‘Sasanian’ silver plate from al-Ṣabāḥ Collection in light of aesthetic features of Sasanian toreutics

• Authors: SKUPNIEWICZ Patryk
• Languages of publication: EN

Abstracts

EN

Recently published silver plate from al-Sabah Collection, of unknown provenance, has been firmly attributed as Sasanian. In fact, technically, it is related to the Sasanian silverwork however aesthetic examination allows to raise the doubts whether it is genuine. The plate must be compared not only with central-Sasanian artworks but all ancient ‘Oriental silver’, including pieces attributed as Hephtalite or Sogdian. The design of the plate does not have any relation with any of the known examples of late antique oriental toreutics. Central scene of heroic combat with powerful beast or beasts has never been surrounded with the ring containing other hunting scenes is unknown as well. The disbalanced decorum is even more clear when we remind that the central scene shows hunting on foot and the marginal ones – mounted. The details of fixed aesthetic elements – position of personages, beasts, weapons do not belong to Sasanian canon. The unique nature of the plate might result from many factors but the combination of unknown provenance and lack of relation to legitimate Sasanian canon require utmost cautiousness towards the object.

Keywords

EN

Sasanian silver; al-Sabah Collection; toreutics; Iran; Art

• Publisher: Instytut Historii Uniwersytet w Siedlcach
• Journal: Historia i Świat
• Year: 2019
• Issue: 8
• Pages: 59-78

Dates

published

2019

Contributors

author

SKUPNIEWICZ Patryk

• Instytut Historii i Stosunków Międzynarodowych Wydział Humanistyczny Uniwersytet Przyrodniczo-Humanistyczny w Siedlcach

