Nie wszystko zaczęło się od Bunsena i Kirchhoffa – nieznane wątki wczesnej historii spektroskopu optycznego (1810–1860)

• Authors: RODZEŃ Jacek

Title variants

EN

Not all began with Bunsen and Kirchhoff. Unknown topics in the early history of the optical spectroscope (1810–1860)

• Languages of publication: PL EN

Abstracts

EN

The present paper tries to confront the widespread view according to which the inventors of the optical spectroscope were essentially two eminent German scholars: Robert W. Bunsen (1811–1899) and Gustav R. Kirchhoff (1824–1887). Extensive searches in the available published sources were performed. The main result is that this opinion appears to be wrong. It also clearly points to several other researchers who effectively constructed basic types of the spectroscope much earlier, already in the years 1810–1860. Of course, there is no doubt that Bunsen’s and Kirchhoff’s groundbreaking research (1859–1861) led to the consolidation of a new research method, i.e. spectrochemical analysis, but not to the invention of the spectroscope itself. It is true that available sources concerning the history of the spectroscope are very few. Also very few studies have so far been devoted on this subject. We discuss this briefly. Next, the paper presents the main historical types of the spectroscopic apparatus, in particular Joseph Fraunhofer’s (1787–1826) three examples (two prismatic ones and one with diffraction grating) invented in the years 1810–1823; William Simms’ (1793–1860) “two-telescopic” type with collimator (this type was actually implemented in the BunsenKirchhof’s version of the apparatus). Then we describe a similar to Simm’s version, Jacques Babinet’s (1794–1872) “two-telescopic” reflecting goniometer (later in 1850s widely used in spectroscopic observations). We describe also Félix Dujardin’s (1801–1860) spectroscope à vision directe (authorship of which is unduly attributed to Giovanni-Battista Amici, 1786–1863). Three other variants of the “two-telescopic” spectroscope constructed in 1850s by Francesco Zantedeschi (1797–1873), Moritz Meyerstein (1808–1882) and William Crookes (1832–1919) are also discussed. The apparatus of the latter scholar (the so-called spectrum camera) may be regarded as a prototype of the first spectrograph. In the last part of the paper we raise the following question: how can we explain the fact that certain instruments, normally used in surveying (theodolites, repeating circles), often modified, were used in the scientific refractometric/spectroscopic research in the first half of the XIXth century?

• Publisher: Polska Akademia Umiejętności
• Journal: Prace Komisji Historii Nauki PAU
• Year: 2012
• Volume: 11
• Pages: 227-270

Dates

published

2012

Contributors

author

RODZEŃ Jacek

• Instytut Bibliotekoznawstwa i Dziennikarstwa, Uniwersytet Jana Kochanowskiego, Kielce

