Confronting Institutional Discrimination in a Color-Blind World

• Authors: Eric O. Silva , Christopher J. Gillmann , KeyAnna L. Tate
• Languages of publication: EN

Abstracts

EN

This article builds on the scholarship on color-blind ideology by examining discourse challenging two cases of institutional discrimination (the criminalization of unauthorized immigrants and sports teams’ use of Native American symbolism). Our research questions are first, what general options do anti-racists have for navigating norms of color-blindness in the public sphere? Second, how does context influence how people confront institutional discrimination? Based on an ethnographic content analysis of 165 letters to the editor published in American newspapers, we find that opponents of institutional discrimination have the choice of addressing one of four laminations. In each lamination, authors acknowledge framings of racial discrimination that are unacknowledged in previous ones. In the abstraction lamination, authors do not recognize race and ethnicity. In the pigmentation lamination, authors identify race and ethnicity, but not discrimination. Authors in the discrimination lamination acknowledge the practice is harmful to a particular racial or ethnic group, and the contextualization lamination lends added dimensionality to the discourse. A comparison of the laminations of pro-immigrant and anti-mascot letters demonstrates varying willingness to acknowledge racial discrimination. Namely, the pro-immigrant discourse was more color-blind than anti-mascot criticism. We consider the potential causes of these findings and offer suggestions for future research in the conclusion

Keywords

EN

Color-Blind Racism; Framing; Laminations; Indian Mascots; Immigration

• Publisher: Uniwersytet Łódzki. Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Łódzkiego
• Journal: Qualitative Sociology Review
• Year: 2018
• Volume: 14
• Issue: 1
• Pages: 84-108

Dates

published

2018-03-15

Contributors

author

Eric O. Silva

• Georgia Southern University, U.S.A.

