2015 | 46 | 2 | 262-277
Article title

Aristotelian Moral Psychology and the Situationist Challenge

Title variants
Languages of publication
For some time now moral psychologists and philosophers have ganged up on Aristotelians, arguing that results from psychological studies on the role of character-based and situation-based influences on human behavior have convincingly shown that situations rather than personal characteristics determine human behavior. In the literature on moral psychology and philosophy this challenge is commonly called the “situationist challenge,” and as Prinz (2009) has previously explained, it has largely been based on results from four salient studies in social psychology, including the studies conducted by Hartshorne and May (1928), Milgram (1963), Isen and Levin (1972), and Darley and Batson (1973). The situationist challenge maintains that each of these studies seriously challenges the plausibility of virtuous personal characteristics by challenging the plausibility of personal characteristics more generally. In this article I undermine the situationist challenge against Aristotelian moral psychology by carefully considering major problems with the conclusions that situationists have drawn from the empirical data, and by further challenging the accuracy of their characterization of the Aristotelian view. In fact I show that when properly understood the Aristotelian view is not only consistent with empirical data from developmental science but can also offer important insights for integrating moral psychology with its biological roots in our natural and social life.
Physical description
  • Aquinas, T. (1993). Commentary on Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics, C. Litzinger (trans.). Notre Dame: Dumb Ox Books.
  • Aristotle. (1963). Categories and de interpretatione, J. Ackrill (trans.). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  • Aristotle. (1998). Politics, C. Reeve (trans.). Indianapolis: Hackett.
  • Aristotle. (2000). Prior and posterior analytics, W. D. Ross (trans.). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  • Aristotle. (2011). Nicomachean ethics, R. C. Barlett & S. D. Collins (trans.). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
  • Athanassoulis, N. (2000). A response to Harman: Virtue ethics and character traits. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 100, 215-221. [Crossref]
  • Bem, D. (1983). Toward a response style theory of persons in situations. In M. Page (ed.), Nebraska symposium on motivation, 1982: Personality - Current theory and research (pp. 201-231). Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press.
  • Blasi, A. (1980). Bridging moral cognition and moral action: A critical review of the literature. Psychological Bulletin, 88, 1-45.[Crossref]
  • Blass, T. (1984). Interactionism. In R. Corsini (ed.), Encyclopedia of psychology, volume 2 (pp. 234-235). New York: Wiley.
  • Blass, T. (1987). Interactionism. In R. Corsini (ed.), Concise encyclopedia of psychology (pp. 605-606). New York: Wiley.
  • Blass, T. (1991). Understanding behavior in the Milgram obedience experiment: The role of personality, situations, and their interactions. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 60, 398-413. http://[Crossref]
  • Blevins, G., & Murphy, T. (1974). Feeling good and helping: Further phonebooth findings. Psychological Reports, 34, 326. http://dx.doi. org/10.2466/pr0.1974.34.1.326[Crossref]
  • Bowers, K. (1973). Situationism in psychology: An analysis and a critique. Psychological Review, 80, 307-336.[Crossref]
  • Burley, P., & McGuinness, J. (1977). Effects of social intelligence on the Milgram paradigm. Psychological Reports, 40, 767-770.[Crossref]
  • Burton, R. (1963). Generality of honesty reconsidered. Psychological Review, 70, 481-499.[Crossref]
  • Buss, D. M. (1991). Evolutionary personality psychology. Annual Review of Psychology, 42, 459-491.[Crossref]
  • Churchwell, J. C., & Yurgelun-Todd, D. A. (2013). Age-related changes in insula cortical thickness and impulsivity: Significance for emotional development and decision-making. Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience, 6, 80-86.[Crossref]
  • Croom, A. M. (2014a). Embodying martial arts for mental health: Cultivating psychological well-being with martial arts practice. Archives of Budo Science of Martial Arts and Extreme Sports, 10, 59-70.
  • Croom, A. M. (2014b). Vindicating virtue: A critical analysis of the situationist challenge against Aristotelian moral psychology.
  • Integrative Psychological and Behavioral Science, 48, 18-47. http://[Crossref]
  • Croom, A. M. (2012a). Music, neuroscience, and the psychology of well-being: A précis. Frontiers in Psychology, 2, 393. http://dx.doi. org/10.3389/fpsyg.2011.00393[Crossref]
  • Croom, A. M. (2012b). Aesthetic concepts, perceptual learning, and linguistic enculturation: Considerations from Wittgenstein, language, and music. Integrative Psychological and Behavioral Science, 46, 90-117.[Crossref]
  • Curtis, M., & Bharucha, J. (2009). Memory and musical expectation for tones in cultural contexts. Music Perception, 26, 365-375.[Crossref]
  • Darley, J., & Batson, C. (1973). “From Jerusalem to Jericho”: A study of situational and dispositional variables in helping behavior. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 27, 100-108.[Crossref]
  • Dingemanse, N. J., Bouwman, K. M., van de Pol, M., van Overveld, T., Patrick, S. C., Matthysen, E., & Quinn, J. L. (2012). Variation in personality and behavioural plasticity across four populations of the great tit Parus major. The Journal of Animal Ecology, 81, 116-126. [Crossref]
  • Doris, J. (1998). Persons, situations, and virtue ethics. Nous, 32, 504-530.[Crossref]
  • Elms, A. (1972). Social psychology and social relevance. Boston: Little, Brown.
