Snakes or Ladders? Job Quality Assessment among Temp Workers from Ukraine in Hungarian Electronics

• Authors: Meszmann Tibor T.
• Languages of publication: EN

Abstracts

EN

In contrast to the usual integration of migrant workers in the ‘bottom jobs’ on the labour market, the employment of Ukrainian workers in Hungarian electronics plants seems to take place in a more beneficial way. With the active mediation of temporary (temp) agencies, Ukrainian migrant workers are offered regular blue-collar assembly work, together with the same social rights and benefits as their local Hungarian colleagues. Relying, in our analysis, on the literature on industrial sociology, migration research and global value chains, we are developing a critical perspective in which migration and employment are not seen as separate spheres but as mutually reinforcing each other. We combine bottom-up empirical research based on interviews with workers and a sectoral inquiry on industrial and employment relations in the temp agency sector supplying multinational corporations. Our main argument is that complex contracting also means subtle controlling. Such contracting is not the cheapest form but it creates a different, efficient employment regime with dependent, controllable, flexibly available, ‘fluid’ employees. Employee respondents described their position as dependent, ‘out of control’ and a temporary earning opportunity. Devoid of clear mechanisms for controlling their work conditions or growth within the job, all respondents turned to a more instrumental approach, in which they invested in building up social capital through friendships, networks and personal relationships. Obtaining Hungarian citizenship and learning the language were two other main strategies for dealing with insecurity. Their efforts correspond with and reinforce a more globally integrated but ethnically motivated immigration regime, characteristic of post-socialist Hungary.

Keywords

EN

migration; precarious employment; temporary work agencies; job quality; Hungary; Ukraine

• Publisher: Ośrodek Badań nad Migracjami Uniwersytetu Warszawskiego oraz Polska Akademia Nauk
• Journal: Central and Eastern European Migration Review
• Year: 2019
• Volume: 8
• Issue: 1
• Pages: 75-93

Contributors

author

Meszmann Tibor T.

