Some Remarks on War Rituals in Archaic Italy and Rome and the Beginnings of Roman Imperialism

• Authors: Piegdoń Maciej
• Languages of publication: EN

Abstracts

EN

The success of Roman expansion in the Republican period and the durability of the empire, which survived the fall of the Republic and continued to function for the next few hundred years under the rule of emperors, drew the attention of both scholars and rulers in subsequent eras. The Imperium Romanum became a model for other states that attempted to build their own empires in later times. What captures our attention in discussions on Roman imperialism is mainly one, so far unresolved, dilemma: was Roman expansion a result of the material and psychological benefits that individual social groups enjoyed as a result of the aggressive policy, or a product of the Roman society’s atavistic tendencies for using violence? This seems to be a very difficult question to answer. If we also consider other elements that cause aggression, such as fright, fear (metus Gallicus, Punicus, Etruscus, etc.) of something or someone and a desire to win fame or glory over an enemy, then solving the problem seems impossible indeed. Finding the right answer is not made any easier by the historical sources. On the one hand, they are very biased, as they hide the actual reasons under a thick layer of propaganda and apologetic slogans; so thick, in fact, that in many cases the Romans’ true motives seem incomprehensible. The majority of available accounts present the Romans as the defenders of the weak and their allies. This is the result of a strong propaganda rhetoric used by the Romans in order to justify themselves in contemporary eyes and in posterity too. We should also note one more element that could have had an influence on the development of an imperial mentality in Rome, i.e. the broadly defined civilisation and cultural milieu in which Rome came to be – Italy. A cursory comparison of various Roman war rites with the rituals of other inhabitants of Italy indicates that war was very much a part of the mentality of Italic communities. The presence of war rites in Italic tribes suggests that in Italy, war was an important element of existence. Rome was an integral part of this world, which meant that the presence of a strong military component and aggressiveness in the life of the Roman community was natural.

Keywords

EN

Roman imperialism; Roman expansion; war rituals; bellum iustum; devotio; clarigatio; ius fetiale

• Publisher: Uniwersytet Jagielloński
• Journal: Electrum
• Year: 2014
• Volume: 21
• Pages: 87–97

