Making Indigenous Religion at the San Francisco Peaks: Navajo Discourses and Strategies of Familiarization

• Authors: Seth Schermerhorn

Abstracts

EN

Navajo claims pertaining to the sacredness of the San Francisco Peaks (as well as those of several other Native American tribes), while no doubt profoundly sincere, are necessarily and strategically positioned in relation to the contemporary legal struggles within which they have arisen. However, I cannot stress too heavily that this should not suggest that their claims are spurious, invented, or in other words “inauthentic.” Greg Johnson asserts that “frequently, the specter against which authenticity is measured is what critics might call “postured tradition,” a shorthand means of suggesting that tradition expressed in political contexts is ‘merely political’” (2007: 3). To be sure, the discourses that posit the sacredness of the Peaks are fundamentally and simultaneously both religious and political; yet this does not necessarily mean that traditional religious claims made in contemporary political contexts are motivated by purely political considerations. Although these claims are necessarily formulated to persuade others of the incontestable “authenticity” of their claims, I suggest that the degree to which this incontestability is achieved is directly related to an accumulation and accretion of discourse resulting from nearly four decades of continuing conflict at the Peaks.

Keywords

EN

religion-making; Indigenous; Navajo; authenticity; sacred places; San Francisco Peaks

• Publisher: University of Silesia Press
• Journal: Review of International American Studies
• Year: 2023
• Volume: 16
• Issue: 1
• Pages: 143-186

