Why Is Plato’s Good Good?

• Authors: Aidan R. Nathan

Abstracts

EN

The form of the Good in Plato’s Phaedo and Republic seems, by our standards, to do too much: it is presented as the metaphysical principle, the epistemological principle and the principle of ethics. Yet this seemingly chimerical object makes good sense in the broader context of Plato’s philosophical project. He sought certain knowledge of necessary truths (in sharp contrast to the contingent truth of modern science). Thus, to be knowable the cosmos must be informed by timeless principles; and this leads to teleology and the Good. The form of the Good, it is argued, is what makes the world knowable insofar as it is knowable. This interpretation plugs a significant gap in the scholarship on the Good and draws attention to a deep connection between Plato’s epistemology and his teleological understanding of the cosmos.

Keywords

EN

Form of the Good; teleology; Plato’s epistemology; necessity

• Publisher: Uniwersytet im. Adama Mickiewicza w Poznaniu
• Journal: Peitho. Examina Antiqua
• Year: 2022
• Volume: 13
• Issue: 1
• Pages: 125-136

Dates

published

2022

Contributors

author

Aidan R. Nathan

• The University of Sydney, Australia

• https://orcid.org/0000000330667626

References

• Allen, R. E., 1970, Plato’s Euthyphro and the Earlier Theory of Forms, London.
• Annas, J., 1982, “Aristotle on Inefficient Causes”, Philosophical Quarterly 32, pp. 311–26.
• Annas, J., 1993, The Morality of Happiness, Oxford.
• Bailey, D. T. J., 2014, “Platonic Causes Revisited”, Journal of the History of Philosophy 52, pp. 15–32.
• Benitez, E. E., 1995, “The Good or The Demiurge: Causation and the Unity of Good in Plato”, Apeiron 28, pp. 113–40.
• Burnyeat, M. F., 1981, “Aristotle on Understanding Knowledge”, in: E. Berti (ed.), Aristotle on Science in the Posterior Analytics, Padua, pp. 79–139.
• Cairns, D., Herrmann, F.-G., Penner, T. (eds.), 2007, Pursuing the Good: Ethics and Metaphysics in Plato’s Republic, Edinburgh.
• Cobb, W. S., 1977, “Plato’s Treatment of Immortality in the Phaedo”, Southern Journal of Philosophy 15, pp. 173–188.
• Evans, D., 2000, “‘Beyond Reality’: Plato’s Good Revisited”, Royal Institute of Philosophy 47, pp. 105–18.
• Foster, M. B., 1934, “The Christian Doctrine of Creation and the Rise of Modern Natural Science”, Mind Association 43, pp. 446–68.
• Frede, D., 1992, “Accidental Causes in Aristotle”, Synthese 92, pp. 39–62.
• Frede, M., 1987, “The Original Notion of Cause”, in: M. Frede, Essays in Ancient Philosophy, Minneapolis, pp. 125–50.
• Freeland, C. A., 1991, “Accidental Causes and Real Explanations”, in: L. Judson (ed.), Aristotle’s Physics: A Collection of Essays, Oxford, pp. 49–72.
• Grene, M., 1963, A Portrait of Aristotle, Chicago.
• Hahm, D. E., 1977, The Origins of Stoic Cosmology, Columbus.
• Hankinson, R. J., 1989, “Galen and the Best of All Possible Worlds”, Classical Quarterly 39, pp. 206–27.
• Hooykaas, R., 2000, Religion and the Rise of Modern Science. Vancouver.
• Keyt, D., 1969, “Plato’s Paradox that the Immutable is Unknowable”, Philosophical Quarterly 19, pp. 1–14.
• Long, A. A., 1986, Hellenistic Philosophy: Stoics, Epicureans, Sceptics, Second Edition, Berkeley–Los Angles.
• Moss, J., 2019, “Is Plato’s Epistemology about Knowledge?”, in: S. Hetherington, N. D. Smith (eds.), What the Ancients Offer to Contemporary Epistemology, New York, pp. 68–85.
• Penner, T., 2007, “What is the Form of the Good the Form of? A Question About the Plot of the Republic”, in: Cairns, Herrmann, Penner (2007), pp. 15–41.
• Reeve, C. D. C., 2000, Substantial Knowledge: Aristotle’s Metaphysics, Indianapolis.
• Rowe, C., “The Form of the Good and the Good in Plato’s Republic”, in: Cairns, Herrmann, Penner (2007), pp. 124–53.
• Santas, G., 1983, “The Form of the Good in Plato’s Republic”, in: J. P. Anton, A. Preus (eds.), Essays in Ancient Greek Philosophy, Vol. 2, Albany, pp. 232–63.
• Sedley, D., 1998, “Platonic Causes”, Phronesis 43, pp. 114–32.
• Seel, G., 2007, “Is Plato’s Conception of the Form of the Good Contradictory?”, in: Cairns, Herrmann, Penner (2007), pp. 168–96.
• Sharma, R., 2009, “Socrates’ New Aitia: Causal and Metaphysical Explanations in Plato’s Phaedo”, Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy 39, pp. 137–77.
• Wolfsdorf, D., 2005, “Euthyphro 10A2–11B1: A Study in Platonic Metaphysics and its Reception Since 1960”, Apeiron 38, pp. 1–71.

Identifiers

DOI

10.14746/PEA.2022.1.6

Biblioteka Nauki

28408719