American Art Criticism between the Cultural and the Ideological (I)

• Authors: Gabriel C. Gherasim
• Languages of publication: EN

Abstracts

EN

Starting from the presupposition that art and art criticism in the United States of America are closely linked and that the very meanings and receptions of art works have been reflected by various writings in the field of art criticism, this first part of a comprehensive study on the topic attempts, on the one hand, to divide the historical evolution of American fine arts and art criticism into several distinct periods, and on the other, to evaluate the major directions of art criticism by considering its historical periods as being markedly ideological or cultural, as the case may be. Thus, considering the approximately 150 years of historical accomplishments of art criticism in the United States, I will argue that the starting point of American art criticism is visibly cultural, while the next two periods are characterised by ideological art criticism, noting that the ideological orientation differs in the two time frames. The fourth moment in the evolution of art criticism marks the revival of the cultural, so that, within the fifth, the postmodern art criticism could no longer grasp a clear distinction between the cultural and the ideological. The present article will focus on the first two important orientations in art criticism in the United States, 1865-1900 and 1908-1940, respectively; a future study will consider the remaining three periods, following this historicist approach of art criticism in the United States.

Keywords

EN

American art criticism; cultural art criticism; ideological art criticism; temporal periodisation of art criticism

• Publisher: Sciendo
• Journal: American, British and Canadian Studies Journal
• Year: 2014
• Volume: 23
• Issue: 1
• Pages: 93-107

Dates

published

2014-12-01

online

2015-02-06

Contributors

author

Gabriel C. Gherasim

• Babes-Bolyai University

References

• Barnum, P.T. “Mr. Barnum on Museums.” Brushes with History. Writing on Art from The Nation 1865-2001. Ed. Peter G. Meyer. New York: Nation, 2001. 7-10. Print.
• Berger, John. “The Cultural Snob. There Is No Highbrow Art.” Brushes with History. Writing on Art from The Nation 1865-2001. Ed. Peter G. Meyer. New York: Nation, 2001. 256-61. Print.
• Brenner, Anita. “Frontiers of Machine Art.” Brushes with History. Writing on Art from The Nation 1865-2001. Ed. Peter G. Meyer. New York: Nation, 2001. 179-81. Print.
• Cox, Kenyon. “The International Art Exhibition.” Brushes with History. Writing on Art from The Nation 1865-2001. Ed. Peter G. Meyer. New York: Nation, 2001. 109-10. Print.
• - - -. Artist and Public and Other Essays on Art Subjects. New York: Scribner, 1914. Print.
• Crunden, Robert M. American Salons: Encounters with European Modernism 1885-1917. New York: Oxford UP, 1993. Print.
• Danto, Arthur. “Introduction.” Brushes with History. Writing on Art from The Nation 1865-2001. Ed. Peter G. Meyer. New York: Nation, 2001. xxixxviii. Print.
• Hafif, Marcia. “The Critic Is (?) Artist.” M/E/A/N/I/N/G. An Anthology of Artists’ Writings, Theory, and Criticism. Ed. Susan Bee and Mira Schor. Durham: Duke UP, 2000. 127-30. Print.
• Hartley, Marsden. “Dissertation on Modern Painting.” Brushes with History. Writing on Art from The Nation 1865-2001. Ed. Peter G. Meyer. New York: Nation, 2001. 126-28. Print.
• James, Henry. “The Ruskin/ Whistler Trial - Part I, II.” Brushes with History. Writing on Art from The Nation 1865-2001. Ed. Peter G. Meyer. New York: Nation, 2001. 24-28. Print.
• Jameson, Fredric. The Ideologies of Theory. London: Verso, 2008. Print.
• Kuspit, Donald. The Critic Is Artist: The Intentionality of Art. Ann Arbor: UMI, 1984. Print.
• Marshall, Margaret. “Off with His Head (Editorial).” Brushes with History. Writing on Art from The Nation 1865-2001. Ed. Peter G. Meyer. New York: Nation, 2001. 176-77. Print.
• Mather Jr., Frank J. “Art Prices and Art Values.” Brushes with History. Writing on Art from The Nation 1865-2001. Ed. Peter G. Meyer. New York: Nation, 2001. 86-88. Print.
• - - -. “Old and New Art.” Brushes with History. Writing on Art from The Nation 1865-2001. Ed. Peter G. Meyer. New York: Nation, 2001. 110-12. Print.
• - - -. “The Artist in Our World.” Brushes with History. Writing on Art from The Nation 1865-2001. Ed. Peter G. Meyer. New York: Nation, 2001. 88-90. Print.
• - - -. “The Armory Exhibition.” Brushes with History. Writing on Art from The Nation 1865-2001. Ed. Peter G. Meyer. New York: Nation, 2001. 112-16. Print.
• McLanathan, Richard. Art in America. A Brief History. London: Thames, 1973. Print.
• Meyer, Peter G., ed. Brushes with History. Writing on Art from The Nation 1865-2001. New York: Nation, 2001. Print.
• Morgan, H. Wayne. Keepers of Culture: The Art-Thought of Kenyon Cox, Royal Cortissoz, and Frank Jewett Mather Jr. Ohio: Kent State UP, 1989. Print.
• N. N. “Art in the Victorian Era.” Brushes with History. Writing on Art from The Nation 1865-2001. Ed. Peter G. Meyer. New York: Nation, 2001. 69-74. Print.
• Raverty, Dennis. Struggle over the Modern: Purity and Experience in American Art Criticism 1900-1960. Madison: Fairleigh Dickinson UP, 2005. Print.
• Rosenfeld, Paul. “Bread Lines and a Museum.” Brushes with History. Writing on Art from The Nation 1865-2001. Ed. Peter G. Meyer. New York: Nation, 2001. 155-56. Print.
• Stillman, W. J. “Ruskin and His Writings.” Brushes with History. Writing on Art from The Nation 1865-2001. Ed. Peter G. Meyer. New York: Nation, 2001. 20-23. Print.

Identifiers

DOI

10.1515/abcsj-2014-0029