Via Pulchritudinis: the narrative of violence and vulnerability in painting in view of Hans-Georg Gadamer’s hermeneutic aesthetics

• Authors: Malgorzata Holda

Abstracts

EN

In the article, I explore the many faces of violence and vulnerability evoked in religious and secular painting. Drawing upon Hans-Georg Gadamer’s phenomenology of art as play, I aim to show that the creative activity of both the artist and the viewer exceeds the mere actualization of the past event or the instantiation of poetic fantasy. Bringing into conversation Bosch’s, Caravaggio’s, Millais’s, and Waterhouse’s masterpieces, this essay interrogates how their embodiments of the uncanny proximity of violence and vulnerability as two conflicting sides of our human experience complicate the expected symmetry and clear-cut distinction between belligerency and gentleness, powerfulness and the powerlessness, benevolence and malevolence. Inviting us to appreciate the authenticity of their subtle meanings in the continuous veiling and unveiling (Verbegung/Entbergung) of truth, the selected artworks prompt, simultaneously, a possibility of our self-recognition. In the process of our patient tarrying in front of them, we are called on to attend to and acknowledge the more complex realities that speak to our lived experience and defy its apparent homogeneity.

Keywords

EN

art; violence; vulnerability; Hans-Georg Gadamer; hermeneutic aesthetics

• Publisher: Wydawnictwo Naukowe Chrześcijańskiej Akademii Teologicznej w Warszawie
• Journal: Studia z Teorii Wychowania
• Year: 2023
• Volume: XIV(2 (43))
• Pages: 161-186

