PL EN


2015 | 19 | 85-106
Article title

Mapping mistakes: the cartographic confusion of ancient Kleitor

Selected contents from this journal
Title variants
Languages of publication
EN
Abstracts
EN
The ancient Greek city of Kleitor lies in a small valley in north central Arkadia. Although only recently the target of systematic excavations, the first plan of its remains was published almost 200 years ago. While this earliest plan is essentially correct in the details, it is also a simple schematic representation with little topographical detail. When a revised plan of the site – comprising a much more skillful representation of the topography – was published in the late 19th century, it soon supplanted the original in the scholarship. Hidden behind its topographic accuracy and artistic flourishes, however, lies the fact that the mapping of the archaeological remains themselves was incorrect. Consequently, as this plan continued to be modified and reproduced throughout the following century, so too were its mistakes duplicated and exaggerated. Showing the cartographical evolution in the representation of ancient Kleitor and its reception by scholars, this paper demonstrates how scholars have constructed their interpretations of the remains around the unintentional predisposition to equate artistic quality with accuracy, and the consequences of this bias on the archaeological interpretations of the site.
Year
Volume
19
Pages
85-106
Physical description
Contributors
References
  • Baker-Penoyre J. 1902. Pheneus and the Pheneatike. JHS 22, 28–40.
  • Boblaye M. E. P. 1836. Expédition scientifique de Morée. Recherches géographiques sur les ruines de la Morée. Paris.
  • Bursian C. 1862. Geographie von Griechenland. Leipzig.
  • Curtius E. 1851. Peloponnesos, eine historisch-geographische Beschreibung der Halbinsel. Gotha.
  • Dodwell E. 1819. A Classical and Topographical Tour Through Greece, During the Years 1801, 1805, and 1806. London.
  • Frazer J. G. 1898. Pausanias’ Description of Greece, vols 1–6. London.
  • Gell W. 1817. Itinerary of the Morea: Being a Description of the Routes of that Peninsula. London.
  • Gaertringen F. H. von and Lattermann H. 1911. Arkadische Forschungen. Berlin.
  • Jost M. 1985. Sanctuaires et cultes d’Arcadie. (Études Péloponnésiennes 9). Paris.
  • Leake W. M. 1830. Travels in the Morea: with a Map and Plans. London.
  • Loring W. 1892. The walls and internal topography. In Excavations at Megalopolis 1890–91, 106–122. (The Society for the Promotion of Hellenic Studies: Supplementary Papers 1). London.
  • Maher M. forthcoming. The Fortifications of Arkadian City-States in the Classical and Hellenistic Periods. (Oxford Monographs on Classical Archaeology). Oxford.
  • Meyer E. 1939. Peloponnesische Wanderungen. Reisen und Forschungen zur antiken und mittelalterlichen Topographie von Arkadia und Achaia. Zürich.
  • Nielsen T. H. 2002. Arkadia and its Poleis in the Archaic and Classical Periods. (Hypomnemata 140). Göttingen.
  • Papandreou G. 1920. Παπανδρέου Γ. Αρχαιολογικαί και τοπογραφικαί έρευναι εν τῃ επαρχίᾳ Καλαβρύτων. Prakt 75, 95–146.
  • Petritaki M. 1987. Πετριτάκη Μ. Χρονικά. ArchDelt 42, 164.
  • Petritaki M. 1988. Πετριτάκη Μ. Χρονικά. ArchDelt 43, 163–144.
  • Petritaki M. 1989. Πετριτάκη Μ. Χρονικά. ArchDelt 44, 137.
  • Petritaki M. 1991. Πετριτάκη Μ. Χρονικά. ArchDelt 46, 152.
  • Petritaki M. 1992. Πετριτάκη Μ. Χρονικά. ArchDelt 47, 144–146.
  • Petritaki M. 1993. Πετριτάκη Μ. Χρονικά. ArchDelt 48, 128–130.
  • Petritaki M. 1996. Πετριτάκη Μ. Kλείτωρ, μια πόλη της Αρκαδικής Αζανίας. Αρχαιολογία και Τέχνες 61, 81–88.
  • Petritaki M. 2005. Πετριτάκη Μ. Kλείτωρ. Η πόλη υπο το φῶς των ανασκαφῶν. Γενική θεῶρηση ανασκαφικῶν δεδομένων. In E. Østby (ed.), Ancient Arcadia. Papers from the Third International Seminar on Ancient Arcadia. Held at the Norwegian Institute at Athens, 7–10 May 2002, 351–362. Athens.
  • Reinach S. and Le Bas P. 1888. Voyage archéologique en Gréce et en Asie Mineure. Paris.
  • Scranton R. 1941. Greek Walls. Cambridge, Mass.
  • Wagstaff J. M. 2004. Leake, William Martin (1777–1860). Oxford
  • Dictionary of National Biography. Retrieved from http://www.oxforddnb.com/ (status as of May 24, 2010).
  • Winter F. E. 1971. Greek Fortifications. Toronto.
  • Winter F. E. 1989. Arkadian notes. Part 2: The walls of Mantinea,
  • Orchomenos, and Kleitor. Echos du Monde Classique/Classical Views 33, 189–200.
Document Type
Publication order reference
Identifiers
YADDA identifier
bwmeta1.element.desklight-f5a71551-4388-457e-b6fb-539f895fc7f5
JavaScript is turned off in your web browser. Turn it on to take full advantage of this site, then refresh the page.