Judas Maccabeus’ Wars Against Judaea’s Neighbours in 1 Maccabees 5: A Reassessment of the Evidence

• Authors: Berthelot Katell
• Languages of publication: EN

Abstracts

EN

The fifth chapter of the First Book of Maccabees recounts a whole range of wars waged by Judas Maccabeus against Judaea’s neighbours, who are depicted as threatening the lives of the Jews living in their midst. The account of these punitive expeditions contains the only explicit reference found in the book to an anathema (ḥerem) against a foreign people, a reference which has led some scholars to see Judas as re-enacting the biblical prescription of the ḥerem against the Canaanites. In contrast with this interpretation, the present article argues that the description in 1 Maccabees 5 is highly literary and rhetorical, and that it is part of a strategy which aims at presenting Judas as the heir of the first kings of Israel. In particular, a careful literary analysis shows that nearly all the differences between the accounts in 1 and 2 Maccabees can be explained by taking into consideration the project of the author to present Judas’s military expeditions in the light of Saul’s campaigns, following 1 Samuel 10–15 (especially 14:47–48). Given the indebtedness of 1 Maccabees 5 toward such biblical traditions, the historicity of Judas’s wars against Judaea’s neighbours should be re-assessed.

Keywords

EN

history of Second Temple Judaism; 1 Maccabees 5; Judas Maccabeus; biblical models

• Publisher: Uniwersytet Jagielloński
• Journal: Electrum
• Year: 2014
• Volume: 21
• Pages: 73–85

Dates

online

2015-03-03

Contributors

author

Berthelot Katell

• CNRS / Universite Aix-Marseille, 58 Boulevard Charles Livon, 13284 Marseille, France

