Happy is the Land that Needs No Heroes

• Authors: Coates Donna

Abstracts

This essay interrogates two articles by the Canadian historian Jeff Keshen and the Australian historian Mark Sheftall, which assert that the representations of soldiers in the First World War (Anzacs in Australia, members of the Canadian Expeditionary Forces, the CEF), are comparable. I argue, however, that in reaching their conclusions, these historians have either overlooked or insufficiently considered a number of crucial factors, such as the influence the Australian historian/war correspondent C. E. W. Bean had on the reception of Anzacs, whom he venerated and turned into larger-than-life men who liked fighting and were good at it; the significance of the “convict stain” in Australia; and the omission of women writers’ contributions to the “getting of nationhood” in each country. It further addresses why Canadians have not embraced Vimy (a military victory) as their defining moment in the same way as Australians celebrate the landing at Anzac Cove (a military disaster), from which they continue to derive their sense of national identity. In essence, this essay advances that differences between the two nations’ representations of soldiers far outweigh any similarities.

Keywords

EN

The Great War; Australian war literature; Canadian war literature; ANZAC; the battle of Vimy Ridge; cultural memory/amnesia

• Publisher: Institute of English Studies, University of Warsaw
• Journal: Anglica. An International Journal of English Studies
• Year: 2018
• Issue: 27/3
• Pages: 111-142