References

• Anderson B. (2010). Migration, Immigration Controls and the Fashioning of Precarious Workers. Work, Employment and Society 24(2): 300–317.
• Andrijašević R., Sacchetto D. (2016). From Labour Migration to Labour Mobility? The Return of the Multinational Worker in Europe. Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research 22(2): 219–231.
• Bair J. (2009). Global Commodity Chains: Genealogy and Review, in: J. Bair (ed.), Frontiers of Commodity Chain Research, pp. 1–34. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
• Barrientos S. (2011). ‘Labour Chains’: Analysing the Role of Labour Contractors in Global Production Networks. BWPI Working Paper 153. Manchester: University of Manchester, Brooks World Poverty Institute.
• Barrientos S., Gereffi G., Rossi A. (2011). Economic and Social Upgrading in Global Production Networks: A New Paradigm for a Changing World. International Labor Review 150(3–4): 319–340.
• Bertalan B. (1997). Feketemunka Imortból, Avagy a Hétköznapi Diplomácia Eredete, in: E. Sík, J. Tóth (eds), Migráció és Politika, pp. 121–135. Budapest: MTA Politikai Tudományok Intézete Nemzetközi Migráció és Munkaügyi Kutatóközpont.
• Chan J., Pun N., Selden M. (2013). The Politics of Global Production: Apple, Foxconn and China’s New Working Class. New Technology, Work and Employment 28(2): 100–115.
• Castel R. (2000). The Roads to Disaffiliation: Insecure Work and Vulnerable Relationships. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 24(3): 519–535.
• Coe N. M., Johns J., Ward K. (2007). Mapping the Globalisation of the Temporary Staffing Industry. Professional Geographer 59(4): 503–520.
• Cranston S., Schapendonk J., Spaan E. (2018). New Directions in Exploring the Emigration Industries: Introduction to Special Issue. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 44(4): 543–557.
• Çağlar A., Gereöffy A. (2008). Ukrainian Migration to Hungary: A Fine Balance Between Migration Policies and Diaspora Politics. Journal of Immigrant and Refugee Studies 6(3): 326–343.
• England K., Stiell B. (1997). ‘They Think You’re as Stupid as Your English Is’: Constructing Foreign Domestic Workers in Toronto. Environment and Planning A 29(1): 195–215.
• Erőss Á., Kovály K., Tátrai P. (2016). Effects of the Ukrainian Crisis in Transcarpathia: The Hungarian Perspective. CMR Working Paper 92/150. Warsaw: University of Warsaw, Centre of Migration Research.
• Fedyuk O., Volodko V. (2018). Is Transnational Labour Rights Protection Possible? Sending Country‘s Perspective: Ukrainian Country Report. Online: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1pXZugNnTJSybl8oNcQ8b-e0DmPcvOUOq/view (accessed: 1 April 2019).
• Feischmidt M., Zakariás I. (2010). Migráció és Etnicitás. A Mobilitás Formái és Politikái Nemzeti és Transznacionális Térben, in: M. Feischmidt (ed.), Etnicitás. Különbségteremtő Társadalom, pp. 152–169. Budapest: Gondolat, MTA Kisebbségkutató Intézet.
• Fellini I., Ferro A., Fullin G. (2007). Recruitment Processes and Labour Mobility: The Construction Industry in Europe. Work Employment and Society 21(2): 277–298.
• Findlay P., Kalleberg A. L., Warhurst C. (2013). The Challenge of Job Quality. Human Relations 66(4): 441–451.
• Gereffi G. (2005). The Global Economy: Organization, Governance and Development, in: N. Smelser, R. Swedberg (eds), Handbook of Economic Sociology, pp. 160–182. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, Russell Sage Foundation.
• Gordon J. (2015). Global Labour Recruitment in a Supply Chain Context. Geneva: International Labour Office.
• Gödri I. (2011). Nemek Közötti Eltérések a Külföldi Allampolgárok Munkaerő-Piaci Helyzetében Magyarországon, in: I. Nagy, T. Pongrácz (eds), Szerepvaltozasok. Jelentes a Ferfi Ak es a Nők Helyzeteről 2011, pp. 88–112. Budapest: TÁRKI–Nemzeti Erőforrás Minisztérium.
• Gödri I., Soltész B., Bodacz-Nagy B. (2014). Immigration or Emigration Country? Migration Trends and Their Socio-Economic Background in Hungary: A Longer-Term Historical Perspective. Budapest: Hungarian Demographic Research Institute.
• Groutsis D., van den Broek D., Harvey W. (2015). Transformations in Network Governance: The Case of Migration Intermediaries. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 41(10): 1558–1576.
• Hammer N., Riisgaard L. (2015). Labour and Segmentation in Value Chains, in: K. Newsome, P. Taylor, J. Bair, A. Rainnie (eds), Putting Labour in Its Place: Labour Process Analysis and Global Value Chains, pp. 83–99. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
• Hárs Á. (2010). Migráció és Munkaerőpiac Magyarországon. Tények, Okok, Lehetőségek, in: Á. Hárs, J. Tóth (eds), Változó Migráció – Változó Környezet, pp. 15–53. Budapest: MTA Kisebbségkutató.
• Hárs Á. (2016). The Experiences of a New Emigrant Country: Emerging Migration from Hungary, in: M. Kahanec, K. Zimmermann (eds), Labor Migration, EU Enlargement, and the Great Recession, pp. 271–296. Berlin, Heidleberg: Springer-Verlag.
• Holgate J. (2005). Organising Migrant Workers: A Case Study of Working Conditions and Unionization at a Sandwich Factory in London. Work, Employment and Society 19(3): 463–480.
• Jones K. (2014). ‘It Was a Whirlwind. A Lot of People Made a Lot of Money’: The Role of Agencies in Facilitating Migration from Poland into the UK Between 2004 and 2008. Central and Eastern European Migration Review 3(2): 105–125.
• Juhász J., Csatári F., Makara E. (2010). ‘Ukrán Allampolgárok Munkavállalása Magyarországon’: Záró Tanulmány. Budapest: Panta Rhei Társadalomkutató Bt.
