The Books of Chronicles and Ezra-Nehemiah as a Project of New Future for Israel

• Authors: Waldemar Chrostowski

Abstracts

EN

1–2 Chronicles and Ezra-Nehemiah express a different approach to the future of Israel to that provided in the Earlier Prophets. Firstly, the nature and the dating of this part of the Hebrew Bible are discussed, suggesting the end of the fifth and the very beginning of the fourth century B.C. as the time of its origins. Secondly, the retrospect of the past in 1–2 Chronicles is presented with a very specific attitude towards the Exile. The article focuses on the detailed analysis of Ezra 4:1–5, a passage representing the very core of this book. Against the backdrop of the identity of the deputation visiting Jerusalem as seen by the author of Ezra and the completely different self-presentation of the envoys from the north, the serious conflict that ensues is described. It bears analogies with the former antagonisms and tensions between the kingdom of Judah and the kingdom of Israel. On the basis of this conflict, a new reality emerges, namely Judaism. The religion of the preexilic Israel was profoundly transformed, having been exclusively limited to those Judeans who had come back from the Exile. As a result of this separation, the question of the “true Israel” became more crucial, setting new direction for the project of the national and religious identity of biblical Israel.

Keywords

EN

1–2 Chronicles; Books of Ezra and Nehemiah; Jerusalem Temple; Babylonian exile; Persian period; Samaritans

• Publisher: Uniwersytet Kardynała Stefana Wyszyńskiego w Warszawie
• Journal: Collectanea Theologica
• Year: 2020
• Volume: 90
• Issue: 5
• Pages: 153-191