  • Elms, A., & Milgram, S. (1966). Personality characteristics associated with obedience and defiance toward authoritative command. Journal of Experimental Research in Personality, 1, 282-289.
  • Emmons, R., Diener, E., & Larsen, R. (1986). Choice and avoidance of everyday situations and affect congruence: Two models of reciprocal interactionism. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 51, 815-826.[Crossref]
  • Endler, N. (1984). Interactionism. In N. Endler & J. McV Hunt (eds.), Personality and the behavioral disorders, volume 1 (pp. 183-217). New York: Wiley.
  • Eng, J. (2012). Homeless numbers down, but risks rise. NBC News.
  • Eysenck, H. (1939). Primary mental abilities. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 9, 270-275. [Crossref]
  • Eysenck, M., & Eysenck, H. (1980). Mischel and the concept of personality. British Journal of Psychology, 71, 191-204. [Crossref]
  • Feather, N., & Volkmer, R. (1988). Preference for situations involving effort, time pressure, and feedback in relation to Type A behavior, locus of control, and test anxiety. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 55, 266-271.[Crossref]
  • Fleeson, W., & Gallagher, P. (2009). The implications of Big Five standing for the distribution of trait manifestation in behavior: Fifteen experience-sampling studies and a meta-analysis. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 97, 1097-1114. http://dx.doi. org/10.1037/a0016786[Crossref]
  • Fratkin, J. L., Sinn, D. L., Patall, E. A., & Gosling, S. D. (2013). Personality consistency in dogs: A meta-analysis. PloS One, 8, e54907.
  • Giunta, S. (2012). Living with honor: A memoir of Medal of Honor recipient Staff Sergeant Salvatore A. Giunta. New York: Simon & Schuster.
  • Gormly, J. (1983). Predicting behavior from personality trait scores.
  • Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 9, 267-270.[Crossref]
  • Graham, J., Haidt, J., Koleva, S., Motyl, M., Iyer, R., Wojcik, S. P., & Ditto, P. H. (2013). Moral foundations theory: The pragmatic validity of moral pluralism. In P. Devine & A. Plant (eds.), Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, Volume 47 (pp. 55-130).[Crossref]
  • Graham, J., Nosek, B. A., Haidt, J., Iyer, R., Koleva, S., & Ditto, P. H. (2011). Mapping the moral domain. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 101, 366-385.[Crossref]
  • Grammer, J. K., Carrasco, M., Gehring, W. J., & Morrison, F. J. (2014). Age-related changes in error processing in young children: A schoolbased investigation. Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience, 9, 93-105.[Crossref]
  • Haidt, J. (2008). Morality. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 3, 65-72. [Crossref]
  • Haidt, J. (2006). The Happiness Hypothesis: Finding Modern Truth in Ancient Wisdom. New York: Basic Books.
  • Haidt, J. (2003). The moral emotions. In R. J. Davidson, K. R. Scherer, & H. H. Goldsmith (eds.), Handbook of Affective Sciences (pp. 852-870). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  • Haidt, J., & Joseph, C. (2008). The moral mind: How five sets of innate intuitions guide the development of many culture-specific virtues, and perhaps even modules. In P. Carruthers, S. Laurence, & S.
  • Stich (eds.), The Innate Mind, Volume 3: Foundations and the Future (Chapter 19). Oxford: Oxford University Press.[Crossref]
  • Haidt, J., & Joseph, C. (2004). Intuitive ethics: How innately prepared intuitions generate culturally variable virtues. Daedalus, 133, 55-66.[Crossref]
  • Hannon, E., & Trehub, S. (2005). Tuning in to musical rhythms: infants learn more readily than adults. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 102, 12639-12643.[Crossref]
  • Harman, G. (1999). Moral philosophy meets social psychology: Virtue ethics and the fundamental attribution error. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 99, 315-331. stable/4545312
  • Harman, G. (2000). The nonexistence of character traits. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 100, 223-226. stable/4545327
  • Hartshorne, H., & May, M. (1928). Studies in the nature of character, volume 1: Studies in deceit. New York: MacMillan.
  • Hartshorne, H., May, M., & Maller, J. (1929). Studies in the nature of character, volume 2: Studies in self-control. New York: MacMillan.