References

• Alder K. 2003: The Measure of All Things. The Seven-Year Odyssey and Hidden Error That Transformed the World, Free Press, New York et al.
• Angus-Butterworth L.M. 1958: Glass [w:] A History of Technology, t. 3, red. Ch. Singer et al., Clarendon Press, Oxford, s. 206–244.
• Arago F.J.D. 1839: [komunikat w imieniu J. Babineta], „Comptes Rendus”, t. 8, s. 710.
• Ball D.W. 2006: Field Guide to Spectroscopy, SPIE Press.
• Ball D.W. 2010: Happy Sesquicentennial, Spectroscopy!, „Spectroscopy”, nr 25, s. 16–19.
• Bennett J.A. 1984: The celebrated phaenomena of colours: a history of the spectroscope in the nineteenth century, Whipple Museum, Cambridge.
• Beudant F.S. 1841: Cours élémentaire d’histoire naturelle. Mineralogie – Geologie, Paris.
• Biot J.-B. 1816: Traité de physique expérimentale et mathématique, t. 3, Deterville, Paris.
• Biot J.-B., Arago F.J.D. 1806: Mémoire sur les affinités des corps pour la lumière, et particulièrement sur les forces réfringentes des différens gaz, „Mémoires de la classe des sciences mathématiques et physiques de l’Institute national de France”, nr 7, s. 301–385.
• Brachner A., Seeberger M. 1976: Joseph von Fraunhofer. Ausstellung zum 150. Todestag, Deutsches Museum, München.
• Buchwald J.Z. 1989: The Rise of the Wave Theory of Light, Optical Theory and Experiment in the Early Nineteenth Century, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
• Bunsen R., Roscoe H. 1859: Photochemische Untersuchungen. Zweite Abhandlung…, „Annalen der Physik”, nr 100, s. 43–88.
• Burchard U. 1998: History and development of the crystallographic goniometer, „The Mineralogical Record”, nr 29, s. 517–583.
• Burns D.T. 1988: Towards a definitive history of optical spectroscopy. Part II: Introduction of slits and collimator lens. Spectroscopes available before and just after Kirchhoff and Bunsen’s studies, „Journal of Analytical Atomic Spectrometry”, nr 3, s. 285–291.
• Cantor G. 1983: Optics after Newton. Theories of Light in Britain and Ireland, 1704–1840, Manchester University Press, Manchester.
• Chapman A. 1993: The astronomical revolution [w:] Möbius and his Band, red. J. Fauvel et al., Oxford University Press, Oxford, s. 35–77.
• Chen X. 2000: Instrumental Traditions and Theories of Light. The Uses of Instruments in the Optical Revolution, Kluwer, Dordrecht.
• Chen X. 2005: Visual photometry in the early 19th: a ‘good’ science with ‘bad’ measurements, [w:] Wrong for the Right Reasons, red. J.Z. Buchwald, A. Franklin, Springer, Dordrecht, s. 161–183.
• Cooper J.T. 1831: On the method of observing the fixe lines in the solar spectrum, „Journal of the Royal Institution of the Great Britain”, nr 2, s. 289–292.
• Crookes W. 1856: Photographic researches on the spectrum – The spectrum camera and some of its applications, „Journal of the Photographic Society”, nr 2, s. 292–295.
• Daumas M. 1972: Scientific Instruments of the 17th & 18th Centuries, Praeger, New York.
• Deiman J.C. 2003: Optics and optical instruments, 1600–1800 [w:] Companion Encyclopedia of the History and Philosophy of the Mathematical Sciences, red. I. Grattan-Guinness, The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, s. 1158–1164.
• Dingle H. 1963: A 100 years of spectroscopy, „British Journal for the History of Science”, nr 1, s. 199–216.
• Dörries M. 1994: Balances, Spectroscopes, and the Reflexive Nature of Experiment, „Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science”, nr 25, s. 1–36.
• Dujardin F. 1839: Appareil destiné à observer les raies noires du spectre solaire, „Comptes Rendus”, nr 8, s. 253–254.
• Dyck W. von 1912: Georg von Reichenbach, Selbstverlag des Deutschen Museums, München.