Dates

published

2020

Contributors

author

Waldemar Chrostowski

• Cardinal Stefan Wyszyński University in Warsaw

• https://orcid.org/0000000287332192

References

• Waldemar Chrostowski: “Kronikarskie dzieło historyczne jako projekt nowej przyszłości Izraela,” Collectanea Theologica 89 (2019) no. 4, 7–46.
• Ackroyd P.R., The Chronicler in His Age, JSOTSuppl. 101, Sheffield 1991.
• Albertz R., A History of Israelite Religion in the Old Testament Period, vol. 1: From the Exile to the Maccabees, London 1994.
• Albertz R., Die social- und religionsgeschichtliche Folgen der Exilszeit, Bibel und Kirche 55/2000, 127–131.
• Becking B., Ezra’s Re-enactment of the Exile, in: Grabbe L.L., Leading Captivity Captive. “The Exile” as History and Ideology, JSOTSuppl. 278, European Seminar in Historical Methodology 2, Sheffield 1998, 40–61.
• Becking B., Does Ezra Present the Return from Exile as a Second Exodus?, Biblische Notizen 177/2018, 65–73.
• Bedford P.R., Diaspora: Homeland Relations in Ezra-Nehemiah, Vetus Testamentum 52/2002, 147–165.
• Ben Zvi E., Towards a Sense of Balance: Remembering the Catastrophe of Monarchic Judah/(Ideological) Israel and Exile through Reading Chronicles in Late Yehud, in: Evans P.S., Williams T.F. (eds.), Chronicling the Chronicler: The Book of Chronicles and Early Second Temple Historiography, Winona Lake, IN 2013, 247–265
• Ben Zvi E., Chronicles and Samuel-Kings: Two Interacting Aspects of a Memory System in the Late Persian/Early Hellenistic Period, in: Becker U., Bezzel H. (eds.), Rereading the “relecture”? The Question of (Post)chronistic Influences in the Latest Redactions of the Book of Samuel, Tübingen 2014, 41–56.
• Bettenzoli G., Księga Ezdrasza i Księga Nehemiasza, in: Farmer W.R. (ed.), Chrostowski W. (ed. pol.), Międzynarodowy komentarz do Pisma Świętego. Komentarz katolicki i ekumeniczny na XXI wiek, Warszawa 2001, 577.
• Bodner K., Reading the Lists: Several Recent Studies of the Chronicles Genealogies, in: Evans P.S., Williams T.F. (eds.), Chronicling the Chronicler: The Book of Chronicles and Early Second Temple Historiography, Winona Lake (IN) 2013, 29–41.
• Broshi M., Eight Critical Junctures in Ancient Jewish History, in: Dobos K.D., Köszeghy M. (eds.), With Wisdom as a Robe. Qumran and Other Jewish Studies in Honor of Ida Fröhlich, Hebrew Bible Monographs 21, Sheffield 2009, 15–22.
• Carter Ch.E., Ideology and Archaeology in the Neo-Babylonian Period. Excavating Text and Tell, in: Lipschits O., Oeming M. (eds.), Judah and the Judeans in the Persian Period, Winona Lake (IN) 2006, 301–322.
• Chrostowski W., Asyryjska diaspora Izraelitów i inne studia, Rozprawy i Studia Biblijne 10, Warszawa 2003, 13–125.
• Chrostowski W., Babilońskie deportacje mieszkańców Jerozolimy i Judy oraz inne studia, Rozprawy i Studia Biblijne 34, Warszawa 2009, 13–108.
• Chrostowski W., Trzecia Świątynia w Jerozolimie i inne studia, Rozprawy i Studia Biblijne 44, Warszawa 2012, 38–166.
• Chrostowski W., Konflikt wokół odbudowy świątyni (Ezd 4,1-5). Przyczynek do transformacji religii biblijnego Izraela i narodzin judaizmu, Collectanaea Theologica 89 (2019) no. 3, 43–83.
• Ciecieląg J., Zerubbael and His Role in the Creation of Yehud Province, Polish Journal of Biblical Research 10/2011, 57–62.
• Coggins R.J., The First and Second Books of Chronicles, Cambridge 1976.
• Crown A.D., Redating the Schism Between the Judaeans and the Samaritans, JQR 82 (1991) no. 1–2, 17–50.
• Dušek J., Mt Gerizim Sanctuary, Its History and Enigma of Origin, Hebrew Bible and Ancient Israel 3/2014, 111–133.
• Edelman D., Cultic Sites and Complexes Beyond the Jerusalem Temple, in: Staurakopoulou F., Barton J. (eds.), Religious Diversity in Ancient Israel and Judah, New York–London 2010, 82–103.
• Gane R., The Role of Assyria in the Ancient Near East during the Reign of Manasseh, Andrews University Seminary Studies 35/1997, 21–32.
• Grätz S., Bund und Erwählung in Esra-Nehemiah, in: MacDonald N. (ed.), Covenant and Election in Exilic and Post-Exilic Judaism, Tübingen 2015, 128–138.
• Farmer W.R. (ed.), Chrostowski W. (ed. pol.), Międzynarodowy komentarz do Pisma Świętego. Komentarz katolicki i ekumeniczny na XXI wiek, Warszawa 2000.
• Faust A., Deportations and Demography in Sixth-Century B.C.E. Judah, in: Wright J. L. (ed.), Interpreting Exile. Interdisciplinary Studies of Displacement and Deportation in Biblical and Modern Contexts, Atlanta 2011, 91–103.
• Finkelstein I., The Expansion of Judah in II Chronicles: Territorial’s Legitimation for the Hasmoneans? Zeitschrift für Alttestametliche Wissenschaft 127/2015, 669–695.