References

• Abadie, P. (2014, forthcoming): Le Premier Livre des Maccabées : une écriture entre mémoire et relecture, in: M.-F. Baslez, O. Münnich (eds.), La mémoire des persécutions: Autour des livres des Maccabées, Leuven.
• Abel, F.-M. (1949), Les livres des Maccabées, Paris.
• Abel, F.-M. (1952), Histoire de la Palestine: Depuis la conquête d’Alexandre jusqu’à l’invasion arabe, vol. 1, Paris.
• Arenhoevel, D. (1967), Die Theokratie nach dem 1. und 2. Makkabäerbuch, Mainz.
• Attridge, H.W. (1984), Historiography, in: M.E. Stone (ed.), Jewish Writings of the Second Temple Period: Apocrypha, Pseudepigrapha, Qumran Sectarian Writings, Philo, Josephus, Minneapolis: 157–184.
• Bartlett, J.B. (1973), The First and Second Books of the Maccabees, Cambridge.
• Batsch, C. (2005), La guerre et les rites de guerre dans le judaïsme du deuxième Temple, Leiden.
• Berthelot, K. (2007), The Biblical Conquest of the Promised Land and the Hasmonean Wars according to 1 and 2 Maccabees, in: G. Xeravits, J. Zsengellér (eds.), The Books of Maccabees: History, Theology, Ideology, Leiden: 45–60.
• Corley, J. (2011), Canonical Assimilation in Ben Sira’s Portrayal of Joshua and Samuel, in: J. Corley, H. van Grol (eds.), Rewriting Biblical History: Essays on Chronicles and Ben Sira in Honor of Pancratius C. Beentjes, Berlin–New York: 57–77.
• Dommershausen, W. (1985), 1 Makkabäer – 2 Makkabäer, Würzburg.
• Goldstein, J.A. (1983), I Maccabees: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary, The Anchor Bible 41A, New York.
• Goldstein, J.A. (1987), How the Authors of 1 and 2 Maccabees Treated the ‘Messianic’ Promises, in: J. Neusner et al. (eds.), Judaisms and Their Messiahs at the Turn of the Christian Era, Cambridge: 69–96.
• Graetz, H. (1891), History of the Jews, vol. 1, New York.
• Grimm, C.L.W. (1853), Das erste Buch der Maccabäer, Leipzig.
• Honigman, S. (2014), Tales of High Priests and Taxes: The Books of the Maccabees and the Judean Rebellion against Antiochos IV, Berkeley.
• Horsley, R.A. (2002), The Expansion of Hasmonean Rule in Idumea and Galilee: Toward a Historical Sociology, in: Ph. Davies, J. M. Halligan (eds.), Second Temple Studies III. Studies in Politics, Class and Material Culture, Sheffield: 134–165.
• Kappler, W. (1936), Maccabaeorum libri I–IV, fasc. 1. Maccabaeorum liber I, Göttingen.
• Lichtenberger, H. (2005), Geschichtsschreibung und Geschichtserzählung im 1. und 2. Makkabäerbuch, in: E.-M. Becker (ed.), Die antike Historiographie und die Anfänge der christlichen Geschichtsschreibung, Berlin: 197–212.
• Manning B., Metzger H.G. (1977), The New Oxford Annotated Bible with the Apocrypha: Revised Standard Version, Containing the Second Edition of the New Testament and an Expanded Edition of the Apocrypha, New York.
• Mendels, D. (2004), Memory in Jewish, Pagan and Christian Societies of the Graeco-Roman World, London–New York.
• Park, H.D. (2007), Finding Herem? A Study of Luke-Acts in the Light of Herem, London.
• Parker, V.L. (2006), Judas Maccabaeus’ Campaigns Against Timothy, Biblica 87: 457–476.
• Rappaport U. (2001), 1 Maccabees, in: J. Barton, J. Muddiman (eds.), The Oxford Bible Commentary, Oxford: 710–734.
• Rappaport, U. (2004), The First Book of Maccabees. Introduction, Hebrew Translation, and Commentary, Jerusalem [Hebr.].
• Regev, E. (2013), The Hasmoneans: Ideology, Archaeology, Identity, Göttingen.
• Schwartz, D.R. (1998), The Other in 1 and 2 Maccabees, in: G.N. Danton, M.J. Bernstein (eds.), Reading 4QMMT. New Perspectives on Qumran Law and History, Atlanta: 68–80.
• Schwartz, D.R. (2011), Mattathias’ Final Speech (1 Maccabees 2): From Religious Zeal to Simonide Propaganda, in: A.M. Maeir, J. Magness, L.H. Schiffman (eds.), ‘Go Out and Study the Land’ (Judges 18:2). Archaeological, Historical and Textual Studies in Honor of Hanan Eshel, Leiden: 213–223.
• Schwartz, J. (1990), Once more on the “boundary of Gezer.” Inscriptions and history of Gezer and Lydda at the end of the Second Temple Period, IEJ 40: 47–57.
• Schwartz, S. (1991): Israel and the Nations Roundabout. I Maccabees and the Hasmonean Expansion, JJS 42: 16–38.
• Shatzman, I. (2007): Jews and Gentiles from Judas Maccabaeus to John Hyrcanus According to Contemporary Jewish Sources, in: S.J.D. Cohen and J.J. Schwartz (eds.), Studies in Josephus and the Varieties of Ancient Judaism: Louis H. Feldman Jubilee Volume, Leiden: 237–270.
• Sievers, J. (2001), Synopsis of the Greek Sources for the Hasmonean Period. 1–2 Maccabees and Josephus, War 1 and Antiquities 12–14, Roma.
• Van der Kooij, A. (2012), The Claim of Maccabean Leadership and the Use of Scripture, in: B. Eckhardt (ed.), Jewish Identity and Politics between the Maccabees and Bar Kokhba. Groups, Normativity, and Rituals, Leiden: 29–49.
• Von Dobbeler, S. (1997), Die Bücher 1/2 Makkabäer, Stuttgart.
• Weinfeld, M. (1993), The Promise of the Land. The Inheritance of the Land of Canaan by the Israelites, Berkeley.

Identifiers

DOI

10.4467/20800909EL.14.001.2780