Two neglected details in Plato’s chariot allegory

• Authors: Zaborowski Robert
• Languages of publication: EN

Abstracts

EN

This paper is the first of two discussing several problems in Plato’s allegory of the soul in the Phaedrus. I revisit the description of what goes on in the lover’s soul when he approaches and encounters the beloved (253e5–255a1), because I think that crucial issues arising from the description have been neglected or misinterpreted so far and that crucial passages have been mistranslated. After considering two minor points concer- ning (i) the evil of the black horse and the origin of the soul’s fall and (ii) the white horse’s capacity to restrain itself, the more substantive issue of neglected details is then addressed. The first detail taken up is the meaning of the whole soul in 253e5 and the second pertains to Plato’s description of memory as falling back- wards in 254b5. An analysis of Plato’s text leads to a conclusion that the simple model of a tripartite soul, in the way it is commonly attributed to Plato, is not supported by the Phaedrus. The interpretation of both neglected details instead gives support to the thesis that, on the one hand, the three elements of the soul are each functionally complex and, on the other, each function is ascribed to more than one element of the Platonic soul

Keywords

EN

Plato chariot allegory, (the whole) soul memory two–level structure of the soul

• Publisher: Polska Akademia Nauk. Instytut Historii Nauki im. Ludwika i Aleksandra Birkenmajerów
• Journal: Organon
• Year: 2016
• Volume: 48
• Pages: 191-224

