The Lithuanian Referendum on Extending the Working of the Ignalina Nuclear Power Station: The Rationality of Actors within (Un-)Changing Structures

• Authors: Liudas Mažylis , Aušrinė Jurgelionytė
• Languages of publication: EN

Abstracts

EN

This article explores the structural factors and the arguments of the political actors in the Lithuanian referendum of 2008 on extending the working of the Ignalina Nuclear Power Station. By applying a new institutionalism theoretical perspective, this article studies campaign development, its structural framework and the actors' arguments. The presupposition has been confirmed that the value normative environment of the referendum was long-term and sustained, without any "paradigmatic shifts" during the referendum debates themselves. With that said, the equilibrium of competing normative attitudes was shifted towards agreeing with an extension of the work as a "minor evil". Within this structural environment, a range of "second order" features was typical for the referendum campaign model, additionally reinforced by another parallel (chronologically coinciding) campaign, that of the elections to the Seimas. Minor shifts in the otherwise overwhelming YES vote could be evoked by formal mechanical nuances, if nothing else. The diverse positions of the political actors involved in the campaign - whether active, critical, reluctant, or floating ones - were supposed to shift their opinion(s) within a stable structural value normative environment, not seeking any reconsideration. This model of referendum campaign development is typical for the Lithuanian direct democracy tradition. Frequently, a referendum serves as a supplementary formal institutional instrument allowing an expansion of the field of political debates and/or the possibility for political actors to place themselves within a stable value normative structure where they may strive for additional mobilization of behalf of their electorate.

Keywords

EN

Referendum; Lithuania; Ignalina nuclear power station; institutions; campaign; political actors

• Publisher: Sciendo
• Journal: Baltic Journal of Law & Politics
• Year: 2012
• Volume: 5
• Issue: 1
• Pages: 117-136

Dates

published

2012-01-01

online

2012-08-30

Contributors

author

Liudas Mažylis

• Faculty of Political Sciences and Diplomacy, Vytautas Magnus University, Lithuania

author

Aušrinė Jurgelionytė

• Faculty of Political Sciences and Diplomacy, Vytautas Magnus University, Lithuania

References

• Buch, Roger, and Kasper M. Hansen. "The Danes and Europe: From EC 1972 to Euro 2000 - Elections, Referendums and Attitudes." Scandinavian Political Studies Vol. 25, No. 1 (2002): 1-24.
• Closa, Carlos. "Why convene referendums? Explaining choices in EU constitutional politics." Journal of European Public Policy No. 14:8 (December 2007): 1311-1332.
• Ehin, Piret. "Determinants of Public Support for EU Membership: Data from Baltic Countries." European Journal of Political Research Vol. 40, No. 1 (2001): 31-56.
• FitzGibbon, John. "Ireland's No to Lisbon: Learning the Lessons from the failure of the Yes and the Success of the No Side." EPERN Working Paper No. 21 (2009): 1-27.
• Franklin, N. Mark. "Learning from the Danish case: A comment on Palle Svensson's critique of the Franklin thesis." European Journal of Political Research No. 41 (2002): 751-757.
• Gaidys, Vladas, and Leonardas Rinkevičius. "Černobylio baimė, pigios energijos nauda ar kai kas daugiau? Dvidešimties metų visuomenės nuomonės apie Ignalinos AE sociologiniai tyrimai Lietuvoje." Filosofija. Sociologija T. 19, Nr. 4 (2008): 102-111.
• Hobolt, Sara Binzer. "Direct Democracy and European Integration." Journal of European Public Policy 13:1 (January 2006): 153-166.[Crossref]
• Law on Referendum of the Republic of Lithuania //
• Makaraitytė, Indrė. "Ignalinos AE neverta nemokamo alaus." Atgimimas.lt // http://www.atgimimas.lt/Aktualijos/2008-metai-spalio/Ignalinos-AE-nevertanemokamo-alaus (accessed April 28, 2012).
• Mažylis, Liudas. Kodėl netiko Europai Konstitucija Europai (Kaunas: Vytauto Didžiojo universitetas, 2005).
• Mažylis, Liudas. "Lietuvos referendumas dėl narystės Europos Sąjungoje." Politologija Nr. 2 (34) (2004): 3-39.
• Mažylis, Liudas, and Ingrida Unikaitė. "Europe and Election of the Parliament of the Republic of Lithuania." EPERN Election Briefing No. 47 (October 2008) // www.sussex.ac.uk/sei/documents/epern-election-briefing-no-47.pdf (accessed April 26, 2012).
• Mažylis, Liudas, and Ingrida Unikaitė. Euro-Referenda: Lithuania's Case. The Central Europe beyond Double Enlargement (Vilnius: Vilnius University Press, 2004).
• Miller, Vaughne. "The Treaty of Lisbon after the Second Irish Referendum." Research Paper 09/75 (October 8, 2009): 1-45.
• Morel, Laurence. "The Rise of ‘Politically Obligatory’ Referendums: The 2005 French Referendum in Comparative Perspective." West European Politics Vol. 30, No. 5 (November 2007): 1041-1067.
• Opperman, Kai. "The Politics of Pledging EU Referendums. A Typology of Reasons for Governments to Commit to Referendums on European Integration." Paper prepared for presentation at the 6th ECPR General Conference (25-27 August 2011): 1-21.
• "Referendumą inicijavusiems Seimo nariams-daugiau laiko TV ekranuose." Delfi.lt //
• Reif, Karlheinz, and Hermann Schmitt. "Nine Second-Order National Elections. A Conceptual Framework for the Analysis of European Election Results." European Journal of Political Research No. 8 (1980): 3-44.
• Taggart, Paul. "Questions of Europe - The Domestic Politics of the 2005 French and Dutch Referendums and their Challenge for the Study of European Integration." Journal of Common Market Studies Vol. 44, Issue Supplement s1 (September 2006): 7-25.
• The Central Electoral Commission of the Republic of Lithuania. "Central Election Commission Report" //
• The Central Electoral Commission of the Republic of Lithuania. "Election to the Seimas and the Referendum on prolonging the work of the Ignalina Nuclear Power Plant of 12th October 2008, Results of Referendum" //
• The Central Electoral Commission of the Republic of Lithuania. "Election to the Seimas and the Referendum on prolonging the work of the Ignalina Nuclear Power Plant of 12th October 2008. Voting results of 12th October 2008" //
• The Central Electoral Commission of the Republic of Lithuania. "Referenda initiatives. Declare the referendum had not obtained the required number of signatures" //
• Thelen, Kathleen. "Historical Institutionalism and Comparative Politics." Annual Reviews Political Science No. 2 (1999): 369-404.
• The Treaty of Accession 2003, Protocol No. 4 on the Ignalina nuclear power plant in Lithuania //
• Vaičiūnas, Žygimantas. "Europos Sąjungos bendros energetikos politikos formavimasis ir Lietuvos interesai." Politologija Nr. 55 (2009): 89-120.
• Žilys, Juozas. "Konstituciniai politinės sistemos pagrindai": 53-82. In: Algis Krupavičius and Alvidas Lukošaitis. Lietuvos politinė sistema. Sąranga ir raida. Poligrafija ir informatika, 2004.

Identifiers

DOI

10.2478/v10076-012-0006-y