WIĘCEJ TEORII I WIĘCEJ PRAKTYKI? KSZTAŁCENIE INTERDYSCYPLINARNE I NIEDOGMATYCZNE W PROGRAMACH STUDIÓW PRAWNICZYCH AMERYKAŃSKICH UCZELNI

• Authors: Tymoteusz Zych
• Languages of publication: PL

Abstracts

PL

More Theory, more Practice? Interdisciplinary and NonDogmatic Education in American Law School CurriculaSummaryWhile American legal education is very often invoked as a modelfor Polish law faculties, the actual role of interdisciplinary and non--dogmatic courses in the curricula of American law schools has not beencoherently analysed yet. The American example shows that the conceptof legal education has a significant impact on the development of thelegal system. Interdisciplinary courses have been present in the curricula of university law schools since the beginning of American history.Currently the American Bar Association requires law schools to includenon-dogmatic contents in their curricula to obtain accreditation. Thewidest range of non-dogmatic courses is offered by the most prestigiouslaw schools. Leading American legal thinkers of all currents emphasisethe importance of interdisciplinary and non-dogmatic subjects in theeducational process. The paper concludes with a comparative analysisof the role of interdisciplinary subjects in law school curricula in Polandand in the United States.

Keywords

PL

edukacja prawnicza; przedmioty niedogmatyczne; kształcenie interdyscyplinarne; prawo anglosaskie

• Publisher: Uniwersytet Kardynała Stefana Wyszyńskiego w Warszawie
• Journal: Zeszyty Prawnicze
• Year: 2016
• Volume: 16
• Issue: 1
• Pages: 53-87