• Kalleberg A. (2009). Precarious Work, Insecure Workers: Employment Relations in Transition. American Sociological Review 74(1): 1–22.
• Kántor Z. (2014). Hungary’s Kin-State Politics, 2010–2014. Minority Studies 17: 23–32.
• Langerné Rédei M. (2011). Ukrán Munkavállalás Magyarországon, in: Á. Kincses (ed.), Ukrán Allampolgárok Magyarországon, pp. 70–90. Budapest: Európai Integrációs Alap.
• Lindquist J., Xiang B., Yeoh B. S. A. (2012). Introduction. Opening the Black Box of Migration: Brokers, the Organization of Transnational Mobility and the Changing Political Economy in Asia. Pacific Affairs 85(1): 7–19.
• MacKenzie R., Forde C. (2009). The Rhetoric of Good Workers Versus the Realities of Employers’ Use and the Experiences of Migrant Workers. Work, Employment and Society 23(1): 142–159.
• May J., Wills J., Datta K., Evans Y., Herbert J., McIlwaine C. (2007) Keeping London Working: Global Cities, the British State and London’s New Migrant Division of Labour. Transactions 32(2): 151–167
• Melegh A. (2011). A Globalizáció és Migráció Magyarországon. Educatio 2: 166–180.
• Melegh A. (2016). Unequal Exchanges and the Radicalization of Demographic Nationalism. Intersections. East European Journal of Society and Politics 2(4): 87–108.
• Meszmann T. T. (2016). The Rise of the Dual Labour Market: Fighting Precarious Employment in the New Member States Through Industrial Relations. PRECARIR Country Report: Hungary. Bratislava: CELSI.
• Migrationonline (2018). Press Release: Country Studies Reveal Common Labour Rights Violations and Possibilities of Enforcing Migrant Workers’ Rights in the Visegrad Countries. Migrationonline.cz – Multicultural Center Prague. Online: https://migrationonline.cz/en/e-library/press-release-country-studies-re... (accessed: 2 April 2019).
• MPAJ (2011). Policy for Hungarian Communities Abroad – The Strategic Framework for Hungarian Communities Abroad. Budapest: Ministry of Public Administration and Justice, State Secretariat for Hungarian Communities Abroad.
• Nagy L. N. (2016). Varga Mihály nagy bejelentése: Vendégmunkások kellenek! Heti válasz, 17 September. Online: http://valasz.hu/uzlet/varga-mihaly-nagy-bejelentese-vendegmunkasok-kell... (accessed: 8 June 2019).
• NFSZ (2018). A Külföldi Allampolgárok Magyarországi Munkavállalásának főbb Sajátosságai. Budapest: Nemzetgazdasági Minisztérium – Elemzési és Bérpolitikai Osztály. Online: https://nfsz.munka.hu/Lapok/full_afsz_kozos_statisztika/stat_kulf_munkav... (accessed: 2 April 2019).
• Nyberg-Sørensen N., Gammeltoft-Hansen T. (2013). Introduction, in: N. Nyberg-Sørensen, T. Gammeltoft-Hansen (eds), The Migration Industry and the Commercialization of International Migration, pp. 1–24. London: Routledge.
• Pakurár M., Oláh J., Cehla B. (2012). Az Ukrajnai Munkavállalók Munkavállalási Jellemzői Magyarországon. Gazdálkodás 56(2): 1–9.
• Peck J., Theodore N., Ward K. (2005). Constructing Markets for Temporary Labour: Employment Liberalisation and the Internationalisation of the Staffing Industry. Global Networks 5(1): 3–26.
• Piore M. J. (1979). Birds of Passage: Migrant Labor and Industrial Societies. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
• Pollert A., Charlwood A. (2009). The Vulnerable Worker in Britain and Problems at Work. Work, Employment and Society 23(2): 343–362.
• Rodriguez N. (2004). ‘Workers Wanted’: Employer Recruitment of Immigrant Labor. Work and Occupations 31(4):453–473.
• Rossi A. (2011). Economic and Social Upgrading in Global Production Networks: The Case of the Garment Industry in Morocco. Unpublished PhD thesis. Brighton: University of Sussex, Institute of Development Studies.
• Sík E. (2012). Csúcson a Migrációt Tervezők Aránya. Budapest: TÁRKI. Online: http://www.tarki.hu/hu/news/2012/kitekint/20120523_migracio.html (accessed: 2 April 2019).
• Soltész B., Erőss Á., Karácsonyi D., Kincses Á. (2014): Hungary: Cross-Border Migration in a Fragmented Ethnic Space, in: Á. Erőss, D. Karácsonyi (eds), Discovering Migration between Visegrad Countries and Eastern Partners, pp. 72–87. Budapest: HAS Geographical Institute.
• Soltész B., Zimmerer G. (2014). Migration between the EU, V4 and Eastern Europe: The Present Situation and Possible Future. The Perspective of Hungary, in: M. Jaroszewicz, M. Lesińska (eds), Forecasting Migration Between the EU, V4 and Eastern Europe, pp. 122–138. Warsaw: Centre for Eastern Studies.
• State Statistics Service of Ukraine (2019). Заборгованість із виплати заробітної плати [Salary Delays]. Online: https://ukrstat.org/uk/operativ/operativ2015/gdn/prc_rik/prc_rik_u/dsz_u... (accessed: 29 May 2019).
• Stronglab (2018). Towards Stronger Transnational Labour Inspection Cooperation project. Online: https://anblokkegyesulet.wordpress.com/2018/02/24/ukrainian-temporary-ag... and http://migrationonline.cz/en/about-us/current-projects/stronglab (accessed: 18 May 2019).
• Stubnya B. (2016). Ukrán migránsokat hoz a kormány, titokban vendégmunkaprogram indult. Index, 22 September. Online: https://index.hu/gazdasag/allas/2016/09/22/ukran_migransokat_hoz_a_korma...
• gba_titokban (accessed: 2 June 2019).
• Thompson P., Newsome N., Commander J. (2013). ‘Good When They Want To Be’: Migrant Workers in the Supermarket Supply Chain. Human Resource Management Journal 23(2): 129–143.
• Williams F. (2012). Converging Variations in Migrant Care Work in Europe. Journal of European Social Policy 22(4): 363–376.

Notes

EN