Między historią, ideologią i teologią. Pro-Dawidowa lektura tradycji o Saulu w Pierwszej Księdze Kronik

• Authors: Dariusz Dziadosz

Title variants

EN

Between History, Ideology and Theology. Pro-David Reading of the Saul Traditions in 1 Chronicles

Abstracts

EN

The main purpose of the big part of 1 Chronicles was to convince theJews in the Second Temple Period that David was the legal ruler of Israel,chosen by YHWH, the whole population, and even by the house of Saul.Reading the text about the next stages of Saul and David’s political career in1 Chronicles 10:1˗9:30 one may get the impression that the narration is veryselective (cf. 1 Sam 9:1˗31:13), that many events are omitted and only thosewhich emphasize the glory of Jesse’s son are presented. Analysing thoseMIĘDZY HISTORIĄ, IDEOLOGIĄ I TEOLOGIĄ– 89 –texts one may arrive at the conclusion that David was the opposite of hispredecessor in each field, and only he was able to guarantee a permanentpolitical and military futurity for Israel. For ideological and theological reasonsthe Chronicler has castigated Saul and glorified David. In the historypresented by him, YHWH always sides with Jesse’s son and not with Saul.This point of view justifies the ideological argumentations of the Chroniclerwhose main purpose was to show the political transformations in Israel infavour of David, although these resulted in the bloody overthrow of Saul’sdynasty (2 Sam 2:1˗4:12; 21:1-14). Unlike the deuteronomistic history, hisvision of the history of the monarchy is completely theological. Historicalevents and politics were for him a background pointing to the presence ofGod and His dominant influence on Israel’s first two kings. The establishmentof the monarchy was for the Chronicler one of the most importantmilestones in the history of Israel. However, unlike the earlier historians, hedid not stress its political, social and military significance, but he evaluatedit only from the perspective of God’s plan of salvation.

Keywords

PL

1Kronik; Kronikarz; tradycje o Saulu; historiografia deuteronomistyczna

EN

1 Chronicles; the Chronicler; Saul traditions; deuteronomistic historiography

• Publisher: Uniwersytet Kardynała Stefana Wyszyńskiego w Warszawie
• Journal: Collectanea Theologica
• Year: 2019
• Volume: 89
• Issue: 4
• Pages: 47-93