Dates

published

2016-12-01

Contributors

author

Tymoteusz Zych

References

• Baker John Hamilton, The Third University of England: Inns of Court and
• the Common-law Tradition, Ann Arbor 1990
• Berard Timothy J., The Relevance of Social Sciences for Legal Education,
• «Legal Education Review» 19.1/2009, s. 189-215
• Blackstone William, Commentaries on The Laws of England in Four Books,
• t. I, Philadelphia 1893
• Brown Brendan F., Recent Trends in United States Legal Education, «Journal
• of Legal Education» 26.3/1973-1974, s. 283-293
• Cardozo Benjamin N., The Growth of the Law, New Haven 1924
• Chroust Anton-Herman, The Beginning, Flourishing and Decline of the Inns
• of Court, «Vanderbilt Law Review» 10/1963, s. 79-123
• Cooper Byron D., The Integration of Theory, Doctrine and Practice in Legal
• Education, «Journal of the Association of Legal Writing Directors» 1/2002,
• s. 50-64
• Davis Peggy Cooper, Ehrenfest-Steinglass Elisabeth, A Dialogue about
• Socratic Teaching, «New York University Review of Law and Social Change»
• 2/1997, s. 249-279
• Derriman James, Pageantry of Law, London 1955
• Dworkin Ronald Myles, Biorąc prawa poważnie, tłum. T. Kowalski, Warszawa 1998
• El-Khawas Elaine, Accreditation in the USA. Origins, Developments and
• Future Prospects, Paris 2001
• Glendon Mary Ann, A Nation under Lawyers: How the Crisis of Legal Profession is Changing American Society, Cambridge-Massachusetts 1994
• Goodhart Arthur R., Case Law in England and America, «Cornell Law
• Quarterly» 15.2/1929-1930, s. 173-181
• Goodman Douglas J., Silbey Susan, Defending Liberal Arts from the Law,
• [w:] Law in Liberal Arts, Ithaca 2005, s. 17-40
• Grodziski Stanisław, Z dziejów staropolskiej kultury prawnej, Kraków 2004
• Hart Herbert Lionel Adolphus, Positivism and the Separation of Law and
• Morals, «Harvard Law Review», 71.4/1958, s. 593-629
• Hoffman David, A Course of Study, Respectfully Adressed to the Students of
• Law in the United States, Baltimore 1817
• Hollander Barnett, The English Bar, a Priesthood; the Tribute of an American Lawyer, London 1964
• Izdebski Hubert, Podsumowanie konferencji «Nauka i nauczanie prawa.
• Tradycja i przyszłość», [w:] Nauka i nauczanie prawa. Tradycja i przyszłość,
• Warszawa 2009
• Jenkins Iredell, Theory and Practice in Law, «University of Florida Law
• Review» 19.3/1966-1967, s. 404-425
• Kennedy Duncan, Carrington Paul, Legal Education and the Reproduction
• of Hierarchy: A Polemic against the System, New York 2004
• Kimball Bruce A., The Inception of Modern Professional Education: C.C.
• Langdell, 1826-1906, Chapel Hill 2009
• Korybski Andrzej, McClellan Marshall John, Systemy edukacji prawniczej w Polsce i USA – próba porównania, [w:] Studia z historii państwa,
• prawa i idei. Praca dedykowana profesorowi Janowi Malarczykowi, red.
• Korobowicz Artur, Olszewski Henryk, Lublin 1997, s. 181-196
• Kronman Anthony T., The Lost Lawyer: Failing Ideals of the Legal Profession,
• Cambridge-Massachusetts 2001
• Kruse Katherine R., Learning from Practice: what ADR needs from a Theory
• of Justice, «Nevada Law Journal» 5.2/2004-2005, s. 389-398
• Llewelyn Karl Nickerson, The Bramble Bush: on our Law and It’s Study,
• New York 1960
• Maxwell-Fyfe David, The Inns of Court and their Impact on the Legal Profession in England, «Southwestern Law Journal» 4/1950, s. 391-397.
• McManis Charles R., The History of First Century American Legal Education: A Revisionist Perspective, «Washington University Law Quarterly»
• 3/1981, s. 597-659
• Mell Patricia, Crossing the Bar – Law Schools and Their Disciples, «Michigan
• Bar Journal» 79.10/2000, s. 1392-1397.
• Menkel-Meadow Carrie, Too Little Theory, too Little Practice? Stevens’s „Law
• School”, «American Bar Foundation Research Journal» 10.3/1985, s. 675-690
• Moline Brian J., Early American Legal Education, «Washburn Law Journal»
• 4/2002-2003, s. 775-802
• Newman Stephen A., Using Shakespeare to Teach Persuasive Advocacy, «Journal of Legal Education» 57.3/2007, s. 36-59
• Osiatyński Wiktor, Czy każdy prawnik musi być uczonym?, [w:] Humanizacja
• zawodów prawniczych a nauczanie akademickie, Warszawa 2003, s. 67-71
• Pollock Frederick, The Origins of the Inns of Court, «Law Quarterly Review»
• /1932, s. 163-170
• Posner Richard R., The Decline of Law as an Autonomous Discipline: 1962-
• , «Harvard Law Review» 100.4/1987, s. 761-780
• Prest Wilfrid, The Learning Exercises at the Inns of Court 1590-1640, «The
• Journal of the Society of the Public Teachers of Law» 9.3/1966-1967, s. 301-313
• Proctor Polly Beth, Toward Mythos and Mythology: Applying a Feminist
• Critique to Legal Education to Effactuate a Socialization of Both Sexes in
• Law School Classrooms, «Cardozo Women’s Law Journal» 10.3/2003-2004,
• s. 577-602
• Rau Zbigniew, Nauki społeczne i humanistyczne w wykształceniu prawniczym
• z perspektywy dydaktyki doktryn polityczno-prawnych, [w:] Humanizacja
• zawodów prawniczych a nauczanie akademickie, Warszawa 2003, s. 61-65
• Scalia Antonin, A Matter of Interpetation: Federal Courts and the Law,
• Princeton 1997
• Schlegel John, More Theory, More Practice, «Legal Service Bulletin» 13.2/1988,
• s. 71-73
• Schoenfeld Marcus, J.D. or LL.B as the Basic Law Degree, «Cleveland-
• -Marshall Law Review» 12.3/1963, s. 573–579
• Schuwerk Robert P., Reflections on Ethics and Mediation, «South Texas Law
• Review» 38.2/1997, s. 757-768
• Stake Jeffrey Evans, The Interplay between Law School Rankings, Reputations, and Resource Allocation: Ways Rankings Mislead, «Indiana Law
• Journal» 81.1/2006, s. 230-279
• Stein Ralph Michael, The Path of Legal Education from Edward I to Langdell:
• a History of Insular Reaction, «Chicago-Kent Law Review» 57.2/1981,
• s. 429-454.
• Stevens Robert, Law school: Legal Education in America from the 1850s to
• the 1980s, Chapel Hill 1983
• Story Joseph, The Inauguration of Author as Dane Professor of Law, [w:] The
• History of Legal Education in the United States: Commentaries and Primary
• Sources, Philadelphia 1999, s. 297-317
• W. Sullivan, A. Colby, J.W. Wegner, L. Bond, L.S. Shulman, Educating
• Lawyers: Preparation for the Profession of Law, San Francisco 1999
• Tokarczyk Roman, Prawo amerykańskie, Warszawa 2009
• Turska Anna, Refleksja o modelu edukacyjnym prawników naszych czasów,
• «Przegląd Prawniczy Uniwersytetu Warszawskiego» 6.2/2007, s. 116-123
• Tushnet Mark, The Interdisciplinary Legal Scholarship: Case of History-in-
• -Law, «Chicago-Kent Law Review» 71.3/1995-1996, s. 909-935
• Zoll Fryderyk, Jaka szkoła prawa?, Kraków 2004.

Identifiers

DOI

10.21697/zp.2016.16.1.03