Dates

online

2015-03-03

Contributors

author

Piegdoń Maciej

• Uniwersytet Jagielloński w Krakowie, Polska, Gołębia 24, 31-007 Kraków

References

• Ammerman, A.J. (2013), Looking at Early Rome with Fresh Eyes: Transforming the Landscape, in: J. DeRose Evans (ed.), A Companion to the Archaeology of the Roman Republic, Oxford: 169–180.
• Ancilotti, A., Cerri, R. (1996), La tavole di Gubbio e la civiltà degli Umbri, Perugia.
• Armstrong, J. (2013), Claiming Victory: The Early Romans, in: A. Spalinger, J. Armstrong (eds.), Rituals of Triumphs in the Mediterranean World, Leiden–Boston: 7–22.
• Badian, E. (1967), Roman Imperialism in the Late Republic, Pretoria.
• Balbuza, K. (2005): Triumfator. Triumf i ideologia zwycięstwa w starożytnym Rzymie epoki cesarstwa, Poznań.
• Beard, M. (2007), The Roman Triumph, Harvard.
• Bellen, H. (1985), Metus Gallicus – Metus Punicus. Zum Furchtmotive in der römischen Republik, Wiesbaden–Stuttgart.
• Bietti Sestieri, A.M. (2010), L’Italia nell’età del bronzo a dell ferro. Dalle palaffite a Romolo (2200–700 a.C.), Roma.
• Bonfante Warren, L. (1971), Roman Triumphs and Etruscan Kings. The Latin Word Triumphus, in: R.C. Lugton, M.G. Saltzer (eds.), Studies in Honor of J. Alexander Kerns, Hague–Paris: 108–120.
• Bradley, G. (2000), Ancient Umbria. State, Culture, and Identity in Central Italy from the Iron Age to the Augustan Era, Oxford.
• Brunt, P.A. (2001), Roman Imperial Themes, Oxford.
• Champion, C.B. (2004), Roman Imperialism. Readings and Source, Oxford.
• Cornell, T. (1989a), Rome and Latium to 390 B.C., CAH2 VII, 2: 243–308.
• Cornell, T. (1989b), The Recovery of Rome, CAH2 VII, 2: 309–350.
• Cornell, T. (1989c), The Conquest of Italy, CAH2 VII, 2: 351–419.
• Cornell, T. (1995), The Beginnings of Rome. Italy and Rome from the Bronze Age to the Punic Wars (c. 1000–264 BC), London–New York.
• Cornell, T. (1997), Ethnicity as a Factor in Early Roman History, in: T. Cornell, K. Lomas (eds.), Gender and Ethnicity in Ancient Italy, London: 9–21.
• Cornell, T. (2002), The End of Roman Imperial Expansion, in: J. Rich, G. Shipley (eds.), War and Society in the Roman World, London–New York: 139–170.
• Davies, P.J.E. (2013), The Archeology of Mid-Republican Rome. The Emergence of a Mediterranean Capital, in: J. DeRose Evans (ed.), A Companion to the Archeology of the Roman Republic, Oxford: 441–458.
• Dench, E. (1995), From Barbarians to New Men, Oxford.
• Dench, E. (1997), Sacred Springs to the Social War. Myths of Origins and Questions of Identity in Central Italy, in: T. Cornell, K. Lomas (eds.), Gender and Ethnicity in Ancient Italy, London: 43–52.
• Eckstein, A.M. (2006), Conceptualizing Roman Imperial Expansion under the Republic. An Introduction, in: P. Erdkamp (ed.), A Companion to the Roman Army, Oxford: 567–589.
• Edlund-Berry, I. (2013), Early Rome and the Making of “Roman” Identity through Architecture and City Planning, in: J. DeRose Evans (ed.), A Companion to the Archeology of the Roman Republic, Oxford: 406–426.
• Erskine, A. (2013), Hellenistic Parades and Roman Triumphs, in: A. Spalinger, J. Armstrong (eds.), Rituals of Triumphs in the Mediterranean World, Leiden–Boston: 37–56.
• Flaig, E. (2013), Zrytualizowana polityka rzymska. Znaki, gesty i władza w starożytnym Rzymie, Poznań.
• Forsythe, G. (2005), A Critical History of Early Rome, Berkely–Los Angeles–London.
• Frézouls, E. (1983), Sur l’historiographie de l’impérialisme romain, Ktema 8: 141–162.
• Gillmeister, A. (2009), Strażnicy ksiąg sybillińskich. Collegium viri sacris faciundis w rzymskiej religii publicznej, Zielona Góra.
• Gruen, E. (1984), The Hellenistic World and the Coming of Rome, vol. I–II, Berkely–Los Angeles–London.
• Harris, W.V. (1971), Rome in Etruria and Umbria, Oxford.
• Harris, W.V. (1992), War and Imperialism in Republican Rome 327–70 B.C., Oxford.
• Harrison, T. (2008), Ancient and Modern Imperialism, Greece and Rome 55 (1): 1–22.
• Hermon, E. (1983), Concept de pouvoir et concept d’empire à l’époque républicaine à Rome: pour une analyse linguistique et historique, Ktema 8: 175–184.
• Hopkins, K. (1979), Conquerors and Slaves, Cambridge.
• Hölkeskamp, K.J. (2006), History and Collective Memory in the Middle Republic, in: N. Rosenstein, M. Morstein-Marx (eds.), A Companion to the Roman Republic, Oxford: 478–495.
• Kowalska, E. (1986), Triumf – instytucja sakralna i polityczna w Rzymie republikańskim, Meander 41: 33–48; 71–84.
• Linderski, J. (1984), Si vis pacem, para bellum: Concept of Defensive Imperialism, in: W.V. Harris (ed.), The Imperialism of Mid-Republican Rome, Rome: 133–164.
• Maciejowski, M. (2012), Rzymski podbój Hiszpanii (218–178 przed Chr.). Aspekty polityczne, militarne i społeczne, Zasole.
• MacMullen, R. (2011), The Earliest Romans. A Character Sketch, Ann Arbor, MI.
