Policyholder Obligations After an Insured Event: Are Baltic Insurance Laws Too Insurer-Friendly Compared to the Principles of European Insurance Contract Law?

• Authors: Olavi-Jüri Luik
• Languages of publication: EN

Abstracts

EN

This article explores the differences between the Estonian Law of Obligations Act, the Latvian Insurance Contract Law and Lithuanian rules contained in the Civil Code and Insurance Law in comparison with the Principles of European Insurance Contract Law with regards to the policyholder's obligations after insured event. The three key obligations after insured event, i.e., (i) the obligation to reduce damage, (ii) the obligation to report an insured event, and (iii) the obligation to cooperate, play a major role in the performance obligation of the insurer. It is precisely the proper performance of those obligations that determines how quickly the policyholder receives insurance indemnity, should there be an insured event. Breach of those obligations may in certain cases result in a refusal to pay insurance indemnity. Compared with national laws of the Baltic States, the relevant regulation provided in the PEICL is more favourable and consumer-friendly for policyholders.

Keywords

EN

Insurance contract; Principles of European Insurance Contract Law; loss mitigation; notice of insured event; claims cooperation

• Publisher: Sciendo
• Journal: Baltic Journal of Law & Politics
• Year: 2012
• Volume: 5
• Issue: 1
• Pages: 137-164

Dates

published

2012-01-01

online

2012-08-30

Contributors

author

Olavi-Jüri Luik

• Faculty of Law, University of Tartu (Estonia) Attorney at law in Law Firm LEXTAL, Estonia

References

• Basedow, Jürgen, John Birds, Malcolm Clark, Herman Cousy, and Helmut Heiss. Principles of European Insurance Contract Law (PEICL). Munich: European Law Publishers GmbH, 2009.
• Ben-Shahar, Omri, and Kyle D. Logue. "Outsourcing Regulation: How Insurance Reduces Moral Hazard." Program in law and economics working paper series No. 12-004 (April 2012) //
• Borselli, Angelo. "Unfair Terms in Insurance Contracts." Insurance Law Review No. 2 (2011).
• Clarke, Malcolm. Policies and Perceptions of Insurance Law in the Twenty-First Century. Oxford University Press, 2005.
• Cohen, Lloyd R., and Michelle E. Boardman. "Methodology: applying economics to insurance law-an introduction": 19-32. In: Julian Burling and Kevin Lazarus. Research Handbook on International Insurance Law and Regulation. Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd., 2011.
• Doract, Walter. "The Optional European Contract Law and why success or failure may depend on scope rather than substance." Max Planck Private Law Research Paper No. 11/9. (June 25, 2011) //
• Heiss, Helmut, Malcolm Clarke, and Mandeep Lakhnan. "Europe: Toward a harmonised European insurance contract law-the PEICL": 603-621. In: Julian Burling and Kevin Lazarus. Research Handbook on International Insurance Law and Regulation. Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd., 2011.
• Hoppu, Esko, and Mika Hemmo. Vakuutusoikeus (Insurance Law). Porvoo: WS Bookwell OY, 2006 [in Finnish].
• Lahe, Janno. Kindlustusõigus (Insurance law). Tallinn: Juura, 2007 [in Estonian].
• Lehtipuro, Katriina, Irene Luukkonen, and Lea Mäntyniemi. Vakuutuslainsäädänto (Insurance Legislation). Sastamala: Finanssi- ja Vakuutuskustannus OY, 2010 [in Finnish].
• Low, Gary. "Will firms consider a European optional instrument in contract law?" European Journal of Law and Economics Vol. 33, No. 3 (2012): 521-540 // DOI: 10.1007/s10657-011-9276-1.[Crossref][WoS]
• Norio-Timonen, Jaana. Vakuutussopimuslain pääkohdat (The Main Points of Insurance Contract Act). Helsinki: Talentum, 2010 [in Finnish].
• Rantala, Jukka, and Teivo Pentikäinen. Vakuutusoppi (Insurance Doctrine). Sastamala: Finanssi- ja Vakuutuskustannus OY, 2009 [in Finnish].
• Rühl, Giesela. "Information Obligations (Insurance Contracts)". In: Jürgen Basedow, Klaus Hopt, and Reinhard Zimmermann, eds. Encyclopaedia of European Private Law. Oxford University Press, 2012 // http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1989536 (accessed July 2, 2012).
• Varul, Paul, Irene Kull, Villu Kõve, and Martin Käerdi. Võlaõigusseadus II. Kommenteeritud väljaanne (Law of Obligations Act II. Executive edition). Tallinn: Juura, 2007 [in Estonian].
• BTA SE General Insurance Terms and Conditions. No. 3. //
• BTA SE Home Insurance conditions. No. 3F-2 //
• Draft Common Frame of Reference. Chapter III, Section IX: Insurance Contract. Project Group "Restatement of European Insurance Contract Law" (August 2009) //
• European Parliament Resolution of 8 June 2011 on Policy Options for Progress towards a European Contract Law for Consumers and Businesses. 2011/2013(INI) //
• Finnish Insurance Contract Act. No. 28.6.1994/543 //
• General Insurance Conditions of the If P&C Insurance AS //
• Irina Malantšuk v. Seesam Rahvusvaheline Kindlustuse AS. Tallinn Circuit Court, 2009, no. 2-08-3737 [in Estonian] //
• Jaanus Sarv v. Salva Kindlustuse AS. Supreme Court of the Republic of Estonia, 2001, no. 3-2-1-56-01 [in Estonian] //
• Law of Obligations Act (Estonia). State Gazette (Riigi Teataja), part 1, July 18, 2011, no. 21.
• Law on Insurance (Lithuania). Official Gazette (Valstybės žinios), 2003, no. 94-4246.
• Lietuvos Draudimas Home Insurance Policy Wording. No. 064 //
• Liis Kommesaare v. QBE Kindlustuse Eesti AS. Tallinn Circuit Court, 2008, no. 2-06-6604 [in Estonian] //
• Margus Saks v. AS If Eesti Kindlustus. Supreme Court of the Republic of Estonia, 2007, no 3-2-1-106-07 [in Estonian] //
• OÜ Autorent ja Kinnisvara Q v. ERGO Kindlustuse AS. Supreme Court of the Republic of Estonia, 2001, no. 3-2-1-88-04 [in Estonian] //
• OÜ Sepmar v. BTA apdrošinašanas akciju sabiedriba. Tartu Circuit Court, 2011, no 2-10-14648 [in Estonian] //
• OÜ Valboreks v. ERGO Kindlustuse AS. Tallinn Circuit Court, 2007, no 2-04-111 [in Estonian] //
• Principles of Claim Handling Established by the Finnish Association of Insurance Companies [in Finnish] //
• Seesam Insurance AS Motor Vehicle Insurance Conditions. 1/2012 //
• Sergei Vasenkin v. Seesam Rahvusvahelise Kindlustuse AS. Tallinn Circuit Court, 2009, no. 2-07-43148 [in Estonian] //
• The Civil Code of the Republic of Lithuania. Official Gazette (Valstybės žinios), 2000, no. 74-2262.
• The Insurance Contract Law (Latvia). Latvian Herald (Latvijas Vestnesis), no. 188/189, June 30, 1998; no. 15.
• UAB Arijus v. If P&C Insurance AS. Supreme Court of the Republic of Lithuania, 2010, no 3K-3-210/2010 [in Lithuanian] //

Identifiers

DOI

10.2478/v10076-012-0007-x