The Limits of Leadership

• Authors: Iwona Sobis , Frits van den Berg , Michiel S. de Vries
• Languages of publication: EN

Abstracts

EN

In Public Administration, it is taken for granted that reforms are initiated and conducted by leaders. However, one can wonder whether change is indeed always coming from leadership and whether the concept thereof as the driving force behind change and the panacea for all the problems encountered during reforms is not a bit overrated in recent literature. This paper presents the argument that it is not the leaders but the employees in the teams and working groups and the experienced organizational members in particular who are the real carriers of reforms. It goes through the recent and older theoretical literature as well as through known empirical research regarding the matter and suggests that mainly co-workers are able to provide reform in terms of content, direction and practical solutions. The conclusion is that leadership is indeed an overrated factor in explaining reforms. The emphasis on leadership disregards an old-fashioned but perhaps still relevant concept, namely that working groups / project teams are oft en self-regulating, despite what leaders believe. Although empirical research taking organizational tenure into account is scarce and scattered, there is some evidence that the communities of practice are important for conserving, changing and developing organizational values and norms. In consequence, theorizing about reforms and especially the implementation thereof needs to pay more attention to horizontal relations in the organization - the role of colleagues and especially the role of experienced organizational members.

Keywords

EN

leadership; employee engagement; administrative reform

• Publisher: Sciendo
• Journal: NISPAcee Journal of Public Administration and Policy
• Year: 2012
• Volume: 5
• Issue: 1
• Pages: 131-154