Contributors

author

Coates Donna

• University of Calgary

References

• “Australia’s Conscription Debate, 1916–1917.” https://ww1.s..nsw.gov.au/stories/ australias-conscription-debate
• Bailey, Matthew, and Sean Brawley. 2018. “Why Weren’t We Taught? Exploring Frontier Conflict Through the Lens of Anzac.” Journal of Australian Studies 42: 1: 19–33.
• Bean, C. E. W., ed. 1916. The Anzac Book: Written and Illustrated in Gallipoli by the Men of Anzac. Melbourne: Cassell.
• —. 1934 [1921]. The Offi cial History. The Story of Anzac: From the Outbreak of War to the End of the First Phase of the Gallipoli Campaign, May 4 1916. Vol. 1. Sydney: Angus and Robertson.
• Bethune, Brian. 2005. “It’s Sublime and Deadly.” Maclean’s: 30–32.
• Beynon, Francis Marion. 1988 [1919]. Aleta Dey. London: Virago.
• Blackburn. Grace. 1930. The Man Child. Ottawa: Graphic.
• Brookes, Mabel. 1917. Broken Idols. Melbourne: Melville and Mullen,.
• Brown, Eric and Tim Cook. 2011. “The 1936 Vimy Pilgrimage.” Canadian Military History 20. 2: 39.
• Buitenhuis, Peter. 1987. The Great War of Words: British, American and Canadian Propaganda and Fiction, 1914–1933. Vancouver: UBC Press.
• “Canadian National Vimy Memorial.” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian_National_Vimy_Memorial
• Carrigg, David. 2017. “Tim Cook Examines Role of Vimy Ridge in Canadian Culture.” https://vancouversun.com/entertainment/books/tim-cooki-examines-ro...
• Clark, Anna. 2017. “The Place of Anzac in Australian Historical Consciousness.” Australian Historical Studies 48: 19–34.
• “The Conscription Crisis” http://www.cbc.ca/history/EPISCONTENTSE1EP12CH2PA3LE.html
• “Conscription, 1917.” https://www.warmuseum.ca/fi rstworldwar/history/life-athome-during...
• Cook, Ramsay. 1970. “Nationalism in Canada or Portnoy’s Complaint Revisited.” South Atlantic Quarterly 69: 3–25.
• Cook, Tim. 2017. Vimy: The Battle and the Legend. Canada, USA, UK, Ireland, Australia, New Zealand, India, South Africa, China: Penguin Random House Canada.
• Everett-Green, Robert, 2017. “Vimy Ridge: Birthplace of a Nation – Or of a Canadian Myth?” https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/battle-ofvimy-rid...
• Freeman, Alan. “Canada’s ‘Disgrace’ on Vimy Ridge.” http://www.network54.com/Search/view/57886/958412549/Canada’s
• Foran, Charles. 2016. “Searching for a Canada of the Soul, Not the Census.” Toronto: The Globe and Mail F3.
• Gerster, Robin. 1988. Big-Noting: The Heroic Theme in Australian War Writing. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press.
• Gray, Charlotte. 2017. The Promise of Canada: 150 Years – People and Ideas That Have Shaped Our Country. Toronto: Simon and Schuster.
• —. 2017 (30 December). “Canada 150: Anniversaries, the Enemy of Good History.” The Globe and Mail: O4.
• Grimshaw, Pat, Marilyn Lake, Ann McGrath, and Marian Quartly. 2006. “Giving Birth to the Nation.” Creating a Nation, 1788–2007. Perth: API Network. 201–224.
• Hamilton, Graeme. 2016. ‘“Breaking the Faith’: Critics Angry Over Renaming of Vimy Ridge Park for Parizeau.” National Post, Toronto: A3.
• Hillmer, Norman. 2010. “The Canadian War Museum and the Military Identity of an Unmilitary People.” Canadian Military His
• Holbrook, Carolyn. 2017. “Adaptable Anzac: Past, Present and Future.” The Honest History Book. Ed. David Stephens and Alison Broinowski. Sydney: New South Publishing. 48–62.
• How, Douglas. 1998. “A Literature of Stone.” Maclean’s: 91.
• Howells, Coral Anne. 1987. Private and Fictional Words: Canadian Women Novelists of the 1970s and 1980s. London: Methuen.
• Hucker, Jacqueline. 2007. ‘“After the Agony in Stony Places’: The Meaning and Signifi cance of the Vimy Monument.” Vimy Ridge: A Canadian Reassessment. Ed. Geoff rey Hayes, Andrew Iraocci, and Mike Bechtold. Waterloo: Wilfrid Laurier Press. 279–290.
• Hughes, Robert. 1986. The Fatal Shore: The Epic of Australia’s Founding. New York: Vintage.
• Inglis, K. S. 1970. “The Australians at Gallipoli-II.” Historical Studies 14: 363–367.
• Jenkins, Anthony. “Why It’s Important to Refl ect on Vimy.” http:/v1.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20070409.wevimy09/front/Front/Front
• Kroetsch, Robert. 1997. “Disunity as Unity: A Canadian Strategy.” New Contexts of Canadian Criticism. Ed. Ajay Hebele, Donna Palmateer Pennee, and T. R. Struthers. Peterborough, ON: Broadview Press. 355–365.
• Lake, Marilyn. March 2006. “The Militarisation of Australian Historical Memory.” Teaching History 40. 1: 15–16.
• —. and Henry Reynolds, with Mark McKenna and Joy Damousi. 2010. What’s Wrong with Anzac? The Militarisation of Australian History. Sydney: New South, University of New South Wales.
• “The Legacy of Canada’s WWI Conscription Crisis.” http://montrealgazette.com/feature/the-legacy-of-canadas-wwi-conscri...
• Macintyre, Stuart. 1986 [1901–1942]. The Succeeding Age. Vol. 4. The Oxford History of Australia. Melbourne: Oxford University Press.
• Mackenzie, Compton, 1929. Gallipoli Memories. London: Cassells.
• Marlowe, Mary, 1918. The Women Who Wait. London: Simpkin Marshall Hamilton Kent & Co.
• McKernan, Michael. 1980. The Australian People and the Great War. Melbourne: Nelson.
• McClung, Nellie. 1917. The Next of Kin: Those Who Wait and Wonder. Toronto: Thomas Allen.
• McKay, Ian, and Jamie Swift. 2012. Warrior Nation: Rebranding Canada in an Age of Anxiety. Toronto: Behind the Lines.
• —. 2016. The Vimy Trap: Or, How We Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Great War. Toronto: Between the Lines.
• Masefield, John. 1916. Gallipoli. London: Heinemann.
• Montgomery, L. M. 1982 [1920]. Rilla of Ingleside. Toronto: Seal.
• Morton, Desmond, and J. L. Granatstein. 1989. Marching Toward Armageddon: Canadians and the Great War 1914–1919. Toronto, Lester.
• Paris, Erna. 2018. “Canada’s Multiculturalism Is Our Identity.” The Globe and mail: O5.
• Reynolds, Henry. 2013. Forgotten War. Sydney: New South Publishing.
• Richler, Noah. 2012. What We Talk About When We Walk About War. Fredericton: Goose Lane.
• Rixon, Annie [Mrs. Richard de Clare Studdert]. 1940. Yesterday and Today. Sydney: Criterion.
• Scarry, Elaine. 1987. The Body in Pain: The Making and Unmaking of the World. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
• Scates, Bruce. 2006. Return to Gallipoli: Walking the Battlefi elds of the Great War. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
• Selley, Chris. 2016. “Are We Really Any Good at This?” National Post: A8.
• Serle, Geoffrey. 1965. “The Digger Tradition and Australian Nationalism.” Meanjin Quaterly 24. 2: 149–158.
• Sheftall, Mark. 2015. “Mythologising the Dominion Fighting Man: Australian and Canadian Narratives of the First World War, 1914–39.” Australian Historical Studies 46: 1: 81–99.
• Spears, Tom. 2017. “Harsh Reviews for Vimy Centennial.” National Post: NP2.
• Stevens, Paul, and John Saywell. 1983. Lord Minto’s Canadian Papers: A Selection of the Fourth Earl of Minto, 1898–1904. Vol. 1. Toronto: The Champlain Society.
• Swift, Jamie. 2015. ‘“How the Yearning for Peace after a Trench War’s Horror Gave Way to Vapid ‘Vimyism.’ The Battleground of Remembrance: Struggles at the Intersection of Canadian War History and Public Memory.” Canadian Issues Themes Canadiens: 36–39.
• Thiessen, Vern. 2007. “Vimy.” Canada and the Theatre of War: Eight World War One and Two Plays. Ed. Donna Coates and Sherrill Grace. Toronto: Playwrights Canada Press, 223–267.
• Thompson, Nicole. 2015. “Looking Back at Vimy.” Calgary Herald: B3.
• Turner, Ian. 1974. “1914–1919.” A New History of Australia. Ed. F. K. Crowley. Melbourne: Heinemann. 312–356.
• Valpy, Michael. “Setting a Legend in Stone.” http://v.1.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20070407.wvi
• —. “Vimy Ridge: The Making of a Myth.” http://v1.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20070406.cover
• Vance, Jonathan F. 2007. “The Making of Vimy.” National Post: A21.
• “Vimy Ridge Day in Canada.” https://www.timenddate.com/holidays/canada/vimy-ridge-day?hc_loc...
• Walker, Shirley. 1985. “The Boer War: Paterson, Abbott, Brennan, Miles Franklin and Breaker Morant.” Australian Literary Studies 12: 207–222.
• Walsh, Michael J. K., 2017. “Then In 1915: Eric Bogle’s ‘And the Band Played Waltzing Matilda.’” Journal of Australian Studies 41. 2: 237–251.
• Weinreb, Arthur. 2002. “Vimy Vidi Vichy.” http://canadafreepress.com/2002/weinreb91602.htm
• Wise, Syd. 1985. Australian Journal of the War Memorial 7: 3–11.