływania na środowisko jako instytucja prawa ochrony środowiska, Lublin
• Haładyj A., (2017), Granice partycypacji w podejmowaniu decyzji publicznych – przyczynek do dyskusji, „Samorząd Terytorialny” nr 3
• Jaworowicz-Rudolf A., (2015), Przewidywalność działań administracji jako warunek zaufania do władz publicznych, w: Kasiński M., Stahl M., Wlaźlak K. (red.), Sprawiedliwość i zaufanie do władz publicznych w prawie administracyjnym, Warszawa
• Lawrence D. P. (2000), Planning theories and environmental impact assessment, “Environmental Impact Assessment Review” nr 20(6)
• Lostarnau C. i in, (2011), Stakeholder participation within the public environmental system in Chile: Major gaps between theory and practice, “Journal of Environmental Management” nr 92(10)
• Morgan R. K., (2012), Environmental impact assessment: the state of the art, “Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal” nr 30(1)
• Pirker B., (2016), Access to Justice in Environmental Matters and the Aarhus Convention's Effects in the EU Legal Order: No Room for Nuanced Self‐executing Effect?, “Review of European, Comparative & International Environmental Law” nr 25(1)
• Sax J. L., (1973), The (unhappy) truth about NEPA, “Oklahoma Law Review” nr 26
• Śladkowska E., (2005), Wydanie decyzji administracyjnej bez podstawy prawnej w ogólnym podstępowaniu administracyjnym, „Samorząd Terytorialny” nr 11
• Wójcicki M., (2013), Pojęcie, istota i formy partycypacji społecznej w procesie planowania przestrzennego, „Rozwój Regionalny i Polityka Regionalna” nr 24
• Yang T., (2019), The Emergence of the Environmental Impact Assessment Duty as a Global Legal Norm and General Principle of Law, Hastings Law Journal nr 70(525)

Identifiers

DOI

10.14746/ppr.2019.24.1.1.