author

Christopher J. Gillmann

author

KeyAnna L. Tate

References

• Altheide, David L. and Christopher J. Schneider. 2013. Qualitative Media Analysis. Los Angeles, CA: Sage.
• Armstrong, Elizabeth A. and Suzanna M. Crage. 2006. “Movements and Memory: The Making of the Stonewall Myth.” American Sociological Review 71(5):724-751.
• Baca, Lawrence R. 2004. “Native Images in Schools and the Racially Hostile Environment.” Journal of Sport and Social Issues 28(1):71-78.
• Benford, Robert D. and David A. Snow. 2000. “Framing Processes and Social Movements: An Overview and Assessment.” Annual Review of Sociology 26:11-39.
• Bloch, Katrina Rebecca. 2014. “‘Anyone Can Be an Illegal’: Color- Blind Ideology and Maintaining Latino/Citizen Borders.” Critical Sociology 40(1):47-65.
• Bonilla-Silva, Eduardo. 2006. Racism without Racists: Color-Blind Racism and Racial Inequality in Contemporary America. New York: Rowman and Littlefield Publishers.
• Bonilla-Silva, Eduardo. 2012. “The Invisible Weight of Whiteness: The Racial Grammar of Everyday Life in Contemporary America.” Ethnic and Racial Studies 35(2):173-194.
• Borer, Michael Ian and Adam Murphree. 2008. “Framing Catholicism: Jack Chick’s Anti-Catholic Cartoons and the Flexible Boundaries of the Culture Wars.” Religion and American Culture: A Journal of Interpretation 18(1):95-112.
• Borer, Michael Ian and Tyler S. Schafer. 2011. “Culture War Confessionals: Conflicting Accounts of Christianity, Violence, and Mixed Martial Arts.” Journal of Media and Religion 10(4):165-184.
• Brown, Hana E. 2013. “Race, Legality, and the Social Policy Consequences of Anti-Immigrant Mobilization.” American Sociological Review 78(2):290-314.
• Cacho, Lisa Marie. 2000. “‘The People of California are Suffering’: The Ideology of White Injury in Discourses of Immigration.” Cultural Values 4(4):389-418.
• Callais, Todd M. 2010. “Controversial Mascots: Authority and Racial Hegemony in the Maintenance of Deviant Symbols.” Sociological Focus 43(1):65-81.
• Charmaz, Kathy. 2014. Constructing Grounded Theory. Los Angeles, CA: Sage.
• Chavez, Leo R. 2008. The Latino Threat: Constructing Immigrants, Citizens, and the Nation. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
• Cress, Daniel M. and David A. Snow. 2000. “The Outcomes of Homeless Mobilization: The Influence of Organization, Disruption, Political Mediation, and Framing.” American Journal of Sociology 105(4):1063-1104.
• Davis, Laurel R. 1993. “Protest against the Use of Native American Mascots: A Challenge to Traditional American Identity.” Journal of Sport and Social Issues 17(1):9-22.
• Davis-Delano, Laurel R. 2007. “Eliminating Native American Mascots: Ingredients for Success.” Journal of Sport and Social Issues 31(4):340-373.
• Douglas, Karen Manges, Rogelio Sáenz, and Aurelia Lorena Murga. 2015. “Immigration in the Era of Color-Blind Racism.” American Behavioral Scientist 59(11):1-23.
• Dove, April Lee. 2010. “Framing Illegal Immigration at the U.S.-Mexican Border: Anti-Illegal Immigration Groups and the Importance of Place in Framing.” Research in Social Movements, Conflicts, and Change 30:199-237.
• Esacove, Anne W. 2004. “Dialogic Framing: The Framing/ Counter Framing of ‘Partial-Birth’ Abortion.” Sociological Inquiry 74(1):70-101.
• Every, Danielle and Martha Augoustinos. 2007. “Constructions of Racism in the Australian Parliamentary Debates on Asylum Seekers.” Discourse and Society 18(4):411-436.
• Farnell, Brenda. 2004. “The Fancy Dance of Racializing Discourse.” Journal of Sport and Social Issues 28(1):30-55.
• Feagin, Joe R. 1997. “Old Poison in New Bottles: The Deep Roots of Modern Nativism.” Pp. 13-43 in Immigrants Out: The New Nativism and the Anti-Immigrant Impulse in the United States, edited by Juan F. Perea. New York: New York University Press.
