Empathy: A Double Edged Sword

• Authors: Violet Cheung-Blundena , Man Yoke Moke , Pranita Ramanan

Abstracts

EN

In the domain of interpersonal relations empathy has been widely regarded as a valuable tool for peacebuilding. Past research has shown that if enough empathy is extended to a victim of violence, insight into the victim’s plight tends to give pause to the aggressor and also prompt bystanders to help. While the victim is the sole recipient of empathy in an interpersonal conflict, elevating the concept of empathy from an individual level analysis to a group level analysis encounters further complications. In intergroup conflicts, both parties in the conflict stand to receive empathy. In light of this, one theoretical question is whether both kinds of empathy, those directed to the ingroup members and the outgroup members, have similar utilities in peacebuilding. We reference the literature on intergroup contact and intergroup threats, to scrutinize the role of empathy in intergroup conflicts. We argue that ingroup and outgroup empathy have the opposite effects on group violence – directing empathy to the outgroup results in the denouncement of aggression, whereas directing empathy to the ingroup may lead to a desire to counterattack. Thus, rather than boosting the overall amplitude of empathy, striking the right balance is the key of leveraging empathy towards peace.

Keywords

EN

empathy; ethnocultural empathy; ingroup and outgroup; aggression; war; peace

• Publisher: Wydawnictwo Adam Marszałek
• Journal: Kultura i Edukacja
• Year: 2014
• Issue: 5(105)
• Pages: 193-210