Dates

published

2019

Contributors

author

Dariusz Dziadosz

References

• Abadie P., 1-2 Chroniques, w: T. Römer, J. Macchi, C. Nihan (red.), Introduction à l’Ancien Testament, Labor et fides, Genève 2004, s. 594-603;
• Ackroyd P., The Theology of the Chronicler, LTQ 8(1973), s. 101-116;
• _______, The Chronicler as Exegete, JSOT 2(1977), s. 2-32;
• Adam K., Saul und David in der judäischen Geschichtsschreibung: Studien zu 1 Samuel 16 ˗ 2 Samuel 5, FAT 51, Mohr Siebeck, Tübingen 2007;
• Arnold B.T., Samuel, Books of, w: B.T. Arnold, H.G. Williamson (red.), Dictionary of the Old Testament. Historical Books, InterVarsity Press, Downers Grove-Nottingham 2005, s. 866-877;
• Bartelmus R., Heroentum in Israel und seiner Umwelt, ATANT 65, Theologischer Verlag, Zürich 1979;
• Becker J., 1 Chronik, NEB 18, Echter Verlag, Würzburg 1986;
• Benzinger I., Die Bücher der Chronik – erklärt, KHCAT 20, J.C. Mohr, Tübingen 1901;
• Ben Zvi E., The Book of Chronicles: Another Look, SR 31(2002), s. 261-281;
• Berges U., Die Verwerfung Sauls. Eine thematische Untersuchung, FzB 61, Echter Verlag, Würzburg 1989;
• Bezzel H., Saul: Israels König in Tradition, Redaktion und früher Rezeption, FAT 1.97, Mohr Siebeck, Tübingen 2015;
• _______, Saul und die Philister: Redaktionskritische Überlegungen zu 1 Samuel 13˗14, w: W. Dietrich, The Books of Samuel. Stories – History –Reception History, BETL 284, Peters, Leuven 2016, s. 457-466;
• Botterweck G., Zur Eigenart der chronistischen Davidgeschichte, TQ 136(1956), s. 402-435;
• Braun R., 1Chronicles, WBC 14, Word Books, Waco 1986;
• Carlson R., David the Chosen King. A Traditio-Historical Approach to the Second Book of Samuel, Almqvist & Wilksell, Stockholm 1964;
• Coggins J., The First and Second Books of the Chronicles, CBC, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1976;
• Cudworth T., War in Chronicles. Temple Faithfulness and Israel’s Place in the Land, Oxford 2014;
• _______, The Davidic “Heart” for the Temple in Chronicles, CBQ 81(2; 2019), s. 204-216;
• Curtis E., Madsen A., A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Books of Chronicles, T&T Clark, Edinburgh 1994;
• Dietrich W., David, Saul und die Propheten. Das Verhältnis von Religion und Politik nach den prophetischen Überlieferungen vom frühesten Königtum in Israel, BWANT 122, Kohlhammer, Stuttgart 1987;
• _______, 1 Samuel 1˗12, BKAT 8.1, Neukirchener, Neukirchen-Vluyn 2011;
• Dockery H., Holman Concise Bible Commentary, Broadman & Holman Publishers, Nashville 1998;
• Donner H., Die Verwerfung des Königs Sauls, w: H. Donner (red.), Aufsätze zum Alten Testament, BZAW 224, de Gruyter, Berlin 1994, s. 133-164;
• Dziadosz D., Monarcha odrzucony przez Boga i lud. Proces redakcji biblijnych tradycji o Saulu, Wydawnictwo Archidiecezji Przemyskiej, Przemyśl 2006;
• Edenburg C., Pakkala J. (red.), Is Samuel among the Deuteronomist? Current Views on the Place Samuel in a Deuteronomistic History, SBL 16, Society of Biblical Literature, Atlanta 2013;
• Eissfeldt O., The Old Testament, an Introduction, Harper & Row, New York 1965;
• Foresti F., The Rejection of Saul in the Perspective of the Deuteronomistic School. A Study of 1Sam 15 and Related Texts, STT 5, Edizioni del Teresianum, Rome 1984;
• Gabriel I., Friede über Israel. Eine Untersuchung zur Friedenstheologie in Chronik I 10 ˗ II 36, OBS 10, Österreichisches Katholisches Bibelwerk, Klosterneuburg 1990;
• Galbiati E., Serafini F., Historyczny atlas Biblii, Jedność, Kielce 2006;
• Gertz J., Witte M., Schmid K. (red.), Die deuteronomistischen Geschichtswerke, BZAW 365, de Gruyter, Berlin 2012;
• Graham M., The Utilization of 1 and 2 Chronicles in the Reconstruction of Israelite History in the Nineteenth Century, SBLDS 116, Scholars Press, Atlanta 1990;
• Heinrich A., David und Klio. Historiographische Elemente in der Aufstiegsgeschichte Davids und im Alten Testament, BZAW 401, de Gruyter, Berlin 2009;
• Hill A., 1 & 2 Chronicles, NIVAC, Zondervan, Grand Rapids 2003;
• Ho C., Conjectures and Refutations. Is 1Samuel XXXI 1-13 Really the Source of 1Chronicles X 1-12?, VT 45(1995), s. 82-106;
• Ishida T., The Royal Dynasties in Ancient Israel. A Study on the Formation and Development of Royal-Dynastic Ideology, BZAW 142, de Gruyter, New York 1977;
• Janzen D., Chronicles and the Politics of Davidic Restoration. A Quiet Revolution, T&T Clark, Bloomsbury 2017;
• Kaiser O., Der historische und der biblische König Saul (Teil I), ZAW 122(4; 2010), s. 520-545;
• ______, Der historische und der biblische König Saul (Teil II), ZAW 123(1; 2011), s. 1-14;
• Kalimi I., Reshaping of Ancient Israelite History in Chronicles, Eisenbrauns, Winona Lake 2005;
• ______, Starożytny historyk izraelski. Studium o Kronikarzu, jego epoce, miejscu działalności i dziele, Nomos, Kraków 2016;
• Kittel R., Die Bücher der Chronik übersetzt und erklärt, GHAT 6.1, Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, Göttingen 1902;
• Klein R., 1 Chronicles. A Commentary on 1Chronicles, HCHCB, Fortress Press, Minneapolis 2006;