• Fenelon, James. 1999. “Indian Icons in the World Series of Racism.” Research in Politics and Society 6:25-45.
• Fryberg, Stephanie A. et al. 2008. “Of Warrior Chiefs and Indian Princesses: The Psychological Consequences of American Indian Mascots.” Basic and Applied Social Psychology 30(3):208-218.
• Fryberg, Stephanie A. et al. 2012. “How the Media Frames the Immigration Debate: The Critical Role of Location and Politics.” Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy 12(1):96-112.
• Gamache, Ray. 2010. “Inventing Tradition: The Garripo Report and the Paraphernalia of Jurisprudence.” Studies in Symbolic Interaction 34:63-86.
• Goffman, Erving. 1974. Frame Analysis: An Essay on the Organization of Experience. Boston: Northeastern University Press.
• Goodman, Simon. 2010. “‘It’s Not Racist to Impose Limits on Immigration’: Constructing the Boundaries of Racism in the Asylum and Immigration Debate.” Critical Approaches to Discourse Analysis across Disciplines 4(1):1-17.
• Gusfield, Joseph R. 1963. Symbolic Crusade: Status Politics and the American Temperance Movement. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press.
• Harlan, Chico and Jerry Markon. 2016. “What It Will Take for President Trump to Deport Millions and Build the Wall.” Washington Post, November 09. Retrieved November 09, 2016 (https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/11/09/what-it-will-take-for-president- trump-to-deport-millions-and-build-the-wall/).
• Hedley, Mark M. and Sarah A. Clark. 2007. “The Microlevel Discourse of Social Movement Framing: Debating Antiwar Protests on a University Listserv.” Sociological Focus 40(1):26-47.
• Hoberman, John. 1997. Darwin’s Athletes: How Sport Has Damaged Black America and Preserved the Myth of Race. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company.
• Holyfield, Lori, Matthew Ryan Moltz, and Mindy S. Bradley. 2009. “Race Discourse and the US Confederate Flag.” Race, Ethnicity, and Education 12(4):517-537.
• Jacobs, Michelle R. 2014. “Race, Place, and Biography at Play: Contextualizing American Indian Viewpoints on Indian Mascots.” Journal of Sport and Social Issues 38(4):322-345.
• Jacobs, Ronald N. 1996. “Civil Society and Crisis: Culture, Discourse, and the Rodney King Beating.” American Journal of Sociology 101(5):1238-1272.
• Kil, Sang Hea. 2014. “A Diseased Body Politic: Nativist Discourse and the Imagined Whiteness of the USA.” Cultural Studies 28(2):177-198.
• Kim, Sei-hill et al. 2011. “The View of the Border: News Framing of the Definition, Causes, and Solutions to Illegal Immigration.” Mass Communication and Society 14(3):292-314.
• Kim-Prieto, Chu et al. 2010. “Effect of Exposure to an American Indian Mascot on the Tendency to Stereotype a Different Minority Group.” Journal of Applied Social Psychology 40(3):534-553.
• King, C. Richard and Charles Fruehling Springwood. 2000. “Fighting Spirits: The Racial Politics of Sports Mascots.” Journal of Sport and Social Issues 24(3):282-304.
• Kohut, Andrew et al. 2012. Changing News Landscape: Even Television Is Vulnerable. Washington: The Pew Research Center for The People & The Press.
• Lakoff, George and Sam Ferguson. 2006. The Framing of Immigration. Berkeley, CA: Rockridge Institute.
• Léonard, Marie. 2014. “Census and Racial Categorization in France: Invisible Categories and Color-Blind Politics.” Humanity and Society 38(1):67-88.
• Lio, Shoon, Scott Melzer, and Ellen Reese. 2008. “Constructing Threat and Appropriating ‘Civil Rights’: Rhetorical Strategies of Guns Rights and English Only Leaders.” Symbolic Interaction 31(1):5-31.
• Lippard, Cameron D. 2011. “Racist Nativism in the 21st Century.” Sociology Compass 5(7):591-606.
• Liptak, Adam. 2012. “Court Splits Law Verdicts; Upholds Hotly Debated Centerpiece, 8-0.” New York Times, June 26.