• Fox R. 1990: Laplacian physics [w:] Companion to the History of Modern Science, red. R.C. Olby et al., Routledge, London, s. 264–277.
• Frankel E. 1976: Corpuscular optics and the wave theory of light: the science and politics of a revolution in physics, „Social Studies of Science”, nr 6, s. 141–184.
• Fraunhofer J. 1817: Bestimmung des Brechungs- und Farbenzerstreuungsvermögens verschiedener Glassarten, in Bezug auf die Vervollkommnung achromatischer Fernröhre, „Denkschriften der Königlichen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu München”, nr 5, s. 193–226.
• Fraunhofer J. 1821: Neue Modification des Lichtes durch gegenseitige Einwirkung und Beugung der Strahlen, und Gesetze derselben, „Denkschriften der Königlichen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu München”, nr 8, s. 1–76.
• Fraunhofer J. 1823: Kurzer Bericht von den Resultaten neuerer Versuche über die Gesetze des Lichtes, und die Theorie derselben, „Annalen der Physik”, nr 74, s. 337–378.
• Grandeau L.N. 1863: Instruction practique sur l’analyse spectrale, Mollet-Bachelier, Paris.
• Greenslade Th. jun., Spectrometers, http://physics.kenyon.edu/EarlyApparatus/Optics/Spectrometers/Spectrometers.html (dostęp on-line: 20.04.2011).
• Häfner R., Riekher R. 2003: Die Pioniere der Sternspektroskopie: Die stellarspektroskopischen Untersuchungen von Fraunhofer (1816–1820) und Lamont (1836) [w:] Beiträge zur Astronomiegeschichte, t. 6, red. W.R. Dick et al., Verlag Harri Deutsch, Frankfurt a. Main, s. 137–165.
• Hakfoort C. 1995: Optics in the Age of Euler: Conceptions of the Nature of Light, 1700–1795, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
• Harman P.M. 1982: Energy, Force, and Matter: the Conceptual Development of Nineteenthcentury Physics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
• Hauksbee F. sen. 1709: Physico-Mechanical Experiments on Various Subjects…, R. Brugis, London, s. 175–180.
• Hearnshaw J.B. 1989: The Analysis of Starlight. One Hundred and Fifty Years of Astronomical Spectroscopy, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge et al.
• Hearnshaw J.B. 2009: Astronomical Spectrographs and their History, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
• Heilbron J.L. 1993: Weighing Imponderables and Other Quantitative Science around 1800, University of California Press, Berkeley.
• Hennig J.B. 2003a: Der Spektralapparat Kirchhoffs und Bunsens, Deutsches Museum, Berlin et al.
• Hennig J. 2003b: Bunsen, Kirchhoff, Steinheil and the Elaboration of Analytical Spectroscopy, „Nuncius”, nr 2, s. 741–754.
• Hentschel K. 2002a: Mapping the Spectrum: Techniques of Visual Representation in Research and Teaching, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
• Hentschel K. 2002b: Spectroscopy or spectroscopies?, „Nuncius”, nr 17, s. 589–614.
• Hentschel K. 2005: Gaußens unsichtbare Hand: Der Universitäts-Mechanicus und MaschinenInspector Moritz Meyerstein. Ein Instrumentenbauer im 19. Jahrhundert, Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, Göttingen.
• Hooke R. 1665: Micrographia…, Jo. Martyn, and Ja. Allestry, London.
• Hong S. 2002: Theories and experiments on radiation from Thomas Young to X Rays [w:] The Cambridge History of Science, t. 5: The Modern Physical and Mathematical Sciences, red. M. Jo Nye, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, s. 272–288.
• Hübner K. 2010: Gustav Robert Kirchhoff: Das gewöhnliche Leben eines aussergewöhnlichen Mannes, Verlag Regionalkultur, Ubstadt-Weiher-Heidelberg et al.
• Jackson M.W. 2000: Spectrum of Belief. Joseph Fraunhofer and the Craft of Precision Optics, The MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass.
