Full-text resources of CEJSH and other databases are now available in the new Library of Science.
Visit https://bibliotekanauki.pl

PL EN


1979 | 4 | 287-295

Article title

Zagadnienia metodologiczne w dziedzinie rekonstrukcji zabytków

Content

Title variants

EN
METHODOLOGICAL PROBLEMS IN THE FIELD OF RECONSTRUCTION OF ANCIENT OBJECTS

Languages of publication

PL

Abstracts

EN
According to principles of methodology any theoretical consideration of problems has to start with an outline of the considered field, followed with statement of purpose, well formulated definitions and an orderly arrangement of ideas. On such background further detailed considerations can be carried out in a possibly objective way. In the field of conservation and reconstruction of ancient objects there is a definite lack of such a methodological base. Motivations, interpretations and discussions have a rather individual, subjective and emotional background. Hence, no possibilities exist for more objective rational criteria. The aim of the article is to suggest a possible classification of basic factors influencing the eventual final effects of reconstruction and to draw some critical conclusions as concerns the present state of affairs both in movable and immovable groups of objects. First, a basic definition of ancient object and reconstruction is given. The object has to be treated as a document from the past and its value lies in its authenticity. On the other hand reconstruction will never be authentic and its value lies in a possibly exact repetition of the original. As concerns the „evaluation" of the reconstruction there are several possible criteria, depending on particular cases and their requirements. The simplest is the evaluation by the amount of reconstructed parts versus the preserved original. Important is which parts have been reconstructed, how near their form corresponds to the lost original, what is the technical and aesthetic level of reconstruction, as well as proper motivation, respect for age and historical importance, and last but not least a proper adherence to ethical standards. By these is understood a proper respect for the original and for the need of its preservation with all historical evidence. These theoretical considerations are followed with commented examples as well from the field of movable as of immovable objects, with the general principle in view that the basic methodology and ethical principles are the same for a l l kinds of ancient objects notwithstanding their cathegory or value. The final remarks concern the wrong lines of „propaganda” for reconstruction, identified as conservation, done by radio, television and by press articles. There may also be need to introduce more oi these theoretical methodological subjects to academic teaching ol restorers, because at present it seems that these studies are going a bit too far into reconstruction as their main objective, withoul a proper theoretical and critical background.

Keywords

Year

Issue

4

Pages

287-295

Physical description

Dates

published
1979

Contributors

  • doc. dr, Warszawa

References

  • Ragguaglio detle arti 1954—1958. Editalia, Roma 1959, s. 82.
  • Księżna von Kassel odzyskała twarz, ale..., „Express Wieczorny”, 31.XII.1973.
  • E. van d eWe t r ri ng, Kunsthistorisch onderzoek bij restaurat ie [Badania historyka sztuki pomocne przy restaurowaniu], „Bulletin”, nr 0, Central Research Laboratory, Amsterdam 1977, s. 29—38.
  • A. W r o b l e w s k i , Drugie życie dziel sztuki, „Życie Warszawy”, z dnia 18.1.1979; B. Z a g o r s k a , Na Wydziale Konserwacji studenci ASP ratują zabytki, „Trybuna Ludu”, z dnia 29.XI. 1978; A. Mi s i o r o w s k i , Wypowiedź w audycji Dialogi i zbliżenia, Polskie Radio, program II, 18.XI.1978.
  • Problems o f the Completion o f Art Objects, International Restorers’ Seminar, Veszprem 15—27.VII.1978. Institute of Conservation and Methodology of Museums, Budapest 1979.

Document Type

Publication order reference

Identifiers

YADDA identifier

bwmeta1.element.desklight-c21d5fbf-9b99-4f36-9b11-5f053b3ad579
JavaScript is turned off in your web browser. Turn it on to take full advantage of this site, then refresh the page.