Search results

1

Horthy a jeho doba – proměny hodnocení

100%

Irmanová E.

Český časopis historický (The Czech Historical Review)

|

2011

|

vol. 109

|

issue 1

15-43

EN

The personality of the Regent Miklos Horthy, as well as the regime of the inter-war Hungary were assessed rather differently by Hungarian historiography from 1945 – from labelling Horthy as a fascist dictator to a more realistic re-assessment of him from the 1970s onwards.

2

TRIANON RITUALS OR CONSIDERATIONS OF SOME FEATURES OF HUNGARIAN HISTORIOGRAPHY

88%

Holec R.

Historický časopis (Historical Journal)

|

2011

|

vol. 59

|

issue suppl. issue

25 – 48

EN

The study connected with the approaching anniversary of the conclusion of the Treaty of Trianon examines the instrumentalization of this event in part of Hungarian historiography. Biased arguments, the so-called national viewpoint, double standards for the same phenomena, absence of context, lack of perception of preceding developments, demonization of particular personalities and phenomena, uncritical argumentation from the 1910 nationality statistics, which used unreliable methods, accompany this instrumentalization. All this is only part of a rich repertoire. The study comments on the character of the most recent Trianon publications and generalizes about some common features of Hungarian historiography, especially the absence of self-reflection and problems with the analysis of their own historical failures, as well as the tendency of the main stream of Hungarian historiography to ignore these negative trends. They are tacitly accepted without comment or the necessary critical detachment, which gives the impression of agreement. There are more than enough similar negative phenomena in Slovakia, but here they evoke polemics and the majority of professional historians distance themselves from them. Only those, who can express their position and not be silent at home, have the right to look beyond the frontiers and express critical views of the situation in neighbouring countries.

3

TRIANONSKÉ RITUÁLY ALEBO ÚVAHY NAD NIEKTORÝMI JAVMI V MAĎARSKEJ HISTORIOGRAFII

88%

Holec R.

Historický časopis (Historical Journal)

|

2010

|

vol. 58

|

issue 2

291-312

EN

The study connected with the approaching anniversary of the conclusion of the Treaty of Trianon examines the instrumentalization of this event in part of Hungarian historiography. Biased arguments, the so-called national viewpoint, double standards for the same phenomena, absence of context, lack of perception of preceding developments, demonization of particular personalities and phenomena, uncritical argumentation from the 1910 nationality statistics, which used unreliable methods, accompany this instrumentalization. All this is only part of a rich repertoire. The study comments on the character of the most recent Trianon publications and generalizes about some common features of Hungarian historiography, especially the absence of self-reflection and problems with the analysis of their own historical failures, as well as the tendency of the main stream of Hungarian historiography to ignore these negative trends. They are tacitly accepted without comment or the necessary critical detachment, which gives the impression of agreement. There are more than enough similar negative phenomena in Slovakia, but here they evoke polemics and the majority of professional historians distance themselves from them. Only those, who can express their position and not be silent at home, have the right to look beyond the frontiers and express critical views of the situation in neighbouring countries.

Refine search results

2 Historický časopis (Historical Journal)

1 Český časopis historický (The Czech Historical Review)

2 2011

1 2010

2 Holec R.

1 Irmanová E.

Horthy a jeho doba – proměny hodnocení

TRIANON RITUALS OR CONSIDERATIONS OF SOME FEATURES OF HUNGARIAN HISTORIOGRAPHY

TRIANONSKÉ RITUÁLY ALEBO ÚVAHY NAD NIEKTORÝMI JAVMI V MAĎARSKEJ HISTORIOGRAFII