• James F.A.J.L. 1983a: The Establishment of Spectro-Chemical Analysis as a Practical Method of Qualitative Analysis, 1854–1861, „Ambix”, nr 30, s. 30–53.
• James F.A.J.L. 1983b: The Study of Spark Spectra, „Ambix”, nr 30, s. 137–162.
• James F.A.J.L. 1984: Of ‘Medals and Muddles’: the Context of the Discovery of Thallium: William Crookes’s Early Spectro-Chemical Work, „Notes and Records of the Royal Society of London”, nr 39, s. 65–90.
• James F.A.J.L. 1985a: The Creation of a Victorian Myth: the Historiography of Spectroscopy, „History of Science”, nr 23, s. 1–24.
• James F.A.J.L. 1985b: The Discovery of Line Spectra, „Ambix”, nr 32, s. 53–70.
• James F.A.J.L. 1986: Spectro-Chemistry and Myth. A Rejoinder, „History of Science”, nr 24, s. 433–437.
• James F.A.J.L. 1988: The Practical Problems of ‘New’ Experimental Science: Spectro-Chemistry and the Search for Hitherto Unknown Chemical Elements in Britain 1860–1869, „British Journal for the History of Science”, nr 21, s. 181–194.
• James F.A.J.L. 1998: Spectroscopy (Early) [w:] Instruments of Science: an Historical Encyklopedia, red. R. Bud, D. J. Warner, Taylor & Francis Group, s. 563–565.
• Jensen W.B. 2005: The Origin of the Bunsen Burner, „Journal of Chemical Education”, nr 82, s. 1–2.
• Junkes J. 1962: Hundert Jahre chemische Emissions-Spektralanalyse, „Ricerche Spettroscopiche”, nr 5, s. 1–35.
• Kayser H. 1900: Handbuch der Spektroskopie, t. 1, Verlag von S. Hirzel, Leipzig.
• Kepler J. 2008: Schriften zur Optik 1604–1611, oprac. R. Riekher, Harri Deutsch Verlag, Frankfurt am Main.
• Kirchhoff G. 1859a: Ueber die Winkel der optischen Axen des Aragonits für die verschiedenen Fraunhofer’schen Linien, „Annalen der Physik”, nr 108, s. 567–575.
• Kirchhoff G. 1859b: Ueber die Fraunhofer’schen Linien, „Monatsberichte der Königlich Preußischen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Berlin”, s. 662–665.
• Kirchhoff G. 1859c: Ueber das Verhältnis zwischen Emission und Absorption von Licht und Wärme, „Monatsberichte der Königlich Preußischen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Berlin”, s. 783–787.
• Kirchhoff G. 1862: Ueber einen neuen Satz der Wärmelehre, „Verhandlungen des naturhistorisch-medizinischen Vereins zu Heidelberg”, nr 2, s. 16–23.
• Kirchhoff G. 1863: Zur Geschichte der Spektral-Analyse und der Analyse der Sonnenatmosphäre, „Annalen der Physik und Chemie”, nr 118, s. 94–111.
• Kirchhoff G., Bunsen R. 1860: Chemische Analyse durch Spectralbeobachtungen, „Annalen der Physik und Chemie”, nr 110, s. 161–189.
• Kirchhoff G., Bunsen R. 1861: Chemische Analyse durch Spectralbeobachtungen – Zweite Abhandlung, „Annalen der Physik und Chemie”, 113, s. 337–381.
• Laidler K.J. 2001: The World of Physical Chemistry, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
• Lequeux J. 2008: François Arago, un savant généreux: physique et astronomie au XIXè siècle, EDP Sciences, Paris.
• Lerebours N.-M.-P, Secretan M. 1853: Catalogue et Prix des Instruments, Paris.
• Lockemann G. 1956: The Centenary of the Bunsen Burner, „Journal of Chemical Education”, nr 33, s. 20–22.
• Lockyer J.N. 1873: The Spectroscope and its Application, Macmillan, London.
• Lockyer J.N. 1887: The Chemistry of the Sun, Macmillan, London.
• Lowthorp J. 1699: An Experiment of the Refraction of the Air Made at the Command of the Royal Society, Mar. 28. 1699, „Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London”, nr 21, s. 339–342.
• Maier C.L. 1981: The Role of Spectroscopy in the Acceptance of the Internally Structured Atom, 1860–1920, Arno Press, New York.
• Malus E. 1811: Théorie de la double réfraction de la lumière dans les substances cristallines, „Mémoires présentés à l’Institut des sciences par divers savants”, nr 2, s. 303–508.