• Giffone B.D., According to Which “Law of Moses”? Cult Centralization in Samuel, Kings and Chronicles, Vetus Testamentum 67/2017, 432–447.
• Goodnick P., Ezra Rejects Patrilinear Descent, The Jewish Bible Quarterly 26/1998, 250–254.
• Grabbe L.L., Israel’s Historical Reality after the Exile, in: Becking B., Korpel M.C.A. (eds.), The Crisis of Israelite Religion. Transformation of Religious Tradition in Exilic and Post-Exilic Times, Old Testament Studies 42, Leiden 1999, 9–44.
• Hobson R., The Memory of Samaria in the Books of Kings, in: Edelman D.V., Ben Zvi E. (eds.), Memory and the City in Ancient Israel, Winona Lake, IN, 2014, 219–229.
• Hoglund K.G., The Chronicler as Historian: A Comparativist Perspective, in: Graham M.P. et al. (eds.), The Chronicler as Historian, Sheffield 1997, 19–29.
• Hunt A., Missing Priests. The Zadokites in Tradition and History, Library of Hebrew Bible/Old Testament Studies 452, New York 2006.
• Irudaya R., Who are the Samaritans? Vidyajyoti 68/2004, 576–594.
• Japhet S., The Historical reliability of Chronicles: The History of the Problem and Its Place in Biblical Research, Journal for the Study of the Old Testament 33/1985, 83–107; Ibid. in: Exum J.Ch., The Historical Books, The Biblical Seminar 40, Sheffield 1997, 258–281.
• Kalimi I., Historia, historiografia a wiarygodność historyczna. Księga Kronik na tle starożytnego piśmiennictwa bliskowschodniego i grecko-rzymskiego, Poznańskie Studia Teologiczne 23/2009, 7–25;
• Kalimi I., Starożytny historyk izraelski. Studium o Kronikarzu, jego epoce, miejscu działalności i dziele, Kraków 2016.
• Knoppers G.N., I Chronicles 1–9, The Anchor Bible 12, New York 2003.
• Knoppers G.N., I Chronicles 10–29, The Anchor Bible 12A, New York 2004.
• Knoppers G.N., Judah, Levi, David, Solomon, Jerusalem, and the Temple: Election and Covenant in Chronicles, in: MacDonald N. (ed.), Covenant and Election in Exilic and Post-Exilic Judaism, Tübingen 2015, 139–168.
• Knoppers G.N., Revisiting the Samarian Question in the Persian Period, in: Lipschits O., Oeming M. (ed.), Judah and Judaeans in the Persian Period, Winona Lake (IN) 2006, 265–289.
• Langkammer H., Księgi Ezdrasza-Nehemiasza. Wstęp – przekład z oryginału – komentarz – ekskursy, Pismo Święte Starego Testamentu II/3, Poznań–Warszawa 1971.
• Langkammer H., Kwestia źródeł w 1 i 2 Księdze Kronik i technika ich opracowania, in: Chrostowski W. (ed.), „Pan moim światłem”. Księga pamiątkowa dla Księdza Profesora Jerzego Chmiela w 65. rocznicę urodzin, Ad Multos Annos 4, Warszawa 2000, 214–218;
• Langkammer H., Historia teologizowana. Fenomen interpretacji historii w 1–2 Krn, Quaestiones Selectae 17 (2010) no. 26, 87–106.
• Lau P.H.W., Gentile Incorporation into Israel in Ezra-Nehemiah? Biblica 90/2009, 356–373.
• Lawson Younger K., The Deportations of the Israelites, Journal of Biblical Literature 117/1998, 201–227.
• Lynch M.J., The Davidic Covenant and Institutional Integration in Chronicles, in: MacDonald N. (ed.), Covenant and Election in Exilic and Post-Exilic Judaism, Tübingen 2015, 169–188.
• Magen Y, The Dating of the First Phase of the Samaritan Temple on Mount Gerizim in Light of the Archaeological Evidence, in: Lipschits O., Knoppers G.N., Albertz R. (eds.), Judah and Judaeans in the Fourth Century B.C.E., Winona Lake (IN) 2007, 157–211.
• Merill E.H., The Theology of the “Chronicles”: What Difference Does It Make? Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society 59/2016, 691–700.
• Moore M.B., Kelle B.E., Biblical History and Israel’s Past. The Changing Study of the Bible and History, Grand Rapids (MI)–Cambridge (U.K.) 2011, 367–388.
• Münnich M., O pokusach uświęcania historii, albo o nadgorliwości biblijnego Kronikarza słów parę, in: Borkowska U. (ed.), Peregrinatio ad veritatem. Studia ofiarowane profesor Aleksandrze Witkowskiej OSU z okazji 40-lecia pracy naukowej, Prace Wydziału Historyczno-Filologicznego 111, Lublin 2004, 315–324;
• Na’man N., Population Changes in Palestine Following Assyrian Deportations, Tel Aviv 20/1993 no. 2, 104–124.
• Nihan Ch., Cult Centralization and the Torah Traditions in Chronicles, in: Dubovsky P., Markl D., Sonnet L.-P. (eds.), The Fall of Jerusalem and the Rise of the Torah, Tübingen 2016, 253–288.
• Nodet E., A Search for the Origins of Judaism. From Joshua to the Mishnah, Journal for the Study of the Old Testament 248, Sheffield 1997, 154–160.
• North R., Księga Ezdrasza i Nehemiasza, in: Brown R. E., Fitzmyer J. A., Murphy R. E. (ed.), Chrostowski W. (ed. pol.), Katolicki komentarz biblijny, Prymasowska Seria Biblijna 17, Warszawa 2001, 340–364.
