Emptying Śūnyatā: a Critical Reading of Nishitani’s Religion and Nothingness

• Authors: Ramunas Motiekaitis
• Languages of publication: EN

Abstracts

EN

In this article, invoking some terms of phenomenology and general principles of structural semiotics, I critically examine and reveal some aporetic aspects of Nishitani’s interpretation of Buddhist concept of sūnyatā presented in his seminal work Religion and Nothingness. My critics are directed to deeply ingrained claims among scholars of a “rejection of any form of dualism” and “non-substantial philosophy” as unique characteristics of the Kyoto school or “logic of the East”. My arguments are based on examining how linguistic differentiating articulation and narrative rendering that perform a fundamental role in human cognition are at work in definition of “emptiness” (sūnyatā) too. Thus emptiness is not completely empty; being certain philosophical identity it can be articulated only by differentiation from other identities, and thus different is included in it. Nishitani needed logocentric modes of thought, as a dialectical (m)other for constructing his sūnyatā ontology. Accordingly, the realms that are considered to be secondary or derivative (i.e. sensual and rational, or linguistic representations) appear to be the condition for constituting the primary (suchness of things, sūnyatā). Considering universal mechanisms of the articulation of values I am also asking whether sūnyatā paradigm indeed is so fundamentally different from Western paradigms centered on idea, God, or a rational subject as Nishitani wants to think. Since we find a clear hierarchical differentiation into truth and illusion, authentic and inauthentic modes of thought and time, and initial and derivative ontological realms, features of “strong thought” (in sense of Vattimo) are evident in his work. I am also suggesting, that possibly by considering not sūnyatā or “idea” but human languages as a universal “house of being”, we would be able to “empty” discourses of radical difference and uniqueness, and in this way become post-nationalistically modern. Philosophy, in order not to turn into a onesided ideology, should reflect on its mythological and narratological conditions, i.e. dances on certain semiotic axes. From such a perspective, the gravitational trajectory of human thought, longing for conjunction with the absolute, defined either as God or as sūnyatā, will seem similar rather than different.

Keywords

EN

Semiotics; Buddhism; Śūnyatā; differentiation; dialectics; intentionality

• Publisher: Sciendo
• Journal: International Journal of Area Studies
• Year: 2015
• Volume: 10
• Issue: 1
• Pages: 69-83

Dates

published

2015-03-01

online

2015-05-15

Contributors

author

Ramunas Motiekaitis

• LITHUANIAN ACADEMY OF MUSIC AND THEATRE

References

• Cassiner, E., 1953. Language and Myth. Tr. by Suzanne K. Langer. Dover Publications Inc. NY.
• Corrington, R. S., 2000. A Semiotic Theory of Theology and Religion. Cambridge University Press.
• Deleuze, G., Guattari F., 2005. A Thousand Plateaus: Capitalism and Schizophrenia. Translation and Foreword by Brian Massumi. University of Minnesota Press.
• Derrida, J., 1978. Force and Signification (pp. 3-30) in Writing and Difference. Tr. Alan Bass. Routledge & Kegan Paul, London.
• Eco, U., 2012. Inventing the Enemy: Essays. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Press.
• Faure, B., 1991. The Rhetoric of Immediacy: A Cultural Critique of Chan/Zen Buddhism. Princeton University Press.
• Faure, B., 1993. Chan Insights and Oversight: An Epistemological Critique of the Chan Tradition. Princeton University Press.
• Greimas, A. J., 1987. On meaning: Selected Writings in Semiotic Theory. Tr. By Paul J. Perron and Frank H. Collins, foreword by Frederic Jameson; introduction by Paul J. Perron. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
• Heidegger, M., 1996. Being and Time. Tr. Joan Stambaugh. SUNY Press.
• Hegel, G. W. F., 1977. Phenomenology of Spirit. Tr. A. V. Miller with Analysis of the Text and Foreword by J. N. Findlay. Oxford University Press.
• Hegel, G. W. F., 1991. The Encyclopaedia Logic (with the Zusätze) (Part I of the Encyclopaedia of Philosophical Scineces with the Zusätze). A New Translation with Introduction and Notes by T. F. Geraets, W. A. Suchting, and H. S. Harris. Hackett Publishing Company, Inc. Indianapolis/Cambridge.
• Heisig, J. W., 2009. Nishitani Keiji and the Overcoming of Modernity (1940-1945). In Frontiers of Japanese Philosophy 6: Confluences and Cross-Currents (p. 297-329), ed. Raquel Bouso Garcķa and James W. Heisig. Nanzan Institute for Religion and Culture.
• Heisig, K., Maraldo (eds.) Japanese Philosophy: A Sourcebook. University of Hawai’i Press.
• Kopf, G., 2011. Language Games, Selflessness, and the Death of God: A/Theology in Contemporary Zen Philosophy and Deconstruction. In Japanese and Continental Philosophy: Conversations with the Kyoto School. Ed. by Bret W. Davis, Brian Schroeder, and Jason M. Wirth. Indiana University Press (p. 160-178).
• Lotman, Y., Ivanov V.V., Pjatigorski J. M., Toporov V.N., Uspenskij B.A. 1998. Theses on the Semiotic Study of Cultures. Tartu: Tartu Semiotics Library 1.
• Nishitani, Keiji, 1982. Religion and Nothingness. Tr. Jan Van Bragt, University of California Press, Berkeley. Abbreviation: RN Nishitani, Keiji, (1986-1995)『西谷啓治著作集』 [Collected works of Nishitani Keiji], Tokyo: Sōbunsha. Vol 10. Abbreviation: NKC
• Suares, P., 2011. The Kyoto School’s Takeover of Hegel: Nishida, Nishitani and Tanabe Remake the Philosophy of Spirit. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers Inc.
• Tremblay, J., 2008. Hidden Aspects of Temporality from Nishida to Watsuji. In Frontiers of Japanese Philosophy 2: Neglected Themes and Hidden Variations, (pp. 160-176). Ed. Victor Sōgen Hori and Melissa Anne-Marie Curley. Nanzan Instutitute for Religion and Culture.
• Vattimo, G., Rovatti, P. A., 2012.Weak Thought. Translated and with an introduction by Peter Carravetta. SUNY Press.
• Zhang, Longxi, 1985. The Tao and the Logos: Notes on Derrida’s Critique of Logocentrism. In Critical Inquiry 11: 385-398.

Identifiers

DOI

10.1515/ijas-2015-0004