Dates

published

2012-07-01

online

2013-05-16

Contributors

author

Iwona Sobis

• Associate Professor, University of Gothenburg, Sweden

author

Frits van den Berg

• Dr., consultant , Patom, Netherlands

author

Michiel S. de Vries

• Professor, Radboud University Nijmegen, Netherlands

References

• Almqvist, R. 2006. New Public Management: Om konkurrensutsättning, kontrakt ochkontroll. Malmö: Liber.
• Amis, J., T. Slack and C. R. Hinings. 2004. “The Pace, Sequence, and Linearity of Radical Change.” The Academy of Management Journal 47 (1), 15-39.
• Ashkanasy, N. M. and C. Gallois. 1994. “Leader Attributions and Evaluations: Effects of Locus of Control, Supervisory Control, and Task Control.” OrganisationalBehaviour and Human Decision Processes 59, 27-50.
• Bantel, K. A. and S. E. Jackson. 1989. “Top Management and Innovations in Banking: Does the Composition of the Top Team Make a Difference ?” StrategicManagement Journal Special Issue: Strategic Leaders and Leadership 10 (S1), 107-124.
• Becker, H. and H. E. Barnes. 1961 [1938]. Social Thought from Lore to Science. New York: Dover.
• Bell, B. S. and S. W. J. Kozlowski. 2002. “A Typology of Virtual Teams, Implications for Effective Leadership.” Group Organization Management 27 (1), 14-49.
• Bovey, W. and A. Hede. 2001. “Resistance to Organisational Change: The Role of Cognitive and Affective Processes.” Leadership & Organizational DevelopmentJournal 22 (1), 372-382.
• Burke, W. W. and G. H. Litwin. 1992. “A Causal Model of Organizational Performance and Change: A Causal Model of Organizational Performance and Change.” Journal of Management 18 (3), 523-545.
• Caiden, G. E. 1991. “What Really is Public Maladministration ?” International Journalof Public Administration 37 (1), 1-16.
• Caiden, G. E. 2007 [1969]. Administrative Reform. Chicago: Aldine.
• Carr, D. E. and P. E. Eagles. n.d. The Commitment Gap: Lessons Learned about EmployeeCommitment in the Parks Canada Agency. Available at van uwaterloo. ca (last accessed 5 June 2012).
• Cohen, S. G. 1991. Teams and Teams Work: Future Directions. Los Angeles, Ca: Center for Effective Organizations, University of Southern California.
• Cronin, M. A. and L. R. Weingart. 2007. “Representational Gaps, Information Processing, and Conflict in Functionally Diverse Teams.” Academy of ManagementReview 32 (3), 761-773.
• Czarniawska, B. and G. Sevón (eds). 1996. Translating Organizational Change. New York: Walter de Gruyter.
• Dasborough, M. T. and N. M. Ashkanasy. 2002. “Emotion and Attribution of Intentionality in Leader-Member Relationships.” The Leadership Quarterly 13, 615-634.[Crossref]
• Dionne S. D., F. J. Yammarino, L. E. Atwater and L. R. James. 2002. “Neutralizing Substitutes for Leadership Theory.” Journal of Applied Psychology 87 (3), 454-464.[Crossref]
• Douglas, C. E. 1997. Formal Mentoring Programs in Organizations: An AnnotatedBibliography. Greensboro, North Carolina: Center for Creative Leadership.
• Edmondson, A. C., M. Roberto and M. Watkins. 2003. “A Dynamic Model of Top Management Team Effectiveness: Managing Unstructured Task Streams.” The Leadership Quarterly 14, 297-325.[Crossref]
• Eisenbach, R. K. and R. P. Watson. 1999. “Transformational Leadership in the Context of Organizational Change.” Journal of Organizational Change Management 12 (2), 80-89.[Crossref]
• Fiedler, F. E. 1964. “A Contingency Model of Leadership Effectiveness.” In L.
• Berkowitz (ed.). Advances in Experimental Social Psychology 1, 149-190.
• Finn, R., G. Currie and G. Martin. 2010. “Team Work in Context: Institutional Mediation in the Public Service Professional Bureaucracy.” Organization Studies 3 (08), 1069-1097.[Crossref]
• Golembiewski, R. T. 1985. Humanizing Public Organizations. New York: Lomond.
• Hallin, B. and S. Siverbo. 2010. Styrning och organisering inom hälso- och sjukvård. Lund: Studentlitteratur.
• Hällstén, F. and S. Tengblad. 2006. Medarbetarskap i praktiken. Lund: Studentlitteratur.
• Hersey, P. and H. K. Blanchard. 1996. “Great Ideas Revisited: Revisiting the Life- Cycle Theory of Leadership.” Training & Development Journal 50, 42-48.
• Hersey, P. and H. K. Blanchard. 1979. “Life Cycle Theory of Leadership.” Trainingand Development Journal 33, 94-106.
• Higgins, J. 2007. “Institutional Culture as Keyword.” Triennial Review 3, 150-186.
• Hobbes, T. 2009 [1651]. The Leviathan. Oxford: Oxford UP.
• Hogg, M. A., S. C. Hains and I. Mason. 1998. “Identification and Leadership in Small Groups: Salience, Frame of Reference, and Leader Stereotypicality Effects on Leader Evaluations.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 75 (5), 1248-1263.[Crossref]
• Holt, D. T., A. A. Armenakis, H. S. Field and S. G. Harris. 2007. “Readiness for Organizational Change: The Systematic Development of a Scale.” Journal ofApplied Behavioral Science 43 (2), 232-255. Hood, C. 1995. “The New Public Management in the 1980s: Variations on a Theme.” Accounting, Organization and Society 20 (2-3), 93-109.
• Jackson, B. 2005. “The Enduring Romance of Leadership Studies.” Journal of ManagementStudies 42 (6), 1311-1324.
• Jacobsen, D. I. and J. Thørsvik. 2008. Hur moderna organisationer fungerar. Lund: Studentlitteratur.
• Kerr, S. and J. M. Jermier. 1978. “Substitutes for Leadership: Their Meaning and Measurement.” Organizational Behavior and Human Performance 22, 375-403.[Crossref]
• Kieffer, C. H. 1984. “Citizen Empowerment: A Developmental Perspective.” Preventionin Human Services 3 (2), 9-36. Available at http://pdfserve.informaworld.com/879919_731377804_904473187.pdf (last accessed 16 February 2011).
• Leisink, P. 2003. Reform of Public Bus Transport and Staff Participation and Involvement:Public Law and the Modernizing State. European Group of Public Administration Annual Conference Oeiras, Portugal, 3-6 September 2003. Available at http://soc.kuleuven.be/io/egpa/HRM/lisbon/leisink.pdf (last accessed 18 February 2011).