Dates

published

2023

Contributors

author

Malgorzata Holda

• University of Lodz, Poland

References

• Appelbaum, R. (2017). The Aesthetics of Violence: Art, Fiction, Drama and Film. London–New York: Rowman & Littlefield.
• Beal, J. (2019). The Unicorn as a Symbol for Christ in the Middle Ages. In J. Beal (Ed.), Illuminating Jesus in the Middle Ages (154–188). Leiden: Brill.
• Bosing, W. (2000). Hieronymus Bosch, C. 1450–1516: Between Heaven and Hell, Köln–London–Los Angeles–Madrid–Paris–Tokyo: Taschen.
• Boyiopoulos, K. & Sandy, M. (Eds.) (2016). Decadent Romanticism: 1780-1914. Routledge: London & New York.
• Cohen, M. (1995). Sisters: Relation and Rescue in Nineteenth-century British Novels and Paintings. Associated University Press: London & Toronto.
• Capron, E. (2021). Hieronymus Bosch’s “Christ Mocked” in 10 minutes, National Gallery. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UId53499sTI [accessed 12 Nov 2022].
• Cavallaro, D., J.W. (2017). Waterhouse and the Magic of Color. Jefferson: McFarland & Company.
• Caravaggio: Judith and Holofernes analysis (2020, 9 September). https://ndrw.me/caravaggio-judith-and-holofernes-analysis [accessed 1 Dec 2022].
• Christ Mocked (The Crowning with Thorns). Art UK. https://artuk.org/discover/artworks/christ-mocked-the-crowning-with-thorns-114461 [accessed 1 Dec 2022].
• Cook, W. (2016). Master of dark arts: Why Caravaggio casts a long shadow. BBC Arts, 12 October. https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/articles/zPM37p10WC7ZnDGlZVY04R/master-of-dark-arts-why-caravaggio-casts-a-long-shadow [accessed 10 Oct 2022].
• Davey, N. (2016). Gadamer’s Aesthetics. In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Winter 2016 Edition). https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2016/entries/gadamer-aesthetics/ [accessed Nov 2022].
• Eberhard, P. (2004). The Middle Voice in Gadamer’s Hermeneutics: A Basic Interpretation with Some Theological Implications. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck.
• Fernow, J. (2022). Das Einhorn – von magischen Missverständnissen, Jungfrauen und Jesus Christus. Deutsche Digitale Bibliothek. Kultur und Wissen Online, 21 July. https://www.deutsche-digitale-bibliothek.de/content/journal/entdecken/das-einhorn-von-magischen-missverstaendnissen-jungfrauen-und-jesus-christus/ [accessed 18 Nov 2022].
• Gadamer, H.-G. (1976). Philosophical Hermeneutics. Edited by D.E. Linge, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
• Gadamer, H.-G. (1986). The Relevance of the Beautiful and Other Essays. Translated by N. Walker. Edited by R. Bernasconi. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
• Gadamer, H-G. (1987). GW3: Neuere Philosophie, I: Hegel. Husserl. Heidegger. Tübingen: J. C. B. Mohr.
• Gadamer, H-G. (2000). Truth and Method. Edited and translated by Joel Weinsheimer and Donald G. Marshall. New York: Continuum.
• Gadamer, H.-G. (2007). The Gadamer Reader: A Bouquet of the Later Writings. Edited by R. E. Palmer. Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press.
• Grondin, J. (2002a). Gadamer’s Basic Understanding of Understanding. In The Cambridge Companion to Gadamer (36–51). Edited by R. Dostal. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
• Grondin, J. (2002b). The Philosophy of Gadamer. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
• George, T. (2011). From Work to Play: Gadamer on the Affinity of Art, Truth, and Beauty. Internationales Jahrbuch für Hermeneutik, 10, 107–122.
• Hieronymus Bosch: At the Border of Disorder (2016). Eatthehipster, 5 September. https://eatthehipster.org/2016/09/05/hieronymus-bosch-at-the-border-of-disorder/ [accessed 1 Dec 2022].
• Hieronymus Bosch, Christ Mocked (The Crowning with Thorns), National Gallery, London. https://www.nationalgallery.org.uk/paintings/hieronymus-bosch-christ-mocked-the-crowning-with-thorns [accessed 30 Nov 2022].
• Hołda, M. (2020). L’homme agissant and Self-understanding: Pamela Sue Anderson on Capability and Vulnerability. Text Matters, 10, 7–24.
• Hołda, M. (2021). On Beauty and Being: Hans-Georg Gadamer’s and Virginia Woolf’s Hermeneutics of the Beautiful. Berlin: Peter Lang.
• Judith Beheading Holofernes, 1599 by Caravaggio. Caravaggio. Paintings, Quotes, Biography. http://www.caravaggio.org/judith-beheading-holofernes.jsp [accessed 23 Sep 2022].
• Judith Beheading Holofernes, Gallerie Nazionali Barberini Corsini. https://www.barberinicorsini.org/en/opera/judith-beheading-holofernes/ [accessed 30 Nov 2022].
• Keats J. (1988). La Belle Dames sans Merci. In J. Keats, Selected Poems, London: Penguin Classics https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/44475/la-belle-dame-sans-merci-a-ballad [accessed 1 Oct 2022].
• Kern, S. (1996). Eyes of Love: The Gaze in English and French Paintings and Novels, 1840-1900. London: Reaktion Books.
• King James Bible. https://www.kingjamesbibleonline.org
• Langdon, H. (2012). Caravaggio: A Life. London: Random House.
• Lewis-Anthony, J. (2008). Circles of Thorns: Hieronymus Bosch and Being Human. London & New York: Continuum.
• Maunder, A. & Phegley, J. (Eds.) (2010). Teaching Nineteenth-Century Fiction. London: Palgrave MacMillan.
• Nixon, A. G. (2010). Caravaggio: A Life Sacred and Profane. London: Penguin Books.
• Ostbye, G. (2022). Feminism & Violence Coexist in Artemisia Gentileschi’s Judith. Art & Objects, 20 May. https://www.artandobject.com/news/feminism-violence-coexist-artemisia-gentileschis-judith [accessed 30 Sep 2022].
• Pearson, R. (2010). Fiction and the Visual Arts. In A. Maunder & J. Phegley (Eds.), Teaching Nineteenth-Century Fiction (131–147). London: Palgrave MacMillan.
• Prettejohn, E. (2012). The Cambridge Companion to the Pre-Raphaelites. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
• Ricoeur, P. (2007). Autonomy and Vulnerability. In P. Ricoeur, Reflections on the Just. Translated by D. Pellauer (72–90). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
• Robinson, M. D. (2022). The Surreal Life of Hieronymus Bosch. Art & Objects, 8 December. https://www.artandobject.com/news/surreal-life-hieronymus-bosch?utm_medium=email&utm_source=notes_eletter&utm_campaign=20221208&eletter=1 [accessed 3 Nov 2022].
• Rowland, I. D. (2016). The Mystery of Hieronymus Bosch. The New York Review, 18 August. https://www.nybooks.com/articles/2016/08/18/mystery-of-hieronymus-bosch/ [accessed ¬¬¬¬¬30 Sep 2022].
• Schmidt, L. K. (Ed.) (2000). Language and Linguisticality in Gadamer’s Hermeneutics. Lanham–Boulder–New York–Oxford: Lexington Books.
• Scott, G.F. (1999), “Language Strange: A Visual History of Keats’s ‘La Belle Dame sans Merci.’” Studies in Romanticism, 38: 4, 503–535.
• The Black Brunswicker (2018). WikiArt. Visual Art Encyclopedia, 9 November. https://www.wikiart.org/en/john-everett-millais/the-black-brunswicker-1860 [accessed 10 Nov 2022].
• The Many Faces of Judith (2019). The Brooklyn Art Historian, 2 June. https://thebrooklynarthistorian.com/2019/06/02/the-many-faces-of-judith (2 June) [accessed 3 Aug 2022].
• Troiano G., Mercurio I., Nante N. & Bacci M. (2017). Caravaggio’s Judith and Holofernes: a forensic approach. Egyptian Journal of Forensic Sciences, 7, article 26. https://doi.org/10.1186/s41935-017-0020-z [accessed 12 Oct 2022].
• Wierciński, A. (2019a). Hermeneutics of Education: Exploring and Experiencing the Unpredictability of Education. Zürich: LIT Verlag.
• Wierciński, A. (2019b). Phronetic Education to Integrity: Capability, Courage, and Passion for Thinking. Phainomena. Journal of Phenomenology and Hermeneutics, 28(110–111), 5–15.
• William Blake’s Songs of Innocence and Experience. Tate. https://www.tate.org.uk/art/artists/william-blake-39/blakes-songs-innocence-experience [accessed 26 Nov 2022].
• Zucker, S. & Harris B. (2015). The Unicorn Tapestries. Smarthistory, 29 November. https://www.bing.com/videos/search?q=medieval+tapestries+unicorn+youtube&docid=608005449374710198&mid=26F0F22CE350D3D6D97026F0F22CE350D3D6D970&view=detail&FORM=VIRE [accessed 1 Sept 2022].

Identifiers

DOI

10.5604/01.3001.0053.9079

Biblioteka Nauki

36797160