• Lofland, John et al. 2006. Analyzing Social Settings: A Guide to Qualitative Observation and Analysis. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing Company.
• Luque, John S. et al. 2013. “‘Who Will Pick Georgia’s Vidalia Onions?’ A Text-Driven Content Analysis of Newspaper Coverage on Georgia’s 2011 Immigration Law.” Human Organization 72(1):31-43.
• Maines, David R. 2001. The Faultline of Consciousness: A View of Interactionism in Sociology. New York: Aldine De Gruyter.
• Marshall, Susan E. 1986. “In Defense of Separate Spheres: Class and Status Politics in the Antisuffrage Movement.” Social Forces 65(2):327-351.
• McCammon, Holly J. 2009. “Beyond Frame Resonance: The Argumentative Structure and Persuasive Capacity of Twentieth-Century U.S. Women’s Jury-Rights Frames.” Mobilization 14(1):45-64.
• McFarland, Katherine. 2011. “Media Influence and Frame Diversity in the Debate Over Same-Sex Marriage.” Communication Review 14(4):255-278.
• Mead, George Herbert. 1934. Mind, Self, and Society: From the Standpoint of a Social Behaviorist. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
• Mehan, Hugh. 1997. “The Discourse of the Illegal Immigration Debate: A Case Study in the Politics of Representation.” Discourse and Society 8(2):249-270.
• Messner, Michael A. 2011. “Gender Ideologies, Youth Sports, and the Production of Soft Essentialism.” Sociology of Sport Journal 28(2):151-170.
• Miller, Gale and James A. Holstein. 1989. ‘‘On the Sociology of Social Problems.’’ Perspectives on Social Problems 1:1-16.
• Mills, C. Wright. 1940. “Situated Actions and Vocabularies of Motive.” American Sociological Review 5:904-913.
• Miranda, Luis. 2010. “Get the Facts on the DREAM Act.” The White House Blog. Retrieved April 08, 2015 (https://www.whitehouse.gov/blog/2010/12/01/get-facts-dream-act).
• Moras, Amanda. 2010. “Colour-Blind Discourses in Paid Domestic Work: Foreignness and the Delineation of Alternative Racial Markers.” Ethnic and Racial Studies 33(2):233-252.
• Napolitano, Janet. 2012. “Memorandum: Exercising Prosecutorial Discretion with Respect to Individual’s Who Came to the United States as Children.” Department of Homeland Security. Retrieved April 27, 2015 (http://www.dhs.gov/xlibrary/ assets/s1-exercising-prosecutorial-discretion-individuals- who-came-to-us-as-children.pdf).
• Omi, Michael and Howard Winant. 1994. Racial Formation in the United States. New York: Routledge.
• Ono, Kent A. and John M. Sloop. 2002. Shifting Borders: Rhetoric, Immigration, and California’s Proposition 187. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
• Ottaviano, Gianmarco I. P. and Giavanni Peri. 2006. “The Economic Value of Cultural Diversity: Evidence from US Cities.” Journal of Economic Geography 6(1):9-44.
• Pember, Mary Annette. 2007. “Farewell to the Chief.” Diverse Issues in Higher Education 24(4):18-20.
• Peri, Giovanni. 2011. “Rethinking the Area Approach: Immigrants and the Labor Market in California.” Journal of International Economic 84(1):1-14.
• Peri, Giovanni. 2012. “The Effect of Immigration on Productivity: Evidence from U.S. States.” The Review of Economics and Statistics 94(1):348-348.
• Peroff, Nicholas C. and Daniel R. Wildcat. 2002. “Who Is an American Indian?” The Social Science Journal 39(3):349-361.
• Perrin, Andrew J. 2005. “National Threat and Political Culture: Authoritarianism, Anti-Authoritarianism, and the September 11 Attacks.” Political Psychology 26(2):167-194.
• Pewewardy, Cornel D. 2001. “Educators and Mascots: Challenging Contradictions.” Pp. 257-278 in Team Spirits: The Native American Mascots Controversy, edited by C. R. King and C. F. Springwood. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press.
• Preston, Julia. 2012. “Young Immigrants, in America Illegally, Line Up for Reprieve.” New York Times, August 14.
