Tekstologia wyłożona modo italico (O książce Alfredo Stussiego „Wprowadzenie do edytorstwa i tekstologii”)

• Authors: Janusz S. Gruchała
• Languages of publication: PL

Abstracts

PL

TEXTUAL SCHOLARSHIP ITALIAN-STYLE The review discusses the Polish translation of Alfredo Stussi’s manual Introduzione agli studi di filologia italiana, edited by the Gdańsk publishing house “słowo/obraz terytoria” in 2011. The reviewer starts out by emphasizing that such publications are needed for familiarizing Polish students with textual criticism abroad. It is interesting that in the first chapter Stussi includes some general information on the book as an object, discussing parchment, paper, script, structure of codex, printing techniques etc.; such elementary knowledge is scarce in Polish manuals of textual scholarship. In the next chapters, the Italian author discusses witnesses of the text, errors, kinds of textual variants, and methods of textual criticism, placing emphasis on stemmatic procedures and studying the originals (autographs, prints edited with the participation of the author). Other ways of dealing with the text (e.g. copy-text, the best text) are only mentioned by Stussi; the reviewer’s opinion is that it makes the book less useful for Polish students. His other critical remarks concern the translation of some technical terms into Polish, and especially the literal translation of the title of the last chapter: Filologia d’autore (Polish Filologia autorska), which is vague. Moreover, the edition lacks the bibliographic information necessary for the Polish reader. In the conclusion the reviewer recommends Stussi’s book only to the most interested students.

Keywords

PL

textual scholarship – manual, scholarly editing in Italy

• Publisher: Uniwersytet Jagielloński
• Journal: Wielogłos
• Year: 2012
• Volume: 3
• Issue: 13

Dates

published

2012

online

2012-09-11

Contributors

author

Janusz S. Gruchała