References

• BAULO A.V. (2002), ‘A Sasanian silver plate from the Synya, Archaeology, Ethnology & Anthropology of Eurasia 1, 142-148.
• BOARDMAN J. (2000), Persia and the West, London.
• CARTER M. (2015), Arts of the Hellenized East. Precious Metalwork and Gems of the Pre-Islamic Era, London.
• CIAFALONI D., DELLA ROCA DE CANDAL G. (2011), ‘Sasanian Traditions in Sogdian Paintings: Hunting and Fighting Scenes’, Parthica 13, 111-128.
• FRANCFORT H.P. (2002), ‘Images du combat contre le sanglier en Asie centrale (3 ème au 1 er millénaire av. J.-C.)’, Bulletin of the Asia Institute 16, 117-142.
• FREEMAN D. (2013), (ed.), Splendors of the Ancient East, London.
• GRABAR O. (1967), Sasanian Silver. Late Antique and Early Mediaeval Arts of Luxury From Iran. Michigan.
• GRAY B. (1991), ‘Post-Sasanian Metalwork’, Bulletin of the Asia Institute 5, 59-63.
• GUNTER A.C., JETT P. (1992), Ancient Iranian Metalwork in the Arthur M. Sackler Gallery and the Freer Gallery of Art, Washington D.C.
• HARPER P.O. (1979), ‘Thrones and Enthronement Scenes in Sasanian Art’, Iran 17, 49-64.
• HARPER P.O. (1983), ‘Sasanian Silver’, in The Cambridge History of Iran 3(2), The Seleucid, Parthian and Sasanian Periods, Cambridge, ed. E. YARSHATER, Cambridge, 1113-1130.
• HARPER P.O. (2000), ‘Sasanian Silver Vessels: The Formation and Study of Early Museum Collections’, in Mesopotamia and Iran in Parthian and Sasanian Periods: Rejection and Revival. C. 238 BC-AD 642, ed. J. CURTIS, London, 70-75.
• HARPER P.O. (2006), In Search of a Cultural Identity. Monuments and Arti-facts of the Sasanian Near East. 3rd to 7th Century A. D., New York 2006.
• HARPER P.O. (2008), ‘Image and Identity: Art of the Early Sasanian Dynasty’, in The Sasanian Era. Vol. III. The Idea of Iran, eds.V.S. CURTIS, S. STEWART, London and New York, 71-87.
• HARPER P. O., MEYERS P. (1981), Silver Vessels of the Sasanian Period. Vol. I. Royal Imagery, New York.
• HERRMANN G. (2017), Ancient Ivory. Masterpieces of the Assyrian Empire, London.
• ILYASOV J. (2003), ‘Covered Tile and “Flying” Tassels,’ Iranica Antiqua 38, 259-325.
• KARIMIAN H. (2008), Iranian Society in the Sasanian Period, in Current Research in Sasanian Archaeology, Art and History. Proceedings of a Conference held at Durham University, November 3rd and 4th, 2001, eds. D. KENNET, P. LUFT, Oxford, 99-107.
• KOLESNIKOV A.I. (2012), Sasanidskiy Iran. Istoriya i kultura, St. Petersburg.
• LUKONIN V.G. (1983), ‘Political, Social and Administrative Institutions: Taxes and Trade’, in The Cambridge History of Iran 3(2), The Seleucid, Parthian and Sasanian Periods, Cambridge, ed. E. YARSHATER, Cambridge, 681-746.
• MARSCHAK B.I. (1986), Silberschätze des Orients. Metalkunst des 3.-13. Jahr-hunderts und ihre Kontinuität, Leipzig.
• MARSHAK B.I. (1971), Sogdiiskoe serebro. Ocherki po vostochnoi torevtike, Moskva
• MARSHAK B.I (2002), ‘Pre-Islamic Painting of the Iranian Peoples and its Sources in Sculpture and Decorative Arts’, in Peerless Images. Persian Painting and its Sources, eds. E. SIMS, B.I. MARSHAK, E. J. GRUBE, New Haven and London, 7-19.
• MARSHAK B.I. (2017), Istoriya vostochnoy torevtiki III-XIII vv. i problemy kulturnoy preemstvennosti, Sankt Petersburg.
• MARSHAK B.I., KHIKIS YA. B, (1969), ‘Chilekskie Chashi’, Trudy Gossudarsvennogo Ermitaža 10, 55-80.
• MLEZIVA J. (2016), ‘Silver Vessels from Mes’Aynak’, in Afghanistan. Rescued Treasures of Buddhism, L. STANČO, Prague, 99-105.
• NIKONOROV V. (1997), The Armies of Bactria 700 BC-450 AD, vol. 2, Stockport.
• OLBRYCHT M.J. (2010), ‘Iran Starożytny’, in: Historia Iranu, ed. A. KRASNOWOLSKA, Wrocław, 25-286.
• ROSEN-AYALON M. (1991), ‘A Non-Royal Hunter Vessel’, Bulletin of the Asia Institute 5, 66-67.
• RITTER N.C. (2010), Die altorientalischen Traditionen der sastnidischen Glyptik. Form-Gebrauch- Ikonographie, Wien and Berlin.
• SKJAERVØ P.O. (2013), ‘The Inscription’, in Splendors of the Ancient East. Antiquities from The al- Sabah Collection, M. CARTER, S. GOLDSTEIN, P.O. HARPER, T.S. KAWAMI, P. MEYERS, London, 299.
• SKUPNIEWICZ P.N. (2009), ‘Shafted Weapons of Sasanian Hunting Iconography’, Fasciculi Archaeologiae Historicae 22, 49-64.
• SKUPNIEWICZ P.N. (2015), ‘Tabriz Museum Battle Dish. Formal Considerations’, Metamorfozy Istorii 6, 180-211.
• ŠLYAHOVA V.I. (1977), ‘Serebranyi sosud iz s. Yuldus (Kurganskaya Oblast)’, Sovetskaya Arheologiya 4, 288-292.
• ТREVER К.V., LUKONIN V.G. 1987, Sasanidskoe serebro. Sobranie Gosudarstvennogo Ermitaža. Hudožestvennaya kultura Irana III-VIII vekov, Мoskva

Identifiers

DOI

https://doi.org/10.34739/his.2019.08.04