Obiektywistyczna teoria prawa własności intelektualnej i jej krytyka

• Authors: Cezary Błaszczyk

Title variants

Obiektywistyczna teoria prawa własności intelektualnej i jej krytyka

• Languages of publication: PL

Abstracts

EN

Among many libertarian theories of property, the objectivist “creationist” is one of the most interesting – especially when applied to the problem of intellectual property. First, it is deontological and rules out fiduciary titles to ideal goods based on the positive law. Second, it legitimizes both patents and copyright and regards these institutions as kinds of property. This of course poses a challenge for a system that claims that a right to (acquire) property is absolute. Third, Ayn Rand’s philosophy cherishes great minds of entrepreneurs, inventors and artists, thus making its stance on IP even more significant. Set in Lockean desert-justice, labor theory of property, objectivism claims that an act of projection of a labor onto the nature comprises both physical and mental aspects. A thing to be appropriated needs to be recognized as “a good” first (and thus it is created; moreover, ideal goods are created ex nihilo). Although, the creationist theory cannot overcome the difficulties produced by equally absolute titles of things and ideal goods (and thus it is to be regarded as inconsistent), it is interesting for the legal philosophers and jurists alike. It evokes not only the question of axiological basis for the intellectual property, but also of the correctness of propertarian model of copyright and patents.

Keywords

PL

prawo własności intelektualnej; kreacjonistyczna teoria własności; obiektywistyczna teoria własności; teoria prawa; własność intelektualna; prawo własności; teoretycy; libertarianizm; right of intellectual property; objectivist theory of intellectual property; theory of the law; intellectual property; libertarianism; prawo własności intelektualnej; kreacjonistyczna teoria własności; obiektywistyczna teoria własności; teoria prawa; własność intelektualna; prawo własności; teoretycy; libertarianizm; right of intellectual property; objectivist theory of intellectual property; theory of the law; intellectual property; libertarianism

EN

right of intellectual property; objectivist theory of intellectual property; theory of the law; intellectual property; libertarianism

• Publisher: Instytut Nauk Prawnych PAN / Institute of Legal Studies PAN
• Journal: Studia Prawnicze
• Year: 2016
• Issue: 4 (208)
• Pages: 87-102

Dates

published

2016-09-01

Contributors

author

Cezary Błaszczyk

• Uniwersytet Warszawski

Identifiers

DOI

10.37232/sp.2016.4.4