  • Haas, K. (1966). Obedience: Submission to destructive orders as related to hostility. Psychological Reports, 19, 32-34. pr0.1966.19.1.32[Crossref]
  • Heraclitus. (2001). Fragments, B. Haxton (trans.). New York: Penguin Books.
  • Herde, A., & Eccard, J. A. (2013). Consistency in boldness, activity and exploration at different stages of life. BMC Ecology, 13, 49.[Crossref]
  • Hoffman, M. (2000). Empathy and moral development: Implications for caring and justice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  • Holland, C. (1967). Sources of variance in the experimental investigation of behavioral obedience. Dissertation Abstracts International, 29, 2802A. (University Microfilms No. 69-2146)
  • Hyde, K., Lerch, J., Norton, A., Forgeard, M., Winner, E., Evans, A., & Schlaug, G. (2009). Musical training shapes structural brain development. Journal of Neuroscience, 29, 3019-3025.[Crossref]
  • Isen, A., & Levin, P. (1972). Effect of feeling good on helping: Cookies and kindness. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 21, 384-388.[Crossref]
  • Kharitonova, M., Martin, R. E., Gabrieli, J. D. E., & Sheridan, M. A. (2013). Cortical gray-matter thinning is associated with age-related improvements on executive function tasks. Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience, 6, 61-71.[Crossref]
  • Kiefer, A. W., Wallot, S., Gresham, L. J., Kloos, H., Riley, M. A., Shockley, K., & Van Orden, G. (2014). Development of coordination in time estimation. Developmental Psychology, 50, 393-401. http://dx.doi. org/10.1037/a0033629[Crossref]
  • Kochanska, G. & Aksan, N. (2006). Children’s conscience and selfregulation. Journal of Personality, 74, 1587-1617. [Crossref]
  • Kraus, N., Skoe, E., Parbery-Clark, A., & Ashley, R. (2009). Experienceinduced malleability in neural encoding of pitch, timbre, and timing.[PubMed]
  • Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1169, 543-557. Kraut, R. (2012). Aristotle’s ethics. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. [Crossref]
  • Leary, M., Wheeler, D., & Jenkins, T. (1986). Aspects of identity and behavioral preference: Studies of occupational and recreational choice. Social Psychology Quarterly, 49, 11-18.[Crossref]
  • Lerner, B. (2011). Benevolence. In K. Ryan, B. Lerner, K. Bohlin, O. Nakayama, S. Mizuno & K. Horiuchi (eds.), Happiness and virtue beyond east and west: Towards a new global responsibility (pp. 95-103). Tuttle: Tokyo. Merritt, M. (2000). Virtue ethics and situationist personality psychology. Ethical Theory and Moral Practice, 3, 365-383.[Crossref]
  • Merritt, M. (2009). Aristotelian virtue and the interpersonal aspect of ethical character. Journal of Moral Philosophy, 6, 23-49.[Crossref]
  • Milgram, S. (1963). Behavioral study of obedience. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 67, 371-378. h0040525[Crossref]
  • Milgram, S. (1974). Obedience to authority: An experimental view. New York: Harper & Row.
  • Miller, C. (2003). Social psychology and virtue ethics. The Journal of Ethics, 7, 365-392.[Crossref]
  • Miller, F. (1975). An experimental study of obedience to authorities of varying legitimacy. Ph.D. dissertation, Harvard University.
  • Mischel, W. (1979). On the interface of cognition and personality: Beyond the person-situation debate. American Psychologist, 34, 740-754.[Crossref]
  • Mischel, W. (1968). Personality and Assessment. New York: Wiley.
  • Olweus, D. (1977). A critical analysis of the “modern” interactionist position. In D. Magnusson & N. Endler (eds.), Personality at the crossroads: Current issues in interactional psychology (pp. 221-233). Hillsdale: Erlbaum.
  • Padmanabhan, A., Geier, C. F., Ordaz, S. J., Teslovich, T., & Luna, B. (2011). Developmental changes in brain function underlying the influence of reward processing on inhibitory control. Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience, 1, 517-529.[Crossref]
  • Pons, E., Lewkowicz, D., Soto-Faraco, S., & Sebastian-Galles, N. (2009). Narrowing of intersensory speech perception in infancy. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 106, 10598-10602.[Crossref]
  • Poulsen, C., Picton, T. W., & Paus, T. (2009). Age-related changes in transient and oscillatory brain responses to auditory stimulation during early adolescence. Developmental Science, 12, 220-235. [Crossref]
  • Prinz, J. (2009). The normativity challenge: Cultural psychology provides the real threat to virtue ethics. The Journal of Ethics, 13, 117-144.[Crossref]
  • Prinz, J. (2008). Is morality innate? In W. Sinnott-Armstrong (ed.), Moral psychology: The evolution of morality: Adaptations and innateness (pp. 367-406). Cambridge: MIT Press.