Contributors

author

Zaborowski Robert

• University of Warmia & Mazury

References

• Brinker W., Platons Ethik und Psychologie. Philologische Untrsuchungen über thymetisches Denken und Handeln in den platonischen Dialogen, Peter Lang, Frankfurt am Main 2008.
• Brunschwig J., Un détail négligé dans la caverne de Platon in: La Recta Ratio. Mélanges Bernard Rousset, (ed.) L. Bove, Presses de l’Université de Paris–Sorbonne, Paris 1999, pp. 65–76.
• Brunschwig J., Revisiting Plato’s Cave in: Proceedings of the Boston Area Colloquium in Ancient Philosophy 19, 2003, (eds.) J. J. Cleary & G. M. Gurtler, Brill, Leiden – Boston 2004, pp. 145–177.
• Burger R., Plato’s Phaedrus: A Defense of a Philosophic Art of Writing, Uni- versity of Alabama Press, Alabama 1980.
• Burger R., The Thumotic and the Erotic Soul: Seth Benardete on Platonic Psychology in: Interpretation 32, 1/2004, pp. 57–75.
• Burnyeat M., The passion of reason in Plato’s Phaedrus in: M. Burnyeat, Explorations in Ancient and Modern Philosophy, vol. 2, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2012, pp. 238–258.
• Cazeaux J., Commentaire in: Plato, Phèdre, transl. J. Cazeaux, LGF, Paris 1997.
• Études platoniciennes, vol. 4: Les puissances de l’âme selon Platon, Les Belles Lettres, Paris 2007.
• Ferrari G. R. F., The Struggle in the Soul: Plato, Phaedrus 253c7–255a1 in: Ancient Philosophy 5, 1985, pp. 1–10.
• Ferrari G. R. F., Listening to the Cicadas. A Study of Plato’s Phaedrus, Cam- bridge University Press, Cambridge 1987.
• Frère J., Les Grecs et le désir de l’être. Des Préplatoniciens à Aristote, Les Belles Lettres, Paris 1981.
• Frutiger P., Les Mythes de Platon. Etude philosophique et littéraire, Félix Alcan, Paris 1930.
• Hackforth R., Plato’s Phaedrus, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1952.
• Hermiae Alexandrini, In Platonis Phaedrum Scholia, (ed.) P. Couvreur, Lib- rairie Emile Bouillon, Paris 1901.
• Hermias Alexandrinus, In Platonis Phaedrum Scholia, (eds.) C. M. Lucarini, & C. Moreschini, De Gruyter, Berlin – Boston 2012.
• Hume D., A Treatise of Human Nature, (eds.) L. A. Selby–Bigge & P. H. Nidditch, [2nd ed.] Clarendon Press, Oxford 1978.
• Jackson J. H., Croonian Lectures on Evolution and dissolution of the nervous system, Lecture II in: The British Medical Journal, Apr. 5, 1884, pp. 660–663.
• Jowett B., Introduction to Phaedrus in: The Dialogues of Plato, transl. B. Jowett, vol. 1, [3rd ed.] Macmillan and Co., London 1892.
• Kamtekar R., Speak with the same voice as reason. Personification in Plato’s psychology in: Plato and the Divided Self, (eds.) R. Barney, T. Brennan & C. Brittain, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2012, pp. 77–101.
• Leighton L., The Value of Passions in Plato and Aristotle in: Southwest Phi- losophy Review 11 (Supplement, March 1995), pp. 42–56 (available on–line: http://hdl.handle.net/1974/1914, retrieved on Jul. 1, 2016).
• Liddell H. G., Scott R. & Jones H. S., A Greek–English Lexicon with a Supplement, Clarendon Press, Oxford [9th ed.] 1940 [= LSJ].
• Marsilio Ficino and the Phaedran Charioteer, introd., texts, transl. M. J. B. Allen, University of California Press, Berkeley – Los Angeles – London 1981.
• Monteils–Laeng L., Agir sans vouloir. Le problème de l’intellectualisme moral dans la philosophie ancienne, Classiques Garnier, Paris 2014.
• Parmenides in: H. Diels & W. Kranz, Die Fragmente der Vorsokratiker, vol. 1, Weidmann, Hildesheim 1989 [= DK].
• Plato, Phaedrus, transl. H. N. Fowler, Harvard University Press – William Heinemann Ltd, Cambridge, MA & London 1925.
• Plato, Phaedrus, transl. A. Nehamas & P. Woodruff, Hackett Publishing Com- pany, Inc., Indianapolis – Cambridge 1995.
• Plato, Republic, transl. P. Shorey, Harvard University Press – William Heine- mann Ltd, Cambridge, MA & London 1969.
• Plato and the Divided Self, (eds.) R. Barney, T. Brennan & C. Brittain, Cam- bridge University Press, Cambridge 2012.
• Platon, Phaidros, transl. C. Ritter, Verlag von F. Meiner, Leipzig 1922.
• Platon, Phaidros, Übersetzung und Kommentar von E. Heitsch, Vandenhœck & Ruprecht, Göttingen 1993.
• Platon, Phèdre, transl. E. Chambry, Garnier – Flammarion, Paris 1964.
• Platon, Phèdre, transl. P. Vicaire, Les Belles Lettres, Paris 1985.
• Platon, Phèdre, transl. L. Mouze, Le Livre de Poche, Paris 2007.
• Platon, Phèdre, transl. L. Brisson in: Plato, Œuvres complètes, transl. L. Bris- son & al., Ed. Flammarion, Paris 2011.
• Platon, Phèdre, transl. L. Brisson, GF, Paris 2012.
• Platone, Fedro, transl. P. Pucci in: Platone, Opere complete, vol. 3, Editori Laterza, Roma 1982.
• Platone, Fedro, (ed.) G. Reale, A. Mondadori, Milano 1998.
• Price A. W., Reason’s New Role in the Phaedrus in: Understanding the Phaedrus. II Symposium Platonicum, (ed.) L. Rossetti, Akademia Verlag, Sankt Augustin 1992, pp. 243–245.
• Price A. W., Emotions in Plato and Aristotle in: The Oxford Handbook of the Philosophy of Emotion, (ed.) P. Goldie, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2010, pp. 121–142.
• Price A. W., Parts of the Soul in Plato’s Phaedrus (unpublished, quoted with permission).
• Renaut O., Platon. La médiation des émotions. L’éducation du thymos dans les dialogues, J. Vrin, Paris 2014.
• Rohde E., Psyche: The Cult of Souls and Belief in Immortality Among the Greeks [1894], transl. W. B. Hillis, Routledge, New York – London [reprinted] 2000.
• Romilly de J., Les conflits de l’âme dans le Phèdre de Platon in: Wiener Stu- dien 95, 1982, pp. 100–113.
• Rowe C. J., Plato: Phaedrus, Aris & Phillips, Warminster 1986.
• Sheffield F., Erôs before and after tripartition in: Plato and the Divided Self, (eds.) R. Barney, T. Brennan & C. Brittain, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2012, pp. 211–237.
• The Dialogues of Plato, transl. B. Jowett, vol. 1, [3rd ed.] Macmillan and Co., London 1892.
• The Phaedrus of Plato, English notes and dissertations by W. H. Thompson, Whittaker & Co., London 1868.
• Verdenius W. J., Notes on Plato’s Phaedrus in: Mnemosyne 8, 1955, pp. 265–289.
• Vries de G. J., A Commentary on the Phaedrus of Plato, A. M. Hakkert – Pub- lisher, Amsterdam 1969.
• Woolf R., How to see an unencrusted soul in: Plato and the Divided Self, (eds.) R. Barney, T. Brennan & C. Brittain, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2012, pp. 150–173.
• Yunis H., Commentary in: Plato, Phaedrus, (ed.) H. Yunis, Cambridge Uni- versity Press, Cambridge 2011, pp. 85–249.
• Zaborowski R., La crainte et le courage dans l’Iliade et l’Odyssée. Contri- bution lexicographique à la psychologie homérique des sentiments, Stakroos, Warszawa 2002.
• Zaborowski R., Sur un certain détail négligé dans la caverne de Platon in: Organon 35, 2006, pp. 209–246.
• Zaborowski R., Sur le sentiment chez les Présocratiques, Stakroos, Warszawa 2008.
• Zaborowski R., Plato’s Phdr. 253e5–255a1 revisited [in progress].