• Knierim R., mʽl, w: E. Jenni, C. Westermann (red.), Theological Lexicon of the Old Testament, t. 2, Kaiser Verlag, München 2004, s. 480-482;
• Knoppers G.N., 1Chronicles 1-29. A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary, AB 12A, Doubleday, New York 2004;
• ______, The Historical Study of the Monarchy: Developments and Detours, w: D.W. Baker, B.T. Arnold (red.), The Face of the Old Testament Studies: A Survey of Contemporary Approaches, Baker, Grand Rapids 1999, s. 207-235;
• Lorenzin T., 1˗2 Cronache. Nuova versione, introduzione e commento, Paoline Editoriali, Milano 2011;
• McCarthy D., Hero and Anti-Hero in 1Sam 13,2˗14,46, w: D. McCarthy (red.), Institution and Narrative. Collected Essays, AnBib 108, Roma 1985, s. 252-259;
• McKenzie J., A Theology of the Old Testament, Doubleday, Garden City 1974;
• Mosis R., Untersuchungen zur Theologie des chronistischen Geschichtswerkes, FTS 92, Herder, Freiburg 1973;
• Müller R., Saul, the Charismatic King: Concepts of Political Leadership in 1Sam 11, w: K. Pyschny, S. Schulz (red.), Debating Authority. Concepts of Leadership in the Pentateuch and the Former Prophets, BZAW 507, de Gruyter, Berlin 2018, s. 262-287;
• Na’aman N., Saul, Benjamin and the Emergence of “Biblical Israel” (Part I), ZAW 121(2;2009), s. 211-224;
• _______, Saul, Benjamin and the Emergence of “Biblical Israel” (Part II), ZAW 121(3;2009), s. 335-349;
• Nicholson S., Three Faces of Saul. An Intertextual Approach to Biblical Tragedy, JSOT.S 339, Sheffield Academic Press, Sheffield 2002;
• Nihan C., Nocquet D., 1-2 Samuel, w: T. Römer, J.D. Macchi, C. Nihan (red.), Introduction à l’Ancien Testament, MDB 45, Labor et fides, Genève 2004, s. 277-301;
• Noll K., The Faces of David, JSOT.S 242, Sheffield Academic Press, Sheffield 1997;
• Payne J., 1,2 Chronicles, EBC 4, Zondervan, Grand Rapids 1988;
• Pfeiffer R., Introduction to the Old Testament, Harper & Brothers, New York 1957;
• Popovic A., Saul’s Fault in 1Sam 13,7b-15a. Why Has the First Israelite King Fallen?, Antonianum 68(1993), s. 153-170;
• Pritchard J. (red.), Ancient Near Eastern Texts Relating to the Old Testament, Princeton University Press, Princeton 1969;
• Ringgren H., mʽl, w: G. Botterweck, H. Ringgren, H. Fabry, Theological Dictionary of the Old Testament, t. 8, Eerdmans, Grand Rapids 1997, s. 460-463;
• Schäfer-Lichtenberger C. (red.), Die Samuelbücher und die Deuteronomisten, BWANT 188, Kohlhammer, Stuttgart 2010;
• Segal M., Between Bible and Rewritten Bible, w: M. Henze (red.), Biblical Interpretation at Qumran, Eerdmans, Grand Rapids 2005, s. 10-28;
• Selman M., Jerusalem in Chronicles, w: R. Hess, G. Wenham (red.), Zion City of Our God, Eerdmans, Grand Rapids 1999, s. 43-56;
• Seters Van J., Creative Imitation in the Hebrew Bible, SR 29(2000), s. 395-409;
• Smend R., Die Entstehung des Alten Testaments, TW 1, W. Kohlhammer, Stuttgart 1978;
• Smith J., 1Chronicles: Focus on King David. A Commentary, Lulu.com 2016;
• Stoebe H., Das erste Buch Samuelis, KAT 8.1, Evangelische Verlag, Gütersloh 1973;
• Thompson J., 1,2 Chronicles, NAC 9, Broadman & Holman Publishers, Nashville 1994;
• Tronina A., Pierwsza Księga Kronik, NKB 10.1, Edycja św. Pawła, Częstochowa 2015;
• Trotter J., Reading, Readers and Reading Readers Reading the Account of Saul’s Death in 1Chronicles 10, w: M. Graham, S. McKenzie (red.), The Chronicler as Author. Studies in Text and Texture, JSOT.S 263, Sheffield Academic Press, Sheffield 1999, s. 294-310;
• Veijola T., Die ewige Dynastie. David und die Entstehung seiner Dynastie nach der deuteronomistischen Darstellung, AASF B 193, Suomalainen Tiedeakatemia, Helsinki 1975;
• ______, Das Königtum in der Beurteilung der deuteronomistischen Historiographie. Eine redaktionsgeschichtliche Untersuchung, AASF B 198, Suomalainen Tiedeakatemia, Helsinki 1977;
• Walvoord J., Zuck R., The Bible Knowledge Commentary, Victor Books, New York 1983;
• Weiser A., 1Samuel 15, ZAW 54(1936), s. 1-28;
• Welch A., The Work of the Chronicler: Its Purpose and Its Date, SLBA, Oxford University Press, London 1938;
• Wellhausen J., Prolegomena zur Geschichte Israels, G. Reiner, Berlin 1883;
• ______, Prolegomena to the History of Ancient Israel, Peter Smith, Gloucester 1973;
• Williamson H., 1 and 2 Chronicles, NCBC, Eerdmans, Grand Rapids 1982;
• Willi T., Die Chronik als Auslegung: Untersuchungen zur literarischen Gestaltung der historischen Überlieferung Israels, FRLANT 106, Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, Göttingen 1972;
• Yonick Y., Rejection of Saul as King of Israel, Franciscan Printing, Jerusalem 1970;
• Zalewski S., The Purpose of the Story of the Death of Saul in 1Chronicles X, VT 39(1989), s. 449-467;
• Zenger E., Introduzione all’Antico Testamento, Editrice Queriniana, Brescia 2005;
• Zsengellér J. (red.), Rewritten Bible after Fifty Years: Texts, Terms, or Techniques? A Last Dialogue with Geza Vermes, JSJ.S 166, Brill, Leiden 2013.

Identifiers

DOI

10.21697/ct.2019.89.4.02

Biblioteka Nauki

2033548