The Islamofascists are coming! (or are they?) Assessing the accuracy of a common contemporary analogy

• Authors: Alan Bloomfield
• Languages of publication: EN

Abstracts

EN

This paper assesses the accuracy of the common analogy by which contemporary Islamists are casually conflated with classical fascists. It argues that there are some parallels, in particular the manner in which Islamists and fascists, when pursuing their political agendas, are and were both deeply intolerant of “deviants” and prepared to readily deploy violence against opponents. But it also argues that the analogy remains substantially flawed: in the context of domestic politics, Islamists face authoritarian regimes prepared to use violence against them and which are therefore very different to the liberalist regimes the fascists faced. And from an international perspective the Islamists face great powers united in their determination to ensure they do not rise to power by “capturing” a state, unlike the fascists. While current changes in the Arab world may create conditions more amenable for Islamists to carry out “stealthy” take-overs, until such occur the analogy remains at best only partially valid.

Keywords

EN

liberal; Islamist; fascist; totalitarian; authoritarian

• Publisher: Sciendo
• Journal: Human Affairs
• Year: 2011
• Volume: 21
• Issue: 1
• Pages: 7-17

Dates

published

2011-03-01

online

2011-04-19

Contributors

author

Alan Bloomfield

• Herstmonceux Castle

References

• [1] Abraham, D. The Collapse of the Weimar Republic: Political Economy and Crisis, 2nd Ed. New York: Holmes & Meier, 1986.
• [2] AFP (2010). Praying Muslims like Nazis, says Le Pen daughter Marine. The Australian, 14 December 2010.
• [3] AFP (2011). Al-Qaeda group calls for jihad in Egypt. The Australian, 9 February 2011.
• [4] Al-Awlaki, S. The Ruling on Dispossessing the Unbelievers [sic] Wealth in Dar al-Harb. Inspire 4 (English-language magazine of Al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula.), 55–60, Winter 2011 at http://info.publicintelligence.net/InspireJanuary2011.pdf.
• [5] Al-Bayoumi, R. (Deputy-Chairman, Muslim Brotherhood). Interview with Der Spiegel, 7 February 2011.
• [6] Al-Ghazar, H. (Senior Member, Muslim Brotherhood). Interview with BBC Newsnight, 11 February 2011.
• [7] Almond, G, Appleby, R. S., Sivan, E. Strong Religion: The Rise of Fundamentalisms around the World. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2003.
• [8] Antoun, R. Understanding Fundamentalism: Christian, Islamic and Jewish Movements, 2nd Ed. Plymouth: Rowman & Littlefield, 2008.
• [9] Azra, A. Indonesia, Islam, and Democracy: Dynamics in a Global Context. Jakarta: Solstice, 2006.
• [10] Barber, B., Curtis, M. Friedrich, C. Totalitarianism in Perspective: Three Views. London: Pall Mall Press, 1969.
• [11] Bellin, E. The Robustness of Authoritarianism in the Middle East: Exceptionalism in Comparative Perspective. Comparative Politics 36,2, 139–157, 2004. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/4150140[Crossref]
• [12] Berlin, I. Two Concepts of Liberty, 1958. In N. Warburton (Ed.). Philosophy: Basic Readings. Oxford: Routledge, 2005.
• [13] Berman, S. Civil Society and the Collapse of the Weimar Republic. World Politics, 1997.
• [14] Bessel, R. Why Did the Weimar Republic Collapse? In Ian Kershaw (Ed.). Why Did German Democracy Fail? London: Weidenfeld & Nicholson, 1990.
• [15] Black, I. Egypt’s Muslim Brotherhood is a Force the World Can No Longer Afford to Ignore. The Guardian, 6 February 2011.
• [16] Brzezinski, Z. Ideology and Power in Soviet Politics. New York: Praeger, 1967.
• [17] Buchheim, H. Totalitäre Herrschaft-Wessen und Merkale. Munich: Kösel, 1962.
• [18] Bush, G. Press Conference, Prairie Chapel Ranch (Crawford, Texas), 7 August 2006; speech, National Endowment for Democracy, Washington, 6 October 2005.
• [19] Chalk, P., Ungerer, C. Neighbourhood Watch: The Evolving Terrorist Threat in Southeast Asia. Australian Strategic Policy Institute, 25 June 2008.
• [20] Chung, C-P. China’s “War on Terror”. September 11 and Uighur Separatism. Foreign Affairs 81, 4 2002. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/20033235[Crossref]
• [21] Cole, J. Freidman Wrong About Muslims Again. Informed Comment, 9 July 2005, at http://www.juancole.com/2005/07/friedman-wrong-about-muslims-again-and.html.
• [22] El-Helbawy, K. (Former Spokesman, Muslim Brotherhood in the West). Interview with BBC Hardtalk, 6 February 2011.
• [23] Esposito, J. Unholy War: Terror in the Name of Islam. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002.
• [24] Duran, K. How CAIR put my life in danger. Middle East Quarterly, 37–43, Winter 2002.
• [25] Duran, K., Hechiche, A. Children of Abraham: An Introduction to Islam for Jews. Hoboken: Ktav, 2001.