Dates

published

2023

Contributors

author

Seth Schermerhorn

• Hamilton College

• https://orcid.org/0009000805404190

References

• Aronilth, Wilson, Jr. Foundation of Navajo Culture. Navajo Community College Press, 1992.
• Beck, Peggy, et al. The Sacred: Ways of Knowledge, Sources of Life. Navajo Community College Press, 1992.
• Benally, Klee. Interviewed on KPFK, Pacifica Radio in Los Angeles. UPRISING: Subverting the Airwaves, uprising.org/home/?p=2170. Accessed 13 March 2008.
• Bernbaum, Edwin. Sacred Mountains of the World. Sierra Club Books, 1990.
• Bingham, Sam, and Janet Bingham, eds. Between Sacred Mountains: Navajo Stories and Lessons from the Land. Suntracks and U of Arizona P, 1982.
• Brown, Brian Edward. Religion, Law, and the Land: Native Americans and the Judicial Interpretation of Sacred Land. Greenwood Press, 1999.
• Brugge, David M. “Navajo Prehistory and History to 1850.” Handbook of North American Indian, Volume 10: Southwest, Alfonso Ortiz, ed. Washington: Smithsonian Institution, 1983, pp. 489-501.
• Buckland, A. W. “Four as a Sacred Number.” The Journal of the Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland, vol. 25, 1896, pp. 96-102.
• Chidester, David, and Edward T. Linenthal, eds. American Sacred Space. Indiana UP, 1995.
• Cline, Platt. They Came to the Mountain: The Story of Flagstaff’s Beginnings. Northern Arizona U and Northland P, 1976.
• Correll, J. Lee, and Editha L. Watson, eds. Welcome to the Land of the Navajo: A Book of Information About the Navajo Indians. Navajo Times Publishing, 1969.
• Cronon, William, ed. Uncommon Ground: Rethinking the Human Place in Nature. W. W. Norton & Company, 1996.
• Deloria, Vine, Jr. “Comfortable Fictions and the Struggle for Turf: An Essay Review of The Invented Indian: Cultural Fictions and Government Policies.” Natives and Academics: Researching and Writing about American Indians, edited by Devon Mihesuah. U of Nebraska P, 1998, pp. 65-83.
• Draper, Electra. “Tribes Fight Ski Area over Sacred Site.” Denver Post, 18 October 2005. http:www.denverpost.com/ci_3126412?rss#. Accessed 28 April 2006.
• Evans-Wentz, W. Y. Cuchama and Sacred Mountains, edited by Frank Waters and Charles L. Adams. Swallow Press, 1981.
• Farella, John R. The Main Stalk: A Synthesis of Navajo Philosophy. U of Arizona P, 1984.
• Fink, Jameson M. The Hart Prairie/San Francisco Peaks Controversy: Culture, Land, and Conflict. 1998. Northern Arizona University, MA thesis.
• Frisbie, Charlotte J. Navajo Medicine Bundles, or Jish: Acquisition, Transmission, and Disposition in the Past and Present. U of New Mexico P, 1987.
• Gill, Sam. Mother Earth: An American Story. U of Chicago P, 1987.
• - - -. Native American Religious Action: A Performance Approach to Religion. U of South Carolina P, 1987.
• - - -. “Navajo Views of Their Origin,” Handbook of North American Indian, Volume 10: Southwest, edited by Alfonso Ortiz. Smithsonian Institution, 1983, pp. 502-05.
• - - -. Sacred Words: A Study of Navajo Religion and Prayer. Greenwood Press, 1981.
• Griffen, Joyce. “Skating in the Sistine Chapel: The San Francisco Peaks and (Non-) Implementation of the American Indian Religious Freedom Act.” American Anthropological Association Annual Meeting, November 1983, Chicago, IL. Conference paper.
• Griffin-Pierce, Trudy. Earth is My Mother, Sky is My Father: Space, Time and Astronomy in Navajo Sandpainting. U of New Mexico P, 1992.
• Hallowell, A. Irving. “Ojibwa Ontology, Behavior, and World View.” Culture in History: Essays in Honor of Paul Radin, edited by Stanley Diamond. Columbia UP, 1960, pp. 18-52.
• - - -. “Ojibwa Ontology, Behavior, and World View.” Teachings from the American Earth: Indian Religion and Philosophy, edited by Dennis Tedlock and Barbara Tedlock. Liveright Press, 1975, pp. 139-78.
• Hardeen, George. “Navajo Nation today files appeal in San Francisco Peaks court decision.” Navajo Nation Press Release, 27 February 2006. http://www.navajo.org/images/pdf%20releases/George%20Hardeen/feb06/Navajo%20Nation%20appeals%20Peaks%20decision%20for%20Feb%20%2027.pdf. Accessed 20 November 2006.
• Harjo, Suzan. “O’Connor’s Footprints on Native Sacred Lands.” Indian Country Today, 14 January 2005, p. A3.
• Hobsbawm, Eric, and Terence Ranger, eds. The Invention of Tradition. Cambridge UP, 1983.
• Hopi Cultural Preservation Office. “The Navajo-Hopi Land Issue: A Chronology.” http://www.nau.edu/~hcpo-p/current/Chronology.html. Accessed 1 April 2008.
• In The Light of Reverence. Directed by Christopher McLeod. Bullfrog Films, 2001.
• Indianz.com. “Navajo president testifies in San Francisco Peaks trial.” 3 November 2005. http://www.indianz.com/News/2005/011110.asp. Accessed 20 November 2006.
• Iverson, Peter. Diné: A History of the Navajos. U of New Mexico P, 2002.
• Jenkins, Philip. Dream Catchers: How Mainstream America Discovered Native Spirituality. Oxford UP, 2004.
• Johnson, Greg. “Apache Revelation: Making Indigenous Religion in the Legal Sphere.” Secularism and Religion-Making, edited by Markus Dressler and Arvind Mandair. Oxford UP, 2011., pp. 170-86.
• - - -. Sacred Claims: Repatriation and Living Tradition. U of Virginia P, 2007.
• Kelley, Klara Bonsack, and Harris Francis. Navajo Sacred Places. Indiana UP, 1994.
• Kirk, Nancy, and Jim Kirk. Editorial. Arizona Daily Sun, 5 November 2002.
• LaDuke, Winona. Recovering the Sacred: The Power of Naming and Claiming. South End Press, 2005.
• Lakoff, George, and Mark Johnson. Metaphors We Live By. U of Chicago P, 1980.
• Lincoln, Bruce. Discourse and the Construction of Society: Comparative Studies of Myth, Ritual, and Classification. Oxford UP, 1989.
• Linford, Laurence D. Navajo Places: History, Legend, Landscape. U of Utah P, 2000.
• Lloyd, Harvey. Sacred Lands of the Southwest. Monacelli Press, 1995.
• Lubick, George. “Sacred Mountains, Kachinas, and Skiers: The Controversy over the San Francisco Peaks.” The American West: Essays in Honor of W. Eugene Hollon, edited by Ronald Lora. U of Toledo P, 1980, pp. 133-54.