• Oded B., The Settlements of the Israelite and Judean Exiles in Mesopotamia in the 8th-6th Centuries BCE, in: Galil G., Weinfeld M. (eds.), Studies in Historical Geography and Biblical Historiography Presented to Zecharia Kallai, Vetus Testamentum Suppl. 81, Leiden et al. 2000, 91–103.
• Pummer R., Samaritanism – A Jewish Sect or an Independent Form of Yahwism? in: Mor M., Reiterer F.V. (eds.), Samaritans. Past and Present, Studia Samaritana 5, Berlin–New York 2010, 1–24.
• Ron Z., The First Confrontation with the Samaritans (Ezra 4), The Jewish Bible Quarterly 43/2015, 117–121.
• Sacchi P, Storia del Secondo Tempio. Israele tra VI secolo a. C e I secolo d. C., Torino 1994.
• Schütte W., Wie wurde Juda israelitiesiert? Zeitschschrift für Alttestamentliche Wissenschaft 124/2012, 52–72.
• Sérandour A., Les récits bibliques de la construction du second temple: leurs enjeux, Transeufratene 11/1996, 9–32.
• Shanks H. (ed.), Chrostowski W., (transl. and ed.), Starożytny Izrael. Od Abrahama do zburzenia świątyni jerozolimskiej przez Rzymian, Podręczniki Biblijne 1, Warszawa 2018.
• Smith-Christopher, D.L., Reassessing the Historical and Sociological Impact of the Babylonian Exile (597/587-539 BCE), in: Scott J.M. (ed.), Exile: Old Testament, Jewish and Christian Perspectives, Journal for Study of Judaism Suppl. 56, Leiden 1997, 7–32.
• Schweitzer S., The Genealogies of 1 Chronicles 1–9: Purposes, Forms, and the Utopian Identity of Israel, in: Evans P.S., Williams T.F. (eds.), Chronicling the Chronicler: The Book of Chronicles and Early Second Temple Historiography, Winona Lake (IN) 2013, 9–17.
• Stern E., The Religious Revolution in Persian-Period Judah, in: Lipschits O., Blenkinsopp J. (eds.), Judah and Judeans in the Neo-Babylonian Period, Winona Lake (IN) 2006, 199–205.
• Stern E., Religion in Palestine in the Assyrian and Persian Periods, in: Becking B., Korpel M.C.A. (eds.), The Crisis of Israelite Religion. Transformation of Religious Tradition in Exilic and Post-Exilic Times, Old Testament Studies 42, Leiden 1999, 9–44, 153–255.
• Szamocki G., Wielkoizraelska pertspektywa tożsamości Judy w Pwt 11,29-30, Studia Gdańskie 41/2017, 17–23.
• Tiño J., An Elaboration of Some Theological Issues of Second Temple Judaism in Chronicles and Jubilees, Communio Viatorum 59/2017, 25–47.
• Usue E., Theological Perspectives on the Concept of “Yahwe’s People” in Ezra and Nehemiah during the Early Post-Exilic Period (539-350 BC), pt. I, Old Testament Essays 18/2005, 826–846.
• Usue E., Theological Perspectives on the Concept of “Yahwe’s People” in Ezra and Nehemiah during the Early Post-Exilic Period (539-350 BC), pt. II, Old Testament Essays 19/2006, 205–215.
• Usue E., The Place of Non-Jews/Foreigners in the Early Post-exilic Jewish Community in Ezra-Nehemiah, Old Testament Essay 17/2004, 294–314.
• VanGemeren W.A. (ed.), The New International Dictionary of Old Testament Theology and Exegesis, vol. 1, Carlisle 1996.
• Viezel E., The Order of the Tribes in 1Chron 2–8 according to the Commentary on Chronicles Attributed to Sa’adia Gaon’as Student, Biblische Notizien 174/2017, 91–105.
• Walton J.H., Matthews V.H., Chavalas M.W., Komentarz historyczno-kulturowy do Biblii Hebrajskiej, Prymasowska Seria Biblijna 24, Warszawa 2005.
• Warzecha J., Samarytanie – perspektywa polityczna i religijna, in: Chrostowski W. (ed.), „Słowo Twoje jest prawdą”. Księga Pamiątkowa dla Księdza Profesora Stanisława Mędali CM w 65. rocznicę urodzin, Ad Multos Annos 3, Warszawa 2000, 332–343.
• Wellhausen J., Prolegomena zur Geschichte Israels, Berlin 18832.
• Willi T., The Chronik als Auslegung, FRLANT 106, Göttingen 1972.
• Yamauchi E., The Eastern Jewish Diaspora under the Babylonians, in: Chavalas M.W., Lawson Younger K. Jr. (eds.), Mesopotamia and the Bible. Comparative Explorations, Grand Rapids (MI) 2002, 356–377.
• Zadok R., Judeans in Babylonia – Updating the Dossier, in: Garbay U., Secunda Sh. (eds.), Encounters by the Rivers of Babylon. Scholarly Conversations Between Jews, Iranians and Babylonians in Antiquity, Texts and Studies in Ancient Judaism 160, Tübingen 2014, 109–129.
• Zertal A., The Province of Samaria (Assyrian “Samerina”) in the Late Iron Age (Iron Age III), in: Lipschits O., Oeming M. (eds.), Judah and the Judeans in the Persian Period, Winona Lake (IN) 2006, 377–412.
• Zunz L., Dibre hajamim oder die Bücher der Chronik, in: idem, Die Gottesdienstlichen Vorträge der Juden historisch entwickelt, Frankfurt 1832.

Identifiers

DOI

10.21697/ct.2020.90.5.08

Biblioteka Nauki

2030735