• [26] Fish, M. S. Islam and Authoritarianism. World Politics 551, 2002.
• [27] Friedman, T. Iran and the War of Ideas. New York Times, 19 June 2002.
• [28] Friedman, G. Egypt, Israel and a Strategic Reconsideration, Stratfor.com, 8 February 2011, at http://www.stratfor.com/weekly/20110207-egypt-israel-and-strategic-reconsideration.
• [29] Fromm, E. The Fear of Freedom. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1942.
• [30] Green, R. Bush’s Language Angers US Muslims. BBC News, 12 August 2006, at http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/4785065.stm.
• [31] Hahn, G. Russia’s Islamic Threat. New Haven: Yale University Press, 2007.
• [32] Halliday, F. Two Hours that Shook the World: September 11, 2001: Causes and Consequences. London: Saqi, 2002. - “Founding Statement of Al-Qaeda” (Appendix 1) “Osama bin Laden Statement” (Appendix 5) and “Suleiman Abu Gaith Statement” (Appendix 6).
• [33] Hertzog, M. Can Hamas be Tamed? Foreign Affairs 85, 2, 2006.
• [34] Hobsbawm, E. The Age of Revolution. London: Weidenfeld & Nicholson, 1962.
• [35] Howard, J. Speech, The Quadrant 50th Anniversary Dinner, Canberra, transcript in The Australian, 4 October 2006.
• [36] Karatnycky, A. Muslim Countries and the Democracy Gap. Journal of Democracy 13, 1, 2002. http://dx.doi.org/10.1353/jod.2002.0009[Crossref]
• [37] Khatib, S. A Politicized Hamas and its Jihadist Rivals in Gaza. Stratfor.com, 12 January 2011, at http://www.stratfor.com/180321.
• [38] Lewis, B. What Went Wrong? Western Impact and Middle Eastern Response. London: Phoenix, 2002.
• [39] Lewis, J. Stockholm Bomber: Banned Extremists Recruit Near Taimour Abdulwahab al-Abdaly’s Luton Home. The Telegraph, 19 December 2010.
• [40] Long, B. The Hamas Agenda: How Has it Changed? Middle East Policy 17, 4, 2010. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1475-4967.2010.00467.x[Crossref]
• [41] McGregor, A. J. The Ideology of Fascism: the Rationale of Totalitariainism. New York: Free Press, 1969.
• [42] Mill, J. S. On Liberty. London: Penguin, 1985 [1859].
• [43] Mohan, R. India and the Balance of Power. Foreign Affairs 85, 4, 2006. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/20032038[Crossref]
• [44] Neighbour, S. Full-bred Aussie with a Longing for Sharia Law. The Australian, 21 January 2011.
• [45] Podhoretz, N. World War IV: The Long Struggle against Islamofascism. New York: Doubleday, 2007.
• [46] Radel, J. Lucien. Roots of Totalitarianism: The Ideological Sources of Fascism, National Socialism and Communism. New York: Crane, Russak & Co, 1975.
• [47] Reuters (Editor). Hamas Says Committed to Mutual Truce with Israel. Reuters, 24 December 2010, at http://www.reuters.com/article/2010/12/24/us-palestinians-israel-violenceidUSTRE6BN1RX20101224.
• [48] Rogan, E. The Arabs: A History. London: Penguin, 2009.
• [49] Safire, W. Construing Islam as a Language. The Independent, 8 September 1990.
• [50] Scardino, A. 1-0 in the Propaganda Wars. The Guardian, 4 February 2005.
• [51] Shane, S. As Islamist Group Rises, its Intentions are Unclear. New York Times, 3 February 2011.
• [52] Shapiro, J., Fair, C. C. Understanding Support for Islamist Militancy in Pakistan. International Security 34, 3, 2010. http://dx.doi.org/10.1162/isec.2010.34.3.79[Crossref]
• [53] Sheriden, G. There’s a Scimitar Behind the Smile. The Australian, 10 February 2011.
• [54] Stewart, S. Mohammed Cartoon Dust Hasn’t Yet Settled. Stratfor.com, 6 January 2011, at http://www.stratfor.com/179261.
• [55] Stratfor (2011a). Egypt and the Muslim Brotherhood: A Special Report. Stratfor.com, 5 February 2011, at http://www.stratfor.com/analysis/20110201-egypt-and-muslim-brotherhood.
• [56] Stratfor (2011b). Intelligence Guidance: The Situation in Egypt., Stratfor.com, 27 January 2011, at http://www.stratfor.com/analysis/20110126-intelligence-guidance-situation-egypt.
• [57] Stratfor (2011c). The Egyptian Military’s Next Steps and the Islamist Threat., Stratfor.com, 11 February 2011, at http://www.stratfor.com/analysis/20110211-egyptian-militarys-next-steps-andislamist-threat.
• [58] The Times (Editor). The Hamas Charter: Extracts. The Times, 27 January 2006.
• [59] Walters, G. Jon Snow is Right-Poppy Fascism is Getting Out of Hand. The Telegraph, 3 November 2010.
• [60] Washington Times (Editor). Islamofascism by any other name. Washington Times, 1 September 2006.
• [61] Welsh, D. Salmaan Taseer Murder Throws Pakistan into Fresh Crisis. The Guardian, 4 January 2011.
• [62] White, J. Islamist Mobilisation in Turkey: A Study in Vernacular Politics. Seattle: University of Washington Press, 2002.
• [63] Zakaria, F. Islam, Democracy and Constitutional Liberalism. Political Science Quarterly 119, 1, 2004. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/20202302[Crossref]

Identifiers

DOI

10.2478/s13374-011-0002-z