Wittgenstein i argumentacja krytyczna

• Authors: Richard Shusterman

Title variants

EN

Wittgenstein and Critical Reasoning

• Languages of publication: PL

Abstracts

EN

In his paper Wittgenstein and Critical Reasoning, Richard Shusterman analyses the influence which Wittgensteinian aesthetics has had on contemporary criticism. Concentrating primarily on the second phase of Wittgenstein’s philosophy, Shusterman first demonstrates how the idea of language games and related concepts undermined both essentialist deductive and quasi-scientific inductive models of criticism. In place of these two approaches, Shusterman argues, Wittgensteinian aesthetics offers a new one, which he describes as perceptual-persuasive. In the next step, however, Shusterman observes that Wittgenstein’s followers often commit the very fallacy that Wittgenstein wanted to avoid, by imposing the perceptual persuasive model as the only valid solution for criticism. However, in order to be more in line with Wittgensteinian aesthetics, he argues, we should rather recognise the plurality of possibilities – perceptual-persuasive, deductive or inductive – whose choice depends on the language game currently played.

Keywords

PL

krytyka; argumentacja; dedukcja; indukcja; percepcja; perswazja

EN

criticism; argumentation; deduction; induction; perception; persuasion; criticism; argumentation; deduction; induction; perception; persuasion

• Publisher: Uniwersytet im. Adama Mickiewicza w Poznaniu
• Journal: Przestrzenie Teorii
• Year: 2016
• Issue: 25
• Pages: 323-345

Dates

published

2016-06-15

Contributors

author

Richard Shusterman

Identifiers

DOI

10.14746/pt.2016.25.16