• Malus E. 1817: Description et usage d’un goniomètre répétiteur, „Memoires de physique et de chimie de la Société d’Arcueil”, nr 3, s. 122–131.
• Manuel F.E. 1998: Portret Izaaka Newtona, tłum. S. Amsterdamski, Prószyński i S-ka, Warszawa.
• McGucken W. 1969: Nineteenth-Century Spectroscopy. Development of the Understanding of Spectra 1802–1897, The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore–London.
• McLeod H. (red.) 1912: Royal Society of London of Catalogue of Scientific Papers 1800–1900, Subject Index, Volume III: Physics, part I: Generalities, Heat, Light, Sound, Cambridge University Press.
• Méchain P.F.A., Delambre J.B.J. 1807: Base du système métrique décimal..., t. 2, Baudouin, Paris.
• Meyer H.J. 1885–1892: Meyers Konversations-Lexikon. Eine Encyklopädie des allgemeinen Wissens, t. 15, Verlag des Bibliographischen Instituts, Leipzig.
• Meyerstein M. 1856: Ueber ein Instrument zur Bestimmung des Brechungs- und Zerstreuungsvermögens verschiedenen Medien, „Annalen der Physik”, nr 98, s. 91–98.
• Meyerstein M. 1860: Preisverzeichnis der astronomischen und physikalischen Werkstätte von M. Meyerstein, Universitäts-Instrumenten- und Maschinen-Inspector in Göttingen, „Astronomische Nachrichten”, nr 53, s. 155–160, 263–272, 301–304.
• Miller W.A. 1862: On spectrum analysis, „Pharmaceutical Journal”, nr 3, s. 399–412.
• Mousson A. 1861: Resumé de nos connaissances sur le spectre, „Archives des Sciences Physiques et Naturelles”, nr 10, s. 221–258.
• Newton I. 1672: A New Theory of Light and Colours, „Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London”, nr 6, s. 3075–3087.
• Newton I. 1728: Optical Lectures Read in the Publick Schools of the University of Cambridge: Anno Domini, 1669, Francis Fayram, London.
• Numbers R.L. (red.) 2010: Wyrok na Galileusza i inne mity o nauce i religii, tłum. M. Romanek, Centrum Myśli Jana Pawła II, Warszawa.
• Pfaff J.W. 1823: Wiederholung von Dr. Fraunhofer’s in München merkwürdigen optischen Versuchen, und einige electrisch-magnetische Bemerkungen, „Annalen der Physik”, nr 73, s. 268–277.
• Powell B. 1836: Observations for Determining the Refractive Indices for the Standard Rays of the Solar Spectrum in Various Media, „Transactions of the Ashmolean Society”, nr 1, s. 1–24.
• Riekher R. 2009: Fraunhofer und der Beginn der Astrospektroskopie, „Sitzungsberichte der Leibniz-Sozietät der Wissenschaften zu Berlin”, nr 103, s. 95–113.
• Rodzeń J. 2009a: Znaczenie techniki w protonaukowej fazie rozwoju dyscyplin przyrodniczych [w:] Pogranicza nauki. Protonauka – Paranauka – Pseudonauka, red. J. Zon, Wydawnictwo KUL, Lublin, s. 179–194.
• Rodzeń J. 2009b: Félixa Dujardina idea aparatu spektroskopowego, „Kwartalnik Historii Nauki i Techniki”, nr 2, s. 119–132.
• Rodzeń J. 2010a: Nieznana geneza spektroskopu, „Zagadnienia Filozoficzne w Nauce”, nr 46, s. 72–90.
• Rodzeń J. 2010b: Pierwsze spektroskopy pryzmatyczne, „Postępy Fizyki”, nr 61, s. 20–26.
• Römer H. 2005: Theoretical Optics. An Introduction, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim.
• Ronchi V. 1970: The Nature of Light: an Historical Survey, Heinemann, Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
• Roscoe H. 1869: Spectrum Analysis: Six Lectures Delivered in 1868, before the Society of Apothecaries of London, Macmillan, London.
• Roscoe H. 1900: Bunsen Memorial Lecture, „Transactions of the Chemical Society”, nr 77, s. 513–554.
• Saillard M. 1988: Histoire de la spectroscopie. De la théorie de la lumière et les couleurs de I. Newton (1672) à la découverte de l’effet Zeeman (1897), Blanchard, Paris.
• Scheiner J. 1890: Die Spectralanalyse der Gestirne, W. Engelmann, Leipzig.
