From spontaneous generation to cosmic abiogenesis. An attempt at systematization of biogenesis theories

• Authors: Adam Świeżyński

Abstracts

EN

The question of the origin of life interested people for centuries. All existing views on this subject can be classified into different areas of our knowledge of the world: natural sciences, philosophy, and theology. Some theories (perhaps the majority) contain more or less explicit elements from all of these areas. Thus, it is helpful to take a closer look at them and to classify all the typical groups of theories about the origins of life. We can in this way stress their mutual connections and clarify their own nature. Nowadays, driving forces of pre-biological chemical evolution and the explanation of the transition from “non-life into life” present a great variety of solutions. The differences between the theories, however, as well as the current controversies in the scientific community (e.g., what was “in the beginning”?; where did prebiotic evolution take place? etc.), will be shown to be of secondary importance in comparison with several much more profound philosophical assumptions underlying the origin-of-life-studies. The attempt to organize and classify different types of theories on the genesis of life allows to take into account different kinds of perspectives (theistic, philosophical and scientific), and to compare them to each other. The most general division between theories is based on a distinction between metaphysical conceptions and scientific ones. Some theories answer the question of the emergence of life in general, whereas others tackle the question of the origin of life on Earth only. Interestingly, two traditional ideas concerning the problem of the origin of life (i.e., spontaneous generation and panspermia) are still at play in contemporary scientific research, albeit in a modified form. In the perspective of contemporary scientific research on the origin of life it seems interesting that two main ideas concerning the problem of the origin of life, spontaneous generation and panspermia, are still present as presuppositions of certain theories but have been modified. Moreover, it is evident that the theistic view of the origin of life (creation) does not have to fall into conflict with contemporary scientific theories. Rather, they are complementary. This article is an extension, explanation and refinement of the proposed scheme of the main types of theories on the origin of life. An attempt to classify various biogenesis theories is also proposed. One of the most important questions that will be addressed concerns the philosophical presumptions of biogenetics still informing current research as well as scientific explanations of the origin of life.

Keywords

PL

biogenesis; preexistence of life; creation of life; spontaneous generation; abiogenesis; panspermia

• Publisher: Uniwersytet Kardynała Stefana Wyszyńskiego w Warszawie
• Journal: Studia Philosophiae Christianae
• Year: 2020
• Volume: 56
• Issue: S2
• Pages: 95-113