Dates

published

2014

Contributors

author

Violet Cheung-Blundena

• University of San Francisco

author

Man Yoke Moke

• University of San Francisco

author

Pranita Ramanan

• University of San Francisco

References

• Anderson C.A., Shibuya A., Ihori N., Swing E.L., Bushman B.J., Sakamoto A., Saleem M., Violent Video Game Effects on Aggression, Empathy, and Prosocial Behavior in Eastern and Western Countries: A Meta-Analytic Review, “Psychological Bulletin” 2010, No. 136(2).
• Batson C., Early S., Salvarani G., Perspective Taking: Imagining How Another Feels versus Imagining How You Would Feel, “Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin” 1997, 23(7).
• Batson C., Batson J.G., Griffitt C.A., Barrientos S., Brandt J., Sprengelmeyer P., Bayly M.J., Negative-State Relief and the Empathy – Altruism Hypothesis, “Journal of Personality and Social Psychology” 1989, No. 56(6).
• Block J., On Further Conjectures Regarding Acquiescence, “Psychological Bulletin” 1971, No. 76(3).
• Branscombe N.R., Wann D.L., Collective Self-Esteem Consequences of Outgroup Derogation When a Valued Social Identity Is on Trial, “European Journal of Social Psychology” 1994, No. 24(6).
• Cehajic S., Brown R., Castano E., Forgive and Forget? Antecedents and Consequences of Intergroup Forgiveness in Bosnia and Herzegovina, “Political Psychology” 2008, No. 29(3).
• Cheung-Blunden V., Blunden B., Paving the Road to War with Group Membership, Appraisal Antecedents, and Anger, “Aggressive Behavior” 2008, No. 34(2).
• Cheung-Blunden V., Blunden B., The Emotional Construal of War: Anger, Fear, and Other Negative Emotions, “Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology” 2008, No. 14(2).
• Davis M.H., Measuring Individual Differences in Empathy: Evidence for a Multidimensional Approach, “Journal of Personality and Social Psychology” 1983, No. 44(1).
• Davis M.H., Empathy: Negotiating the Border between Self and Other [in:] The Social Life of Emotions, L.Z. Tiedens, C. Leach (eds.), New York 2004.
• Decety J., Dissecting the Neural Mechanisms Mediating Empathy, “Emotion Review” 2011, No. 3(1).
• Decety J., Lamm C., Empathy versus Personal Distress: Recent Evidence from Social Euroscience [in:] The Social Neuroscience of Empathy, J. Decety, W. Ickes (eds.), Cambridge 2009.
• de Waal F.M., Putting the Altruism Back into Altruism: The Evolution of Empathy, “Annual Review of Psychology” 2008.
• Dunn J., Munn P., Siblings and the Development of Prosocial Behavior, “International Journal of Behavioral Development” 1986, No. 9(3).
• Eisenberg N., Eggum N.D., Empathic Responding: Sympathy and Personal Distress [in:] The Social Neuroscience of Empathy, J. Decety, W. Ickes (eds.), Cambridge 2009.
• Eisenberg N., Miller P.A., Shell R., McNalley S., Shea C., Prosocial Development in Adolescence: A Longitudinal Study, “Developmental Psychology” 1991, No. 27(5).
• Eisenberg N., Schaller M., Fabes R.A., Bustamante D., Mathy R.M., Shell R., Rhodes K., Differentiation of Personal Distress and Sympathy in Children and Adults, “Developmental Psychology” 1988, No. 24(6).
• Elliott R., Bohart A.C., Watson J.C., Greenberg L.S., Empathy, “Psychotherapy” 2011, No. 48(1).
• Feshbach N.D., Feshbach S., The Relationship between Empathy and Aggression in Two Age Groups, “Developmental Psychology” 1969, No. 1(2).
• Gladstein G.A., Feldstein J.C., Using Film to Increase Counselor Empathic Experiences, “Counselor Education and Supervision” 1983, No. 2(23).
• Hoffman M.L., Moral Development [in:] Developmental Psychology: An Advanced Textbook, M. Bornstein, M. Lamb (eds.), Hillsdale 1988.
• Knafo A., Israel S., Ebstein R.P., Heritability of Children’s Prosocial Behavior and Differential Susceptibility to Parenting by Variation in the Dopamine Receptor D4 Gene, “Development And Psychopathology” 2011, No. 23(1).
• Lau R.R., Individual and Contextual Influences on Group Identification, “Social Psychology Quarterly” 1989, No. 52(3).
• Levenson R.W., Ruef A.M., Empathy: A Physiological Substrate, “Journal of Personality and Social Psychology” 1992, No. 63(2).
• Malti T., Gasser L., Buchmann M., Aggressive and Prosocial Children’s Emotion Attributions and Moral Reasoning, “Aggressive Behavior” 2009, No. 35(1).
• Marangoni C., Garcia S., Ickes W., Teng G., Empathic Accuracy in a Clinically Relevant Setting, “Journal of Personality and Social Psychology” 1995, No. 68(5).
• Mehrabian A., Epstein N., A Measure of Emotional Empathy, “Journal of Personality” 1972, No. 40(4).
• Milgram N., Geisis M., Katz N., Haskaya L., Correlates of Readiness for Interethnic Relations of Israeli Jews and Arabs, “Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology” 2008, 14(1).
• Miller P.A., Eisenberg N., The Relation of Empathy to Aggressive and Externalizing/Antisocial Behavior, “Psychological Bulletin” 1988, No. 103(3).
• Nelson L.L., Correlations between Inner Peace, Interpersonal Behavior, and Global Attitudes, paper presented at 115th Annual Convention of the American Psychological Association at San Francisco, 2007.
• Noor M., Brown R., Prentice G., Precursors and Mediators of Intergroup Reconciliation in Northern Ireland: A New Model, “British Journal of Social Psychology” 2008, 47(3).
• Pettigrew T.F., Tropp L.R., How Does Intergroup Contact Reduce Prejudice? Meta-Analytic Tests of Three Mediators, “European Journal of Social Psychology” 2008, No. 38(6).
• Riek B.M., Mania E.W., Gaertner S.L., Intergroup Threat and Outgroup Attitudes: A Meta- Analytic Review, “Personality and Social Psychology Review” 2006, No. 10(4).
• Rothschild Z.K., Abdollahi A., Pyszczynski T., Does Peace Have a Prayer? The Effect of Mortality Salience, Compassionate Values, and Religious Fundamentalism on Hostility toward Out-Groups, “Journal of Experimental Social Psychology” 2009, No. 45(4).
• Staub E., Preventing Violence and Terrorism and Promoting Positive Relations between Dutch and Muslim Communities in Amsterdam, “Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology” 2007, No. 13(3).
• Tropp L.R., Wright S.C., Ingroup Identification as the Inclusion of Ingroup in the Self, “Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin” 2001, No. 27(5).
• Vescio T.K., Sechrist G.B., Paolucci M.P., Perspective Taking and Prejudice Reduction: The Mediational Role of Empathy Arousal and Situational Attributions, “European Journal of Social Psychology” 2003, No. 33(4).
• Wang Y., Davidson M., Yakushko O.F., Savoy H., Tan J.A., Bleier J.K., The Scale of Ethnocultural Empathy: Development, Validation, and Reliability, “Journal of Counseling Psychology” 2003, No. 50(2).
• Watson J.C., Greenberg L.S., Empathic Resonance: A Neuroscience Perspective [in:] The Social Neuroscience of Empathy, J. Decety, W. Ickes (eds.), Cambridge 2009.
• White R.K., The Kinds of Empathy Needed in Arms Control Negotiation, “American Journal of Social Psychiatry” 1987, No. 7(3).
• Xu X., Zuo X., Wang X., Han S., Do You Feel My Pain? Racial Group Membership Modulates Empathic Neural Responses, “The Journal of Neuroscience” 2009, No. 29(26).
• Yzerbyt V., Dumont M., Wigboldus D., Gordijn E,. I Fell for Us: The Impact of Categorization and Identification on Emotions and Action Tendencies, “Journal of Social Psychology” 2003, No. 42.
• Zeldin R., Savin-Williams R.C., Small S.A., Dimensions of Prosocial Behavior in Adolescent Male, “The Journal of Social Psychology” 1984, No. 123(2).
• Zeldin R., Small S.A., Savin-Williams R.C., Prosocial Interactions in Two Mixed-Sex Adolescent Groups, “Child Development” 1982, No. 53(6).

Identifiers

DOI

10.15804/kie.2014.05.12

Biblioteka Nauki

2049007