• Luckert, Karl W. Navajo Mountain and Rainbow Bridge Religion. Museum of Northern Arizona Press, 1977.
• - - -. The Navajo Hunter Tradition. U of Arizona P, 1975.
• Matthaissen, Peter. Indian Country. 1979. Viking Press, 1984.
• Matthews, Washington. Navaho Legends. 1897. U of Utah P, 1994.
• Mazur, Eric Michael. The Americanization of Religious Minorities: Confronting the Constitutional Order. Johns Hopkins UP, 1999.
• McNeley, James Kale. Holy Wind in Navajo Philosophy. U of Arizona P, 1981.
• McPherson, Robert S. Sacred Land, Sacred View: Navajo Perceptions of the Four Corners Region. Signature Books, 1992.
• Michaelsen, Robert S. “American Indian Religious Freedom Litigation: Promise and Perils.” Journal of Law and Religion, vol. 3, no. 1, 1985, pp. 47-76.
• Nabokov, Peter. Where the Lightning Strikes: The Lives of American Indian Sacred Places. Penguin Books, 2006.
• - - -. A Forest of Time: American Indian Ways of History. Cambridge UP, 2002.
• Norrel, Brenda. “Lawsuit filed to halt Peaks desecration.” Indian Country Today. 13 July 2005, p. B1.
• O’Bryan, Aileen. “The Diné: Origin Myths of the Navaho Indians,” Bureau of American Ethnography Bulletin 163. U.S. Government Printing Office, 1956.
• Opler, Morris E. “The Apachean Culture Pattern and Its Origins,” Handbook of North American Indian, Volume 10: Southwest, edited by Alfonso Ortiz. Smithsonian Institution, 1983, pp. 368-92.
• Patton, Laurie L. Who Owns Religion?: Scholars and their Publics in the Late Twentieth Century. U of Chicago P, 2019.
• Pinxten, Rik, et al. Anthropology of Space: Explorations into the Natural Philosophy and Semantics of the Navajo. U of Pennsylvania P, 1983.
• Pratt, Mary Louise. Imperial Eyes: Travel Writing and Transculturation. Routledge, 1992.
• Preston, Douglas. Talking to the Ground: One Family’s Journey on Horseback Across the Sacred Land of the Navajo. Simon & Schuster, 1995.
• Reichard, Gladys A. Navaho Religion: A Study of Symbolism. 1950. Princeton UP, 1963.
• Roa, Raul. “Tribes Protest Federal Plans for Sacred Peaks,” SGV Tribune. 10 December 2007. http://www.savethepeaks.org/. Accessed 18 December 2007.
• Schwarz, Maureen Trudelle. Molded in the Image of Changing Woman: Navajo Views on the Human Body and Personhood. U of Arizona P, 1997.
• Sefiha, Ophir, and Pat Lauderdale. “Sacred Mountains and Profane Dollars: Discourses about Snowmaking on the San Francisco Peaks.” Social & Legal Studies, vol. 17, no. 4, 2008, pp. 491-511.
• Schermerhorn, Seth. Walking to Magdalena: Personhood and Place in Tohono O’odham Songs, Sticks, and Stories. U of Nebraska P, 2019.
• - - -. “Secularisation by the ‘Sacred’?: Discourses of ‘Religion’ and the San Francisco Peaks.” Eras, vol. 11, 2009, pp. 1-17.
• - - -. Regulating Desecration and the San Francisco Peaks: Native American Sacred Land Claims and the Problem of Authenticity. 2008. University Colorado, MA thesis.
• Shaffer, Mark. “Peaks’ Sacred Essence Key to Tribes’ Fight vs. Snowbowl.” Arizona Republic, 7 June 2005. http://www.azcentral.com/arizonarepublic/news/articles/0607peaks06.html. Accessed 28 April 2006.
• Smith, Jonathan Z. “God Save this Honorable Court: Religion and Civic Discourse.” Relating Religion: Essays in the Study of Religion. U of Chicago P, 2004, pp. 375-390.
• Sullivan, Winnifred Fallers. The Impossibility of Religious Freedom. Princeton UP, 2005.
• The Snowbowl Effect. Directed by Klee Benally. Indigenous Action Media, 2005.
• United States, Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit. Wilson v. Block, 20 May 1983.
• United States, Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit, en banc. Navajo Nation v. United States Forest Service, 8 August 2008.
• United States, Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit. Navajo Nation v. United States Forest Service, 12 March 2007.
• United States, Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit. Badoni v. Higginson. 3 November 1980.
• United States, District Court, District of Arizona. Navajo Nation v. United States Forest Service, 11 January 2006.
• - - -. Navajo Nation v. United States Forest Service, 2005.
• United States, Supreme Court. Employment Division of Oregon v. Smith. 17 April 1990.
• - - -. Lyng v. Northwest Indian Cemetery Protective Association. 19 April 1988.
• Van Otten, George A. ed. Respecting a Mountain: Proceedings of the Arizona Humanities Council-Forum on Development of Arizona Snow Bowl on the San Francisco Peaks, Arizona. Northern Arizona University Department of Geography, 1982.
• Van Valkenburgh, Richard F. “Navajo Sacred Places.” Navajo Indians III, edited by Clyde Kluckhohn. Garland Publishing, 1974.
• Walker, Deward. “Protection of American Indian Sacred Geography.” Handbook of American Indian Religious Freedom, edited by Christopher Vecsey. Crossroad Publishing, 1991, pp. 100-15.
• Wenger, Tisa. We Have a Religion: The 1920’s Pueblo Indian Dance Controversy and American Religious Freedom. U of North Carolina P, 2009.
• Winter, Joseph C. “Navajo Sacred Sites and the Transwestern Pipeline Expansion Project.” Papers from the Third, Fourth, and Sixth Navajo Studies Conferences, edited by June-e1 Piper. Navajo Nation Historical Preservation Department, 1993, pp. 65-109.
• Witherspoon, Gary. Language and Art in the Navajo Universe. U of Michigan P, 1977.
• - - -. Navajo Kinship and Marriage. U of Chicago P, 1975.
• Wyman, Leland C., ed. Beautyway: A Navajo Ceremonial. Pantheon Books, 1957.
• - - -. The Mountainway of the Navajo. U of Arizona P, 1975.
• - - -. The Sacred Mountains of the Navajo in Four Paintings by Harrison Begay. Museum of Northern Arizona and Northland Press, 1967.
• Young, Robert W. and William Morgan. Navajo Historical Selections. Bureau of Indian Affairs, 1941.
• Zolbrod, Paul G. Diné Bahane’: The Navajo Creation Story. U of New Mexico P, 1984.

Identifiers

DOI

10.31261/rias.13800

Biblioteka Nauki

27177623