Dates

published

2020

Contributors

author

Adam Świeżyński

• Cardinal Stefan Wyszyński University in Warsaw, Institute of Philosophy

• https://orcid.org/0000000304304530

References

• Bednarczyk A., Z dziejów idei życia we wszechświecie: epoka Oświecenia (Fontenelle, Huygens, Kant). W trzechsetną rocznicę śmierci Christiana Huygensa (1629–1695), Kwartalnik Historii Nauki i Techniki 40(1995)3, 7–48.
• Bernstein M., Prebiotic materials from on and off the early Earth, Philosophical Transactions of The Royal Society B (Biological Sciences) (2006)361, 1689–1702.
• Cooper G., Kimmich N., Belisle W., Sarinana J., Brabham K., Garrel L., Carbonaceous meteorites as a source of sugar-related organic compounds for the early Earth, Nature (2001)414, 879–883.
• Crick F., Life Itself, Simon and Schuster, New York 1981.
• Dose K., Molecular Evolution and Protobiology: An Overview, in: Molecular Evolution and Protobiology, eds. K. Matsuno, K. Dose, K. Harada, D. L. Rohlfing, Plenum Press, New York – London 1984, 1–10.
• Dworkin J. P., Deamer D. W., Sandford S. A., Allamandola L. J., Self-assembling amphiphilic molecules: Synthesis in simulated interstellar/precometary ices, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America (2001)98, 815–819.
• Farley J., The Spontaneous Generation Controversy from Descartes to Oparin, Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore – London 1977.
• Fry I., Are the Different Hypotheses on the Emergence of Life as Di0erent as they Seem?, Biology and Philosophy 10(1995)4, 389–417.
• Ługowski W., Kategoria zmiany jakościowej a biogeneza, IFiS PAN – Ossolineum, Wrocław – Warszawa – Kraków – Gdańsk – Łódź 1985.
• Ługowski W., Philosophical foundations of the theories on the origin of life, Origins of Life and Evolution of the Biosphere 32(2002)5–6, 517–518.
• Ługowski W., Ile jest teorii powstania życia?, in: W poszukiwaniu istoty życia, eds. G. Bugajak, A. Latawiec, Wydawnictwo UKSW, Warszawa 2005, 111–124.
• Ługowski W., Progress or Crisis in the Origin-of-Life Studies? A Philosophical Perspective, Dialogue and Universalism 18(2008)11–12, 207–218.
• Ługowski W., Philosophy and Biogenesis, Wydawnictwo Arboretum, Wrocław 2008.
• Ługowski W., Filozoficzne podstawy teorii biogenezy: kontrowersje rzeczywiste i pozorne, in: Filozoficzne i naukowo-przyrodnicze elementy obrazu świata, vol. 8, eds. A. Lemańska, A. Świeżyński, Wydawnictwo UKSW, Warszawa 2010, 170–190.
• Kreiner J., Skowron S. (eds.), Wypisy z ewolucjonizmu, vol. 1: Powstanie i właściwości żywej materii (Zeszyt 1: Powstanie życia na Ziemi. Część pierwsza: Okres wiary w samorództwo), PWN, Warszawa 1957.
• Krzymowski R., Das Wesen der Urzeugung, Die Natur 46(1897)19, 221–222.
• Krzymowski R., Das Wesen der Urzeugung, Die Natur 46(1897)20, 229–232.
• Mayr E., The Growth of Biological Thought, Harvard University Press, Cambridge MA 1982.
• Monod J., Chance and Necessity, Collins, Fontana Books, Glasgow 1974.
• Neue deutsche Biographie, vol. 13, Duncker and Humblot, Berlin 1982.
• Oparin A. (ed.), The Origin of Life on the Earth: Reports on the International Symposium, Academy of Sciences of the USSR, Moscow 1957.
• Origins of Life and Evolution of Biosphere (Special Issue: Abstracts form the 2008 ISSOL Meeting), 39(2009)3–4, 179–392.
• Pilcher C. B., Lissauer J. J., The quest for habitable worlds and life beyond the solar system, in: Exploring the Origin, Extent, and Future of Life. Philosophical, Ethical, and Theological Perspectives, eds. C. M. Bertka, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2009, 143–166.
• Raulin-Cerceau F., Historical Review of the Origin of Life and Astrobiology, in: Origins. Genesis, Evolution and Diversity of Life, eds. J. Seckbach, Kluwer Academic Press, New York – Boston – Dordrecht – London – Moscow 2004, 17–33.
• Ruse M., The origin of life: philosophical perspectives, Journal of Theoretical Biology (1997)187, 473–482.
• Schulze-Makuch D., Irwin L. N., Life in the Universe. Expectations and Constraints, Springer, Berlin – Heidelberg 2006.
• Seckbach J., Chela-Flores J., Owen T., Raulin F. (eds.), Life in the Universe. From the Miller Experiment to the Search for Life on other Worlds, Kluwer, Dordrecht – Boston – London 2004.
• Shiller B. M., Origin of Life: The 5th Option, Tra*ord Publ., Victoria – Crewe 2004.
• Strick J. E., Sparks of Life. Darwinism and the Victorian Debates over Spontaneous Generation, Harvard University Press, Cambridge 2002.
• Świeżyński A., Nowożytne przemiany idei samorództwa, Roczniki Filozoficzne 57(2009)1, 195–229.
• Thomas P. J., Hicks R. D., Chyba C. F., McKay C. P. (eds.), Comets and the Origin and Evolution of Life, Springer, Berlin – Heidelberg 2006.
• Wickramasinghe N. C. (ed.), The Biological Big Bang. Panspermia and the Origins of Life, Cosmology Science Publ., Cambridge 2010.

Identifiers

DOI

10.21697/spch.2020.56.S2.05

Biblioteka Nauki

1070344