• Quillian, Lincoln. 2006. “New Approaches to Understanding Racial Prejudice and Discrimination.” Annual Review of Sociology 32:299-328.
• Reader, Bill, Guido H. Stempel III, and Daniel K. Daniel. 2004. “Age, Wealth, Education Predict Letters to the Editor.” Newspaper Research Journal 25(4):55-66.
• Robertson, Dwanna L. 2015. “Invisibility in the Color-Blind Era; Examining Legitimized Racism against Indigenous Peoples.” American Indian Quarterly 39(2):113-153.
• Rojas-Sosa, Deyanira. 2016. “The Denial of Racism in Latina/o Students’ Narratives about Discrimination in the Classroom.” Discourse and Society 27(1):69-94.
• Santa Ana, Oto. 2002. Brown Tide Rising: Metaphors of Latinos in Contemporary American Public Discourse. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press.
• Schueths, April M. 2014. “‘It’s Almost Like White Supremacy’: Interracial Mixed-Status Couples Facing Racist Nativism.” Ethnic and Racial Studies 37(13):2438-2456.
• Scotusblog.com. “Arizona v. United States.” Retrieved April 06, 2015 (http://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/arizona- v-united-states/).
• Silva, Eric O. 2007. “Public Accounts: Defending Contested Practices.” Symbolic Interaction 30(2):245-265.
• Silva, Eric O. 2013. “Levels of Disagreement.” Qualitative Sociology Review 9(4):68-83.
• Silva, Eric O. 2014. “Neutralizing Problematic Frames in the Culture Wars: Anti-Evolutionists Grapple with Religion.” Symbolic Interaction 37(2):226-245.
• Silva, Eric O. 2015. “Constructing Mixed Status Families.” Pp. 205-232 in Living Together, Living Apart: Mixed Status Families and US Immigration Policy, edited by April M. Schueths and Jodie Lawston. Seattle, WA: University of Washington Press.
• Snow, David A. 2004. “Framing Processes, Ideology, and Discursive Fields.” Pp. 380-412 in The Blackwell Companion to Social Movements, edited by David A. Snow, Sarah A. Soule, and Hanspeter Kriesi. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing.
• Snow, David A. 2008. “Elaborating the Discursive Contexts in Framing: Discursive Fields and Spaces.” Studies in Symbolic Interaction 30:3-328.
• Somers, Margaret. 1994. “The Narrative Construction of Identity: A Relational and Network Approach.” Theory and Society 23(5):605-649.
• Springwood, Charles Fruehling. 2004. “‘I’m Indian Too!’ Claiming Native American Identity, Crafting Authority in Mascot Debates.” Journal of Sport and Social Issues 28(1):56-70.
• Staurowsky, Ellen J. 2007. “‘You Know, We Are All Indian’: Exploring White Power and Privilege in Reactions to the NCAA Native American Mascot Policy.” Journal of Sport and Social Issues 31(1):61-76.
• Steinberg, Marc W. 1999. “The Talk and Back Talk of Collective Action: A Dialogic Analysis of Repertoires of Discourse among Nineteenth-Century English Cotton Spinners.” American Journal of Sociology 105(3):736-780.
• Steinfeldt, Jesse A. et al. 2010. “Racism in the Electronic Age: Role of Online Forums in Expressing Racial Attitudes about American Indians.” Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology 16(3):362-371.
• Svajlenka, Nicole Prchal and Audrey Singer. 2014. “DACA Renewals Ramp Up.” Brookings Institution. Retrieved April 02, 2015 (http://www.brookings.edu/research/opinions/2014/07/08-daca-renewals- ramp-up-svajlenka-singer).
• van Dijk, Teun A. 1992. “Discourse and the Denial of Racism.” Discourse and Society 3(1):87-118.
• Wahl-Jorgensen, Karin. 2004. “A ‘Legitimate Beef’ or ‘Raw Meat?’ Civility, Multiculturalism, and Letters to the Editor.” Communication Review 7(1):89-105.
• Wahl-Jorgensen, Karin. 2007. Journalists and the Public: Newsroom Culture, Letters to the Editor, and Democracy. Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press.
• Weber, Max. 1968. Economy and Society: An Outline of Interpretive Sociology. Edited by Guenther Roth and Claus Wittich. New York: Bedminster Press.