• Schellen H. 1870: Die Spectralanalyse in ihrer Anwendung auf die Stoffe der Erde und die Natur der Himmelskörper, Westermann, Braunschweig.
• Schellen H. 1872: Spectrum Analysis in Its Application to Terrestrial Substances, and the Physical Constitution of the Heavenly Bodies: Familiarly Explained, D. Appleton and Company.
• Shapiro A.E. 1993: Fits, Passions and Paroxysms: Physics, Method and Chemistry and Newton’s Theories of Colored Bodies and Fits of Easy Reflection, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
• Simms W. 1840: On the Optical Glass Prepared by the Late Dr. Ritchie, „Memoirs of the Royal Astronomical Society”, t. 11, s. 165–170.
• Smith R.W. 2002: Remaking Astronomy. Instruments and Practice in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries [w:] Cambridge History of Science: The Modern Physical and Mathematical Sciences, t. 5, red. M.J. Nye et al., Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, s. 154–173.
• Sorrenson R. 2001: Dollond & Son’s Pursuit of Achromaticity, 1758–1789, „History of Science”, t. 39, s. 31–55.
• Staudenmaier J.M. 1985: Technology’s Storytellers: Reweaving the Human Fabric, MIT Press, Cambridge (Mass.).
• Sutton M. 1986: Spectroscopy, History and Myth: the Victorians Vindicated, „History of Science”, nr 24, s. 425–432.
• Swan W. 1856: On the Prismatic Spectra of the Flames of Compounds of Carbon and Hydrogen, „Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh”, nr 21, s. 411–429.
• Talbot W.H.F. 1826: Some Experiments on Coloured Flames, „Edinburgh Journal of Science”, nr 5, s. 77–81.
• Todd D., Angelo J.A. 2005: A to Z of Scientists in Space and Astronomy, Infobase Publishing, New York.
• Tuckermann A. 1888: Index to the Literature of the Spectroscope, Smithsonian Institute, Washington.
• Tuckermann A. 1902: Index to the Literature of the Spectroscope, 1887–1900, Smithsonian Institute, Washington.
• Turner G.L’E. 1969: The History of Optical Instruments. A Brief Survey of Sources and Modern Studies, „History of Science”, nr 8, s. 53–92.
• Turner G.L’E. 1998: Scientific Instruments 1500–1900. An Introduction, University of California Press, Berkeley et al.
• Tympas A. 2005: Methods in the History of Technology [w:] Encyclopedia of 20th-century Technology, t. 2, red. C.A. Hempstead, Routledge, New York–London.
• Valentin G.G. 1863: Der Gebrauch des Spectroscopes zu physiologischen und ärztlichen Zwecken, Winter, Leipzig.
• Westfall R.S. 1980: Never at Rest. A Biography of Isaac Newton, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
• Wheatstone Ch. 1835: On the Prismatic Decomposition of Electrical Light, „Report of the British Association”, cz. 2, s. 11–12.
• Whiston W., Hauksbee F. jun. 1714: A Course of Mechanical, Optical, Hydrostatical, and Pneumatical Experiments…, London.
• Williams K.R. 2000: A Burning Issue, „Journal of Chemical Education”, nr 77, s. 558–559.
• Windelspecht M. 2003: Groundbreaking Scientific Experiments, Inventions, and Discoveries of the 19th Century, Greenwood Publishing Group.
• Wollaston W.H. 1802: A Method of Examining Refractive and Dispersive Powers, by Prismatic Reflection, „Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London”, nr 92, s. 365–380.
• Wróblewski A.K. 1987: Prawdy i mity w fizyce, Iskry, Warszawa.
• Wróblewski A.K. 2007: Historia fizyki – od czasów najdawniejszych do współczesności, PWN, Warszawa.
• Zantedeschi F. 1856: Descrizione di uno spettrometro e degli esperimenti eseguiti con esso, risguardanti i cambiamenti che si osservano nello spettro solare, Sicca A., Padova.
• Zantedeschi F. 1860/1861: Osservazioni critico-storiche intorno allo spettro luminoso, considerato come fotodoscopio od analizzatore il più squisito che abbia la scienza, „Atti Istituto Veneto”, nr 6, s. 529–543.