• Marshall, B.A. (1972), Crassus’ Ovation in 71 B.C., Historia 21: 669–673.
• Mattingly, D. (2011), Imperialism, Power and Identity. Experiencing the Roman Empire, Oxford.
• Momigliano, A. (1989), The origins of Rome, CAH2 VII, 2: 52–112.
• Morley, N. (2010), The Roman Empire. Roots of Imperialism, New York.
• Musiał, D. (2009), Dionizos w Rzymie, Kraków.
• North, J.A. (1981), The Development of Roman Imperialism, JRS 71: 1–9.
• Oakley, S. (2002), The Roman Conquest of Italy, in: J. Rich, G. Shipley (eds.), War and Society in the Roman World, London–New York: 9–37.
• Orlin, E.M. (2002), Temples, Religion, and Politics in the Roman Republic, Boston–Leiden.
• Östenberg, I. (2009), Staging the World. Spoils, Captives, and Representations in the Roman Triumphal Procession, Oxford.
• Pallottino, M. (1991), A History of the Earliest Italy, London.
• Piegdoń, M. (2009), Galia Przedalpejska. Studia nad rzymską obecnością w północnej Italii w III–I w.pn.e., Kraków.
• Pina Polo, F. (2011), Consuls as curatores pacis deorum, in: H. Beck, A. Duplà, M. Jehne, F. Pina Polo (eds.), Consuls and res publica. Holding High Office in the Roman Republic, Cambridge: 97–115.
• Popławski, M.S. (2011), Bellum Romanum. Sakralność wojny i prawa rzymskiego, Lublin.
• Rich, J. (2002), Fear, Greed and Glory. The Causes of Roman War-making in the Middle Republic, in: J. Rich, G. Shipley (eds.), War and Society in the Roman World, London–New York: 38–68.
• Rich, J. (2008), Warfare and the Army in Early Rome, in: P. Erdkamp (ed.), A Companion to the Roman Army, Oxford: 7–23.
• Rich, J. (2011), The Fetiales and Roman International Relations, in: J.H. Richardson, F. Santangelo (eds.), Priests and State in the Roman World, Stuttgart: 187–242.
• Richardson, J.S. (1994), The Administration of the Empire, CAH2 IX: 564–599.
• Richardson, J.S. (2008), The Language of Empire. Rome and Idea of Empire from the 3rd Century BC to the 2nd Century BC, Cambridge.
• Richardson, J.H. (2012), The Fabii and Gauls. Studies in Historical Thought and Historiography in Republican Rome, Stuttgart.
• Rosenstein, N. (1990), Imperatores Victi. Military Defeat and Aristocratic Competition in the Middle and Late Republic, Berkeley–Los Angeles–Oxford.
• Rosenstein, N. (2006), Aristocratic Values, in: N. Rosenstein, M. Morstein-Marx (eds.), A Companion to the Roman Republic, Oxford: 365–382.
• Rosenstein, N. (2008), Military Command, Political Power, and the Republican Elite, in: P. Erdkamp (ed.), A Companion to the Roman Army, Oxford: 132–147.
• Ross Holloway, R. (1994), The Archeology of Early Rome and Latium, London.
• Rüpke, J. (2006), Communicating with Gods, in: N. Rosenstein, M. Morstein-Marx (eds.), A Companion to the Roman Republic, Oxford: 215–235.
• Salmon, E.T. (1967), Samnium and the Samnites, Cambridge.
• Santangelo, F. (2014), I faeziali fra rituale, diplomazia e tradizioni inventate, in: Gianpaolo Urso (ed.), Sacerdos. Figure del sacro nella società romana. Atti del convegno internazionale Cividale del Friuli, 26–28 settembre 2012, Pisa: 83–103.
• Schumpeter, J.A. (1919), Zur Soziologie der Imperialismen, Tübingen.
• Shatzman, I. (1972), The Roman General’s Authority over Booty, Historia 20: 206–223.
• Stek, T.D. (2013), Material Culture, Italic Identities and the Romanization of Italy, in: J. DeRose Evans (ed.), A Companion to the Archeology of the Roman Republic, Oxford: 337–353.
• Śnieżewski, S. (2006), Wojna, pokój i bogowie w starożytnym Rzymie, Kraków.
• Torelli, M. (1989), Archaic Rome between Latium and Etruria, CAH2 VII, 2: 30–51.
• Toynbee, A.J. (1965), Hannibal’s Legacy. The Hannibalic War’s Effects on Roman Life, vol. I–II, London.
• Várhelyi, Z. (2007), The Specters of Roman Imperialism: The Live Burials of Gauls and Greeks at Rome, Classical Antiquity 26: 276–304.
• Yakobson, A. (2009), Public Opinion, Foreign Policy and ‘Just War’ in the Late Republic, in: C. Eilers (ed.), Diplomats and Diplomacy in the Roman World, Leiden–Boston: 45–72.
• Yarrow, L.M. (2006): Historiography at the End of the Republic, Oxford.
• Wikarjak J. (1984), Ovatio, Balcanica Posnaniensia 3: 33–45.
• Ziółkowski, A. (1992), The Temples of Mid-Republican Rome and Their Historical and Topographical Context, Roma.
• Ziółkowski, A. (1994a), Primordia Urbis, in: J. Wolski, T. Kotula, A. Kunisz (eds.), Starożytny Rzym we współczesnych badaniach. Państwo – społeczeństwo – gospodarka, Kraków: 11–48.
• Ziółkowski, A. (1994b), Podbój Italii przez Rzym. Motywy i mechanizmy, in: J. Wolski, T. Kotula, A. Kunisz (eds.), Starożytny Rzym we współczesnych badaniach. Państwo – społeczeństwo – gospodarka, Kraków: 49–80.
• Ziółkowski, A. (2004), Historia Rzymu, Poznań.
• Ziółkowski, A. (2005), The Aggeres and the Rise of Urban Communities in Early Iron Age Latium, Archeologia 56: 31–51.

Identifiers

DOI

10.4467/20800909EL.14.001.2781