• Williams, Dana M. 2006. “Patriarchy and the ‘Fighting Sioux’: A Gendered Look at Racial College Sports Nicknames.” Race, Ethnicity and Education 9(4):325-340.
• Williams, Dana M. 2007. “Where’s the Honor? Attitudes Toward the ‘Fighting Sioux’ Nickname and Logo.” Sociology of Sport Journal 24(4):437-456.
• Young, Nathan. 2011. “Working the Fringes: The Role of Letters to the Editor in Advancing Non-Standard Media Narratives about Climate Change.” Public Understanding of Science 22(4):443-459.
• Alexich, Deanna. 2007. Letter to the editor. Chico Enterprise-Record (CA), February 24. Retrieved October 07, 2013. Available at LEXIS-NEXIS Academic.
• Bottone, Bobbi. 2012. Letter to the editor. Tampa Bay Times (FL), June 29. Retrieved January 15, 2013. Available at LEXIS-NEXIS Academic.
• Burrows, Ben. 2012. Letter to the editor. The Philadelphia Daily News: Web Edition (PA), June 28. Retrieved January 15, 2013. Available at LEXIS-NEXIS Academic.
• Crisp, John M. 2012. Letter to the editor. Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (PA), June 19. Retrieved January 15, 2013. Available at LEXIS- NEXIS Academic.
• Czarlinsky, Randall. 2012. Letter to the editor. The Houston Chronicle (TX), June 22. Retrieved January 15, 2013. Available at LEXIS-NEXIS Academic.
• Dambrauskas, Deej. 2007. Letter to the editor. The State Journal-Register (Springfield, IL), February 20. Retrieved October 07, 2013. Available at LEXIS-NEXIS Academic.
• DeOcampo, Kim. 2014. Letter to the editor. Vallejo Times Herald (CA), June 24. Retrieved July 18, 2014. Available at LEXIS-NEXIS Academic.
• Dillon, John. 2012. Letter to the editor. San Francisco Chronicle (CA), June 21. Retrieved January 15, 2013. Available at LEXIS- NEXIS Academic.
• Dutt, Mallika. 2012. Letter to the editor. The New York Times, June 27. Retrieved January 15, 2013. Available at LEXIS-NEXIS Academic.
• Edgerton, Dave. 2014. Letter to the editor. Wisconsin State Journal, June 29. Retrieved July 18, 2014. Available at LEXIS-NEXIS Academic.
• Flinchum, Deena. 2012. Letter to the editor. The Roanoke Times (VA), July 02. Retrieved January 15, 2013. Available at LEXIS- NEXIS Academic.
• Gutierez, Marcelino R. 2012. Letter to the editor. San Antonio Express-News (TX), June 20. Retrieved January 15, 2013. Available at LEXIS-NEXIS Academic.
• Haukoos, Gerry D. 2007. Letter to the editor. The Pantagraph (IL), February 27. Retrieved October 07, 2013. Available at LEXIS- NEXIS Academic.
• Margolis, Jonathan J. 2012. Letter to the editor. The New York Times (NY), June 19. Retrieved January 15, 2013. Available at LEXIS-NEXIS Academic.
• Marquez, Anthony. 2012. Letter to the editor. The Philadelphia Inquirer: Web Edition (PA), June 29. Retrieved January 15, 2013. Available at LEXIS-NEXIS Academic.
• Pearce, Rick. 2007. Letter to the editor. The Pantagraph (IL), March 23. Retrieved October 07, 2013. Available at LEXIS-NEXIS Academic.
• Reid, Rodney. 2013. Letter to the editor. USA Today, September 20. Retrieved October 07, 2013. Available at LEXIS-NEXIS Academic.
• Reising, Chris. 2013. Letter to the editor. USA Today, September 20.
• Retrieved October 07, 2013. Available at LEXIS-NEXIS Academic.
• Saifa, Osaama. 2012. Letter to the editor. Contra Costa Times (CA), July 13. Retrieved January 15, 2013. Available at LEXIS-NEXIS Academic.
• Swenning, Christine. 2013. Letter to the editor. Contra Costs Times (CA), November 03. Retrieved July 18, 2014. Available at LEXIS-NEXIS Academic.
• Terry, Jill. 2012. Letter to the editor. Star Tribune (MN), June 19. Retrieved January 15, 2013. Available at LEXIS-NEXIS Academic.
• Trice, Jr., Billy. 2014. Letter to the editor. Contra Costa Times (CA), June 26. Retrieved July 18, 2014. Available at LEXIS-NEXIS Academic.

Identifiers

DOI

10.18778/1733-8077.14.1.05