  • Reeve, C. (2012). Action, contemplation, and happiness: An essay on Aristotle. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Robins, R. W., Fraley, R. C., Roberts, B. W., & Trzesniewski, K. H. (2001). A longitudinal study of personality change in young adulthood. Journal of Personality, 69, 617-640.[Crossref]
  • Rotter, J. (1990). Internal versus external control of reinforcement: A case history of a variable. American Psychologist, 45, 489-493.[Crossref]
  • Rushton, J., Chrisjohn, R., & Fekken, G. (1981). The altruistic personality and the self-report altruism scale. Personality and Individual Differences, 2, 293-302.[Crossref]
  • Sabini, J., & Silver, M. (2005). Lack of character? Situationism reconsidered. Ethics, 115, 535-562.
  • Schmitt, D., Realo, A., Voracek, M., & Allik, J. (2008). Why can’t a man be more like a woman? Sex differences in Big Five personality traits across 55 cultures. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 94, 168-182.[Crossref]
  • Schnupp, J., Nelken, I., & King, A. (2011). Auditory neuroscience: Making sense of sound. Cambridge: MIT Press.
  • Schuett, W., Dall, S. R. X., & Royle, N. J. (2011). Pairs of zebra finches with similar ‘personalities’ make better parents. Animal Behaviour, 81, 609-618.[Crossref]
  • Shalala, S. (1974). A study of various communication settings which produce obedience by subordinates to unlawful superior orders. Dissertation Abstracts International, 36, 979. (University Microfilms No. 75-17,675)
  • Sherman, L. E., Rudie, J. D., Pfeifer, J. H., Masten, C. L., McNealy, K., & Dapretto, M. (2014). Development of the default mode and central executive networks across early adolescence: A longitudinal study. Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience, 10, 148-159.[Crossref]
  • Sigelman, C., & Rider, E. (2009). Life-span human development. Belmont: Wadsworth.
  • Snyder, M., & Gangestad, S. (1982). Choosing social situations: Two investigations of self-monitoring processes. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 43, 123-135.[Crossref]
  • Spearman, C. (1910). Correlation calculated from faculty data. British Journal of Psychology, 3, 271-295.
  • Sreenivasan, G. (2002). Errors about errors: Virtue theory and trait attribution. Mind, 111, 47-68.[Crossref]
  • Stagner, R. (1976). Traits are relevant: Theoretical analysis and empirical evidence. In N. Endler & D. Magnusson (eds.), Interactional psychology and personality (pp. 109-124). New York: Hemisphere.
  • Stamps, J. A., & Groothuis, T. G. G. (2010). Developmental perspectives on personality: Implications for ecological and evolutionary studies of individual differences. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B, 365, 4029-4041.[Crossref]
  • Tremmel, M., & Muller, C. (2012). Insect personality depends on environmental conditions. Behavioral Ecology, 24, 386-392.[Crossref]
  • Trump, D. (2007). Wesley Autrey: The Time 100. Time Magazine.,28804,1595326_1615754_1615746,00.html
  • Vara, A. S., Pang, E. W., Vidal, J., Anagnostou, E., & Taylor, M. J. (2014). Neural mechanisms of inhibitory control continue to mature in adolescence. Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience, 10, 129-139.[Crossref]
  • Vranas, P. (2005). The indeterminacy paradox: Character evaluations and human psychology. Nous, 39, 1-42. [Crossref]
  • Wachtel, P. (1973). Psychodynamics, behavior therapy, and the implacable experimenter: An inquiry into the consistency of personality. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 82, 324-334. h0035132[Crossref]
  • Westerhoff, N. (2008). Set in our ways. Scientific American Mind, 19, 44-49.[Crossref]
  • Weyant, J., & Clark, R. (1976). Dimes and helping: The other side of the coin. Personality and Social Psychology Journal, 3, 107-110.[Crossref]
  • Wills, A., Lavric, A., Croft, G., & Hodgson, T. (2007). Predictive learning, prediction errors, and attention: Evidence from event-related potentials and eye tracking. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience, 19, 843-854.[Crossref]
  • Witte, P. (2012). The state of homelessness in American 2012. Homelessness Research Institute.
  • Wolf, M., & Weissing, F. J. (2012). Animal personalities: Consequences for ecology and evolution. Trends in Ecology and Evolution, 27, 452-461.[Crossref]
  • Zahn-Waxler, C., & Radke-Yarrow, M. (1990). The origins of empathic concern. Motivation and Emotion, 14, 107-130.[Crossref]
  • Zahn-Waxler, C., Radke-Yarrow, M., & King, R. (1979). Child rearing and children’s prosocial initiations toward victims of distress. Child Development, 50, 319-330.
Document Type
Publication order reference
YADDA identifier
JavaScript is turned off in your web browser. Turn it on to take full advantage of this site, then refresh the page.