• Lindgren, L. 2008. Utverderingsmonster: Kvalitets- och resultatmätning i den offentligasektorn. Lund: Studentlitteratur.
• Lindvall, J. 2010. Verksamhetsstyrning: Från traditionell ekonomistyrning till modernverksamhetsstyrning. Lund: Studentlitteratur.
• Lord, R. G. and K. J. Maher. 1991. Leadership and Information Processing: LinkingPerceptions and Performance. Boston: Unwin-Hyman.
• Machiavelli, N. 1984 [1513]. The Prince. London, Random House, Bantam books.
• Mintzberg, H. 1992. “Cycles of Organizational Change.” Strategic Management Journal 13, 39-59.
• Mintzberg, H. 1973. The Nature of Managerial Work. New York: Harper & Row.
• Montana, P. J. and B. H. Charnov. 2008. Management: Leadership and Theory.
• Hauppauge, New York: Barron’s Educational Series.
• Müller, R. and J. R. Turner. 2007. “Matching the Project Manager’s Leadership Style to Project Type.” International Journal of Project Management 25 (1), 21-32.[Crossref]
• Nemec, J. 2010. “New Public Management and its Implementation in CEE: What Do we Know and where Do we Go ?” NISPAcee Journal of Public Administrationand Policy 3 (1), 33-54.
• Nonaka, I. and G. von Krogh. 2006. “Organizational Knowledge Creation Theory: Evolutionary Path and Future Adavance.” Organization Studies 27, 1179-1208. Northouse, P. G. 2004. Leadership: Theory and Practice. Thousand Oaks, London and New Delhi: Sage.[Crossref]
• Ong Heat-Tatt. 1994. Secrets of Ancient Chinese: Art of Motivation. Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia: Pelanduk Publications.
• Orsburn, J. D., L. Moran, E. Musselwhite and J. H. Zenger. 1990. Self-Directed WorkTeams: The New American Challenge. Homewood, IL: Irwin.
• Page, E. C. 2007. “Middle Level Bureaucrats: Policy, Discretion and Control.” In Jos Raadschelders et al. (eds). The Civil Service in the 21st Century. Houndmills: Basingstoke Palgrave, 152-168.
• Page, E. C. 1985. Political Authority and Bureaucratic Power. Knoxville: University of Tennessee Press.
• Peters, B. G. and D. J. Savoie. 1998. Taking Stock: Assessing Public Sector Reforms Quebec: Canadian Centre for Management Development.
• Pollitt, C. 1993. Managerialism and the Public Services. Oxford: Blackwell.
• Quinn, R. E. 1996. Deep Change: Discovering the Leader Within. San Fransisco: Jossey-Bass Publishers.
• Raadschelders, J. C.N. 2003. Government: A Public Administration Perspective. New York: M. E. Sharpe.
• Rainey, H. G. 2009 [1992]. Understanding and Managing Public Organizations. 4th edn. San Francisco: Wiley / Jossey-Bass.
• Reichard, C. 1997. “Neues Steuerungsmodell: Local Reform in Germany.” In Walter J. M. Kickert (ed.). Public Management and Administrative Reform in WesternEurope. Cheltenham and Lyme: Elgar.
• Reichart, C. 2001. New Approaches to Public Management. in: K. König, H. Siedentopf, Public Administration in Germany. Baden-Baden 2001, 541-556.
• Rubinstein, M. and F. Van den Berg. 1992. “Stagnerende veranderingsprocessen.” M&O jaaring 46, 188-204.
• Sabel, C. F. 1995. Design, Deliberation, and Democracy: On the New Pragmatism ofFirms and Public Institutions, Paper presented to the conference on Liberal Institutions, Economic Constitutional Rights, and the Role of Organizations. European University Institute, Florence.
• Schein, E. H. 1985. Organizational Culture and Leadership: A Dynamic View. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
• Sevón, G. 1996. “Organizational Imitation in Identity Transformation.” In B. Czarniawska and G. Sevón (eds). Translating Organizational Change. New York: Walter de Gruyter, 49-68. Sobis, I. and M. S. De Vries. 2010. The Story behind Western Advice to Central Europeduring its Transition Period. Bratislava: NISPAcee Press.
• Sousa, F. H. and J. Vala. 2002. “Relational Justice in Organizations: The Group-Value Model and Support for Change.” Social Justice Research 15 (2), 99-121.[Crossref]
• Stogdill, R. M. 1948. “Personal Factors Associated with Leadership: A Survey of the Literature.” Journal of Personality 25, 35-71.
• Stogdill, R. M. and A. E. Coons. 1957. Leader Behavior: Its Description and Measurement.
• Columbus, OH: Bureau of Business Research, Ohio State University.
• Taylor, F. W. 1998 [1911]. The Principles of Scientific Management. New edn. New York: Dover.
• Tengblad, S., F. Hällstén, C. Ackerman and J. Velten. 2010. Medarbetarskap: Frånord till handling. Malmö: Liber AB.
• Tengblad, S. 2010. Medarbetarskap på 60 minuter. Högskolan i Skövde. Available at http://stressmedicin.com/upload/Regionkanslierna/ISM%20Institutet%20f%C3%B6r%20stressmedicin/Publikationer/%C3%96vrigt/Tengblad%202010,%20Medarbetarskap%20p%C3%A5%2060%20minuter.pdf (last accessed 16 February 2011).
• Terry, L. D. 2002. Leadership of Public Bureaucracies: The Administrator as Conservator. New York: M. E. Sharpe.
• Tyler, T. R. and D. De Cremer. 2005. “Process-Based Leadership: Fair Procedures and Reactions to Organizational Change.” The Leadership Quarterly 16 (4), 529-545.[Crossref]
• Wenger, E. 1998. Communities of Practice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
• WikiLeaks. 2010. WikiLeaks: Global Defense of Sources and Press Freedoms, circa now. Available at http://mirror.wikileaks.info (last accessed 9 December 2010.
• Xu Huang, Kan Shi, Zhijie Zhang and Yat LeeCheung. 2006. “The Impact of Participative Leadership Behavior on Psychological Empowerment and Organizational Commitment in Chinese State-Owned Enterprises: The Moderating Role of Organizational Tenure.” Asia Pacific Journal of Management 23 (3). 345-367.[Crossref]
• Yukl, G. 2010 [1994]. Leadership in Organization. 7thedn. Englewood Cliffs: Pearson Prentice Hall.

Identifiers

DOI

10.2478/v10110-012-0004-1